Knowledge Builders

how long did the amistad trial last

by Torey Heidenreich Published 2 years ago Updated 2 years ago
image

For 8 ½ hours, the 73-year-old Adams passionately and eloquently defended the Africans' right to freedom on both legal and moral grounds, referring to treaties prohibiting the slave trade and to the Declaration of Independence. The Supreme Court decided in favor of the Africans, stating that they were free individuals.Jun 2, 2021

Full Answer

See more

image

How did the Amistad case end?

The Verdict On March 9, 1841, the Supreme Court ruled 7-1 to uphold the lower courts' decisions in favor of the Africans of the Amistad. Justice Joseph Story delivered the majority opinion, writing that “There does not seem to us to be any ground for doubt, that these negroes ought to be deemed free.”

What happened to the Amistad slaves after they were freed?

The Court ordered the 35 surviving Africans to be freed immediately, and not put under federal custody for eventual transportation back to Africa. Abolitionists raised funds for the freed Amistad captives to be returned to Sierra Leone.

What was the Amistad trial?

In 1839, federal criminal trials were heard by the Circuit Court, presided over by a justice of the U. S. Supreme Court. Civil trials, with rare exceptions, were heard by the District Court. The first Amistad trial concerned the criminal charges of murder, mutiny, and piracy against the Africans of the Amistad.

How many slaves died on the Amistad?

Of those, at least 1.5 million are believed to have perished before even reaching shore, done in by the horrid conditions onboard ships. By the time of the Amistad rebellion, the United States and all other major destinations in North and South America had abolished the importation of enslaved people.

Who purchased the slaves on the Amistad?

Two Spanish plantation owners, Pedro Montes and Jose Ruiz, purchased 53 Africans and put them aboard the Cuban schooner Amistad to ship them to a Caribbean plantation.

Who returned the Amistad to the United States?

Judson, ruled in favor of the abolitionists and the Africans' position. In January 1840, he ordered for the Africans to be returned to their homeland by the U.S. government, and for one third of La Amistad and its cargo to be given to Lieutenant Gedney as salvage property.

Where is the Amistad now?

It was built at the Mystic Seaport Museum Shipyard and launched in 2000. Amistad returns to Mystic Seaport Museum on October 12, 2022.

How many children were on Amistad?

four childrenI am sure that you have heard of the slave ship Amistad, and the mutiny that took place on board. But did you know that there were four children on board the ship?

Why is the Amistad case important?

The Amistad Case is one of the most important to ever come before US courts. It influenced the abolitionist movement and proved that many influential people in the United States were in favor of abolishing slavery on the whole.

Where did the Amistad slaves go?

In January 1839, 53 African natives were kidnapped from eastern Africa and sold into the Spanish slave trade. They were then placed aboard a Spanish slave ship bound for Havana, Cuba.

What President helped in the Amistad?

Martin Van Buren was President of the United States during the Amistad trial. The Amistad incident placed Van Buren in a precarious situation.

Who ended slavery?

President Abraham LincolnOn February 1, 1865, President Abraham Lincoln approved the Joint Resolution of Congress submitting the proposed amendment to the state legislatures. The necessary number of states (three-fourths) ratified it by December 6, 1865.

Where did the Amistad slaves go?

In January 1839, 53 African natives were kidnapped from eastern Africa and sold into the Spanish slave trade. They were then placed aboard a Spanish slave ship bound for Havana, Cuba.

How did the Amistad case impact slavery?

At the end of a historic case, the U.S. Supreme Court rules, with only one dissent, that the enslaved Africans who seized control of the Amistad slave ship had been illegally forced into slavery, and thus are free under American law.

What impact did the Amistad case have on the slavery issue in America?

The Amistad Case is one of the most important to ever come before US courts. It influenced the abolitionist movement and proved that many influential people in the United States were in favor of abolishing slavery on the whole.

What happened to Cinque after Amistad?

Cinque returned to Africa with missionaries and the remaining Amistad survivors. After his return he discovered that his family could not be found and his entire village had been destroyed. It is suspected that his family was taken and sold into slavery.

What happened in the Amistad case?

In February of 1839, Portuguese slave hunters abducted a large group of Africans from Sierra Leone and shipped them to Havana, Cuba, a center for the slave trade. This abduction violated all of the treaties then in existence.

Where was the Amistad seized?

Additional Background Information. Montes and Ruiz actually steered the ship north; and on August 24, 1839, the Amistad was seized off Long Island, NY , by the U.S. brig Washington. The schooner, its cargo, and all on board were taken to New London, CT.

How many Amistad Africans were released?

The Court ordered the immediate release of the Amistad Africans. Thirty five of the survivors were returned to their homeland (the others died at sea or in prison while awaiting trial). Materials created by the National Archives and Records Administration are in the public domain.

Who was the leader of the Mutiny on the Amistad?

