Knowledge Builders

what happens if the pull up resistor for an i2c signal is too small

by Mittie Hessel Published 3 years ago Updated 2 years ago

What happens if the pull up resistor for an i2c signal is too small? I2C and other protocols like it use "open drain" (or "open collector") outputs. Too small of a value will once again prevent the output drivers from sinking enough current to pull the pin all the way down to 0.

Too lower value of pull-up resistor will mean the output will fail to go low properly. The lower value pull up resistors have, the better resulting I2C signal should be (provided that circuitry is not overloaded).Nov 26, 2014

Full Answer

Do I need pull-up resistors for I2C?

I2C requires pull-up resistors. But they weren't included in the schematic. Probably, you have internal pull-ups enabled on the ATmega. From what I've read1, ATmega have 20kΩ internal pull-ups, which can be enabled or disabled from the firmware. 20kΩ is way too weak for the I2C pull-up.

Why is the I2C line always high in a microcontroller?

Because there are only 2 logic level outputs from I2C, Low and open circuit. The default condition is all chips on the line are in open circuit mode, and the pull-up resistor makes the line high. The master chip can send an address signal to one of the chips on the line.

Do I2C data and clock lines (SDA and SCL) have pullup resistors?

Just now I realized that the I2C data and clock lines (SDA and SCL) must have pullup resistors. Well, I've built a couple of clocks using the DS1307 RTC (see datasheet) according to the schematic... Stack Exchange Network

How many ohms is an I2C resistor?

Great thing though, is many i2c devices work at a fraction of the max speeds. Just remember, the internal pullups can be up to 70k ohm, a typical i2c resistor is 4.7k\$\endgroup\$ – Passerby Mar 13 '14 at 4:16

Why are pull-up resistors needed on an I2C bus?

The pullup resistors pull the line high when it is not driven low by the open-drain interface. The value of the pullup resistor is an important design consideration for I2C systems as an incorrect value can lead to signal loss.

How do I choose a pull-up resistor for I2C?

These pull-ups would draw 3.3V / 1.77 k = 1.86 mA each when SCL / SDA is low. So, theoretically, if this bus has the absolute maximum amount of capacitance on it, this bus should use at least 1.77 k Ohm pull-up resistors, down to 171 Ohm resistors if their maximum low drive strength is 13.5 mA each during SCL/SDA low.

When choosing the resistance value of I2C pull-up resistors?

Notice the two pull-up resistors on the two communication lines. Resistor selection varies with devices on the bus, but a good rule of thumb is to start with 4.7kΩ resistor and adjust down if necessary. I2C is a fairly robust protocol, and can be used with short runs of wire (2-3m).

Why is pull-up resistor required on the SDA SCL I2C lines?

Both SCL and SDA lines are "open drain" drivers. What this means is that the chip can drive its output low, but it cannot drive it high. For the line to be able to go high you must provide pull-up resistors to the 5v supply.

How do I choose a pull-up resistor?

A rule of thumb is to use a resistor that is at least 10 times smaller than the value of the input pin impedance. In bipolar logic families which operate at operating at 5 V, the typical pull-up resistor value is 1-5 kΩ. For switch and resistive sensor applications, the typical pull-up resistor value is 1-10 kΩ.

Why do we need a pull-up resistor?

To control the current flow, we need those pull-down or pull up resistors. A pull-up resistor allow controlled current flow from supply voltage source to the digital input pins, where the pull-down resistors could effectively control current flow from digital pins to the ground.

What is a weak pull-up resistor?

A resistor with relatively high resistance is called a "weak" pull-up or pull-down; when the circuit is open, it will pull the output high or low more slowly, but will draw less current.

Are pull-up registers required in I2C a true b false?

Are pull up registers required in I2C? Explanation: At physical layer, both SCL and SDA lines are of open drain design, thus pull up resistors are needed.

How do you calculate pull-up and pull-down resistors?

In order to calculate pull-up and pull-down resistance, we need to first apply the formula in Ohm's Law: Resistance = Voltage/Current, or R= V/I.

How many pull-up resistors on I2C bus?

The I2C specification allows a maximum of 3 mA pull-up current on each I2C line. The Aardvark adapter has two internal pull-up resistors on each line: 2.2k ohm and 100k ohm resistors in parallel.

Why I2C lines are open-drain?

Open-Drain for Bidirectional Communication I2C requires that if a master in a multi-master environment transmits a high, but see's that the line is low (another device is pulling it down), to halt communications because another device is using the bus.

Does Arduino I2C need pull-up resistors?

From what I can tell, without the pull-up resistors the I2C lines will not function properly, requiring a base voltage to pull down from.

What is the resistor on an I2C circuit?

As discussed in the I2C Basics module, the resistors that are commonly seen on I2C circuits sitting between the SCL and SDA lines and the voltage source are called pull up resistors. But what is a pull up resistor?

What is pull up resistor?

A pull up resistor is used to provide a default state for a signal line or general purpose input/ouput (GPIO) pin. Typically they are of high resistance thousands or tens of thousands of ohms of resistance.

What is a capacitor in a circuit board?

