Knowledge Builders

is rammed earth durable

by Dr. Rodrick McClure MD Published 2 years ago Updated 2 years ago
image

Durable and strong
Once the rammed earth wall has dried, they typically have a load bearing capacity that is similar to concrete. This means that they are more than strong enough to be used comfortably as building materials. So don't worry, rammed earth walls won't crumble around you!

Full Answer

How long does rammed earth walls last?

A Rammed earth house can easily sustain its integrity for 1000+ years. Primary factors affecting the cost of any project are design and site characteristics.

What are the disadvantages of rammed earth?

Rammed Earth Cons:Soil selection is critical. Not any soil can be used. ... If you don't do it yourself, the labor costs can be expensive. ... Colder climates may require added insulation, like a foam wall with stucco on the outside.Due to the difficulty in designing the forms, circular shapes are usually out.

Is rammed earth stronger than concrete?

Durable. Cement-stabilized rammed earth walls, once cured, have compressive strength comparable to homes made of concrete, which offer high levels of strength and durability, as well as resistance to the elements.

How strong is rammed earth construction?

Rammed earth has proved to be suitable for loadbearing and non-loadbearing construction. Compressive strength is a maximum of 1MPa for unstabilised rammed earth and approximately 10MPa for stabilised rammed earth.

Why is rammed earth not popular?

Unfortunately, a lack of research means a lack of understanding of the material and its structural properties. Another obstacle is regulation, or a lack of it. In Australia, as in most countries, there is no building code for rammed earth buildings.

Does rammed earth crack?

Shrinkage cracks are non-structural and are part of the curing process; as rammed earth cures, moisture evaporates from the walls causing them to shrink and slightly crack. Some people may notice cold joints in the product and may mistake it for a structural deformity.

Does rammed earth need rebar?

Rammed earth walls are reinforced with rebars in areas of high seismic activity. Adding cement to soil mixtures low in clay can also increase the load-bearing capacity of rammed-earth edifices.

Does rammed earth need insulation?

Even with a low R-value, a Watershed Block wall, like any earthen wall, can still contribute to maintaining a comfortable indoor air temperature. And, a low R-value does not mean that a Watershed Block or rammed earth wall needs to be insulated.

Why is rammed earth so expensive?

The Cost of a Rammed Earth House The process is labor-intensive and can inflate final costs if materials are sourced far from the site. That partly drives its high costs. The average cost of a rammed earth wall per m2 ranges from $450-$750.

Does rammed earth need cement?

Rammed earth walls are constructed by ramming a mixture of gravel, sand, silt and a small amount of clay into place between flat panels called formwork. Stabilised rammed earth adds a small amount of cement (typically 5–10%) to increase strength and durability.

Is rammed earth load bearing?

Rammed earth has the highest density of all earth-building techniques and has the highest compression strength. This means that it is the most suitable method for load bearing purposes. In the case of the buildings CLC constructed at Panyaden School, the rammed earth walls carry the bamboo roof structure.

Are rammed earth homes warm?

When designed and built properly, rammed earth homes are warm, dry and energy efficient. Rammed earth walls 'breathe' so they counteract humidity, and they naturally maintain a stable internal temperature throughout the seasons.

Does rammed earth need insulation?

Even with a low R-value, a Watershed Block wall, like any earthen wall, can still contribute to maintaining a comfortable indoor air temperature. And, a low R-value does not mean that a Watershed Block or rammed earth wall needs to be insulated.

Is rammed earth fire proof?

In fact, rammed earth construction is only one method that can create structures that are 100 percent fireproof—not just fire resistant. There are other promising modern construction techniques which could also yield fireproof structures such as 3D printing housing out of a cement slurry.

Is rammed earth expensive to build with?

Rammed earth is expensive due to the amount of time, equipment, and skilled labor that goes into the process. A build could initially cost 30%-70% more to construct with rammed earth vs.

What are the benefits of rammed earth?

