Server headers are generally easy for an attacker to manipulate. However, a comparison of existing server headers does not provide sufficient protection against CSRF attacks, which is why a matching CSRF token is necessary. A CSRF token should be sent with every action that can result in a change of status.
Do I need CSRF?
So, as a rule of thumb, whenever you use cookies and sessions for requests to validate a user, i.e. to confirm or establish trust in a user, use CSRF protection. Since you want to establish trust in your user when he signs up, the same applies.
What is the point of CSRF?
Definition. Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF) is an attack that forces authenticated users to submit a request to a Web application against which they are currently authenticated.
Do you need CSRF on login page?
Yes. In general, you need to secure your login forms from CSRF attacks just as any other. Otherwise your site is vulnerable to a sort of "trusted domain phishing" attack. In short, a CSRF-vulnerable login page enables an attacker to share a user account with the victim.
Is it safe to disable CSRF?
Yes, it is safe to disable if you have a different authentication mechanism that cannot be cloaked. For internal enterprise applications, not much of a concern. We had to disable it because it was interfering with our existing authentication mechanism.
Can a CSRF token be stolen?
Stealing Anti-CSRF Tokens: When CSRF tokens are passed as cookie parameters without Secure and HTTPOnly flags, an attacker can potentially steal the CSRF token via XSS or other attacks.
What is CSRF and how do you prevent it?
What Are CSRF Tokens. The most popular method to prevent Cross-site Request Forgery is to use a challenge token that is associated with a particular user and that is sent as a hidden value in every state-changing form in the web app.
Should CSRF token be in cookie?
CSRF tokens should not be transmitted using cookies. Inserting the CSRF token in the custom HTTP request header via JavaScript is considered more secure than adding the token in the hidden field form parameter because it uses custom request headers.
Is CSRF token necessary for REST API?
The CSRF token is required for any later REST API calls. The client must send a valid token with every API request. The token is sent in a custom request HTTP header. The name of the custom header is X-IBM-SPM-CSRF.
Does JWT prevent CSRF?
CSRF protection using the power of JWTs. Provides a number of stateless methods of csrf protection, if you don't want to keep a session. Defaults to the double submit method of csrf protection, but supports a number of different strategies.
Why should we disable CSRF?
It is an attack that forces an end user to execute unwanted actions on a web application in which they are currently authenticated. CSRF attacks specifically target state-changing requests, not theft of data, since the attacker has no way to see the response to the forged request.
Is CSRF illegal?
3. Example of a CSRF attack using a GET request. When the user clicked the malicious, the hacker leads the user to the malicious web application that does the job of sending illegal request. The request considered to be Illegal because the user is not aware of the request sent.
What is the difference between CORS and CSRF?
Using CSRF, that website could execute actions with the user's Mixmax credentials. We previously discussed using CORS to secure user data, while allowing some cross-origin access. CORS handles this vulnerability well, and disallows the retrieval and inspection of data from another Origin.
Why do CSRF attacks work?
CSRF takes advantage of web applications that allow attackers to predict all the details of a particular action. Since browsers send credentials like session cookies automatically, attackers can create malicious web pages which generate forged requests that are indistinguishable from legitimate ones.
Why is CSRF difficult to detect?
"CSRF attacks are also very difficult to detect, because they look very much like a legitimate request from a trusted user." OWASP currently ranks CSRF attacks as the number eight most common and critical Web application vulnerability, down from the five spot since the last list was compiled.
What is the result of CSRF attacks?
CSRF attacks target functionality that causes a state change on the server, such as changing the victim's email address or password, or purchasing something. Forcing the victim to retrieve data doesn't benefit an attacker because the attacker doesn't receive the response, the victim does.
What is the difference between CSRF and XSS?
What is the difference between XSS and CSRF? Cross-site scripting (or XSS) allows an attacker to execute arbitrary JavaScript within the browser of a victim user. Cross-site request forgery (or CSRF) allows an attacker to induce a victim user to perform actions that they do not intend to.
What is CSRF?
Cross-site request forgery (also known as CSRF) is a web security vulnerability that allows an attacker to induce users to perform actions that they do not intend to perform. It allows an attacker to partly circumvent the same origin policy, which is designed to prevent different websites from interfering with each other.
What is the impact of a CSRF attack?
