Was Jesus born in a cave?
The Early Church Fathers wrote about Jesus being born in a cave. Justin Martyr (150 A.D.), Origen (250 A.D.), Jerome (325 A.D.) each believed this was the case. In 335 A.D, Emperor Constantine approved the cave that was the traditional site of Jesus’ birth to be turned into a holy site, and is known as the “ Church of the Nativity .”
Was Jesus born in a barn or a barn?
No, probably not. We get this idea from Christmas carols, artwork, and other stories, but the Gospel accounts of the birth of Jesus do not indicate that He was born in a stable, a barn, or a cave.
Was Jesus really born in a stable?
No, probably not. We get this idea from Christmas carols, artwork, and other stories, but the Gospel accounts of the birth of Jesus do not indicate that He was born in a stable, a barn, or a cave. Instead, Jesus was most likely born in a house.
Was Jesus born in the Church of the Nativity?
Justin Martyr (150 A.D.), Origen (250 A.D.), Jerome (325 A.D.) each believed this was the case. In 335 A.D, Emperor Constantine approved the cave that was the traditional site of Jesus’ birth to be turned into a holy site, and is known as the “ Church of the Nativity .”
Who wrote about Jesus being born in a cave?
Where was Jesus born?
Why did Jesus use a room for Passover?
Was Jesus born in a barn or a stable?
The birth of Christ may be the most famous Bible story of all, reprised annually in nativity scenes across the world each Christmas: Jesus was born in a stable, because there was no room at the inn.
What type of place was Jesus born in?
Since at least the 2nd century AD people have believed that the place where the Church of the Nativity, Bethlehem, now stands is where Jesus was born. One particular cave, over which the first Church was built, is traditionally believed to be the Birthplace itself.
What did the place where Jesus was born look like?
The church was originally commissioned by Constantine the Great a short time after his mother Helena's visit to Jerusalem and Bethlehem in 325–326, on the site that was traditionally considered to be the birthplace of Jesus....Church of the NativityStatusActiveLocationLocationBethlehem, West BankCountryPalestine19 more rows
Does the Bible say Jesus was born in a manger?
and she gave birth to her firstborn, a son. She wrapped him in cloths and placed him in a manger, because there was no room for them in the inn.
Why was Jesus born in a barn?
If you look at any manger scene or contemporary nativity sets, this is the popular image presented. Understandably, the reasoning goes like this: Jesus was placed in a manger, which was a feeding trough for livestock, so he must've been born in the barn with the animals.
What is Jesus actual birthday?
By the fourth century, however, we find references to two dates that were widely recognized — and now also celebrated — as Jesus' birthday: December 25 in the western Roman Empire and January 6 in the East (especially in Egypt and Asia Minor).
Can I visit the place Jesus was born?
Security measures around the church are very high and you usually can only enter the church if you have one of the scarce pre-booked entrance tickets. The site of Jesus' birth is located in the basement of the Church of the Nativity, known as the Grotto of the Nativity.
Where is the exact spot Jesus was crucified?
GolgothaGolgotha, (Aramaic: “Skull”) also called Calvary, (from Latin calva: “bald head” or “skull”), skull-shaped hill in ancient Jerusalem, the site of Jesus' crucifixion. It is referred to in all four Gospels (Matthew 27:33, Mark 15:22, Luke 23:33, and John 19:17).
Where did Mary and Joseph live before Jesus was born?
Both of the gospels which describe the nativity of Jesus agree that he was born in Bethlehem and then later moved with his family to live in Nazareth. The Gospel of Matthew describes how Joseph, Mary, and Jesus went to Egypt to escape from Herod the Great's slaughter of the baby boys in Bethlehem.
Why did God allow Jesus to be born in a stable?
In 1323, St Francis decided to create the Nativity scene that we know today. He felt that people had forgotten the meaning of Christmas and wanted a visual reminder for people of the importance of Jesus birth. The stable reminds us that Jesus came into the world with nothing.
What does the H stand for in Jesus?
In partially Latinised form, the IHC component is rendered JHC or JHS. This is the origin of the interjection, which seems to imagine that H is Jesus' middle initial, and Christ his surname, rather than his title (ho khristos: the anointed).
Where was Jesus laid when he was born?
Jesus was born in Bethlehem; since there was nowhere for them to stay in the town, the infant was laid in a manger while angels announced his birth to a group of shepherds who worshipped him as Messiah and Lord.
When and where was Jesus born?
Although born in Bethlehem, according to Matthew and Luke, Jesus was a Galilean from Nazareth, a village near Sepphoris, one of the two major cities of Galilee (Tiberias was the other). He was born to Joseph and Mary sometime between 6 bce and shortly before the death of Herod the Great (Matthew 2; Luke 1:5) in 4 bce.
