can a former employer give a bad reference in california

What can my former employer say about me California?

Under California law, an employer is not obligated to provide a reference for a former employee, but should it choose to do so, the employer may provide information about job performance, qualifications, and eligibility for rehire.

What to do if past employer is giving bad reference?

Here are some actions you can take to address a reference that's having a negative impact on your job search:Contact your former employer. ... Ask for feedback from your potential employer. ... Ask others for help. ... Check your other references. ... Make positive changes.

Can my last employer gave me bad reference?

It is commonly assumed that a previous employer must give a reference and is legally prohibited from giving a bad one. This is not the case. Your employer can give you a bad or unfavourable reference, but only if they genuinely believe it to be true and accurate and have reasonable grounds for that belief.

Can I sue my old employer for giving a bad reference?

Legal Consequences for Bad Employment References If an employer makes negative comments about you when they are contacted for an employment reference you may be able to bring a lawsuit against them for defamation. It's important to note though that the truth is a defense to defamation.

What are past employers allowed to say about you?

There are no federal laws restricting what information an employer can disclose about former employees.

Are references allowed to say bad things?

Generally, an employer is not prohibited by law from providing truthful information about a former employee to a prospective employer. The law has little reason to discourage employers from providing their honest assessments of an employee's performance, regardless of whether this assessment is good or bad.

Can employers get in trouble for bad references?

As discussed above, it is not illegal to give a bad reference so long as the reference is factual or an honest opinion not motivated by malice. To avoid any liability for a bad reference, an employer had better make sure to: Investigate to determine the truth of the contents of the reference; and.

How do you find out if a former employer is slandering you?

Reference Checking Services Hire a reference-checking service to find out what previous employers are saying about you. For a fee, these companies will pose as a potential employer and call previous employers for a job reference check.

Will a bad reference ruin my career?

As long as it's fair and accurate, a reference can show that you're not suitable for a job. For example, a reference can show you do not have enough experience for a job or say that you were dismissed.

What is HR allowed to ask from previous employers?

The HR employee can ask a former employer whether they'd rehire a job candidate. The former employer's HR policies might prohibit anything beyond a "Yes" or "No" response to this particular inquiry, but a "No" response gives the prospective employer something to think about.

What constitutes a bad reference?

What is a bad reference? A bad reference is when a former employer suggests to your potential new employer that you might not be an ideal candidate for a job. They may identify abilities or experiences that are missing from your skill set or explain reasons for your dismissal from a previous role.

Can past employers say bad things about you?

In short, yes. There are no federal laws restricting what an employer can or cannot say about a former employee. That being said, some employers are extremely cautious about what they do and don't say to minimize their liability in the event of a lawsuit.

Will a bad reference ruin my career?

As long as it's fair and accurate, a reference can show that you're not suitable for a job. For example, a reference can show you do not have enough experience for a job or say that you were dismissed.

Can employers get in trouble for bad references?

As discussed above, it is not illegal to give a bad reference so long as the reference is factual or an honest opinion not motivated by malice. To avoid any liability for a bad reference, an employer had better make sure to: Investigate to determine the truth of the contents of the reference; and.

Can a previous employer disclose why you were fired?

Although laws in some states say that a former employer only can offer information about you with your consent, most state laws allow a previous employer to not only reveal that you were fired, but also the reasons why -- as long as the information is true and accurate.

When is a Bad Reference Illegal?

In general, the subjects of bad reference letters cannot pursue claims even if the reference highlights the employer’s negative opinion towards the employee. A bad reference is only illegal when false statements are written as facts with the purpose of making it difficult to or impossible for the employee to get another job. If you would like to learn more about when bad references are illegal, do not hesitate to seek legal assistance with the employment experts at California Labor Law Employment Attorneys Group as soon as possible.

What to do if you have a bad reference?

If the bad reference tampered with your opportunity to get a new job, you could pursue a claim. You have the right to file a lawsuit; however, the type of lawsuit that you are eligible to pursue depends on the specific details of your situation. For instance, you might have grounds to file a defamation claim. You might also have grounds to file a retaliation claim.

Is giving a bad reference illegal in California?

Is giving former employees a bad reference illegal based on California law? According to California employment laws, a bad reference is punishable by law. The law states that it is a misdemeanor when an employer “prevents or attempts to prevent” the former employee from getting a job “by any misrepresentation” in the bad reference letter. If you would like to learn more about what California law states on bad references of employment, do not hesitate to contact California Labor Law Employment Attorneys Group today.