A capacitor is a pair of electrically conductive surfaces with some sort of dielectric material sandwiched between them. This is pretty much also the exact definition of what a printed circuit board is. Unless you’re doing home etching or cheap power supply design, your boards will have the capability of copper laid on both sides of the board. Typically, at least one of those sides is used as a “ground plane”, meaning a giant field of copper that can be connected to from any point on the board by drilling a copper plated hole through the thing to provide a very quick and very low resistance path to ground. The thing that gets drilled through, is typically a material called FR4, a form of fiberglass… technically a flame resistant glass-reinforced epoxy laminate sheet if you’d like to impress your geek friends. What you wind up having is copper on the top, copper on the bottom, and dielectric smack dab in the middle: a capacitor — a dramatically inefficient one — but a capacitor none the less.

What is I2C protocol?

1. I2C is a TTL-logic protocol ; so your data and clock lines are open-drain. In other words, the I2C hardware can only drive these lines low; they are left floating when not a zero. That's where the pull-up resistors come in. This is a simplified diagram, but work with me for a second.

Can ATMega i2c be 3.3V?

The last thing to note though, having the internal pull-ups on, when your ATMega is at 5v, and the i2c device is a 3.3v only device, can cause issues. Or if you have the internal pull-ups on, and external resistors connected to a 3.3v or other voltage, can also cause issues.

How does a pull down resistor work?

A Pull-down resistor works in the same way as the previous pull-up resistor, except this time the logic gates input is tied to ground, logic level “0” (LOW) or it may go HIGH by the operation of a mechanical switch.

What is the maximum pull up resistance required to drop 3 volts for a single TTL 74LS logic

Then using Ohms Law, the maximum pull-up resistance required to drop 3 volts for a single TTL 74LS series logic gate would be 150kΩ. While this calculated value would work, it leaves no room for error as the voltage drop across the resistor is at its maximum while the input current is at its minimum.

What are the two states of a digital logic circuit?

Digital logic circuits operate using two binary states which are normally represented by two distinct voltages: a high voltage V H for logic “1” and low voltage V L for logic “0”. But within each of these two voltage states, there is a range of voltages which define the upper and lower voltages of these two binary states.

What is the logic state of a circuit?

These logic states are represented by two different voltage levels with any voltage below one level regarded as a logic “0”, and any voltage above another level regarded as logic “1”.

What is a digital logic gate?

Digital logic gates can be used for connection to external circuits or devices but care must be taken to ensure that their inputs or outputs function correctly and provide the expected switching condition.

What is a 74LS06?

A 74LS06 Hex Inverter Driver is required to control a single red LED indicator from a 12 volt supply. If the LED requires 15mA at 1.7V voltage drop and the V OL of the HEX Inverter when fully ON is 0.1 volts, calculate the value of the current limiting resistor required to drive the LED.

1.What happens if the pull-up resistor for an I2C signal is …

Url:https://www.quora.com/What-happens-if-the-pull-up-resistor-for-an-I2C-signal-is-too-small

14 hours ago If your pull-up resistor is small enough to allows more current to pass than this, the chip may either be damaged due to excessive sinking current (unlikely), or unable to pull the bus down because of limited current sinking capability (more likely). Then there is non-trivial parasitic capacitance at I/O and PCB traces in range of several pF.

2.I2C Pull Up Resistors - Rheingold Heavy

Url:https://rheingoldheavy.com/i2c-pull-resistors/

1 hours ago  · What happens if the pull up resistor for an i2c signal is too small? I2C and other protocols like it use "open drain" (or "open collector") outputs. Too small of a value will once again prevent the output drivers from sinking enough current to pull the pin all the way down to 0.

3.What happens if I omit the pullup resistors on I2C lines?

Url:https://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/102611/what-happens-if-i-omit-the-pullup-resistors-on-i2c-lines

36 hours ago Furthermore, what happens if the pull up resistor for an i2c signal is too small? There are now additional restrictions on the range of pull-up resistors; the pull-up value will form an RC circuit with the bus capacitance. Too small of a value will once again prevent the output drivers from sinking enough current to pull the pin all the way down to 0.

4.Is there a correct resistance value for I2C pull-up resistors?

Url:https://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/1849/is-there-a-correct-resistance-value-for-i2c-pull-up-resistors

20 hours ago In the event that you have a bus capacitance that exceeds 200pF and you are attempting to drive the I2C bus at Fast Mode speed or greater, pull up resistors will no longer be sufficient, and you’ll need to investigate the use of a current source or switched resistor circuit to supply the SDA and SCL logic high voltage necessary to achieve those signalling speeds with that much C BUS.

5.What is the use of a pull-up resistor in I2C? - Quora

Url:https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-use-of-a-pull-up-resistor-in-I2C

26 hours ago  · The pull-up resistors on all of the break out boards appear in parallel. Combined pull-up becomes too stiff for I2C. [More about this potential ... the pull-up resistor is needed to ensure a logic 1 is seen at the output when the TTL logic is not driving the output low. ... normal TTL and normal CMOS outputs will pull signal both up and down ...

6.Pull-up Resistor and Pull-down Resistor Explained

Url:https://www.electronics-tutorials.ws/logic/pull-up-resistor.html

5 hours ago Probably, you have internal pull-ups enabled on the ATmega. From what I've read 1, ATmega have 20kΩ internal pull-ups, which can be enabled or disabled from the firmware. 20kΩ is way too weak for the I 2 C pull-up. But if the bus has a low capacitance (physically small) and communication is slow enough, then 20kΩ can still make the bus work.

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9