Harlow also concluded that early social deprivation leads to emotional damage, but it can be reversed in monkeys if an attachment was made before the end of the critical period. If social deprivation lasted after the end of the critical period, then no amount of exposure to mothers or peers altered the emotional damage. Ethics of the Study
What did Harlow do with the monkeys?
He is also well known for his research using rhesus monkeys. For his experiments, Harlow (1958) separated infant rhesus monkeys from their mothers.
What did Harlow’s experiment show about human behavior?
Harlow’s experiment also highlighted the influence of early relationships in the behavior of adult monkeys. The deprivation of social stimulation at an early age caused the monkeys to lose interest in this type of contact later on in life when they were given the opportunity. Deprivation of affection in humans
What behavioral differences did Harlow observe between monkeys who had surrogate mothers?
The behavioral differences that Harlow observed between the monkeys who had grown up with surrogate mothers and those with normal mothers were; a) They were much more timid. b) They didn’t know how to act with other monkeys. c) They were easily bullied and wouldn’t stand up for themselves.
How did Harlow separate the infants into two groups?
Harlow (1958) modified his experiment and separated the infants into two groups: the terrycloth mother which provided no food, or the wire mother which did. All the monkeys drank equal amounts and grew physically at the same rate.
What monkeys did Harlow study?
What did Harlow show about fluffy surrogates?
Why is it difficult to know if the infant monkeys truly loved the surrogate mothers?
How does a caregiver respond to an infant?
Why was Harlow's work limited to the role of maternal surrogates?
How many monkeys did Harlow isolate?
What does Harlow's experiment suggest?
See 4 more
About this website
What happened to Harlow's monkeys?
In the Harlow monkey experiment, there were a few different outcomes. Monkeys raised with mothers and other monkeys developed into normal, happy ad...
What is the significant finding of Harlow's experiments on monkeys?
Harlow's monkey experiment showed that love and comfort are non-physical needs. His monkey experiment disproved the common theory that love was bas...
Which belief about attachment did Harlow's work with monkeys disprove?
Harlow's monkey experiment disproved the belief that love is only based on physical needs. The fact that the monkeys grew the most attached to the...
Harlow's Monkey Experiment Summary & Outcome
Harlow's Monkey Experiment. In the 1960s, Harry Harlow (with some help from his wife, Margaret) developed a primate lab at the University of Wisconsin - Madison to study rhesus monkeys. He sought ...
Harry Harlow: Monkey Love Experiments - Simply Psychology
Attachment Theory; Harry Harlow Harry Harlow, Monkey Love Experiments Harry Harlow, Monkey Love Experiments. By Saul McLeod, published 2020. Harlow (1958 wanted to study the mechanisms by which newborn rhesus monkeys bond with their mothers.
Harlow Monkey Experiment (Definition + Contribution to Psychology)
Attachment Theory and Harlow’s Monkey Experiments. If you have ever read anything from relationship experts or counselors, you might hear this idea: the relationship we have with our parents influences the partners we pick and the way that we go about relationships.
Why “Harlow’s Monkey?” – Harlow's Monkey
In the 1950's, psychologist Harry Harlow began a series of experiments on baby monkeys, depriving them of their biological mothers and using substitute wire and terry cloth covered "mothers". Harlow's goal was to study the nature of attachment and how it affects monkeys who were deprived of their mothers early in life. As an unwitting…
What monkeys did Harlow study?
Harlow also studied the development of rhesus monkeys that were not exposed to a fluffy surrogate or had no surrogate at all. The outcome for these infants was extremely negative. Rhesus infants raised with a milk-supplying metal surrogate had softer feces than infants raised with a milk-supplying fluffy surrogate.
What did Harlow show about fluffy surrogates?
In subsequent experiments, Harlow (1958) showed that the fluffy surrogate acted as a secure base from which rhesus infants could explore an unfamiliar environment or objects. In these experiments, the infants, along with their fluffy surrogates, were placed in an unfamiliar environment like a new cage.
Why is it difficult to know if the infant monkeys truly loved the surrogate mothers?
It is difficult to know whether the infant monkeys truly loved the surrogate mothers because Harlow could not ask them directly or measure the feeling of love using equipment.
How does a caregiver respond to an infant?
How the caregiver responds to the infant is known as sensitive responsiveness (Ainsworth et al., 1978). The fluffy surrogate mothers in Harlow’s experiment were not responsive, obviously; however, their presence, the material used to cover them, and their shape allowed the rhesus infants to cling to them, providing comfort, albeit a basic, unresponsive one.
Why was Harlow's work limited to the role of maternal surrogates?
Conclusions from Harlow’s work were limited to the role of maternal surrogates because the surrogates also provided milk – a function that only female mammals can perform. Consequently, it was posited that human infants have a strong need to form an attachment to a maternal caregiver (Bowlby, 1951).
How many monkeys did Harlow isolate?