Did you receive a bad reference from a former employer?

Did you receive a bad reference from a former employer? Did the bad reference prevent you from getting another job? Unfortunately, many employers provide bad references in regards to former employees. Whether the employer provided the bad reference out of spite, retaliation, or bad faith, the employee who has the subject of the bad reference letter might have grounds to take legal action.

Can you sue for defamation?

If you decide to pursue a claim for defamation, you would have to prove that your former employer intentionally gave the false bad reference in an attempt to make it difficult for you to get another job. If you decide to pursue a claim for retaliation, you must prove that your bad reference was retaliatory. If you would like to learn more about your right to pursue a lawsuit after your former employer gave you a bad reference, do not hesitate to contact our law firm as soon as possible.

When is a Bad Reference Illegal?

Your employer gave you a bad reference, but is it illegal? Without a doubt, your employer has the right to provide you with a bad reference as long as everything in the reference is true. If the reference letter makes negligent statements or blatantly false statements, the bad reference is illegal.

Your Right to File a Lawsuit

Do you have the right to file a lawsuit against the employer that gave you a bad reference? As explained above, giving a bad reference is only illegal when the statements provided are false.

Your Right to be Compensated

Are you entitled to compensation if you file a claim for a bad reference from your former employer? If you sue your former employer, could you receive compensation? If you recently lost the opportunity to get a job due to the false and malicious reference given by your former employer, you have the right to sue and receive compensation.

Understanding the Different Employment Agencies

Without a doubt, you have the right to pursue a civil lawsuit against the employer the employer that gave you a bad reference. However, you might have grounds to pursue a claim with either a federal or state employment agency.

The Statute of Limitations for Your Claim

Is your claim subject to a statute of limitations? A statute of limitations establishes the time that claimants have to pursue their claims. If claimants do not file their claims within the time allowed by the statute of limitations, they could lose their right to sue and receive compensation.

What is the California case law for not providing enough information about an employee?

California case law also subjects employers to liability for not providing enough information about an employee, if they choose to provide a detailed reference. For example, a school district gave a glowing recommendation for a vice principal who had in fact been accused of sexual misconduct and inappropriate behavior with students. The reference provided unconditional praise for the employee, recommending him "without reservation." When the employee was hired by a new school district and again accused of sexual misconduct with a female student, her parents were allowed to sue the former school district. Although the district was under no obligation to provide a reference for the employee in the first place, once it chose to do so, it had a duty not to misrepresent the facts.

What is the law in California that protects employers from defamation?

In California, employers are protected from liability for defamation if they provide reference information based on credible evidence, without malice.

What is a release for a former employer?

If you want a former employer to provide more detailed information that the law requires, you might consider signing a release: an agreement giving the employer permission to respond to prospective employers who call for a reference, and giving up your right to sue the employer for anything said as part of that process.

What is a defamation lawsuit?

In a defamation lawsuit, the plaintiff ( the person bringing the lawsuit) alleges that someone made false and damaging statements about him or her. In the context of employment, defamation claims almost always center on statements the employer makes about the employee once the employment relationship ends. Typically, a former employee claims that the employer made false, negative statements about the employee's performance to a prospective employer who called for a reference, and the prospective employer decided not to offer the employee a job (or to rescind a job offer) because of the poor reference. (To learn more about defamation claims, see Defamation Lawsuits: Do You Have a Case Against a Former Employer?)

What is qualified privilege in California?

California employers enjoy a qualified privilege when they provide reference information to prospective employers. This means that an employer is immune from liability (cannot be sued) for defamation, as long as the employer provides the information to a prospective employer who requests it and acts without malice. California law specifically states that this protection extends to statements about job performance, qualifications, and eligibility for rehire. However, it does not protect statements about an employee's constitutionally protected speech or activities, nor statements about an employee's union or other concerted activities.

What happens if you lose your job?

If you've lost your job, you may be concerned about what your former employer will say to companies that ask for a reference. References often make the difference between landing a new job and receiving a rejection letter. If a former employer is giving out false or misleading information about you, it could doom your job search.

Can an employer be sued for false statements?

However, the employer can be sued if it knows the statements are false or acts with reckless disregard for their trust or falsity.

Can you leave sterling records without a reference?

The clear downside, of course, is that employees with sterling records are left without a potentially valuable reference. Worse yet, inexperienced prospective employers may mistakenly assume the worst about someone who does not receive an explicitly positive reference from their past employer. Nevertheless, such policies are entirely permissible as far as the law is concerned.

