Since the light-sensing mechanism does not function at all unless every part is present, it is irreducibly complex (Behe
Michael Behe
Michael J. Behe is an American biochemist, author, and advocate of the pseudoscientific principle of intelligent design. He serves as professor of biochemistry at Lehigh University in Pennsylvania and as a senior fellow of the Discovery Institute's Center for Science and Cultu…
Full Answer
What did Behe mean by irreducible complex?
Behe described several features of living cells and systems—features unknown to Darwin—that he considered to be irreducibly complex. These include the light-sensing mechanism in eyes, the human blood-clotting system and the bacterial flagellum. The irreducible biochemistry of vision
What is irreducible complexity?
Irreducible complexity is an argument against evolution. Evolution teaches the concept of the survival of the fittest. The more a creature's physical and mental attributes enhance its chances of survival, the more likely it is able to live long enough to mate and pass on those helpful genetic traits to the next generation.
What are some examples of biological systems that are irreducibly complex?
There are several biological systems that seem to be irreducibly complex. Bacterial flagella: The most commonly mentioned is the flagella, or whip-like propulsion device, of bacteria. It consists of a drive shaft, bushing, a stator, a rotor, and a switch regulator.
What is an example of irreducible complexity in bacteria?
The bacterial flagellum. A third example of irreducible complexity is the “motor” of the bacterial flagellum. This is like a tail sticking out of a bacterium that allows it to move. It’s a long, hairlike external filament embedded in the cell membrane.
Why do we have multiple photoreceptors?
What is the name of the genus that possesses a small stigma, or eye spot, that is capable?
How did the eye evolve?
How much does the average human eye weigh?
What is the pit in the patch?
Which gelatinous mass was formed by separation of the two layers?
Which layer of the eye allows for more blood vessels?
See 2 more
About this website
What is an example of irreducible complexity?
Blood clotting cascade The process of blood clotting or coagulation cascade in vertebrates is a complex biological pathway which is given as an example of apparent irreducible complexity.
What did Darwin say about the evolution of the eye?
Summary: When Darwin's skeptics attack his theory of evolution, they often focus on the eye. Darwin himself confessed that it was "absurd" to propose that the human eye evolved through spontaneous mutation and natural selection.
What did Darwin say about irreducible complexity?
"If it could be demonstrated that any complex organ existed, which could not possibly have been formed by numerous, successive, slight modifications, my theory would absolutely break down," Darwin wrote. Yet no true examples of irreducible complexity have ever been found.
How did complex eyes evolve?
Complex eyes could have evolved from very simple ones by natural selection as long as each gradation was useful. The key to the puzzle, Darwin said, was to find eyes of intermediate complexity in the animal kingdom that would demonstrate a possible path from simple to sophisticated.
Why is the human eye so complex?
2:545:27How The Human Eye Evolved To Be So Complex - YouTubeYouTubeStart of suggested clipEnd of suggested clipThey even have a retina and ocular muscles that allow for eye movement. These eyes would have beenMoreThey even have a retina and ocular muscles that allow for eye movement. These eyes would have been able to form a simple image over a broad range of wavelength.
How did Darwin believe the eye was formed?
Charles Darwin knew that with his theory of evolution he was able to explain that once an eye was created by random chance then selective pressure would give rise to the diversity seen within different species.
What is an example of specified complexity?
He provides the following examples to demonstrate the concept: "A single letter of the alphabet is specified without being complex. A long sentence of random letters is complex without being specified. A Shakespearean sonnet is both complex and specified."
Why are there no transitional fossils?
Not every transitional form appears in the fossil record, because the fossil record is not complete. Organisms are only rarely preserved as fossils in the best of circumstances, and only a fraction of such fossils have been discovered.
What is the difference between evolution and intelligent design?
In contrast, intelligent design is a less comprehensive alternative to evolutionary theory. While evolution relies upon detailed, well-defined processes such as mutation and natural selection, ID offers no descriptions of the design process or the designer.
What are complex eyes?
Complex eyes distinguish shapes and colours. The visual fields of many organisms, especially predators, involve large areas of binocular vision for depth perception. In other organisms, particularly prey animals, eyes are located to maximise the field of view, such as in rabbits and horses, which have monocular vision.
Did eyes evolve multiple times?
Eyes may have evolved as many as 40 times during metazoan development. Some basic eye molecules, such as retinal and the opsins, are highly conserved and present throughout most multicellular animals.
How did humans evolve eyes?
Scientists believe a depression formed around the light sensitive spot, creating a pit that made its 'vision' a little sharper. Eventually, the pit's opening could have gradually narrowed, creating a small hole that light would enter, much like a pinhole camera.