Read More... Warrant for Habeas Corpus Ordering Sengbe Pieh (Joseph Cinque), Leader of the Mutiny, and the Other Africans Who Were Aboard the Amistad to Appear in Court.

Who seized the Amistad?

The brig Washington that seized the Amistad was commanded by Lt. Thomas R. Gedney. In maritime law, compensation is allowed to persons whose assistance saves a ship or its cargo from impending loss. Lt. Gedney claimed that it was with great difficulty and danger that he and his crew were able to recapture the Amistad from the Africans. They claimed that, had they not seized the vessel, it would have been a total loss to its "rightful" owners. Gedney and his crew believed they were entitled to salvage rights (or the full $65,000). At that time in U.S. history, even individuals acting in their official capacity as officials of the government were entitled to salvage rights.

Why were the claims to the Africans as property not legitimate?

The district court ruled that the case fell within Federal jurisdiction and that the claims to the Africans as property were not legitimate because they were illegally held as slaves. The U.S. District Attorney filed an appeal to the Supreme Court.

Who captured the Amistad?

Yet they faced a formidable suite of opponents. The naval officers who captured the Amistad claimed salvage rights to both the vessel and its human cargo, as did two hunters who had come across some of the Africans looking for water along the Long Island shoreline. Ruiz and Montes likewise wanted their so-called property back, whereas the Spanish and U.S. governments requested that the Africans be returned to Cuba, where near-certain death awaited them. Believing the court would take his side, President Martin Van Buren sent a Navy ship to pick up the Africans and transport them away before the abolitionists could file an appeal.

Where did the Amistad go at night?

During the day, the two Spaniards set an eastward course, as they had been told to do. At night, however, they headed north and west in the hope of being rescued. After passing through the Bahamas, where the Amistad stopped on various small islands, it moved up the coast of the United States.

What did Ruiz and Montes do?

Ruiz and Montes, meanwhile, were relieved of their weapons, tied up and ordered to sail back to Sierra Leone. Having all grown up away from the ocean, the Africans depended on Ruiz and Montes for navigation. During the day, the two Spaniards set an eastward course, as they had been told to do.

What ship did the Amistad slaves go on?

Then, after several weeks, they and 500 or so other captives were loaded onto the Tecora, a Brazilian or Portuguese slave ship. According to testimony that the Amistad captives gave later, they were shackled around the ankles, wrists and neck and forced to sleep tightly together in contorted positions, with not enough headroom to even stand up straight. Whippings were handed out for even minor offenses, like not finishing breakfast, and each morning dead bodies were brought up from the lower deck and tossed into the ocean.

Why did the Amistad leave Havana?

On June 28, the Amistad left Havana under the cover of nightfall so as to best avoid British antislavery patrols. Onboard, the captives continued suffering severe mistreatment, including the pouring of salt, rum and gunpowder into freshly inflicted wounds.

Where did the Tecora land?

Following two months at sea, the Tecora landed in Havana, Cuba, then a Spanish colony, where potential buyers once again poked and prodded the surviving captives like livestock. Undeterred by the illegality of the transactions, José Ruiz purchased 49 adults and Pedro Montes purchased four children, with plans to bring them to sugar plantations a few hundred miles away in Puerto Príncipe (now Camagüey), Cuba. Ruiz and Montes, both Spaniards, then loaded the enslaved people onto the Amistad (which ironically means “Friendship” in Spanish).

How many people died in the Amistad Rebellion?

Of those, at least 1.5 million are believed to have perished before even reaching shore, done in by the horrid conditions onboard ships. By the time of the Amistad rebellion, the United States and all other major destinations in North and South America had abolished the importation of enslaved people. Yet since slavery itself remained legal in most ...

What was the U.S. vs. Amistad case?

The U.S. vs. Amistad began in February 1841. The U.S. case argued that, under treaty obligations, the captives be returned to Spain. Adams stated that American ideals of freedom demanded that the Pieh and the others be set free and returned to their homes in what is presently Sierra Leone. The Supreme Court ruled 7-1 on the side of the captive Africans. They found that they were not Span ish, were taken illegally from Africa, and should return to Africa. The majority decision stated:

What was the impact of the Amistad case on the Africans?

It went from being a fragmented group to a legitimate movement, and the Amistad case helped centralize their message about the injustice of slavery. This is just one story associated with the Amistad event.

What was the case of Pieh and the others?

While Pieh and the others were in a New Haven prison, their case was sent to the U.S. District Court (also the Old Statehouse ). A U.S. attorney, under direction from Secretary of State John Forsyth, presented Spain’s argument that the captives should be returned to Cuba. The African captive’s defense was organized by the Amistad Committee - a group of local abolitionists. They argued that Spanish law and international treaty forbade the importation of Africans for the slave trade. Pieh and the others described their kidnap, mistreatment, and sale into slavery. The District Court ruled that the African captives were not Spanish and should return to Africa.

