Knowledge Builders

what does schindler tell goeth about power

by Mr. Brendan Zemlak Published 3 years ago Updated 2 years ago
image

Goeth, who clearly has had too much to drink, tells Schindler, "The more I look at you-I watch you-you're never drunk." As Schindler stares, the commandant continues, "Oh, that's, that's real control. Control is power. That's power."

Full Answer

What does Schindler say to goeth?

Schindler: That's power, Amon. That is power. This conversation occurs between Goeth and Schindler after a party at Goeth's villa. Goeth is drunk and stumbling, while Schindler is cool and composed. In this quote, Schindler tries to influence Goeth to cease his random slaughter.

What is power according to Schindler?

He believes that power is having the ability to do something, but not doing it. He says, “Power is when we have every justification to kill, but we don’t.” I agree with Schindler’s definition because it takes more of yourself to not do something when you know you possibly could rather than actually doing it.

How does Amon conveys his respect for Schindler in this passage?

Amon conveys his respect for Schindler because he doesn't get drunk. He states that getting drunk limits a person's control and control is power. Schindler then goes on to say that real power and control is to pardon or forgive. Today I want to show you a clip from the movie Schindler’s List.

Why doesn't Amon Goeth get drunk in the movie Schindler?

A great scene where Oscar Schindler (played by Liam Neeson) sits with the heinous German prison camp leader, Amon Goeth (played by Ralph Fiennes). They have a conversation about power. Amon conveys his respect for Schindler because he doesn't get drunk. He states that getting drunk limits a person's control and control is power.

image

What is Schindler's idea of power?

He believes that power is having the ability to do something, but not doing it. He says, “Power is when we have every justification to kill, but we don't.” I agree with Schindler's definition because it takes more of yourself to not do something when you know you possibly could rather than actually doing it.

What deal does Schindler make with Goeth?

Oskar makes a deal with Goeth to buy back his Jews with his own money and take them to Czechoslovakia to open a new munitions factory.

What does the girl in the red coat symbolize?

The Girl in the Red Coat To Schindler, she represents the innocence of the Jews being slaughtered. He sees her from high atop a hill and is riveted by her, almost to the exclusion of the surrounding violence.

How does Schindler's List portray forgiveness?

Schindler saw this sadistic practice as Goeth's quest for power. To slow the killing, Schindler conned Goeth into trying a different path to power. “You can be such a big man,” he coaxed, “by forgiving these foolish Jews for their mistakes. Instead of shooting them, say 'I forgive you.

When Schindler's morality takes a hold of him what proposal does he make to Goeth?

He persuades Goeth to sell him his workers, as well as Goeth's maid, Helen Hirsch, to work in his factory in Czechoslovakia. The men and women are transported to Czechoslovakia on two separate trains, however, and the women are inadvertently diverted to Auschwitz, where Schindler is forced to buy them again.

What kind of person is Amon Goeth?

Sadistic and ruthless, Amon Goeth represents the evil of the Nazi Party. Goeth finds a sanctioned outlet for his cruelty in the Nazi military and is representative of the mindless evil of the Third Reich and its “final solution.” He views Jews as vermin, creatures unworthy of possessing basic human rights.

What does the candle represent in Schindler's List?

For the Jewish people, lighting the candle represents their relationship with God in observing the commandment to keep the Sabbath. The lighting of the candle in the first scene means that Spielberg wants to start out with a strong affirmation of the Jewish faith.

Is the red coat a true story?

A red coat does not a conflict make. Finally, though it is a work of fiction, the novel includes photos of the buildings or shops described and even photos of some of the supposedly fictional people.

Why are the candles in color in Schindler's List?

While the scene remains black and white, the candle's light flickers into colour, symbolic of the continuation of Jewish life and tradition in the face of annihilation.

Is Schindler's List realistic?

Twenty-five years later, the film is seen as a realistic depiction of life during the Holocaust, in terms of the brutality of the Nazis and the lifestyles of those they persecuted, though it does stray from the real story in a few big ways.

How does Schindler influence Goeth?

In this quote, Schindler tries to influence Goeth to cease his random slaughter. Understanding Goeth's need for power, he attempts to persuade him by telling him that power and violence are not the same. The following day, Goeth tries to follow Schindler's advice, but finds himself unable to do so.