How did evolution create the eye?
Scientists think the earliest version of the eye was formed in unicellular organisms, who had something called 'eyespots'. These eyespots were made up of patches of photoreceptor proteins that were sensitive to light. They couldn't see shapes or colour, but were able to determine whether it was light or dark out.
What evolved first eyes or ears?
Eyes, by at least 40 million years. The only invertebrates with ears are land arthropods and they didn't emerge until about 480 million years ago.
How was the eye formed?
The eye begins to develop as a pair of optic vesicles on each side of the forebrain at the end of the 4th week of pregnancy. Optic vesicles are outgrowings of the brain which make contact with the surface ectoderm and this contact induces changes necessary for further development of the eye.
What is the significance of the human eye in the history of research on evolution quizlet?
-It provides a clear example of very rapid evolutionary change. The incompleteness of the fossil record may be masking periods of faster change for some kinds of adaptations.
16981. Irreducible Complexity and Flagella - Deconstructing ID
Part 2 of a 7-part series with Dr. Eugenie C. Scott.: Debunking Intelligent Design. Dr. Scott criticizes claims by creationists that flagellated bacteria (flagellum) are an example of irreducible complexity. She concludes that examples of irreducible co
16983. Creation Science - Challenging the Theory of Evolution
Part 4 of a 7-part series with Dr. Eugenie C. Scott: Science, Religion, and Evolutionary Theory. Dr. Scott discusses the history of creationism/intelligent design, which was revived in the United States in the 1960s. Some conservative Christians believe
16984. McLean versus Arkansas Board of Education
Part 5 of a 7-part interview with Dr. Eugenie C. Scott: Creation Science on Trial. Dr. Scott discusses the legal challenge to the Balanced Treatment for Creation-Science and Evolution-Science Act introduced in Arkansas in 1981. Evidence by creation scie
16980. Intelligent Design and Creationism as Science
Part 1 of a 7-part interview with Eugenie C. Scott: Religion, Science, and Theory. Dr. Scott describes intelligent design as a fundamentally religious explanation that has no scientific basis. She discusses the difference between hypothesis and theory,
16986. God and Science - Incompatible?
Part 7 of a 7-part series with Dr. Eugenie C. Scott: The Bible, the Flood, and the Grand Canyon. Dr. Scott believes that affirming science and believing in God are compatible. However, claims by creationists that the Grand Canyon was created by a flood
16985. Keeping God out of the Classroom - Creation Science and Constitution
Part 6 of a 7-part series with Dr. Eugenie C. Scott: Creation Science Brings Religion to the Classroom. Dr. Scott discusses attempts by the creationist movement to introduce religion into high school science curricula. She makes the point that because w
17008. Introducing Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory's DNA Learning Center - in Chinese
The mission of the DNA Learning Center is to prepare students and families to thrive in the gene age. We envision a day when all elementary students are exposed to principles of genetics and disease risk; when all high school students have the opportunity
What are the characteristics of an irreducibly complex system?
Three characteristics identify an irreducibly complex system: did it have to happen (was it inevitable by the laws of physics?), did it happen by accident, and did an intelligent agent cause it to happen? Since these questions can't be answered definitively, irreducible complexity is a game of statistics—what is the chance that this essential thing could have spontaneously developed by accident? In the case of irreducibly complex systems, that chance is mathematically negligible.
Why is irreducible complexity important?
Irreducible complexity brings up those complex biological mechanisms that show no sign of evolution—micro or macro—because any simplification or alteration in their design would leave them useless for their specific purpose. In order for these mechanisms to have developed, several complex genetic changes would have had to occur simultaneously—an event that is inconsistent with evolution and mathematically nearly impossible. There are several biological systems that seem to be irreducibly complex.
What is the difference between microevolution and macroevolution?
Eventually, simple fins evolve into arms, hands, and fingers that can play Rachmaninoff on the piano. Microevolution refers to small changes. A bird with a slightly longer beak than its nest-mates is able to reach more bugs in the holes of trees and live a healthier, longer life. It therefore produces more offspring who also have longer beaks and live healthier, longer lives.
How did the eye evolve?
The eye: Although evolutionists have attempted to show how the eye could have evolved, the sheer complexity of the mechanism defies explanation. The retina actually interprets much of the input before it reaches the brain. The processors in the brain would have had to evolve parallel with yet independently of the development of the eye itself. Even the computer simulation of the evolution of the eye shows how only an intentional design could have resulted in such functionality.
What is irreducible complexity?