Why was Jesus born in a manger?
Jesus is born in a manger because all the travelers overcrowded the guest rooms. After the birth, Joseph and Mary are visited not by wise men but shepherds, who were also overjoyed at Jesus' birth. Luke says these shepherds were notified about Jesus' location in Bethlehem by angels.
Was Jesus born in Bethlehem or Jerusalem?
The town of Bethlehem of Judea, about six miles south of Jerusalem, has always been considered the birthplace of Jesus. According to the New Testament, Joseph and Mary were living in Bethlehem of Judea at the time of Jesus' birth and later moved to Nazareth up north.
Where does it say in the Bible when Jesus was born?
The date of birth of Jesus is not stated in the gospels or in any historical reference, but most biblical scholars assume a year of birth between 6 and 4 BC.
Why was Jesus born in a barn?
Jesus was born in a barn with animals around, because when Joseph and Mary walked house by house looking for a place to stay because he was going to be born and it was cold out and they had no where to go every one said NO when they asked for a place to stay. so they went to a barn to give birth to baby Jesus. then the three kings came to see him.
Was Jesus Born in a Stable, a Cave or a House?
The word kataluma is also used in Luke 22. In this verse we find it translated using a different word: Luke 22:11 And ye shall say unto the goodman of the house, The Master saith unto thee, Where is the guestchamber, where I shall eat the passover with my disciples?. Here “kataluma” is translated as “guest chamber.”
Was Jesus Born in a Barn? - Redeeming God
No not a barn or a cave, he was born on the edge of a field near the Shepard’s they mention a watch tower that had a opening for the sacrificial lambs to be kept it was in Oct 7BC during the feast of Tabernacles.
Was Jesus Born in a House? | Answers in Genesis
When we think of the place where Jesus was born, we naturally picture a stable or barn. But is that what the Bible says?
Where was Jesus born?
The question of where Jesus was born is often answered with a city – Bethlehem. We know this from Biblical prophesies and narrative accounts like in Luke 2:4 and Matthew 2:1. But Bible scholars are less sure about more specific details involving the setting. Again, we know from Luke’s gospel where Jesus was not born – an inn, because there wasn’t room for his parents ( Luke 2:7 ). Was Jesus born in a cave? While this question is not much discussed in modern times, the tradition that connects a cave with Christ 's birth is very ancient.
Where are caves in the Bible?
The Scriptures, Josephus, and all travelers speak of the numerous caves that are found throughout Palestine. They were used for dwellings, for fortresses and places of refuge, for cisterns, for prisons, and for sepulchers, which Easton’s Bible Dictionary says is a kind of burial place.
What are the objections to the cave theory?
Objections to the Cave Theory. 1. Luke’s gospel account of Jesus’ birth doesn’t mention it. The objection that Luke says nothing of a cave is not important. His purpose is simply to show the humble and friendless state of the infant child, and this is done by the mention of the circumstances that there was no room for His parents, ...
Why is tradition important to caves?
Tradition makes caves the setting of so many other remarkable events. A more important objection is that drawn from the fact that tradition makes caves or grottoes to be the sites of so many remarkable events. That naturally awakens our incredulity.
Who wrote the book The Life of Our Lord upon the Earth?
Adapted from The Life of Our Lord upon the Earth by Samuel James Andrews.
Can a cave be used as a stall for cattle?
It is indeed hard to believe that the present artificial cave, so deep down and inaccessible, could ever have been used as a stall for cattle. Perhaps the fact may be that the cave, in its original shape, was connected with a house, forming its rear apartment, and used as a stable.
Why did Mary lay Jesus in a manger?
In my book, Christmas Redemption, I briefly look at the wording in Luke 2:7 which says that when Jesus was born, Mary laid Him in a manger because there was no room for them in the inn. I suggest in that the word “inn” is most likely a mistranslation, and the word really should be “tent” or “tabernacle.” The word refers to a “temporary shelter” which can be erected and taken down quickly, not to “temporary lodging” at a place like an inn.
Where did Joseph and Mary go for the census?
One objection to this whole idea is that Luke 2:1-7 says that Joseph and Mary traveled to Bethlehem for the census. Except for the possible reference in Luke 2:7, nothing is mentioned about the Feast of Tabernacles. The solution seems to lie in Luke 2:6.
Why were there goats in Luke 2:7?
The reason they were there was because there was no room for them outside in the tent.
Was Jesus born in a stable?
Or a stable? Or a cave? No, probably not. We get this idea from Christmas carols, artwork, and other stories, but the Gospel accounts of the birth of Jesus do not indicate that He was born in a stable, a barn, or a cave. Instead, Jesus was most likely born in a house.