In the partial isolation experiments, Harlow isolated a group of 56 monkeys from other monkeys; although they could hear and see the other monkeys, they were prevented from interacting with or touching them. These monkeys developed aggressive and severely disturbed behavior, such as staring into space, repetitive behaviors, and self-harm through chewing and tearing at their flesh.
What does Harlow's experiment suggest?
The results from Harlow’s experiments suggest that the role of the primary caregiver is not limited to satisfying infants’ primary drives.
Why does attachment develop in monkeys?
In contrast, Harlow’s explanation was that attachment develops as a result of the mother providing “tactile comfort,” suggesting that infants have an innate (biological) need to touch and cling to something for emotional comfort. Harry Harlow did a number of studies on attachment in rhesus monkeys during the 1950's and 1960's.
How long did infant monkeys stay isolated?
Harlow (1965) took babies and isolated them from birth. They had no contact with each other or anybody else. He kept some this way for three months, some for six, some for nine and some for the first year of their lives.
How long do monkeys stay with their surrogate mothers?
These behaviors were observed only in the monkeys who were left with the surrogate mothers for more than 90 days. For those left less than 90 days the effects could be reversed if placed in a normal environment where they could form attachments.
Why do monkeys cling to objects?
Clinging is a natural response - in times of stress the monkey runs to the object to which it normally clings as if the clinging decreases the stress.
What behavior did the monkeys have?
The results showed the monkeys engaged in bizarre behavior such as clutching their own bodies and rocking compulsively. They were then placed back in the company of other monkeys.
What did the Terrycloth mother provide?
In the first group, the terrycloth mother provided no food, while the wire mother did, in the form of an attached baby bottle containing milk.
Which experiment did Harlow modify?
Experiment 2. Harlow (1958) modified his experiment and separated the infants into two groups: the terrycloth mother which provided no food, or the wire mother which did. All the monkeys drank equal amounts and grew physically at the same rate. But the similarities ended there.
Why did Harlow study the bond between newborn rhesus monkeys with their mothers?
These infants were highly dependent on their mothers for nutrition, protection, comfort, and socialization. The behavioral theory of attachment suggests that an infant would form an attachment with a caregiver that provides food.
How does social deprivation affect monkeys?
Harlow also concluded that early social deprivation leads to emotional damage, but it can be reversed in monkeys if an attachment was made before the end of the critical period. If social deprivation lasted after the end of the critical period, then no amount of exposure to mothers or peers altered the emotional damage.
What did Harlow do to the rhesus monkeys?
In the 1930s, Harlow was running experiments with rhesus macaques concerning learning development. To this end, he chose to raise them in a nursery setting rather than with their mothers. While Harlow and his associates could care for the physical needs of the baby monkeys, there was no denying that they regularly behaved much differently than those raised by their mothers. These socially isolated infants were reclusive, clung to their cloth diapers, and often showed signs of fear or aggressiveness. These observations, along with the later growing general debate over a mother’s role in her child’s development, would inspire Harlow to conduct his famous experiments.
What was the most famous experiment Harlow conducted?
His most famous experiment involved separating an infant from its mother a few hours after birth and letting it be “raised” by two “surrogate mothers.” The two mothers were made out of wire and wood, but one had a soft cloth covering. In one group, only the cloth mother had a bottle attached to it. For the other, only the wire mother provided the baby sustenance. According to the prevailing beliefs of the time, the infant should have shown an attachment for whichever mother held the bottle, but this wasn’t the case. In all groups, the infants overwhelmingly preferred the cloth mother. Those with the nourishing wire mother would only approach it to feed and then return to their cloth mother.
How does isolation affect rhesus macaques?
Harlow also investigated how different lengths of isolation affected rhesus macaques’ abilities to socialize with peers. Subjects were isolated for months and even years. He found that 90 days was the critical period. Subjects exhibited dramatic, debilitating behavior but, when integrated with controls of the same age, slowly started to adapt and eventually show normal behavior. After the critical period passes, no amount of exposure to surrogate mothers or peers can cause the subjects to fully alter their behavior nor make up for the emotional damage suffered. The longer subjects were isolated, the more debilitating their behavior became. In some cases, severely isolated subjects developed emotional anorexia upon reintegration with their peers and subsequently died.
What is the ISBN number for Harry Harlow's book Love at Goon Park?
Blum, Deborah. Love at Goon Park: Harry Harlow and the Science of Affection. Basic Books, New York, 2002. ISBN: 978-0-7382-0278-5.
What does Cordelia seek comfort from?
When scared, Cordelia sought comfort from her father rather than you, even though you were closer. She has a stronger attachment to Brian, so she sought him out. Once she had received some contact comfort from him, she was able to go back to playing and having fun.
Why is adoption important?
