Knowledge Builders

is radiant floor heating more efficient than baseboard

by Cassie Wilderman Published 2 years ago Updated 2 years ago
image

Radiant heating has a number of advantages. It is more efficient than baseboard heating and usually more efficient than forced-air heating because it eliminates duct losses. People with allergies often prefer radiant heat because it doesn't distribute allergens like forced air systems can.

How energy efficient is electric baseboard heat?

On a technical level, yes, baseboard heaters are efficient in that they convert all incoming energy into heat. This specific system also typically warms your home in zones, meaning that you can control different rooms of your home with different thermostats—definitely a checkmark on the energy-efficient list.

Are baseboard heaters bad?

Baseboard heaters can be unsafe near flammable or combustible material. Fire departments recommend keeping all furniture, rugs, beds, and curtains—so most household items, to be safe—at least 12 inches away from baseboard heaters. These installations can also be hazardous for little ones wandering about the house.

How efficient are hydronic baseboard heaters?

Hydronic baseboard heaters are 40% more efficient than forced-air heating systems, more compact, and lack moving parts too. This allows them to require less maintenance, take up less space and keep going for decades.

Why is my hot water baseboard heater not working?

How do I know if my baseboard heater is working?

  • Look for a tripped breaker in the thermostat
  • Look for faulty wiring in the circuit breaker panel
  • In the end, start the heater and see if it’s functioning at all

image

Does radiant floor heat save money?

Radiant heat provides an average saving of 15% on heating bills thanks to the efficient way it warms a home. Once installed, underfloor heating needs virtually no maintenance and comes with a 30 Year Guarantee for total peace of mind.

Do radiant floors use a lot of electricity?

If you've ever wondered, “Do heated floors use a lot of electricity?”, the answer is: less than you would think. In reality, a radiant heating system for a small bathroom uses about the same amount of energy as a freezer.

How much more efficient is radiant floor heating?

15%However, with radiant heating, the floors are heated directly, resulting in less lost energy. Radiant floors are so energy efficient that they save an average of 15% on heating bills.

What are the cons of radiant floor heating?

Cons of Radiant Floor HeatingInstallation Cost. When estimating the cost of an installation, a safe cost estimation bracket is between $10 to $20 per square foot dependant on the type of system you choose for your home. ... Installation Time. ... Floor Height Issue.

Can you heat a whole house with radiant floor heating?

Yes! While it generally is room-specific (i.e., for the kitchen or bathroom, where you are standing a great deal, or might be in bare feet), it is a viable and effective way to heat your home. If you plan to use radiant heating to heat your whole house, the hot water method (hydronic) is recommended.

Are radiant floors worth it?

Radiant floor heating is one of the most energy-efficient ways to heat your home. In fact, they are considered at least 20 to 25% more energy-efficient than forced-air heating systems.

Should I turn off radiant floor heating in summer?

Underfloor heating can be switched off during Summer when the outside temperature is warm enough. This is because it takes longer to warm up and cool down than other heating methods, making it harder to adjust your settings when the outside temperature is warming your home.

What is the most efficient heating system?

In general, furnaces are the most efficient of the heating systems, especially if you have natural gas. They work by heating air with a component called a heat exchanger and pushing it into the home through a duct system, using a fan (often referred to as a blower).

Do radiant heaters use a lot of electricity?

How Much Energy Does It Use? Electric radiant floor heating systems are generally very efficient and use as much or less energy than other heating systems.

How long will radiant floor heat last?

An average radiant floor heating system has a lifespan of 50 years. However, the life expectancy of radiant heating systems varies depending on the kind of components used in the design. For example, regular boilers can last up to 20 years, while tankless boilers have a much longer lifespan.

How long does radiant flooring last?

In-floor radiant heat systems are durable and reliable, capable of outlasting your home furnace. With proper care and maintenance, a floor heating system can last up to 35 years.

Can you have AC with radiant heat?

Sure you can. In fact, separate heating and cooling systems really make the most sense. Radiant floor heating keeps the heat near the floor where it does the most good; and air conditioning ductwork is placed only where it is needed to cool your home. The result is optimal comfort and efficiency all year 'round.

Do radiant heaters use less electricity?

Infrared heaters use 30 to 40 % less energy than regular heaters. Compared to other forms of electric heating such as portable radiant space heaters, infrared heaters are much more efficient. Therefore, they save on electricity use and costs. Infrared heaters do not heat the air but heat people and objects directly.

Can you leave heated floors on all the time?