Irreducible complexity - What is it? Irreducible complexity is an argument against evolution. Evolution teaches the concept of the survival of the fittest. The more a creature's physical and mental attributes enhance its chances of survival, the more likely it is able to live long enough to mate and pass on those helpful genetic traits to ...
What are the biological systems that are irreducibly complex?
There are several biological systems that seem to be irreducibly complex. Bacterial flagella: The most commonly mentioned is the flagella, or whip-like propulsion device, of bacteria. It consists of a drive shaft, bushing, a stator, a rotor, and a switch regulator.
Is chance a watertight argument?
In the case of irreducibly complex systems, that chance is mathematically negligible. Irreducible complexity is not a watertight argument for the involvement of intelligence in the formation of biological systems.
Why is the blood clotting cascade irreducibly complex?
Each protein is extremely complex in its own right, but it is the cascade that Behe identified as irreducibly complex, because all of the molecules must be present for the system to work. If even one is missing (as in the case of hemophilia), the system fails. Thus it is irreducibly complex (Behe, pp. 78-88).
What does it mean to be a blind watchmaker?
But instead of admitting to a designer, some evolutionists use terms like “a blind watchmaker” to describe the process of evolution. Essentially that is saying the incredible complexity and fine tuning that we see in the universe, on the earth and in our human bodies, appeared by pure chance and is essentially un intelligent design.
Why is each protein irreducibly complex?
Each protein is extremely complex in its own right, but it is the cascade that Behe identified as irreducibly complex, because all of the molecules must be present for the system to work. If even one is missing (as in the case of hemophilia), the system fails. Thus it is irreducibly complex (Behe, pp. 78-88).
What type of biological system could not be formed by ‘numerous successive, slight modifications’?
Behe wrote: “What type of biological system could not be formed by ‘numerous successive, slight modifications’? Well, for starters, a system that is irreducibly complex. By irreducibly complex I mean a single system composed of several well-matched interacting parts that contribute to the basic function, wherein the removal of any one of the parts causes the system to effectively cease functioning” (p. 39).
What did Darwin not see?
What Darwin couldn’t see. Research on the human body since Darwin’s time has been able to demonstrate incredible complexity far beyond what Darwin was able to comprehend. What made this research possible was the invention of the electron microscope, allowing scientists to view beyond the wavelengths of light.
What is irreducible complexity?
The first example offered of irreducible complexity is the biochemistry of vision. When light strikes a photosensitive cell in an animal eye, it is absorbed by a molecule that alters an attached protein, which then initiates what biochemists call a “cascade”—a precisely integrated series of molecular reactions—that in this case causes a nerve impulse to be transmitted to the brain. The result, as interpreted by the brain, is vision.
How is the flagellum attached to the drive shaft?
The flagellum itself is attached to the drive shaft by a hook that functions as a universal joint so the flagellum can twist as it turns.
Why do we have multiple photoreceptors?
Over successive generations, possessing multiple photoreceptors became the norm in the gene pool, because individuals with mutations encoding for an increased number of photoreceptors were better able to react to their surroundings. An arms race began, fueling the evolution of the new sensory organ.
What is the name of the genus that possesses a small stigma, or eye spot, that is capable?
Uni-cellular protists of the genus Euglena posses a small stigma, or eye spot, that is capable of detecting light, but unable to form images.
How did the eye evolve?
First of all, the evolution of the eye was a step-by-step, cumulative process — it didn't just spring into existence fully formed through some astronomically lucky macro-mutation. That's impossible, and no one is seriously suggesting that that's how it happened. Things like that don't happen by random chance, even over billions of years. Only with the help of a non-random process like natural selection can something like the eye come into being.
How much does the average human eye weigh?
There's a lot going on in there. The average human eye only weighs about 7 or 8 grams, but they are absolutely jam packed full of stuff. Chances are, you're the proud owner of two of these little beauties. Right now, they're busy using all of that intricate machinery to refract and focus light from your computer screen onto light sensitive rods and cones. From there, the light is being transduced into nerve signals, which are then being carried via your optic nerve into your visual cortex, where the raw information is getting filtered and patched together into something that you can make sense of.
What is the pit in the patch?
A slight depression in the patch created a pit, for the first time allowing a limited ability to sense from which direction light or shadow was coming from.
Which gelatinous mass was formed by separation of the two layers?
Separation of these two layers allowed another gelatinous mass to form, the aqueous humor, which further increased refractive power.
Which layer of the eye allows for more blood vessels?
A transparent layer evolved in front of the lens. This transparent layer, the cornea, further focused light, and also allowed for more blood vessels, better circulation, and larger eyes.