What was the first civil rights case in the United States?

Funds for the trip were raised by the Amistad Committee. The Amistad court case is credited with being the first civil rights case in the United States.

What did the Supreme Court rule in the Pieh case?

Adams stated that American ideals of freedom demanded that the Pieh and the others be set free and returned to their homes in what is presently Sierra Leone. The Supreme Court ruled 7-1 on the side of the captive Africans.

Who appealed the Supreme Court decision?

The U.S. Attorney appealed the decision to the next highest court, the Circuit Court, which upheld the District Court's opinion. The U.S. Attorney then appealed the decision to the Supreme Court. The Amistad Committee approached former President and Secretary of State John Quincy Adamsand asked him to argue the defense before the Supreme Court.

Background

Sengbe Pieh, leader of the La Amistad uprising, pictured as a Muslim (1839). Beinecke Rare Book & Manuscript Library

Arguments before Supreme Court

On February 23, 1841, U.S. Attorney General Henry D. Gilpin began the oral argument phase before the Supreme Court. Gilpin first entered into evidence the papers of La Amistad, which stated that the Africans were Spanish property. Gilpin argued that the Court had no authority to rule against the validity of the documents.

Decision

On March 9, Associate Justice Joseph Story delivered the Court's decision. Article IX of Pinckney's Treaty was ruled inapplicable since the Africans in question had never been legal property. They were not criminals, as the U.S.

Aftermath and significance

The Africans greeted the news of the Supreme Court's decision with joy. Abolitionist supporters took the survivors – 36 men and boys and three girls – to Farmington, a village considered "Grand Central Station" on the Underground Railroad. Their residents had agreed to have the Africans stay there until they could return to their homeland.

What happened to the Amistad?

In the fight to liberate themselves the Africans killed two white crew members. Americans captured the ship on Long Island and took it to New London , Connecticut. Authorities then wrongly classified the men as runaway slaves, property, and murderers and imprisoned them in New Haven. The Mende captives ultimately underwent three separate trials, including a final appeal at the US Supreme Court, before finally being vindicated.

Where did the first trial take place?

But instead the prisoners’ ordeal moved to the District Court in New Haven, where the young interpreter’s skills proved invaluable in allowing the captives to tell their own stories to defense attorneys and the court.

What happened on July 2, 1839?

On July 2, 1839, the Africans seized the schooner Amistad from Portuguese slavers who planned to sell these free men as slaves in Cuba. In the fight to liberate themselves the Africans killed two white crew members. Americans captured the ship on Long Island and took it to New London, Connecticut.

Where was the Amistad towed?

American authorities charged the Mende with murder, imprisoned them in New Haven, Connecticut, and towed the Amistad to New London.

Who was the Captain of the Amistad?

Death of Capt. Ferrer, the Captain of the Amistad, July 1839, 1998.152.180 - Connecticut Historical Society. In early 1839, Portuguese slave hunters abducted a large group of African people in Sierra Leone and transported them aboard the slave ship Tecora to Havana, Cuba, for auction to the highest bidder. Two Spaniards, Don Pedro Montez and Don ...

When did the Mende case start?

The Supreme Court began hearing the case in January of 1841. American abolitionists rallied to the defense of the Mende, raising money to hire future Connecticut governor Roger Sherman Baldwin and former US president John Quincy Adams to represent them in court.

Did the Spanish enslave the Mende?

A district court judge then ruled that, as former free men living in Africa, the Spanish had no right to enslave the Mende. He ordered the captives released and returned to Africa. Once again, however, considerations of international diplomacy complicated the case.

What court was the first to hear the Amistad trial?

In 1839, federal criminal trials were heard by the Circuit Court , presided over by a justice of the U. S. Supreme Court. Civil trials, with rare exceptions, were heard by the District Court. The first Amistad trial concerned the criminal charges of murder, mutiny, and piracy against the Africans of the Amistad.

Who took possession of the Amistad?

