Knowledge Builders

is baseboard heat the same as radiant heat

by Trace Dietrich Published 3 years ago Updated 2 years ago
image

While both baseboard heating systems and electric radiant heating systems use similar concepts, they are certainly not created equal. Efficiency: Baseboard heaters aren't exactly known for their efficiency.

Baseboard heating is a hot trend for the coldest climates, providing a good choice for homes where the area experiences temperatures near or below freezing regularly. Radiant floor heating 1 warms cold feet and heats a room evenly, eliminating cold corners.Mar 13, 2017

Full Answer

How energy efficient is electric baseboard heat?

On a technical level, yes, baseboard heaters are efficient in that they convert all incoming energy into heat. This specific system also typically warms your home in zones, meaning that you can control different rooms of your home with different thermostats—definitely a checkmark on the energy-efficient list.

Are baseboard heaters bad?

Baseboard heaters can be unsafe near flammable or combustible material. Fire departments recommend keeping all furniture, rugs, beds, and curtains—so most household items, to be safe—at least 12 inches away from baseboard heaters. These installations can also be hazardous for little ones wandering about the house.

How efficient are hydronic baseboard heaters?

Hydronic baseboard heaters are 40% more efficient than forced-air heating systems, more compact, and lack moving parts too. This allows them to require less maintenance, take up less space and keep going for decades.

Why is my hot water baseboard heater not working?

How do I know if my baseboard heater is working?

  • Look for a tripped breaker in the thermostat
  • Look for faulty wiring in the circuit breaker panel
  • In the end, start the heater and see if it’s functioning at all

image

What is the difference between radiant and baseboard heat?

Generally, radiant heating systems take a longer time to heat the entire room. However, once the heat spreads throughout the home, the space remains warm for a longer time. On the other hand, baseboard systems are often used to distribute heat only where it's needed.

Is baseboard heat radiant heat?

Baseboard Radiators The heated water is distributed through pipes into baseboards in various rooms. The heat is then delivered through radiation and convection. Although these are called radiant heating systems, most of the heat delivered is by convection.

What type of heating is baseboard heating?

zone heatingElectric baseboard heating systems — also known as electric resistance heating — is a form of zone heating that individually creates and controls the temperature in each room of your home. There are no furnaces, boilers, heating ducts, vents or blowers involved in distributing the heat.

Can you mix radiant heat with baseboard heat?

Floor Heating Because it doesn't require ductwork, radiant heat flooring is an efficient way to heat a home and can be used in conjunction with other types of heating, such as forced-air furnaces and baseboard heaters. This is a good option for home additions to avoid the cost of running more ductwork into the space.

How do you keep your house warm with baseboard heat?

0:081:43DIY with Dave: How to make your baseboard heating more efficient.YouTubeStart of suggested clipEnd of suggested clipRight off the bat. Make sure to keep a close eye on that thermostat. And adjust it based on what youMoreRight off the bat. Make sure to keep a close eye on that thermostat. And adjust it based on what you're up to if you're just hanging out and reading poetry like I am 21 degrees Celsius is.

What is the disadvantage of baseboard electric heat?

The Cons of Electric Baseboard Heating Best used for supplemental heating needs, the biggest cons of electrical baseboard heating are centered on their annual heating costs. Across the US, natural gas is almost always a less expensive way to heat your home.

Can you leave baseboard heaters on all the time?

Yes, while baseboard heaters are considered very safe, and the risk of fire is pretty low if misused, there is a risk of fire. Here are some safety and maintenance tips for preventing fire and to maximize the heating capabilities in a room. Don't Block the Airflow.

Why is baseboard heat so expensive?

The upfront cost of installing electric baseboard heating is less expensive compared to other types of heating, but it can be more expensive in the long-term because it isn't as efficient. One reason is because baseboard placement often results in heat leaving the home.

Do you need a furnace with baseboard heating?

Typically hardwired into the circuitry of the home with either a 120-volt or 240-volt supply, this type of baseboard heater doesn't require a furnace, boiler, or any other additional equipment. Operationally, electric baseboards depend on convection: The unit pulls cooler air in through a vent.

What are the disadvantages of radiant heating?

Cons of Radiant Floor HeatingInstallation Cost. When estimating the cost of an installation, a safe cost estimation bracket is between $10 to $20 per square foot dependant on the type of system you choose for your home. ... Installation Time. ... Floor Height Issue.

Can you heat an entire house with radiant heat?

Yes! While it generally is room-specific (i.e., for the kitchen or bathroom, where you are standing a great deal, or might be in bare feet), it is a viable and effective way to heat your home. If you plan to use radiant heating to heat your whole house, the hot water method (hydronic) is recommended.

Can you put wood floors over radiant heat?

Thanks to advances in the heated floor industry, you can install hardwood floors over radiant heat - with confidence. That means you can enjoy the natural beauty of oak, ash, cherry, maple, hickory, walnut and other fine hardwoods and the comfort and efficiency of radiant heating.