Why was Jesus born in a cave?
Jesus was born in a cave not because his parents were followers of a secretive underground mystery cult, but because he is the righteous one who "can live with the everlasting burning". Justin is thus the earliest author to write about the birth of Jesus in a cave, but he does not tell us anything about the cave's appearance in his own day.
Where does the idea of a nativity cave come from?
So where does the idea of a nativity cave come from? Two second century Christian texts - Justin's Dialogue with Trypho and the Protoevangelium of James - describe the birth of Jesus in a cave. We don't know where Justin's information comes from, but the fact that he mentions the cave is significant. In his Dialogue (78.5), Justin is very bothered by the fact that Trypho the Jew regards Jesus as yet another magician belonging to one the many mystery cults prevalent in the Roman Empire. The idea of a nativity cave is a big problem for Justin because it is very similar to the underground caves used for Mithraic initiation rites. So instead, Justin introduces the cave as a fulfillment of Hebrew Scripture. Isaiah 33:14 asks “Who among us can live with the devouring fire?" the answer to which is the righteous one, who is described as follows:
How authentic is the Nativity Grotto in Bethlehem?
How authentic is the Nativity Grotto in Bethlehem? It depends on what one means by "authentic". The historical Jesus was probably born in Nazareth, not Bethlehem. The earliest gospel, Mark, refers to him many times as "the Nazarene" and contains no birth account at all. It simply assumes that he was born in the same place where he spent his childhood. The two later gospels that do contain a Bethlehem birth scene, Matthew and Luke, clearly do so to imbue Jesus with the necessary Davidic qualities of the Messiah (cf. Micah 5:1). But these two gospels do not mention the birth taking place in a cave. Matthew says it was in a "house", while Luke mentions "a manger, because there was no place for them in the inn." The latter is the inspiration for the barnyard nativity scenes we are used to seeing at this time of year. So in terms of real-world authenticity, this site falls short. But there is a different kind of authenticity which comes from generations of pilgrims venerating a site. Let us call this imagined authenticity. In these terms, the Nativity Grotto is as authentic as they come. Pilgrims have been coming to pray at this cave since the third century (at least).
What is the testimony of Origen?
In his writings he alludes several times to visiting biblical sites, each time using the phrase "it is pointed out" (δείκνυται). This seems to be Origen's way of reassuring the reader that he was given a guided tour of the place in question, so his knowledge is reliable. Very few Christians engaged in pilgrimage to the Holy Land in the 3rd century. For the most part, the institution of pilgrimage only took off after the imperialization of Christianity in the mid-4th century. The Pilgrim of Bordeaux (333) is generally regarded as the earliest Christian to visit biblical sites in Palestine and write a travelogue, known as the Itinerarium Burdigalense. But at some point in the early third century Origen toured the holy land in search of places found in the Bible. What is so interesting is that he refers to the physical place here as "another source," as though it is comparable to the textual accounts found in the Old and New Testaments. This textualization of the land reminds me very much of the idea expressed in the title of J.M.P. Otts 1893 book, The Fifth Gospel: The Land where Jesus Lived. Of course, Origen does not mention anything about the date of Jesus' birth. The complicated question of how the Church settled on December 25 as the birth date is explored here.
Why was Jesus born in a cave?
Churches, like the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America, state that Jesus was born in a cave, as they were used by shepherds of the time to shelter animals from hostile weather. "Joseph found a cave-like place where they could rest. This place was used by shepherds to protect their sheep in stormy weather. It was here that Mary gave birth ...
Who was the professor who believed the Church was on the very place where Jesus was born?
Qustandi Shomali, history professor at Bethlehem University, told CBN that he believed the Church to be upon the very place where Jesus was born. "The Church of the Nativity was built over this place in 326 when Emperor Constantine decided to declare Christianity as the official religion of the Roman Empire," said Shomali.
Where did the Magi make their way to Jesus?
The Magi make their way to Him by a star. For a new child has been born for us, the God before all ages.". In modern Bethlehem, the ancient sanctuary of the Church of the Nativity stands over what is believed by many to be the exact location of Jesus' birth.
Where is the Christ child laid?
Surrounded by farm animals, the Christ child is laid within a manger, a stable that was likely made of wood with hay on the ground. Traditional images of said manger, the displays erected outside of churches, on public property or at home, generally involve a simple wooden structure as the setting. However, in some Christian traditions ...
Who gave birth to Jesus?
It was here that Mary gave birth to Jesus," reads an entry on the Archdiocese's website. "Today, the Virgin bears Him who is transcendent, and the earth presents the cave to Him who is beyond reach. Angels, along with shepherds glorify Him. The Magi make their way to Him by a star.
Was Justin the cave influenced by pagan sources?