Adoption is championed as superior over other arrangements because it provides the permanence needed for attachment bonds to develop. Harlow showed that love doesn’t develop from simply caring for the physical needs of a child: it comes from providing a feeling of safety and comfort. A father can play just as critical of a role in his child’s development as the mother. You don’t need to be a biological parent to truly care for a child. An infant raised by guardians rather than their biological mother is not guaranteed to suffer from such an arrangement.
What did the fear test show?
Later experiments - “open-field tests” and “fear tests” - showed that when frightened, infants would seek comfort from their cloth mothers, clinging to them and eventually calming down. Those without their surrogate mother or those with only a wire mother present would stay fearful, frequently hud dling in a ball, rocking themselves, sucking their thumbs, or screeching in terror.
What did Harlow do to test Bowlby's theory?
Harlow experimented with rhesus monkeys, an Asian species that’s assimilates to living with humans easily. The purpose of the study was to examine their behavior in the laboratory to confirm Bowlby’s attachment theory. He separated the baby monkeys from their mothers to see how they reacted. However, his methods were questionable.
Why did the babies cling to the dolls?
When the babies were scared, they clung tightly to the doll, because it gave them a sense of security. This allowed Harlow to verify how important the relationship with and attachment to the mother is when babies are very young.
What is attachment theory?
Attachment theory centers around the psychological phenomena that occur when we establish affective bonds with other people. The way we do so is conditioned by how our parents interacted with us during childhood. If the relationship wasn’t positive, this often results in toxic relationships and emotional dependence in adulthood.
What happens if a relationship is not positive?
If the relationship wasn’t positive, this often results in toxic relationships and emotional dependence in adulthood. Children who have been separated from their parents seek the attachment that was taken away from them in their future relationships. John Bowlby was a pioneer of attachment theory. He discovered that maternal deprivation can ...
What happened to monkeys when they reached adult age?
When the monkeys reached an adult age, they couldn’t properly relate to the other monkeys. They couldn’t find partners, felt no need to reproduce, and some even stopped eating and drinking. Many died.
How long were monkeys trapped in cages?
Many of the monkeys were trapped inside these chambers for months, and some even years. Deprived of all social and sensory stimulation, the monkeys started to show changes in their behavior as a result of their confinement. The monkeys that were confined for a year entered a catatonic state. They became passive and indifferent towards everyone and everything.
What happens if you don't receive affection?
Extrapolating these conclusions onto human beings, children who don’t receive enough affection when they’re young, who are isolated and rejected, will have difficulty developing healthy relationships.
What monkeys did Harlow study?
Harlow also studied the development of rhesus monkeys that were not exposed to a fluffy surrogate or had no surrogate at all. The outcome for these infants was extremely negative. Rhesus infants raised with a milk-supplying metal surrogate had softer feces than infants raised with a milk-supplying fluffy surrogate.
What did Harlow show about fluffy surrogates?
In subsequent experiments, Harlow (1958) showed that the fluffy surrogate acted as a secure base from which rhesus infants could explore an unfamiliar environment or objects. In these experiments, the infants, along with their fluffy surrogates, were placed in an unfamiliar environment like a new cage.
Why is it difficult to know if the infant monkeys truly loved the surrogate mothers?
It is difficult to know whether the infant monkeys truly loved the surrogate mothers because Harlow could not ask them directly or measure the feeling of love using equipment.
How does a caregiver respond to an infant?
How the caregiver responds to the infant is known as sensitive responsiveness (Ainsworth et al., 1978). The fluffy surrogate mothers in Harlow’s experiment were not responsive, obviously; however, their presence, the material used to cover them, and their shape allowed the rhesus infants to cling to them, providing comfort, albeit a basic, unresponsive one.
Why was Harlow's work limited to the role of maternal surrogates?
Conclusions from Harlow’s work were limited to the role of maternal surrogates because the surrogates also provided milk – a function that only female mammals can perform. Consequently, it was posited that human infants have a strong need to form an attachment to a maternal caregiver (Bowlby, 1951).
How many monkeys did Harlow isolate?
In the partial isolation experiments, Harlow isolated a group of 56 monkeys from other monkeys; although they could hear and see the other monkeys, they were prevented from interacting with or touching them. These monkeys developed aggressive and severely disturbed behavior, such as staring into space, repetitive behaviors, and self-harm through chewing and tearing at their flesh.
What does Harlow's experiment suggest?
The results from Harlow’s experiments suggest that the role of the primary caregiver is not limited to satisfying infants’ primary drives.
Harlow’s Experiments: A Brief Summary
Three Fascinating Findings & Their Implications
Its Connection to Love and Attachment Theory
Follow-Up and Related Experiments
Criticisms of Harlow’s Experiments
Ethical Considerations of Harlow’s Experiments
- Harlow continued to perform experiments on rhesus monkeys, including studying the effects of partial to complete social deprivation. It is highly unlikely that Harlow’s experiments would pass the rigorous requirements of any ethics committee today. The separation of an infant from their parent, especially intending to study the effect of this separ...
Relevant Positivepsychology.Com Resources
A Take-Home Message