It is advised that in the depths of winter, an underfloor heating system should be kept on at all times. Although it should be at different temperatures depending on usage and activity in the house. This is because underfloor heating can take two to three hours to warm up, so it is best to not completely turn it off.

What is the most efficient way to run underfloor heating?

For an efficient system and quick response times, set your underfloor heating temperature to 16°C in “off” periods. This will result in a quicker warm up time as the heating system needs to supply less energy.

Does radiant heat use electricity?

Radiant heating systems require either natural gas or electricity as a fuel source. In the case of electricity, the components are heated by electrical resistance.

What is Radiant Floor Heating?

Radiant floor heating utilizes a series of heat cables that run below your finished floor to provide a silent, safe and evenly-distributed blanket of heat across the entire room by convection and radiation. Unlike conventional HVAC units that blow hot air around the room, along with all of the dust and allergens in the air, electric radiant heat doesn’t require noisy fans or any mechanical equipment to move the heat. Hot air naturally rises from the surface of the floor, heating the entire room at the same time without leaving uncomfortable cold spots.

How much more does it cost to heat a room with baseboard heat than with a HVAC unit?

In fact, it costs 2-3 times more to heat a room with baseboard heat than with a HVAC unit. All the money saved in installation is lost in operating costs. The unit only heats the area directly in front of it, leaving cold spots in the room.

How many volts does a baseboard heater use?

What is Baseboard Heating? Electric baseboard heaters are typically sold in two-foot to eight-foot lengths and can be 120 volt or 240 volt (240 is more efficient). They operate primarily through convection, by heating a coil that is surrounded by air fins, allowing the heat to naturally rise and heat the air in the room.

What is warmup heating?

Warmup is the world’s best-selling electric floor heating brand and has been an innovator in the electric radiant floor heating industry for over 25 years . Their DCM-PRO Uncoupling System with the anti-fracture membrane provides Warmup with the confidence necessary to guarantee the mat and cable for life. They have simplified the installation process, making comfortable radiant floor heating available to most homeowners.

What are the drawbacks of underfloor radiant flooring?

The primary drawback to the underfloor radiant system is that your existing flooring will need to be replaced so that the new grid can be installed beneath it. This is actually a benefit if you are completing a remodel, since the flooring would be replaced anyway.

Why are heat pumps mounted in front of windows?

They are usually mounted in front of windows so that much of the heat that is distributed is lost heating up the cold air at the window. They take up space in a room and can be dangerous if flammable items such as furniture and draperies are placed too close to the heating unit.

How much does radiant heating cost?

Average US costs are $11-$30 per square foot depending on the system selected and local labor rates. Operating costs are optimized when the system is installed over an insulation board with a tile or stone finished surface. However, electric radiant floor heating systems will work under most floor coverings.

Why is radiant floor heating so expensive?

Radiant floor heating is a more expensive option because of the labor needed to install the system and ensure it is properly anchored to the existing subfloor. Further, the need for either a radiant x-block installed to your existing hot water heater or a full boiler system for larger projects will increase costs.

How efficient is baseboard heating?

Baseboard heating is most effective in rooms with large windows in cold climates, but the cost of running an electric unit is much higher. Baseboard heating works most efficiently in spaces from 50 to 200 square feet.

How much does a hydronic radiant heater cost?

On average, hydronic radiant heating systems cost between $6,000 and $14,000. If you’re installing an electric system in a small space like a bathroom, costs average around $700. Buying and installing electric baseboard heaters in a home will cost between $472 and $788 each for quality, long-lasting units. For a three-bedroom, 1,400-square-foot ...

How does radiant floor heating work?

Radiant floor heating 1 systems come in two varieties: a boiler-based hydronic system and an electric coil system. The heat source for a hydronic radiant floor system is a boiler centrally located in the home. The heat the boiler produces is transferred to PEX tubing carrying hot water beneath the home’s flooring. If electric power is used, heating coils are located beneath the floor instead. Electric systems are best used as an add-on in a specific room or area, such as in a small bathroom or near a vanity, whereas hydronic systems are intended to heat an entire house. Because the coils or tubing are spread throughout the room under the floor, the room is more evenly heated. However, the radiant system makes heating a cold room a slower process. Once the heat rises from the floor, the room will remain warm longer than with baseboard heat.

What type of floor system is best for allergies?

Radiant floor systems and hydronic baseboard systems are the preferred choices for allergies since they are closed systems. No allergens or other irritants will be circulated during the heating cycle.

Why do baseboard heaters need to be spaced?

