Destructive Obedience Destructive obedience is the act of obeying a command to harm another. This type of obedience is seen in criminal relationships, sometimes influenced by substance abuse, where one partner has immense emotional sway over the other.
What are some examples of destructive obedience?
Examples of destructive obedience include soldiers obeying orders to attack civilians, medical personnel following a doctor’s orders even when they know the doctor is mistaken, and participants complying with the experimenter in Stanley Milgram ’s classic behavioral study of obedience. Compare constructive obedience.
What is destructive obedience in a relationship?
Destructive Obedience. Destructive obedience is the act of obeying a command to harm another. This type of obedience is seen in criminal relationships, sometimes influenced by substance abuse, where one partner has immense emotional sway over the other. This type of obedience is also seen in some cults, religions,...
What is the meaning of obedience?
Obedience is a form of social influence that occurs when a person yields to explicit instructions on orders from an authority figure. Obedience is compliance with commands given by an authority figure. In the 1960s‚ the social psychologist Stanley Milgram did a famous research study called the obedience study.
What is destructive obedience according to Milgram?
Milgram (1963) claimed that destructive obedience is not a consequence of moral weakness or an evil character; rather it is a response to a particular set of situational factors. Evaluate this statement. In order to evaluate this statement it is important to first understand what Milgram meant.
What are some examples of destructive obedience?
What is the act of obeying a command to harm another?
What is destructive obedience psychology?
Destructive obedience is the act of obeying a command to harm another. This type of obedience is seen in criminal relationships, sometimes influenced by substance abuse, where one partner has immense emotional sway over the other.
How do you resist destructive obedience?
And people everywhere are liable to obey authorities who incrementally ratchet up their destructive orders....Here are the lessons we should learn: Resist early. ... Resist loudly, visibly, and intelligently. ... Use authority to resist authority.More items...•
What are the 3 factors that affect obedience?
Conformity to social roles as investigated by Zimbardo. Explanations for obedience: agentic state and legitimacy of authority, and situational variables affecting obedience including proximity, location and uniform, as investigated by Milgram.
What is constructive obedience?
compliance with the orders of a social authority that results in some benefit to the compliant individual or the larger society of which he or she is a part.
What are the effects of destructive obedience?
compliance with the direct or indirect orders of a social, military, or moral authority that results in negative outcomes, such as injury to innocent victims, harm to the community, or the loss of confidence in social institutions.
Why do people blindly follow orders?
In everyday situations, people obey orders because they want to get rewards, because they want to avoid the negative consequences of disobeying, and because they believe an authority is legitimate. In more extreme situations, people obey even when they are required to violate their own values or commit crimes.
What factors reduce obedience?
Milgram conducted many variations of this basic procedure to explore some of the factors that affect obedience. He found that obedience rates decreased when the learner was in the same room as the experimenter and declined even further when the teacher had to physically touch the learner to administer the punishment.
Does personality affect obedience?
Political orientation and social activism were also related to obedience. Conclusion Our results provide empirical evidence suggesting that individual differences in personality and political variables matter in the explanation of obedience to authority.
What kind of person is obedient?
obedient, docile, tractable, amenable mean submissive to the will of another. obedient implies compliance with the demands or requests of one in authority.
How is obedience constructive and how can it be destructive?
Obedience can be constructive, by helping us know right from wrong. It also keeps Bruno from getting in trouble. However, obedience can also be destuctive, because we are being taught what we have to do, not what we should do. In the story, it is destructive, because Bruno does whatever his father says.
What are some real life examples of obedience?
What are some real-life examples of obedience? A real-life example of obedience includes a child honoring the wishes of parents. Another example would be a soldier respecting the commands of a higher-ranking soldier.
How can I be more obedient to God?
By gratefully taking care of the small things God has placed in you life, like making your bed and watering your plants, you are showing him that you are a good shepherd of what he gives you. By obeying in all things, even the mundane, you are showing God that you are willing and able to obey whatever he asks of you.
What does being obedient to God mean?
What does OBEDIENCE mean? In simple terms it means hearing the word of God and acting on it. It implies aligning our will to God's will; doing what God has asked us to do. It is when we completely surrender to His authority and base our decisions and our actions on His Word.
Why does the door in the face technique work?
It has been found the door-in-the face technique produces high levels of compliance only when the same person makes the request, and the requests are similar in nature. This technique works due to the principle of reciprocity (Cialdini et al., 1975).