Do companies have blanket policies?

Nowadays, it is not unusual for entire companies to have "blanket" policies that require or encourage management or HR representatives to provide very limited information in response to a prospective employer's request for a reference about any employee. For instance, supervisors or HR reps could be directed to limit their sharing ...

Is a negative reference a defamation lawsuit?

Opinions also are generally protected, and simply because someone disagrees with their former employer's opinion does not entitle them to collect damages under defamation law. Instead, only false factual statements are subject to defamation lawsuits that are governed by individual states' laws.

Can a prior employer make a bad reference illegal?

As suggested above, it is only by straying from the truth that a prior employer can make a bad reference illegal. However, there are some practical challenges with any defamation case, some of which are are heightened in the context of job references. Discovering the cause or reason why a job applicant was denied a job is difficult.

Is it illegal to make a bad reference?

However, crossing the line into making misrepresentations or outright lies could make a bad reference illegal. Legal actions based on misstatements made in job references are typically based on defamation laws which prohibit anyone, including employers, from knowingly publishing or spreading false information about another.

Is wrongful reference a misdemeanor?

Further, some states provide more strict laws relating to retaliation or wrongful references against a former employee. For example, California law makes it a misdemeanor when a former employer "by any misrepresentation prevents or attempts to prevent" their former employee from getting a job.

Can an employer give a false reference?

Generally, an employer is not prohibited by law from providing truthful information about a former employee to a prospective employer. The law has little reason to discourage employers from providing their honest assessments of an employee's performance, regardless of whether this assessment is good or bad. However, crossing the line into making misrepresentations or outright lies could make a bad reference illegal. Legal actions based on misstatements made in job references are typically based on defamation laws which prohibit anyone, including employers, from knowingly publishing or spreading false information about another.

Who can provide job references?

Only one person, usually a trained HR professional , should be permitted to provide job references. This person should make it a point to review the applicable state laws where the employee resides and where the prospective employer is located. Also, care should be taken to ensure that the exact same process is used for each job reference request to avoid any claims of discrimination.

Do you have to complete an application form?

It's also a good idea for employers to require all applicants to complete an application form—in addition to or instead of a resume—and to include a release for employers and other entities from which they might request a reference, Rennekamp said.

Can an employer say anything about a worker?

There are no federal laws that address what an employer can or can't say about a worker. Many states, however, have enacted legislation that gives employers a qualified immunity when providing information for a reference check. These statutes generally provide that an employer is immune from civil liability when it responds to a reference check in good faith, explained Molly Lee Kaban, an attorney with Hanson Bridgett in San Francisco. The immunity is lost, however, if it can be shown that the employer knowingly or recklessly provided false or misleading information or acted with malicious intent.

Does Arkansas have immunity from reference checks?

Only certain information is protected under the immunity law in Arkansas, such as dates of employment, wage rates, job duties, details of the last performance evaluation, threats of workplace violence, and the reason for separation. Missouri applies the immunity only when an employer responds in writing to a written request for reference information, and the employer must provide a copy of the written response to the employee.

Does SHRM offer legal advice?

SHRM provides content as a service to its readers and members. It does not offer legal advice, and cannot guarantee the accuracy or suitability of its content for a particular purpose. Disclaimer

Should employers ask about rehire?

Employers shouldn't ask or answer questions about whether a person is eligible for rehire, Rennekamp said. "The answer you get might not indicate anything except how well the person giving the reference liked the individual and will certainly not contain enough specifics on which to base a hiring decision."

Should employers maintain control of their organization?

Employers should maintain control of the information that their organization gives out, Rennekamp said. They might do that by putting limits on who can give a reference or what information can be provided. "However, we should all keep in mind that all employers need information about past performance and behavior in order to determine if an individual is a good fit for the position," she added.

Why do employers release references?

Providing a Reference. Many employers will release only basic information when contacted for a reference to protect themselves from lawsuits. They usually confirm employment dates and job responsibilities, salary history, and might include information about whether you were dismissed or chose to leave on your own.

What to do if you are not getting an offer?

If You are Concerned, Speak Up. If you are failing to receive offers for jobs for which you are qualified and you suspect it might be due to negative references, speak up. You can ask a potential employer why they chose not to extend an offer (they might not tell you) and you can speak with an attorney about your rights.

Can you file a grievance against your employer?

This is true if you leave the company and move on completely, or if you file a legal action against the company for something they were doing. If you are a victim of a hostile work environment or discrimination, federal and state laws may protect your right to file a grievance against your employer. If they choose to bad-mouth you as a result of your whistle blowing, they may be violating anti-retaliation laws.