On the 23d day of January, 1840, Thomas R. Gedney, and Richard W. Meade, officers of the United States surveying brig Washington, on behalf of themselves and the officers and crew of the brig Washington, and of others interested and entitled, filed a libel in the District Court of the United States, for the District of Connecticut, stating that off Culloden Point, near Montauck Point, they took possession of a vessel which proved to be a Spanish schooner called the Amistad, of Havana, in the island of Cuba, of about 120 tons burden; and the said libellants found said schooner was manned by forty-five negroes, some of whom had landed near the said point for water; and there were also on board, two Spanish gentlemen, who represented themselves to be, and, as the libellants verily believe were part owners of the cargo, and of the negroes on board, who were slaves, belonging to said Spanish gentlemen; that the schooner Amistad sailed on the 28th day of June, A.D. 1839 from the port of Havana, bound to a port in the province of Principe, both in the island of Cuba, under the command of Raymon Ferrer as master thereof: that the schooner had on board and was laden with a large and valuable cargo, and provisions, to the amount, in all, of forty thousand dollars, and also money to the sum and amount of about two hundred and fifty dollars; and also fifty-four slaves, to wit, fifty-one male slaves, and three young female slaves, who were worth twenty-five thousand dollars; and while on the voyage from Havana to Principe, the slaves rose upon the captain and crew of the schooner, and killed and murdered the captain and one of the crew, and two more of the crew escaped and got away from the schooner; that the two Spaniards on board, to wit, Pedro Montez, and Jose Ruiz, remained alive on board the schooner after the murder of the captain, and after the negroes had taken possession of the vessel and cargo; that their lives were spared to assist in the sailing of the vessel; and it was directed by the negroes, that the schooner should be navigated for the coast of Africa; and Pedro Montez, and Jose Ruiz did, accordingly, steer as thus directed and compelled by the negroes, at the peril of their lives, in the daytime, and in the night altered their course and steered for the American shore; but after two months on the ocean, they succeeded in coming round Montauck Point, then they were discovered in coming by the libellants, and the two Spanish gentlemen begged for and claimed the aid and protection of the libellants. That the schooner was accordingly taken possession of, and recaptured from the hands and possession of the negroes who had taken the same; that the schooner was brought into the port of New London, where she now is; and the schooner would with great difficulty, exposure, and danger have been taken by the libellants, but for the surprise upon the blacks who had possession thereof, a part of whom were on shore; and but for the aid and assistance and services of the libellants, the vessel and cargo would have been wholly lost to the respective owners thereof. That the cargo belongs to divers Spanish merchants and others, resident in the island of Cuba, and to Pedro Montez and Jose Ruiz, the latter owning most of the slaves.

What was the claim of Lieutenant Gedney and others to salvage on the alleged slaves dismissed?

The claim of Lieutenant Gedney and others to salvage on the alleged slaves was dismissed. The libels and claims of Ruiz and Montez being included under the claim of the minister of Spain, were ordered to be dismissed, with costs taxed against Ruiz and Montez respectively.

Who claimed the Amistad as slaves?

On the 29th of August, 1839, Jose Ruiz and Pedro Montez, of Cuba, filed claims to all the negroes on board of the Amistad , except Antonio, as their slaves. A part of the merchandise on board the vessel was also claimed by them. They alleged that the negroes had risen on the captain of the schooner, and had murdered him;

When did Ferrer say "Let pass in the schooner Amistad"?

Let pass in the schooner Amistad, to Guana ja, Ferrer, master. Havana, June 27th, 1839

Who is the master of the schooner Amistad?

Let pass in the schooner Amistad, to Guanaja, Ferrer, master.

Who presided over the Spanish ship trial?

Judge Smith Thompson presided as the criminal trial began on September 19, 1839. After three days of arguments, Judge Thompson ruled that the court had no jurisdiction over the charges, because the alleged crimes had been committed on a Spanish ship in Spanish waters and were therefore not crimes punishable under U. S. law.

image

1.Amistad Case - Date, Facts & Significance - HISTORY

Url:https://www.history.com/topics/abolitionist-movement/amistad-case

26 hours ago How long did the Amistad trial last? Gilpins argument lasted two hours. John Quincy Adams, former president of the United States and at that time a U.S. Representative from …

2.How the Amistad Rebellion, and Its Extraordinary Trial, …

Url:https://www.history.com/news/the-amistad-slave-rebellion-175-years-ago

12 hours ago On August 26, the Amistad was seized by the U.S Brig Washington in Long Island, New York. All were taken to New London, CT. The Amistad Trial relation to the Talcott Street church is …

3.Amistad: Legal Battle (U.S. National Park Service)

Url:https://www.nps.gov/articles/amistad-legal-battle.htm

11 hours ago  · The U.S. vs. Amistad began in February 1841. The U.S. case argued that, under treaty obligations, the captives be returned to Spain. Adams stated that American ideals of …

4.United States v. The Amistad - Wikipedia

Url:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._The_Amistad

24 hours ago The Amistad civil case was tried before District Judge Andrew Judson. The trial began on November 19, 1839 in Hartford. After testimony was taken on November 20, the trial adjourned …

5.A Different Look at the Amistad Trial: The Teenager Who …

Url:https://connecticuthistory.org/a-different-look-at-the-amistad-trial-the-teenager-who-helped-save-the-mende-captives/

25 hours ago

6.The Amistad - Connecticut History | a CTHumanities Project

Url:https://connecticuthistory.org/the-amistad/

11 hours ago

7.The Amistad Affair: A Trial History - law2.umkc.edu

Url:http://law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/amistad/AMI_TRI.HTM

23 hours ago

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9