Knowledge Builders

how did malcolm xs approach to civil liberties differ from mlks

by Rashad Sanford PhD Published 2 years ago Updated 2 years ago

Both were deeply religious but had different ideologies about how equal rights should be attained. MLK focussed on nonviolent protest (e.g., bus boycotts, sit-ins, and marches), while Malcolm X believed in attaining equal rights by any means necessary.

Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X are frequently seen as opposing forces in the struggle for civil rights and against white supremacy; King is often portrayed as a nonviolent insider, while Malcolm X is characterized as a by-any-means-necessary political renegade.Aug 12, 2020

Full Answer

What was Gandhi's last effect?

What did Douglass do to inspire people?

How should America have confronted the inequalities of the 1960's?

What was the voting act in the 1950s?

Why did the Southern men end reconstruction?

How did Du Bois and Washington help African Americans?

What did MLK say about segregation?

See 4 more

About this website

How did Malcolm X's approach differ from that of MLK's?

Although Malcolm rejected King's message of nonviolence, he respected King as a “fellow-leader of our people,” sending King NOI articles as early as 1957 and inviting him to participate in mass meetings throughout the early 1960s (Papers 5:491).

How was Malcolm X's view on civil rights different from that of Martin Luther King Jr S quizlet?

The two men appealed to a sense of heritage, passionately exposed then-present crimes and needs,and called for action to secure the future. While Martin Luther king used nonviolence to solve problems, and in the other hand Malcolm X encouraged violence, and believe that was the right way.

6 Similarities Between Malcolm X and Martin Luther King Jr

The assassinations were the only option the shameless defenders of racial injustice could result to – and sadly so. On February 21, 1965, Malcolm X was assassinated while delivering a speech at the Audubon Ballroom in Washington Heights, where he was delivering a speech to members of the Afro-American Unity.

Compare And Contrast Mlk And Malcolm X - GraduateWay

Get help on 【 Compare And Contrast Mlk And Malcolm X 】 on Graduateway A huge assortment of FREE essays & assignments Find an idea for your paper!

Compare and contrast Martin Luther King and Malcolm X.

Martin Luther King, Jr. and Malcolm X were both civil rights leaders during the 1960s. Both were deeply religious but had different ideologies about how equal rights should be attained.

How Important Was Martin Luther King Compared to Malcolm X

Essay on How Important Was Martin Luther King Compared to Malcolm X During the 1920’s/1930’s, black Americans faced a huge amount of discrimination from the whites and found if very difficult to achieve civil rights. They

Malcolm X vs Martin Luther King Jr: The difference in Ideologies ...

A mugshot of Malcolm X in 1944, Public domain. Pastor Martin, on the contrary, goes further in his studies than anyone else. Entering university at the age of 15, having 2 university degrees, becoming a doctor of philosophy at the age of 26, Martin's talent is undeniable.

Comparison and Contrast MLK and Malcolm X - Gordon State College

CRITIAL TOPIC SENTENCE 1: Within the letter and the speech, both leaders appeal to their audience’s sense of justice by discussing innate rights. MLK SUB TOPIC SENTENCE : By employing his discussion of just and unjust laws, MLK attempts to convince readers of the rationality of the movement.

What was Gandhi's last effect?

QUOTATION While Gandhi aimed to independent his country from the Britain colonial. The last effect is the method of activism. Gandhi was the first who used the non-violence activism and had success in using it, although King was inspired by Gandhi’s activism and he applied it in his struggles.

What did Douglass do to inspire people?

Douglass was a man needed during his time, who could inspire any crowd for the better . He was born into slavery and separated from his mother when he was an infant so he is more than experienced to know the hardships of being black. If it wasn’t for Douglass history might of been different for not just blacks but every ethnic group. Douglass is one of if not the most important inspirational leaders of the United States history ever

How should America have confronted the inequalities of the 1960's?

America should have confronted the inequalities of the 1960’s by creating a peaceful protest and movement, but if civil rights and peace for are not given, then violence protests should take place in a certain amount of time. Read More.

What was the voting act in the 1950s?

The voting act was an act that supported that african americans have the right to vote like any white man. Another tactic used was the idea of Black Nationalism. African Americans united together was under Malcolm X and islam.

Why did the Southern men end reconstruction?

Reconstruction in 1865 through 1877 was terminated by Southern men due to their lack of acceptance of African Americans in restricting their political rights, not following the North’s precedence of equality, and the assassination of many a men by their ever so popular Klan.

How did Du Bois and Washington help African Americans?