Can you end a relationship with a former employer?

Relationships with former employers never completely end. You might have retirement savings tied up in the company or be responsible for protecting intellectual property and trade secrets. Employers also have responsibilities when it comes to former employees. There are laws regarding what they can say about an employee, which means if your former employer is bad-mouthing you when they receive a reference call, there may be actions you can take to remedy the situation.

Can you ask your former employer what is being said?

You can also ask your former employer what is being said. Again, they might not tell you, but it could provide an opportunity to clear up a misunderstanding or at least alert you to the fact that they aren’t a great reference .

Can you take legal action for retaliatory references?

Navigating the sometimes choppy waters of the job market can be tough for anyone, but it is especially frustrating when a former employer is speaking negatively about your performance. If you have been searching for a job and find things are going well until potential employers contact your references, you might be a victim of retaliatory job references. The bad news is you’ve likely missed out on a few great opportunities because of a past experience. The good news is you have rights and you can take legal action.

Why do employers need to verify employment in California?

Because of the relatively generous legal protection the state provides , businesses conducting employment verification in California should be able to convince employers to share even quite sensitive details, such as why the employee left the company. In states with fewer protections, you may need to limit your employment verification questions to the basics.

How to verify employment?

Basic employment verification corroborates someone’s claim they were once employed at a certain company. Often, the verifier, generally a human resources rep from the company at which an employee seeks employment, will ask for additional details. Employment verification queries may include the following: 1 The employee’s start and end dates 2 Job title or position with the company 3 Reason for leaving the company 4 Income verification for the employee, including salary information (Prohibited in California) 5 Job performance 6 Any skills and types of experience, such as certifications or experience working with specific technologies

What is employment verification?

Basic employment verification corroborates someone’s claim they were once employed at a certain company. Often, the verifier, generally a human resources rep from the company at which an employee seeks employment, will ask for additional details. Employment verification queries may include the following: The employee’s start and end dates.

What is Section 47 C?

Section 47 (c) of California’s civil code classes “communication concerning the job performance or qualifications of an applicant for employment, based upon credible evidence, made without malice, by a current or former employer of the applicant to , and upon request of, one whom the employer reasonably believes is ...

Can employers check salary history?

In January 2018, California enacted a law barring employers from checking salary history information for prospective employees. In fact, section 432.3 of the California labor code specifically states that “An employer shall not rely on the salary history information of an applicant for employment as a factor in determining whether to offer employment to an applicant or what salary to offer an applicant.”

Does a severance agreement protect against malicious statements?

Note that this law does not protect employers against making malicious statements about a former employee, nor does it protect a former employer who reaches out to a prospective employer rather than waiting for that prospective employer to make contact. Finally, if the employee had a severance agreement that includes a nondisparagement clause, the former employer may be limited in what they can say about the employee.

Can former employees sue employers?

That means former employees can’t sue the employer based on such communications — California specifically shields any privileged communication from defamation claims. Therefore, employers can feel safe about sharing details of an employee’s working history, even when those details may cost the former employee a job offer or cause them other problems.

When do defamation lawsuits have merit?

Defamation lawsuits have merits when an employer knowingly makes false factual statements as a bad reference given for a former employee.

How to prove defamation?

Finding out if the reason for not getting a job was due to receiving a bad reference from a former employer is difficult. Even if a bad reference was given, there is rarely any record made of the reference. To prevail against a former employer in a defamation case requires proof that the reference was given and that it contained false factual statements.

Is it illegal to make false statements about a former employee?

However, when a previous employer knowingly makes false statements about a person who worked there, this is illegal and can serve as the basis for a lawsuit if it can be proven. In California, it is also a misdemeanor crime for any former employer to use false misrepresentation to prevent or attempt to prevent a former employee from being hired ...

Is defamation a law?

Any truthful statement made about another person is not defamation, even if the truth may be negative. There are no laws that prevent any employer from giving accurate and truthful information about a previous employee. Opinions of the previous employer are also protected.

Can a bad reference cause a defamation case?

Certainly, there is no denying that a bad reference may cause the rejection of a candidate by a potential employer.

Defamation and References

California Law on References

• California employers enjoy a qualified privilege when they provide reference information to prospective employers. This means that an employer is immune from liability (cannot be sued) for defamation, as long as the employer provides the information to a prospective employer who requests it and acts without malice. California law specifically state...

See more on nolo.com

Getting A Reference