What is the connection between Schindler and the Jewish people?

While Schindler's vice is greed, Goeth's is much more sinister. Furthermore, this quote establishes a connection between Schindler and the Jewish people. He lauds himself for showing up in Poland with nothing but a suitcase and flourishing - the exact same thing that Goeth disparages the Jews for doing.

What camp did Schindler and Stern buy Jews in?

Stern says this after he and Schindler complete the list of Jews who will be transferred to Schindler' s camp, Zwittau-Brinnlitz. The Jews on this list have been bought by Schindler so that they will not be sent to Auschwitz. Stern is drawing a distinction between this list and Schindler's actions in the past.

What is Schindler's War?

Schindler: War. First and foremost this quote elucidates Schindler's role as a profiteer of slave labor. More interestingly, however, this quote parallels Amon Goeth's monologue before the liquidation of the ghetto. When Goeth speaks, he talks of the historical importance of destruction and elimination of the Jews.

Why does Goeth say "Today is history"?

Today is history. Goeth says this to his soldiers before the liquidation of the ghetto. It is meant as inspiration for destruction and violence. This quote is one of the only of its kind in the movie, for it expresses the resentment against Jews and the reasons for the desire to remove them from society.

What does Goeth talk about when he speaks?

When Goeth speaks, he talks of the historical importance of destruction and elimination of the Jews. When Schindler speaks, he talks of the historical importance of his self-made riches. This highlights the difference between the two men, despite the fact that they are both men of power.

What does Schindler believe about women?

Schindler understands the importance of keeping families together. He also recognizes that he must keep a promise he made to the women. He views the Jewish people as humans, not commodities . Schindler thus insists upon receiving the women from his original list at Zwittau-Brinnlitz.

image

1.Schindler's List (power/forgiveness) - TheSource4YM

Url:https://thesource4ym.com/schindlers-list-power-forgiveness/

31 hours ago  · Goeth thinks power is in the act of exerting force, whereas Schindler believes true power lies in the ability to exercise forgiveness and mercy. Divide into Small Groups: Let’s go ahead and split up into our discussion groups, and then …

2.Oskar Schindler and Amon Goeth on Power, Justice, and …

Url:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UMdsW5iAFRE

29 hours ago A central idea in Schindler’s List is power: how it works, who has it, and what its limits are. Viewed from one angle, the power dynamics in the book might seem straightforward: the Nazis have power, and they use it to oppress the Jewish populations of the territories they occupy. But Keneally shows that power is never quite that simple.

3.Schindler's List (1993) - Quotes - IMDb

Url:https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0108052/quotes/qt2270557

10 hours ago  · Schindler has a different view of power. He believes that power is having the ability to do something, but not doing it. He says, “Power is …

4.Videos of What Does Schindler Tell Goeth About Power

Url:/videos/search?q=what+does+schindler+tell+goeth+about+power&qpvt=what+does+schindler+tell+goeth+about+power&FORM=VDRE

18 hours ago Oskar Schindler: Power is when we have every justification to kill, and we don't. Amon Goeth: You think that's power? Oskar Schindler: That's what the Emperor said. A man steals something, he's brought in before the Emperor, he throws himself down on the ground. He begs for his life, he knows he's going to die.

5.Schindler’s List Quotes and Analysis | GradeSaver

Url:https://www.gradesaver.com/schindlers-list/study-guide/quotes

6 hours ago Goeth: I think you are drunk. Schindler: That's power, Amon. That is power. Oskar Schindler and Amon Goeth. This conversation occurs between Goeth and Schindler after a party at Goeth's villa. Goeth is drunk and stumbling, while Schindler is cool and composed. In this quote, Schindler tries to influence Goeth to cease his random slaughter.

6.schindlers list test review Flashcards | Quizlet

Url:https://quizlet.com/468555224/schindlers-list-test-review-flash-cards/

13 hours ago  · What does Schindler tell goeth about power? “Control is power,” Goeth mutters. He argues that because the Nazi's can and do kill Jews at any time they please, Nazi leadership have all the power. Schindler rebukes that claim: “Power is when we have every justification to kill and we don't.” Goeth scoffs. That's power.

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9