Both were on the journey to improve African American’s social and political status in America. However, they had different methods for getting what they wanted. Regardless, they were able to aid in ending discrimination and received equal standing in education, labor, acquiring of land, etc.. If it had only been Du Bois fighting for equality, then he would have achieved the fight for equality sooner. On the contrary, Du Bois only provided one view to how African Americans were being treated; Washington had a friendlier approach.

What did MLK say about segregation?

MLK was very surprisingly realistic about segregation, claiming African Americans had “come a long, long way” but had “a long, long way to go” towards integration. He was of the opinion that through hard work and persistence, one day blacks and whites would regard each others as equals.

What were the differences between MLK and Malcolm X?

Both were deeply religious but had different ideologies about how equal rights should be attained. MLK focussed on nonviolent protest (e.g., bus boycotts, sit-ins, and marches), while Malcolm X believed in attaining equal rights by any means necessary.

What did Malcolm X believe about whites?

Malcolm X, in contrast, took a dimmer of view of whites than King, seeing them through the lens of the black nationalist Nation of Islam of which he was part . He believed violence was often the only language whites understood, because it was the method they had long used to control people of color. In his view of the acceptability of violence, Malcolm X echoed mainstream American thinking, though such sentiments sounded shocking when directed at whites by a black man. Malcolm X also believed, unlike King, that getting white acceptance was impossible. Blacks needed to turn their backs on white culture and develop their own, separate society based on helping each other.

Why did Malcolm X go to Mecca?

It is worth noting that at the end of his life, Malcolm X went to Mecca for the Islamic hajj, or pilgrimage, and there experienced profound transformation. For the first time ever, he experienced whites treating blacks as equals, and he came home believing that reconciliation was possible. Unfortunately, he was assassinated before he could implement his new thinking.

How did Malcolm X and Martin Luther King Jr. die?

were near contemporaries, born four years apart in the 1920s, and both experienced the bitter racism of mid-twentieth-century America. Each died by gun assassination in the 1960s.

What did Malcolm X believe about African Americans?

Only in this way, he believed, would African Americans begin to recover the dignity of which they'd been systematically stripped ever since they were first brought to America in chains.

What did Malcolm X argue about?

He argued that American society was so deeply infested with racism and oppression that African Americans would never be granted anything like equality. It was therefore futile for King and other members of the mainstream civil rights movement to agitate for change within the system; it was the system that was the problem in the first place.

How long is the free trial for eNotes?

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

How are Malcolm X and Martin Luther King different?

...aggressive one, by Malcolm X. While being unquestionably different, they were alike; they both fought for the same goal, but on different battlegrounds. Martin Luther King and Malcolm (Little) X were both students, and bright ones at that! They, amongst the conflicts that the society presented, managed rather peculiarly to keep their minds open; that is, to say, they amassed copious amounts of knowledge about the life in this world. They composed their own philosophies and believed them to be true. They were superlatively the most committed believers of their theories. They both felt compelled to end the racism that the world offered towards the African-American society. For that reason, they set out with one common goal: to abolish this racism forever. As mentioned above, they both share some similarities and copious dissimilarities. Throughout their lives, Martin Luther King and Malcolm X were role models in the continuous battle against racism. They both gave powerful speeches on racism; however their intentions were delivered with different styles and purposes. King had a more positive and idealistic approach compared to Malcolm X's more pessimistic views. King was hopeful in believing that someday, blacks would achieve full equality with whites. Non–violent demonstrations and arguments were King's techniques in reaching equality. Malcolm ...

What was the most important thing about MLK and Malcolm X?

Martin Luther King and Malcolm Civil Rights Movement. They were trying to fight for African American during the civil right movement. They both had very different philosophies, but whose philosophy made the most sense for America in the 1960s? Malcolm X, a great leader in the Civil Right era, had a very tough life at a young age because of his father dying and his mother having a mental break was sent to foster house. Malcolm X got his ideas by going to jail because of drugs from Elijah Muhammad and the Nation of Islam. Malcolm X believed in segregation and also violence if necessary. MLK was a middle class family, kid and faced racism at a young age. MLK was more towards integration and didn't believe in violence. MLK and Malcolm X both had great philosophies, but only some of their philosophies were effective in the 1960s for America.

How did Martin Luther King's style and tactics affect the lives of people?

Martin Luther King’s style and tactics had more of an impact on policies and leaders that effectively brought the dream of equality closer to reality than Malcolm X’s violent action and policies. Both were great leaders whom many admired but were both assassinated by those that vehemently opposed their beliefs and movements. These men changed history and the way people think about each other.