Baseboard units produce heat concentrated around the exterior walls of the home in order to provide a cushion of warm air between the frigid outdoors and the home’s interior. In order to maintain this warmth, baseboard heaters must be carefully spaced beneath each window and along exterior walls.

How do baseboards work?

Most baseboard systems are controlled by thermostats 2 in each room, allowing the homeowner to distribute heat only where it is needed. On the other hand, radiant floor systems are sometimes controlled by a central thermostat. A more expensive option can give control to each room.

What is Radiant Floor Heating?

Radiant floor heating utilizes a series of heat cables that run below your finished floor to provide a silent, safe and evenly-distributed blanket of heat across the entire room by convection and radiation.

What is Baseboard Heating?

Electric baseboard heaters are typically sold in two-foot to eight-foot lengths and can be 120 volt or 240 volt (240 is more efficient). They operate primarily through convection, by heating a coil that is surrounded by air fins, allowing the heat to naturally rise and heat the air in the room.

Common Ground when Comparing Radiant Floor Heating vs. Baseboard Heating

Both methods of heating share some common ground: they offer the homeowner autonomy in selecting which areas of the home are to be heated. Both are silent and both operate without disturbing the surrounding air with blown-in allergens and dust.

Where to Buy a Supplemental Heating Solution

Warmup is the world’s best-selling electric floor heating brand and has been an innovator in the electric radiant floor heating industry for over 25 years. Their DCM-PRO Uncoupling System with the anti-fracture membrane provides Warmup with the confidence necessary to guarantee the mat and cable for life.

How much more efficient is radiant heat?

RESNet adds that radiant systems transmit heat on average some 15 percent more efficiently than conventional radiators. The efficiency gains can be magnified significantly with good insulation and a well-designed system.

What is underfloor radiant heating?

Underfloor radiant heating involves under laying the floor with a hot element or tubing that transfers heat into the room via infrared radiation and convection, obviating the need for forced or blowing air. According to the U.S. Department of Energy’s Energy Savers website, radiant heating has a number of advantages over other forms ...

What is radiant heat?

According to TLC Network’s Green Living Guide, there are two main types of radiant heating, electric and hydronic. In the former, heated wires installed in the floor radiate heat upward. This type of radiant heat is most commonly used to retrofit a single room—especially a bathroom or kitchen—in an older house or building.

Is radiant heating energy efficient?

Several aspects of radiant heating make it more energy efficient. For starters, the uniform heat distribution over the entire surface of a floor heats the lower half of the room, enveloping inhabitants in warmth at a lower overall temperature—in some cases up to five degrees Fahrenheit cooler—than a conventional heating system.

Is radiant heating good for allergies?

And radiant heating is a good choice for those with severe allergies as no potentially irritating particles get blown around the room.

Is hydronic radiant heating more efficient?

Meanwhile, hydronic radiant heating, whereby heated water is forced through tubes under the floor, is more often designed into a new structure from the get-go, and is more energy efficient overall.

Does radiant heat save money?

Of course, pairing a radiant heating system with an energy efficient EnergySTAR-approved programmable thermostat can indeed save households hundreds of dollars a year on home heating bills while keeping inhabitants warmer all year long. Many states offer financial incentives to upgrade home and commercial heating systems in ways that boost energy efficiency. Check out the free Database of State Incentives for Renewable Energy (DSIRE) to find out what kinds of tax rebates or other incentives might be available in your neck of the woods.

Why is radiant heat better than forced air?

It is more efficient than baseboard heating and usually more efficient than forced-air heating because it eliminates duct losses. People with allergies often prefer radiant heat because it doesn’t distribute allergens like forced air systems can. Hydronic (liquid-based) systems use little electricity, a benefit for homes off the power grid or in areas with high electricity prices. Hydronic systems can use a wide variety of energy sources to heat the liquid, including standard gas- or oil-fired boilers, wood-fired boilers, solar water heaters, or a combination of these sources. For more on the different types of energy sources and heat distribution systems for home heating, explore our Energy Saver 101 infographic on home heating.

What is the best floor covering for radiant heat?

Ceramic tile is the most common and effective floor covering for radiant floor heating, because it conducts heat well and adds thermal storage. Common floor coverings like vinyl and linoleum sheet goods, carpeting, or wood can also be used, but any covering that insulates the floor from the room will decrease the efficiency of the system.

What is hydronic radiant floor?