Benefits of Rammed Earth ConstructionNatural beauty of the rammed earth material.Structural walls with large load-bearing capacity.No maintenance.High insulation rating (R33)Fire proof.Engineered for earthquakes.Uses subsoil (not topsoil)Saves trees from our valuable forests.More items...

What is rammed earth?

Rammed earth, also known as taipa in Portuguese, tapial or tapia in Spanish, tàpia in Catalan, pisé (de terre) in French, bijenica in Serbian, and hāngtǔ (夯土) in Mandarin Chinese, is a technique for constructing foundations, floors, and walls using natural raw materials such as earth, chalk, lime, or gravel.

Where are rammed earth buildings found?

Edifices formed of rammed earth are on every continent except Antarctica, in a range of environments including temperate, wet, semiarid desert, montane, and tropical regions. The availability of suitable soil and a building design appropriate for local climatic conditions are the factors that favour its use.

How long does rammed earth cure?

The compressive strength of rammed earth increases as it cures. Cement-stabilised rammed earth is cured for a minimum period of 28 days. In modern rammed earth buildings, the walls are constructed on top of conventional footings or a reinforced concrete slab base. Contemporary slip formwork in use.

What is the surface of an eroded rammed earth wall?

Detail of the surface of an eroded rammed-earth wall: apart from the patches of damage, the surface shows regular horizontal lines caused by the wooden formwork and subtler horizontal strata from successive courses.

Why did the interest in rammed earth decline after World War II?

The prevailing perception that such materials and techniques perform poorly in regions prone to earthquakes has prevented their use in much of the world. In Chile, for example, rammed earth edifices normally cannot be conventionally insured against damage or even be approved by the government.

How does rammed earth insulation work?

In colder climates, rammed-earth walls can be insulated by inserting insulation such as styrofoam or rigid fibreglass panels within internal and external layers of rammed earth.

How many people are needed to work on rammed earth?

Rammed earth works require at least one skille d person for quality control. All other workers can be unskilled or semi-skilled.

What are the advantages of rammed earth?

List of the Advantages of Rammed Earth. 1. It provides excellent insulating options for off-grid living. If you want to start homesteading and live off of the grid, then rammed earth buildings are an excellent choice for energy retention. You gain the benefits of an environmentally friendly construction material while receiving high levels ...

What is rammed earth construction?

Rammed earth construction is a technique used for building foundations, floors, and walls while only using natural raw materials. This ancient approach offers a sustainable building method that features chalk, lime, gravel, or compressed soil. Edifices formed from rammed earth are found on every continent except Antarctica. It works well in a range of environments, including tropical, desert, and wetland biomes.

How to make rammed earth?

Making rammed earth requires the compaction of a damp mixture of soil that has suitable proportions of gravel, clay, and stabilizer. You can put it into any formwork to create the desired structure. After a wall is completed, it will be sufficiently strong enough to stand on its own.

How long do rammed earth buildings last?

These buildings have already proven to be sturdy for more than a century, and archaeological evidence suggests that some structures could last for more than 1,000 years.

How long does rammed earth cure?

Its compressive strength continues to grow as the structure dries. Cement-stabilized rammed earth must cure for a minimum of 28 days. Modern rammed earth structures sit on top of a constructed footing or a reinforced concrete slab.

Why do you need to use natural materials when building a structure with rammed earth?

Because you are only using natural materials when building a structure with rammed earth, you don’t need to worry about any toxic substances being part of the manufacturing process . You even have the option to create natural forms so that you can avoid any potential chemical exposure from concrete or wood surfaces.

Do rammed earth buildings have to be square?

Most countries have building codes that contractors must follow when creating structures for residential or commercial purposes. Rammed earth buildings don’t always fall into these regulations, which means the quality of the craftsmanship may be questionable. This issue also dictates a square structure for most projects since round forms aren’t always available.

What is rammed earth?

Rammed earth is a building material made by compacting specific types of soil with components including earth, chalk, lime, or gravel. Builders compact layers of a damp mixture of the previously mentioned components into a framework. This ancient technique has been used to build walls, floors, and foundations and is now taking its place in the sustainable architecture realm.