What was the difference between Malcolm X and Martin Luther King?

and Malcolm X had very different beliefs and tangible differences in the actions of their followers in how to achieve equal rights for black Americans. Dr. Martin Luther King was fighting for a color-blind society where people would be judged and valued on their skills and characters rather than the color of their skin.

Why did Malcolm X believe equality is impossible?

Malcolm X’s despair about life was reflected in his angry, pessimistic belief that equality is impossible because whites have no moral conscience.Malcolm X, however, promoted nationalist and separatist doctrines.

What did Malcolm X believe was the most effective method to achieve the goal of equality?

Dr. Martin Luther King preached non-violent means of expression and actions that he believed were the most effective method to achieve the goal of equality. Dr. King’s non-violent methods had the ability to not only influence people ...

What did Malcolm X say in the 1960s?

During the 1960’s Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. and Malcolm X represented two sides of the Civil Rights Movement. Speaking to all of humanity, Dr. King made these famous peaceful words, “I have a dream, a dream that one day this nation will rise up and live out the true meaning of its creed: “We hold these ...

What did Malcolm X believe?

For most of his life, he believed that only through revolution and force could blacks attain their rightful place in society . Malcolm X joined the Nation of Islam eventually becoming the chief spokesperson and had a great influence on black Americans. Malcolm X believed that only through revolution and force could black Americans attain their ...

Who are the two African Americans who fought for a difference?

African Americans are fortunate to have leaders who fought for a difference in Black America. Martin Luther King, Jr. and Malcolm X are two powerful men in particular who brought hope to blacks in the United States. Both preached the same message about Blacks having power and strength in the midst of all the hatred that surrounded them.

What was the goal of Martin Luther King and Malcolm X?

For that reason, they set out with one common goal: to abolish this racism forever. As mentioned above, they both share some similarities and copious dissimilarities. Throughout their lives, Martin Luther King and Malcolm X were role models in the continuous battle against racism.

What did Malcolm X believe?

Malcolm X’s realization of the reality, that his beliefs, as he incorporated them from Elijah Mohammad – a key figure of African American Muslim society called the Nation of Islam, which organized many events against the Caucasian race and secretly employed illegal tactics to promote the idea that blacks should separate from whites – were incorrect. After taking a pilgrimage to Mecca, a holy city for Muslims, he learned that Islam teaches racial equality, and not inequality.King, on the contrary, remained with his starting belief: King believed that blacks and whites are equal, and that one day, this will be shown to the world. Dr.

How did Malcolm X's childhood affect his views?

Malcolm X’s rough childhood and past experiences shaped his pessimistic views. Because King was more idealistic, he gave a greater hope to the blacks. Malcolm X’s more realistic speeches and views were seen as pessimistic; promoting separatism and no hope for blacks and whites ever reaching equality.Malcol m X’s arguments were more of a negative reminder of the inequality blacks faced; while King brought about ideas for a hopeful future.

What was Malcolm X's goal?

and Malcolm X were alike, yet very different; the evidence presented clearly shows that they fought for one goal – to abolish racism against African American. They will never be forgotten.

What was the impact of Malcolm X's views on the African American community?

He gave the community a strong voice and a future to look forward to. Malcolm X’s views were seen as ultimately leading to a separatist nation; which was less inspiring for the blacks.

Who led the fight against racism?

These men, however, belonged to two forces; one was led by Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. and the other, a much aggressive one, by Malcolm X.

Did Malcolm X change his beliefs?

King, indeed, never had to change his beliefs. Malcolm X’s often angry tone fueled the white racists. King was a bigger promoter of non-violence, which gave the whites less to criticize. Malcolm was an easier target for the whites because of his anger. His anger also triggered more hatred amongst the black community.

What they fought for throughout their lives?

Analogy also matters; because when going back through their past, they fought for the same cause as a whole, that is, the slogan for the equal rights of the Americans . As far as the rights of the black Americans are concerned, their beliefs in their actions were quite different. Dr. Martin Luther King was fighting for a colour-blind society where people would be judged and valued on their skills and characters rather than the colour of their skin. Malcolm X, on the other hand, was fighting in favour of a separate black nation, instead of integration of all races. Dr. Martin Luther King preached non-violent means of expression and actions that, he believed, were the most effective method to achieve the goal of equality. In short, they both fought for the rights of the Americans but with a different perspective.

How are Malcolm X and Martin Luther different?