What does baseboard heat run off of?

Baseboard Heating 101 Most baseboard heating systems run directly off of electricity, although some homes utilize a hydronic or liquid-based system. A baseboard heating system operates through a similar process as your oven does – circulating convection air currents.

Do baseboard heaters heat well?

Baseboard heating is often more efficient than radiators, and they are even more efficient when they are run constantly, instead of being turned on and off. They also take up valuable real estate along the edges of rooms in your home, often limiting arrangements of furniture and home decor.

Can you heat a house with baseboard heaters?

They don't blow dust throughout the house, a common nuisance with most forced-air systems, and baseboard heaters can be used as the main heating source for your home, as an affordable way to supplement an existing heating system, or to provide heat to a newly added room or particularly cold corner of the house.

Is electric baseboard heat considered central heat?

The heater pulls cool air in and uses a convection process (the circulation of warm and cool air) to heat each room. Doesn't have a central unit. Unlike central heating systems, electric baseboard heaters are stand-alone appliances that heat each individual room or interior space.

What is Baseboard Heating?

Electric baseboard heaters are typically sold in two-foot to eight-foot lengths and can be 120 volt or 240 volt (240 is more efficient). They operate primarily through convection, by heating a coil that is surrounded by air fins, allowing the heat to naturally rise and heat the air in the room.

Common Ground when Comparing Radiant Floor Heating vs. Baseboard Heating

Both methods of heating share some common ground: they offer the homeowner autonomy in selecting which areas of the home are to be heated. Both are silent and both operate without disturbing the surrounding air with blown-in allergens and dust.

Where to Buy a Supplemental Heating Solution

Warmup is the world’s best-selling electric floor heating brand and has been an innovator in the electric radiant floor heating industry for over 25 years. Their DCM-PRO Uncoupling System with the anti-fracture membrane provides Warmup with the confidence necessary to guarantee the mat and cable for life.

How efficient is baseboard heating?

Baseboard heating is most effective in rooms with large windows in cold climates, but the cost of running an electric unit is much higher. Baseboard heating works most efficiently in spaces from 50 to 200 square feet.

How does radiant floor heating work?

Radiant floor heating 1 systems come in two varieties: a boiler-based hydronic system and an electric coil system. The heat source for a hydronic radiant floor system is a boiler centrally located in the home. The heat the boiler produces is transferred to PEX tubing carrying hot water beneath the home’s flooring. If electric power is used, heating coils are located beneath the floor instead. Electric systems are best used as an add-on in a specific room or area, such as in a small bathroom or near a vanity, whereas hydronic systems are intended to heat an entire house. Because the coils or tubing are spread throughout the room under the floor, the room is more evenly heated. However, the radiant system makes heating a cold room a slower process. Once the heat rises from the floor, the room will remain warm longer than with baseboard heat.

How much does a hydronic radiant heater cost?

On average, hydronic radiant heating systems cost between $6,000 and $14,000. If you’re installing an electric system in a small space like a bathroom, costs average around $700. Buying and installing electric baseboard heaters in a home will cost between $472 and $788 each for quality, long-lasting units. For a three-bedroom, 1,400-square-foot ...

Why is radiant floor heating so expensive?

Radiant floor heating is a more expensive option because of the labor needed to install the system and ensure it is properly anchored to the existing subfloor. Further, the need for either a radiant x-block installed to your existing hot water heater or a full boiler system for larger projects will increase costs.

Why do baseboard heaters need to be spaced?

Baseboard units produce heat concentrated around the exterior walls of the home in order to provide a cushion of warm air between the frigid outdoors and the home’s interior. In order to maintain this warmth, baseboard heaters must be carefully spaced beneath each window and along exterior walls.

How do baseboards work?

Most baseboard systems are controlled by thermostats 2 in each room, allowing the homeowner to distribute heat only where it is needed. On the other hand, radiant floor systems are sometimes controlled by a central thermostat. A more expensive option can give control to each room.

What is the difference between hydronic and electric?

Electric systems are best used as an add-on in a specific room or area, such as in a small bathroom or near a vanity, whereas hydronic systems are intended to heat an entire house. Because the coils or tubing are spread throughout the room under the floor, the room is more evenly heated.

Where is the baseboard heating system located?

Baseboard heating systems are typically located on the outside walls of the space . The higher temperature of the baseboard heaters create a current of heat that travels up the wall and across the ceiling cooling as it goes.

How to prevent fire in baseboard heater?

To prevent the risk of fire, clean your baseboard heaters regularly. Dust, loose hair and other objects may cause fire. Always check for items that may be stuck inside baseboard heating units, including small pieces of paper or fabric. Always call a professional electrician when you encounter problems.”

How many watts does a thermoray heater use?