How strong is rammed earth?

They are strong enough to bear loads and resist winds, and durable enough to withstand harsh weather conditions for long periods of time. More than cement stabilizers, other additions can be incorporated into the rammed earth mixture to make it even stronger, like synthetic fiber or steel reinforcement—these will help rammed earth structures perform in a likely manner to concrete in terms of strength, but with a way more sustainable approach. It is believed that further research and technical studies will facilitate the broader use of rammed earth.

When was rammed earth first used?

As evidence suggests, rammed earth was first used during the Neolithic period in China. Some archaeological sites of Chinese cultures that date back to 5000 BCE have structures built with rammed earth—this is perhaps what made this ancient technique a common one in China later on.

What is the most durable form of earth?

Building with earth has taken many forms since the beginning of the construction trade; the most durable form if which is rammed earth. Many civilizations have utilized the soil beneath their feet to build fascinating structures. Perhaps a shred of evidence for the durability of rammed earth is The Great Wall of China lasting some 2,500 years!

Why are rammed earth walls good insulation?

As previously mentioned, rammed earth walls provide very well thermal insulation because of their thickness and density. For the same reasons, they provide high acoustic insulation and reduce noise transmission. This feature makes rammed earth walls on the exterior perfect for locations where heavy rains or strong winds exist—they will create a much calmer and sheltered space.

How thick is a rammed earth wall?

Rammed earth walls are usually a thickness of 1 foot , which, in addition to the density of the material, protects the interiors from extreme weather conditions. The external temperature takes a relatively long time to penetrate rammed earth which stabilized the internal temperature of the buildings. Because of this, rammed earth buildings feel cooler in summers or during the day, and warmer in winters or during the night—making a perfect material where the temperature fluctuates over days or seasons and providing a comfortable space for the inhabitants.

Why did the Rammed Earth gain popularity in the 1800s?

After that, rammed earth gained popularity in the United States during the 1800s because of the book Rural Economy by S.W. Jonson. Several buildings in the US were constructed using this technique, driving scientific research to give it some attention, hence more experiments and rammed earth buildings.

What is rammed earth?

Rammed earth is a low-cost and sustainable building material that can result in highly durable and aesthetically interesting structures.

How old is the rammed earth building technique?

The rammed earth building technique, which requires only a combination of clay-rich soil, water, and a stabilizer, is thousands of years old and a predecessor to materials like adobe and cob.

How long did it take for rammed earth walls to erode?

The study found that after 20 years, only about 2 millimeters of the stabilized rammed earth walls had eroded away on average.

What is the energy needed to make rammed earth?

Typically, the only energy costs involved will be the transportation of soil to the site, costs associated with stabilizers like cement, and the energy needed to tamp down the damp soil into its framework.

Is rammed earth weather resistant?

The growing popularity of the building technique may mean that similar discoveries could be made over the next few years — making rammed earth buildings even more durable and weather-resistant.

Does cured rammed earth help cut down on building costs?

The unique texture of cured rammed earth may also help cut down on extra building costs.

Is a material a good fit for a project?

As a result, the material is often a good fit for project owners on a budget and rural communities which may struggle both with project funding and with the transportation of materials to remote building sites.

How does a rammed earth wall work?

Rammed earth walls are typically much thicker than a concrete wall, which makes them much more effective at controlling indoor temperature fluctuations . An 18” wide wall creates a 12-hour thermal flywheel - outside temperatures take half a day to migrate through the wall to the inside face. This means a mass wall balances out diurnal temperature swings. In most climates and with proper exterior shading, this makes for no cooling loads. Heating loads vary considerably based on orientation and building design. Heating and cooling efficiency are big contributors to energy consumption and carbon footprint reduction.

Does rammed earth need to be maintained?

If the soil is selected correctly and the wall built properly, then rammed earth meets all the required performance standards and will provide decades of serviceability with little or no maintenance. Rammed earth has an inherent beauty that transmits a warmth and natural character very different from concrete.

Is rammed earth cheaper than concrete?