Every being has his own beliefs and those beliefs can easily be judged through the actions he performs. The beliefs can be acknowledged through their backgrounds. May be their childhoods were entirely different and those facts strengthened up their beliefs. Indeed their childhoods were different and their entire life was different too. It is given that one belongs to a very comfortable home, means he entirely spent his life in comfort and wealth. On the other hand, Malcolm X experienced his overall life in misery and plight. As far as Martin Luther is concerned, he is one of the richest man and is very educated. And Malcom X is a self-educated being who acquired his values and beliefs from his parents and society. As far as their families are concerned, Martin Luther came from a family where there were renowned personalities. Malcolm grew up all alone.

Why are Malcolm X and Martin Luther King so important?

Among them, Martin Luther King and Malcolm X are of great importance. Why they are chosen for the comparison is because of the differences between their personalities. During the 1960s Martin presented the two sides of the civil rights. At that time he spoke to all humanity and said, “I have a dream that one day the nation will rise up ...

What was Malcolm X fighting for?

Malcolm X, on the other hand, was fighting in favour of a separate black nation, instead of integration of all races. Dr.

Why was Martin Luther King in favour of equality?

He was mainly in favour to do good with others. Because for him kindness is something that leads a person to the heaven and eventually his soul gets purified.

What did Martin Luther King preach?

Martin Luther King preached non-violent means of expression and actions that, he believed, were the most effective method to achieve the goal of equality. In short, they both fought for the rights of the Americans but with a different perspective.

Why was Martin Luther a well educated man?

Concluding the whole discussion, we can sum up that Martin Luther was a man who was well educated because of the resources his parents provided him. But on the other hand, the other man did not have resources to shape his personality. Rather no one was there to support him.

Why did the white man pay Martin Luther King?

The "white man pays Reverend Martin Luther King, subsidizes Reverend Martin Luther King, so that Reverend Martin Luther King can continue to teach the Negroes to be defenseless.". And the Christianity that motivated King was "the white man's religion.". For his part, civil rights leader Thurgood Marshall called the Nation of Islam "a bunch ...

Did Malcolm X ever meet Martin Luther King?

Although they only met once, Malcol m X was often asked his opinion of Martin Luther King Jr. and the civil rights movement. Initially scornful of King and his strategies, Malcolm later began to recognize the worth of — and even began tentative participation in — the movement.

Who said "We did not always see eye to eye on methods to solve the race problem"?

Condolences. In a telegram to Betty Shabazz after Malcolm's assassination, Martin Luther King Jr. said, "While we did not always see eye-to-eye on methods to solve the race problem, I always had a deep affection for Malcolm and felt he had a great ability to put his finger on the existence and root of the problem.

How old was Malcolm when he was arrested?

Arrested at the age of 21, he was introduced to the Nation of Islam while in prison. The group was also influenced by Garvey’s theories, and following his conversion and release from prison, Malcolm became one of the most prominent disciples of Elijah Muhammad, the group’s leader.

Why did Malcolm and King clash?

King and Malcolm clashed over the best tactics to end racial discrimination and prejudice. Malcolm was highly critical of King’s non-violent approach, believing King’s actions to be too slow-moving and too accommodating to white Americans and going so far as to refer to him as “a 20-century Uncle Tom.”.

When did Malcolm X and MLK meet?

MLK and Malcolm X's historic meeting lasted just minutes. On March 8, 1964, disillusioned with Muhammad’s private life and angered over the group’s refusal to take a more active role in the fight for civil rights, Malcolm publicly broke up with the Nation of Islam.

When did Malcolm X meet Martin Luther King?

The civil rights leaders did not see to eye to eye, and their encounter lasted minutes. On March 26, 1964, Malcolm X and Martin Luther King Jr. met for the first and only time in Washington, D.C. Less than a year later, Malcolm was dead, the victim of an assassin’s bullet, ending any possibility of a permanent thaw between two ...

When was the Civil Rights Act of 1964 signed into law?

history to defeat the legislation, but it eventually passed and the Civil Rights Act of 1964 was signed into law on July 2.

Who was Malcolm's father?

Malcolm (born Malcolm Little), experienced poverty and violence at a young age. His father, a supporter of Marcus Garvey, died when Malcolm was a child, at the hands of what his family believed to be white nationalists. His mother was institutionalized several years later.

Who is Barbara Maranzani?

Barbara Maranzani is a NY-based writer and editor, focusing on American and European history.

What was Gandhi's last effect?

QUOTATION While Gandhi aimed to independent his country from the Britain colonial. The last effect is the method of activism. Gandhi was the first who used the non-violence activism and had success in using it, although King was inspired by Gandhi’s activism and he applied it in his struggles.

What did Douglass do to inspire people?