In a successful CSRF attack, the attacker causes the victim user to carry out an action unintentionally. For example, this might be to change the email address on their account, to change their password, or to make a funds transfer. Depending on the nature of the action, the attacker might be able to gain full control over the user's account. If the compromised user has a privileged role within the application, then the attacker might be able to take full control of all the application's data and functionality.
Why use HTTP referer header?
Aside from defenses that employ CSRF tokens, some applications make use of the HTTP Referer header to attempt to defend against CSRF attacks, normally by verifying that the request originated from the application's own domain. This approach is generally less effective and is often subject to bypasses.
How to defend against CSRF attacks?
The most robust way to defend against CSRF attacks is to include a CSRF token within relevant requests. The token should be:
Why are CSRF vulnerabilities so interesting?
Most interesting CSRF vulnerabilities arise due to mistakes made in the validation of CSRF tokens.
Why is double submit defense used?
This is sometimes called the "double submit" defense against CSRF, and is advocated because it is simple to implement and avoids the need for any server-side state: In this situation, the attacker can again perform a CSRF attack if the web site contains any cookie setting functionality.
How to deliver cross site request forgery?
This might be done by feeding the user a link to the web site, via an email or social media message. Or if the attack is placed into a popular web site (for example, in a user comment), they might just wait for users to visit the web site.
What happens when you submit a form to a server?
When the user submits the form, the server simply has to compare the value of the posted field csrf-token (the name doesn’t matter) with the CSRF token remembered by the server. If both strings are equal, the server may continue to process the form. Otherwise the server should immediately stop processing the form and respond with an error.
What is CSRF token?
A CSRF token is a random, hard-to-guess string. On a page with a form you want to protect, the server would generate a random string, the CSRF token, add it to the form as a hidden field and also remember it somehow, either by storing it in the session or by setting a cookie containing the value.
Why is my bad guy not able to code a CSRF?
Because the bad guy’s malicious page is loaded by your user’s browser from a different domain (b.com instead of a.com), the bad guy has no chance to code a JavaScript, that loads the content and therefore our user’s current CSRF token from your website. That is because web browsers don’t allow cross-domain AJAX requests by default.
How does a Twitter server know who posted a tweet?
On the server the user is identified by a cookie containing their unique session ID, so your server knows who posted the Tweet.
Why is copying static code useless?
Copying the static source code from our page to a different website would be useless, because the value of the hidden field changes with each user. Without the bad guy’s website knowing the current user’s CSRF token your server would always reject the POST request.
What is a token on my bank?
That token is a huge, impossible-to-guess random number that mybank.com will include on their own web page when they serve it to you. It is different each time they serve any page to anybody.
How many reputations do you need to answer a highly active question?
Highly active question. Earn 10 reputation (not counting the association bonus) in order to answer this question. The reputation requirement helps protect this question from spam and non-answer activity.
What is CSRF?
Cross-Site Request Forgery, often abbreviated as CSRF, is a possible attack that can occur when a malicious website, blog, email message, instant message, or web application causes a user’s web browser to perform an undesired action on a trusted site at which the user is currently authenticated. The impact of a CSRF attack is determined by the capabilities exposed within the vulnerable application. CSRF attacks are, on the most basic level, used by an attacker to make a target system perform any available and malicious function via the target's browser without knowledge of the target user. This function usually is not known by the victim until after it has occurred as well.
What is the same site cookie?
The Same-Site Cookie attribute is a newly developed attribute that can be set on cookies to instruct the browser to disable third-party usage for specific cookies. This attribute is set by the server while at the same time setting the cookie itself, and requests the browser to only send the cookie in a first-party context. Because of this, the request has to originate from the same location. Therefore, requests made by third-party sites can not include the same-site Cookie. This effectively eliminates CSRF without requiring the use of synchronizer tokens. The only downside is that Same-Site Cookies are only available in some modern browsers.
What is CSRF attack?
CSRF attacks are, on the most basic level, used by an attacker to make a target system perform any available and malicious function via the target's browser without knowledge of the target user. This function usually is not known by the victim until after it has occurred as well.
What is the best way to prevent cross site request forgery?
The recommended and most widely adopted prevention method for Cross-site Request Forgery is an anti-CSRF token, otherwise known as a synchronizer token. When a user submits information or interacts with the site, or does anything else that generates a cookie, the anti-CSRF token should also be included with the cookie request. This request then gets run through a verification process, wherein the authenticity or even existence of this token is verified before processing the request. If the token is missing or incorrect, the request can be rejected.