Critics of the cave, like Bob Thielclaim, claim they have pointed to the lack of mention of such detail in the Gospels and that writers like Justin were likely influenced by pagan sources. "It would seem that Justin had been earlier (and unknowingly) influenced by one who had exposure to Mithraism, and Justin was looking for justification ...
Where was Jesus born?
First, the Bible certainly teaches that Jesus was born in Bethlehem, but it does not state that Joseph and Mary arrived in that town just in timefor her to deliver.
Why was Jesus born among the animals in the stable?
Misconception: Jesus was born among the animals in the stable because there was no room for Joseph and Mary at the inn. Several years ago, I attended a Christmas drama performed by members of a local church. The main character of the play was an innkeeper. He was eventually forced to turn away Joseph and Mary (who had just arrived in Bethlehem) ...
Why did Joseph and Mary stay in Bethlehem?
Joseph and Mary probably stayed with Joseph's relatives in Bethlehem, but because of the large influx of people, the house would have been crowded and the kataluma (guest room) was full. Consequently, Joseph and Mary would have been relegated to living in the lower level of the house. It is hard to believe that pregnant Mary would have been turned away from a relative's home in a society that greatly valued familial ties.
Where did Mary give birth to Jesus?
Mary likely gave birth to Jesus in the lower level of a crowded house, in which some of the animals had been brought in for the night.3She then wrapped Jesus in swaddling cloths and laid Him in the manger (feeding trough).4.
Where did Joseph and Mary live?
Joseph and Mary probably stayed with Joseph's relatives in Bethlehem, but because of the large influx of people, the house would have been crowded and the kataluma(guest room) was full. Consequently, Joseph and Mary would have been relegated to living in the lower level of the house.
Did the manger expect animals to come out of his house?
Apparently, he expected an animal to come out of his house. Little did he know that his daughter would come out to greet him before any of the animals came out. So there seems to be biblical precedent for keeping animals in the house. This is where the manger comes into play.
Is there a biblical precedent for keeping animals in the house?
Apparently, he expected an animal to come out of his house. Little did he know that his daughter would come out to greet him before any of the animals came out. So there seems to be biblical precedent for keeping animals in the house.
Was he born in a house, inn, stable or cave?
The familiar Christmas story describes an innkeeper who turned Mary and Joseph away from the village inn because of lack of room. They took refuge in a barn or stable where Yeshua of Nazareth (a.k.a. Jesus) was born. He was laid in a manger in the presence of domesticated animals. This is a beautiful story retold countless times at Christmas time.
References used
The following information sources were used to prepare and update the above essay. The hyperlinks are not necessarily still active today.
Where was Jesus born?
From this account we learn that Jesus was born in Bethlehem. Furthermore, when the wise men visited Jesus, He was NOT in a manger nor a cave, but instead was in a house.
How did the Church survive the Persian invasion?
The Church survived the Persian invasion of 614, when all the other churches of the Holy Land were destroyed, because a mosaic over the main door, now gone, showed the Wise Men dressed as Persians - which, of course, they were. (Mander P. The Church of the Nativity - the oldest church in the world. Copyright © 2010 St Mary-On-The-Rock, Ellon. http://www.stmarystjames.org.uk/the-holy-land/14-holy-land-information/69-the-church-of-the-nativity viewed 02/27/10).
Did the wise men come to a house?
The wise men may or may not have been Persian (the Bible simply states that they were from "the East"). But they did not come to a cave or grotto to see baby Jesus--they came to a house. And a house that was apparently in, not outside of, Bethlehem.
Was Jesus born in a manger?
Whether Jesus was born in a building for humans and then moved to a manger is not specified. But what is specified is that he was laid in a manger, which is a place that fodder (like hay) was placed to feed livestock such as cattle and sheep.
Who wrote about Jesus being born in a cave?
The Early Church Fathers wrote about Jesus being born in a cave. Justin Martyr (150 A.D.), Origen (250 A.D.), Jerome (325 A.D.) each believed this was the case. In 335 A.D, Emperor Constantine approved the cave that was the traditional site of Jesus’ birth to be turned into a holy site, and is known as the “ Church of the Nativity .”.
Where was Jesus born?
Jesus was born in Bethlehem in a humble and lowly state. The God of creation was born in a back-woods town and in the overflow section. The details above help fill in the context in some ways that can be helpful to consider the trials that Mary and Joseph faced and to rejoice in God’s providence.
Why did Jesus use a room for Passover?
This is the type of room that Jesus and his disciples used to celebrate the Passover because it was completely expected for faithful Jewish families to show hospitality to travelers, especially to family. When Luke 2:7 says “there was no room for them in the inn,” the Greek word is the word for this guest room, ...