ThermaRay RCHS typically require 6-8 watts per sq.ft. because it is spread evenly across the entire room. The RCHS also creates the aforementioned thermal mass which exponentially lowers operating costs. In colder climates electric baseboard heaters are 3-4 times more expensive to operate than a ThermaRay electric radiant ceiling heating system.

Where is the ThermaRay radiant ceiling?

Most ThermaRay radiant ceiling heating systems are installed between the rafters/trusses and above the sheet rock, steel or wood ceiling.

Is ThermaRay radiant heating good?

ThermaRay radiant heating systems not only create a comfortable environment, but a healthy one as well. Radiant heat, like the sun is the natural way to warm any space. The transference of heat without any moving parts. No fans or blowing or blowing dust and airborne contaminants and No Tick Tick Tick of contracting and expanding thin baseboard metal as it get hot or cools down.

Is radiant ceiling heating evenly placed over the entire room?

Radiant ceiling heating system is evenly placed over the entire room and warm everything equally in the entire space.

Does radiant heat rise?

Although it is a fact that hot air rises, radiant heat does Not. Radiant rays travel in straight lines like a flashlight light until it hits an object that can absorb that warmth.

What happens when you draw cold air into the bottom of a heater?

While the hot air is dispensed from the top of the heater, it is also drawing cold air into the bottom. The heater will continue this process until the air entering the bottom of the heater is the same as the temperature set on the thermostat.

How much does glassheat reduce watts?

Glassheat reduced the watts used per day from 11% to 61% when compared to electric baseboard heat.

Is Glassheat radiant heating more efficient than baseboard heating?

Under control conditions (as documented in the report) the Glassheat heating system was found to be much more energy efficient than the electric baseboard heating system. In addition, the Glassheat system provided more uniform heat distribution throughout the study areas than did the electric baseboard system.

Do baseboard heaters need ductwork?

Although they are by no means the most effective form of heating, baseboard heaters do have their advantages, namely that they require little space, need no ductwork and the initial cost is relatively low.

Is glass heat better than baseboard heat?

With Glassheat heating the heat distribution was about 31% better (more uniform) than with electric baseboard heat.

Why do boilers have to have high water temperature?

Conventional boilers must have return water temperatures high enough to prevent sustained condensation on the fire-side of the boiler, or within the flue pipe. Water vapor is a byproduct of combustion, and if allowed to condense, it can cause severe corrosion. Flue pipes are especially vulnerable, and can fail in a matter of weeks when condensation is present. This could allow toxic gases to be released into the building.

What temperature should a boiler return water be?

Typically, the return water temperature for a gas- or oil-fired boiler should be 140°F or higher to prevent condensation. Since radiant systems operate with a return water temperature in the range of 80° to 100°F, their return water must be mixed with hotter water before it is sent back to the boiler. There are two simple ways to do this — with a four-way valve or with injection mixing.

image

1.Radiant Floor Heating vs. Baseboard Heating: What is the …

Url:https://www.warmup.com/blog/radiant-floor-heating-vs-baseboard-heating

28 hours ago  · Common Ground when Comparing Radiant Floor Heating vs. Baseboard Heating Both methods of heating share some common ground: they offer the homeowner autonomy in …

2.Radiant Floor Heating vs. Baseboard Heating: What is the …

Url:https://www.warmup.ca/blog/radiant-heat-vs-baseboard

10 hours ago  · They found that the Radiant Ceiling System was 33% more efficient than the ASHP and 52% more efficient than Baseboards.he rule of thumb for baseboard heating systems is 10 …

3.Radiant Heat vs. Baseboard Heating (Part I)

Url:http://www.bestradiantheating.com/radiant-articles/radiant-vs-baseboard1.php

14 hours ago  · With the assumption that lower operation temp is more efficient you can see that radiant is likely to be more economical (on the order of, say, 118deg for baseboard heat, and …

4.Radiant Ceiling vs Baseboard Heating Analysis Reveals

Url:https://premierenergyusa.com/radiant-ceiling-vs-baseboard-heating/

13 hours ago Yes you can have baseboard radiators and in-floor radiant. "Can they be in the same loop or zone?" That may not be the best way to plumb, as the radiators and in-floor will likely require …

5.Radiant Heat vs. Baseboard - Fine Homebuilding

Url:https://www.finehomebuilding.com/forum/radiant-heat-vs-baseboard

35 hours ago  · So I want to know if i can put insulation around the entire baseboard from wall to floor. I want to completely block the heat on my apartment. I already call this place to turn the …

6.Radiant Baseboard Heating

Url:https://www.radiant-floor-heating.com/radiant-baseboard-heating/

31 hours ago

7.baseboard heat and radiant floor heat - Houzz

Url:https://www.houzz.com/discussions/2397760/baseboard-heat-and-radiant-floor-heat

22 hours ago

8.Q&A: Combining Radiant and Baseboard Heat | JLC Online

Url:https://www.jlconline.com/business/q-a-combining-radiant-and-baseboard-heat_o

25 hours ago

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9