Douglass was a man needed during his time, who could inspire any crowd for the better . He was born into slavery and separated from his mother when he was an infant so he is more than experienced to know the hardships of being black. If it wasn’t for Douglass history might of been different for not just blacks but every ethnic group. Douglass is one of if not the most important inspirational leaders of the United States history ever

How should America have confronted the inequalities of the 1960's?

America should have confronted the inequalities of the 1960’s by creating a peaceful protest and movement, but if civil rights and peace for are not given, then violence protests should take place in a certain amount of time. Read More.

What was the voting act in the 1950s?

The voting act was an act that supported that african americans have the right to vote like any white man. Another tactic used was the idea of Black Nationalism. African Americans united together was under Malcolm X and islam.

Why did the Southern men end reconstruction?

Reconstruction in 1865 through 1877 was terminated by Southern men due to their lack of acceptance of African Americans in restricting their political rights, not following the North’s precedence of equality, and the assassination of many a men by their ever so popular Klan.

How did Du Bois and Washington help African Americans?

Both were on the journey to improve African American’s social and political status in America. However, they had different methods for getting what they wanted. Regardless, they were able to aid in ending discrimination and received equal standing in education, labor, acquiring of land, etc.. If it had only been Du Bois fighting for equality, then he would have achieved the fight for equality sooner. On the contrary, Du Bois only provided one view to how African Americans were being treated; Washington had a friendlier approach.

What did MLK say about segregation?

MLK was very surprisingly realistic about segregation, claiming African Americans had “come a long, long way” but had “a long, long way to go” towards integration. He was of the opinion that through hard work and persistence, one day blacks and whites would regard each others as equals.

1.Malcolm X vs Martin Luther King Jr: The difference in …

Url:https://melaninful.net/blogs/melaninful-blog/malcolm-x-vs-martin-luther-king

28 hours ago  · Aside from their differences in racial beliefs and ideologies, Malcolm X and Martin Luther King's struggles have a distinct trajectory. The most essential attribute of an activist is …

2.Malcolm X Vs Mlk - 1136 Words | Internet Public Library

Url:https://www.ipl.org/essay/Malcolm-X-Vs-Mlk-PCSAQ85WDSB

4 hours ago 1136 Words. 5 Pages. Open Document. The civil rights movement would not have been possible without the contributions of many ordinary people. But these ordinary people could not have …

3.Compare And Contrast Malcolm X And Mlk In The Civil …

Url:https://www.ipl.org/essay/Compare-And-Contrast-Malcolm-X-And-Mlk-PJ4RVESUZV

3 hours ago Today, Dr. Martin King and Malcolm X as two opposite dogma in terms of today’s history. This misconception, breaches the influences of what each man (King and Malcolm X) had. …

4.Compare and contrast Martin Luther King and Malcolm X.

Url:https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/martin-luther-king-malcolm-x-compare-contrast-235275

23 hours ago  · Malcolm X, a great leader in the Civil Right era, had a very tough life at a young age because of his father dying and his mother having a mental break was sent to foster house. …

5.MLK And Malcolm X Comparison - 839 Words | Studymode

Url:https://www.studymode.com/essays/MLK-And-Malcolm-X-Comparison-85836350.html

25 hours ago  · Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. and Malcolm X had very different beliefs and tangible differences in the actions of their followers in how to achieve equal rights for black Americans. …

6.Differences Between Martin Luther King and Malcolm X

Url:https://graduateway.com/differences-between-martin-luther-king-and-malcolm-x/

31 hours ago  · Malcolm X showed more fury towards white racism and encouraged more protest against white racists than King did.Although Malcolm X is more of an extremist, both men …

7.Compare And Contrast Mlk And Malcolm X - GraduateWay

Url:https://graduateway.com/compare-contrast-mlk-malcolm-x-2/

19 hours ago  · As far as Martin Luther is concerned, he is one of the richest man and is very educated. And Malcom X is a self-educated being who acquired his values and beliefs from his …

8.Difference between Martin Luther King and Malcolm X

Url:https://researchpedia.info/difference-between-martin-luther-king-and-malcolm-x/

27 hours ago Bit by bit, Malcolm began a process of engagement with the movement. He went to Washington and witnessed debate on the Civil Rights Bill of 1964, running into King in the process. "I'm …

9.Malcolm and the Civil Rights Movement | American …

Url:https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/malcolmx-and-civil-rights-movement/

7 hours ago  · The civil rights leaders did not see to eye to eye, and their encounter lasted minutes. On March 26, 1964, Malcolm X and Martin Luther King Jr. met for the first and only …

10.Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X Only Met Once

Url:https://www.biography.com/news/martin-luther-king-jr-malcolm-x-meeting

5 hours ago

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9