Hydronic (liquid) systems are the most popular and cost-effective radiant heating systems for heating-dominated climates. Hydronic radiant floor systems pump heated water from a boiler through tubing laid in a pattern under the floor. In some systems, controlling the flow of hot water through each tubing loop by using zoning valves or pumps and thermostats regulates room temperatures. The cost of installing a hydronic radiant floor varies by location and depends on the size of the home, the type of installation, the floor covering, remoteness of the site, and the cost of labor.

Why do we use dry floors?

Due to recent innovations in floor technology, so-called "dry" floors, in which the cables or tubing run in an air space beneath the floor, have been gaining in popularity, mainly because a dry floor is faster and less expensive to build. Because dry floors involve heating an air space, the radiant heating system needs to operate at a higher temperature.

Why are radiant panels uncomfortable?

Some people find ceiling-mounted systems uncomfortable because the panels heat the top of their heads and shoulders more effectively than the rest of their bodies.

What is radiant floor?

Electric radiant floors typically consist of electric heating cables built into the floor. Systems that feature electrical matting mounted on the subfloor below a floor covering such as tile are also available.

Why do radiant panels have the quickest response time?

Radiant panels have the quickest response time of any heating technology and -- because the panels can be individually controlled for each room —the quick response feature can result in cost and energy savings compared with other systems when rooms are infrequently occupied. When entering a room, the occupant can increase the temperature setting and be comfortable within minutes. As with any heating system, set the thermostat to a minimum temperature that will prevent pipes from freezing.

Radiant Heat In Our Home

I installed radiant heat in our new home in several locations; basement slab, entire first floor (under wood and tile), and under the tile in the bathrooms on the second floor. We installed hot water baseboard in the bedrooms on the second floor.

Using Programmable Thermostats with Radiant Heat

Last winter I did experiment quite a bit with our radiant heat and found that I could save some money by turning back the radiant heat during times when we are not home and asleep. However the length of time that we set back the temperature isn’t quite as long as we do with the baseboard system.

Todd Fratzel

I'm full time builder for a large construction company in New Hampshire. I run their design-build division that specializes in custom homes, commercial design-build projects and sub-divisions. I'm also a licensed civil and structural engineer with extensive experience in civil and structural design and home construction.

image

1.Radiant Floor Heating vs. Baseboard Heating: What is …

Url:https://www.warmup.com/blog/radiant-floor-heating-vs-baseboard-heating

3 hours ago  · Electric radiant floor heat is a far superior option to electric baseboard in every way when you consider their long-term benefits: Evenly distributed heat, Economical and safe to …

2.Radiant Floor vs Baseboard Heating - Fixr.com

Url:https://www.fixr.com/comparisons/radiant-floor-heating-vs-baseboard-heating

19 hours ago  · Radiant heating has a number of advantages: it is more efficient than baseboard heating and usually more efficient than forced-air heating because no energy is …

3.Radiant Floor Heating vs. Baseboard Heating: What is …

Url:https://www.warmup.ca/blog/radiant-heat-vs-baseboard

12 hours ago  · Radiant heating has a number of advantages: it is more efficient than baseboard heating and usually more efficient than forced-air heating because no energy is lost through …

4.Is Under-Floor Radiant Heating More Efficient Than …

Url:https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/underloor-radiant-heating/

1 hours ago  · According to the U.S. Department of Energy’s Energy Savers website, radiant heating has a number of advantages over other forms of heat distribution: “It is more …

5.Radiant Heating | Department of Energy

Url:https://www.energy.gov/energysaver/radiant-heating

21 hours ago Radiant heating has a number of advantages. It is more efficient than baseboard heating and usually more efficient than forced-air heating because it eliminates duct losses. People with …

6.Is Radiant Heat More Efficient Than Traditional Heat …

Url:https://www.homeconstructionimprovement.com/is-radiant-heat-more-efficient/

20 hours ago

7.Radiant Floor Heating System Is More Efficient Than …

Url:/rebates/welcome?url=https%3a%2f%2fresources.made-in-china.com%2farticle%2fproduct-industry-knowledge%2fLnJmBkwKgxij%2fHydronic-Radiant-Floor-Heating-System%2f&murl=https%3a%2f%2fwild.link%2fe%3fc%3d57569%26d%3d2350624%26url%3dhttps%253a%252f%252fresources.made-in-china.com%252farticle%252fproduct-industry-knowledge%252fLnJmBkwKgxij%252fHydronic-Radiant-Floor-Heating-System%252f%26tc%3dbing-&id=made-in-china&name=Made-In-China.com&ra=$4&hash=d0ac6ad5e3e1c863165423df570363e6a634caa0f9025ed79c66592928737863&network=Wildfire

7 hours ago

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9