What happens if a CSRF attack is successful?
The Impact of a successful CSRF attack can vary greatly depending on the privileges of the victim. If the target is a basic user, everything from their personal information to site privileges can be compromised. While that sounds bad, if an administrator account is compromised, an attack can cripple the entire site.
What is CSRF used for?
Some common uses of CSRF include: Transfer money from one bank account to another. Your online session at your bank becomes compromised, and treats this like a legitimate request and sends $1000 from your account to Mallory’s account.
Why is CSRF important?
CSRF attacks can be used on a huge array of sites. If a site allows data to be altered on the user side, then it is a potential target for an attacker. With some of the fixes listed , above, your website can guarantee a much higher level of security. on a wide-range of sites.
Why does CSRF happen?
Is the authentication provided by browser (not limited to cookies) - CSRF happens because authentication information is included in the request by browser irrespective of whether the request was started by the user, or some other open tab. So any kind of authentication in which browser can self include information needs CSRF protection. That includes both cookie based sessions and basic authentication.
What happens if you store tokens in local storage?
Answer : If you store the token in the localStorage and append it to your requests with JS, it would automatically guarantee CSRF protection (by the nature of the attack)
What does it mean when a cookie is stored in a session ID?
If a session id is stored in a cookie the browser will automatically send it along with all requests that go back to the original website. This means that an attacker doesn't actually have to know authentication details to take an action as the victim user.
What is XSS vulnerability?
XSS is application level vulnerability , but its effects can be mitigated by limiting the power of the token through the usage of claims (restrict to minimum necessary)
What does HTTP only do in XSS?
With a cookie you can set the http-only flag, which prevents the application from reading the cookie after it is set. As a result, in the event of an XSS attack, the attacker can still make calls on your behalf, but they can't walk away with the authorization token all together.
Why is client-side statelessness important?
I think it is worth a quick note that one reason that client-side statelessness is important for REST applications is that the ability of intermediaries to cache responses is also a desirable part of the REST paradigm . As long as the application is tracking client-side state, caching is not possible.
What is state changing action?
Is the request doing a state changing action (not the same as REST API Statelessness) - State changing actions are any action that will change the state of the application.. for example delete something, add something, update something. These are actions using which the application will change the backed state of the user. All Post requests and a few Get requests will come under this category. REST APIs can have state changing actions.
What is malicious request?
An attacker sends malicious requests to a site where the user visits an attacker believes that the victim is validated against that particular site.
How can an attacker enter a website?
An attacker can enter into a website by bypassing the authentication process using a CSRF attack.
Why are cookies vulnerable to CSRF?
Cookies are vulnerable as they are sent automatically with the request, allowing attackers to implement CSRF and send malicious requests. The effect of a CSRF vulnerability also depends on the victim’s privilege, whose Cookie is being sent with the attacker’s request. While data retrieval is not the main scope of a CSRF attack, state changes will surely have an adverse effect on the web application being exploited. So it is advised to prevent your website from using preventive methods to safeguard your website against CSRF.
What is cross origin request?
There are some cookies associated with an origin or website, and when a request is sent to that particular origin, cookies are sent along with it. Such requests are called cross-origin requests. While this process, cookies are sent to third parties, which makes CSRF attacks possible.
What is CSRF in email?
Cross-Site Reference Forgery is also referred to as CSRF, and sometimes XSRF. It is a type of fraud attack’ that utilizes the user’s credentials for entering the website and accesses the user’s data. It is usually executed by prompting an unknown link or page advertisement, asking the user to click on it and leading it to deceive malware. Another method of attracting a user into CSRF is by sending scam links in emails or SMS and encouraging them to access the links provided.
How to stop cross site request forgery?
The most common implementation to stop Cross-site Request Forgery (CSRF) is to use a token that is related to a selected user and may be found as a hidden form in each state, dynamic form present on the online application.
When does the browser send cookies?
It is done by the server while setting the cookie; it then requests the browser to send the cookie only when the user is using the web application directly.
Setup
This article assumes you already have a backend that provides a CSRF token solution.
Approach 1: A cookie
The client initializes CSRF protection by calling an endpoint on the API server that sets a cookie with httpOnly set to false holding the CSRF token
Approach 2: An API endpoint
The backend needs to provide an API endpoint (e.g. /csrf) that returns a CSRF token