First, rammed earth is not necessarily less expensive than concrete. Even though the forming systems for the two materials are similar and take more or less the same man-hours to erect, layering and compacting rammed earth into the form takes considerably more labor and equipment than pouring and vibrating concrete. The only savings possible are a reduction in aggregate and cement costs. To achieve these savings a mix design must be developed that utilizes a major portion of either on-site or other free mineral soil and a minimum rate of stabilization.

image

Overview

The process

Making rammed earth involves compacting a damp mixture of subsoil that has suitable proportions of sand, gravel, clay, and stabilizer, if any, into a formwork (an externally supported frame or mold).
Historically, additives such as lime or animal blood were used to stabilize it.
Soil mix is poured into the formwork to a depth of 10 to 25 cm (4 to 10 in) and t…

Characteristics

The compressive strength of rammed earth is dictated by factors such as soil type, particle size distribution, amount of compaction, moisture content of the mix and type/amount of stabiliser used. Well-produced cement-stabilised rammed earth walls can be anywhere between 5 to 20 MPa. Higher compressive strength might require more cement. But addition of more cement can affect t…

Environmental effects and sustainability

Edifices of rammed earth are more sustainable and environmentally friendly than other building techniques that use more cement and other chemicals. Because rammed-earth edifices use locally available materials, they usually have low embodied energy and generate very little waste. The soils used are typically subsoil which conserve the topsoil for agriculture. When the soil excava…

Disadvantages

• Building a strong rammed earth wall requires good knowledge and understanding of soil types. A number of factors influence the strength and durability of rammed earth structures, which need rigorous quality checks.
• Rammed earth walls require additional insulators in colder climates (if following modern building codes and practices).

History

Evidence of ancient use of rammed earth has been found in Neolithic archaeological sites such as those of the Fertile Crescent, dating to the 9th–7th millennium BC, and of the Yangshao and Longshan cultures in China, dating to 5000 BCE. By 2000 BCE, rammed-earth architectural techniques (夯土 Hāng tǔ) were commonly used for walls and foundations in China.

See also

• Adobe
• Alker
• Cob, a very similar material that adds organic fiber to increase strength
• Earth block
• Earth sheltering, the architectural practice of using earth against building walls

External sources

• Rammed earth wall construction at Central Arizona College

1.Videos of Is Rammed Earth Durable

Url:/videos/search?q=is+rammed+earth+durable&qpvt=is+rammed+earth+durable&FORM=VDRE

1 hours ago 1. Durable and strong. Once the rammed earth wall has dried, they typically have a load bearing capacity that is similar to concrete. This means that they are more than strong enough to be …

2.Rammed earth - Wikipedia

Url:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rammed_earth

24 hours ago Rammed earth walls have been around for thousands of years, and there are many examples still standing today. Rammed earth is a very durable material, and properly constructed walls can …

3.18 Advantages and Disadvantages of Rammed Earth

Url:https://greengarageblog.org/18-advantages-and-disadvantages-of-rammed-earth

14 hours ago Strong and Durable Rammed earth is extremely durable and weather resistant. Low Maintenance Rammed earth walls are extremely low maintenance. Soon after built and sealed, they will …

4.7 Facts Everyone Should Know About Rammed Earth …

Url:https://www.arch2o.com/7-facts-everyone-should-know-about-rammed-earth/

15 hours ago According to scientific experiments, both stabilized and unstabilized rammed earth structures are extremely strong and durable. They are strong enough to bear loads and resist winds, and …

5.What are the benefits of rammed earth construction?

Url:https://thebossmagazine.com/what-are-the-benefits-of-rammed-earth-construction/

4 hours ago  · Rammed earth is generally very durable, as this technology has been around for hundreds of years. However, to maintain the integrity of these structures, one needs to keep …

6.Why Not Concrete - Rammed Earth Works

Url:https://www.rammedearthworks.com/blog/2010/07/31/why-not-concrete

11 hours ago  · Is rammed earth stronger or more durable than concrete? The answer is clearly no , but the question should be: is rammed earth strong and durable enough for its intended …

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9