What is the theme of obedience?
... Topic: Psychological Theme on Obedience Obedience is a fundamental value that is integrated in a child or person’s development. Within the family, authority is exercised by parents to discipline and nurture them so that they will act and follow in an orderly manner while in the process of growth. Orderly and peaceful behavior is also required in social interaction, thus, obedience is also required as a person is integrated in the mainstream of the society (Gross, 2010). As they grow, a person needs to comply on requirements and processes in social interaction. This paper will critically discuss about the psychological principles pertaining to obedience and cites practical example of an experimentation done by Milgram (1973) about exacting...
How does Cialdini's consistency principle work?
There are two procedures to gain compliance that usually rest with Cialdini’s consistency principle; the foot-in-the-door procedure which involves making a small request and once compliance is gained, a larger request is made (which was originally desired).This normally works since refusing the larger request is not consistent with allowing the first request. The other technique is that of lowball procedure which gives a very ideal deal to an individual. Once accepted, the terms are changed so that they become less advantageous.
What did Benjamin and Simpson argue about Milgram's obedience experiments?
However, Benjamin & Simpson argue that even though Milgram obedience experiments brought out the effects of ineffectual and irresolute disobedience, it failed to answer the main question or hypothesis it was intended to answer and that is Destructive obedience inside a social context (2009).... Review Assignment (Name) (University) Review Assignment The article The power of the situation: The impact of Milgram's obedience studies on personality and social psychology by Benjamin & Simpson, evaluates the psychological studies done by Stanley Milgram regarding obedience to authority (2009)....
Why is it important for children to obey authority figures?
Accordingly, authority figures in the lives of children are the sources of guidance and knowledge. It is therefore very important that children are socialized to obey such figures for their (children’s) good.
Why do we feel obliged to offer discounts?
This is because we feel indebted to them. For instance, if a supplier has offered you a discount before you may feel indebted to buy from his store. c) Liking-Cialdini argues that we are most likely to be influenced by the people we like or love. Likability may portray itself in several forms such as people who are similar to us, those who give us compliments and simply the people we trust.
The Justification Of Hitler And The Idolization Of Adolf Hitler
However, Hitler would exploit their support and convert it into destruction. During the Second World War, Germans would become perpetrators, accomplices or bystanders. With propaganda portraying Hitler as a godlike figure, citizens began worshipping him for his political prowess.
Judgement At Nuremberg Film Analysis
Also at opening statement, Rolfe quotes “My country, right or wrong”, from the great American jurist supreme court justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, to reinforce his standing on Patriotism. Later, when a case regarding sexual sterilization is introduced, which were signed by those German judges, he quotes again from the Supreme Court Justice.
The Importance Of The Actions Of Adolf Hitler
The Third Reich was controlled by the Nazi Party, a party that favoured totalitarian governments. A totalitarian government admires violence and aggression to maintain order within a country. Therefore, Hitler resorted to using totalitarian ways to keep “order” within Germany.
Hitler's Idea Of Justice Essay
Hitler was able to change his party member 's idea of justice by altering their moral values. Cruelness became more accepted by the people of Germany because Adolf Hitler pushed his interpretation of justice on his citizens.
The Reasons For The Holocaust
In his rise to power as the Chancellor of Germany, he repeatedly expressed these views of superiority, and he used the discontent Germans felt after losing World War I as one of the chief pillars for his rise to power.
Adolf Hitler's Use Of Propaganda
Adolf Hitler was charismatic and manipulative leader who used his spellbinding oratory skills to create sense of blind obedience. Hitler formed a sense of unification by targeting a common scapegoat, and creating the ultimate “Nazi Myth.” Propaganda was a common instrument used to promote jingoistic attitudes.
Analysis Of Stanley Milgram's The Perils Of Obedience
In "The Perils of Obedience," Stanley Milgram conducted a study that tests the conflict between obedience to authority and one's own conscience. What he found that through fear and threats anyone could commit a crime and what he believed that authority plays a huge role in our lives.
Why was everyone debriefed at the end of the experiment?
Due to concerns about the amount of anxiety experienced by many of the participants, everyone was debriefed at the end of the experiment.
What would happen if an authority figure ordered you to deliver a 400 volt electrical shock to another person?
If an authority figure ordered you to deliver a 400-volt electrical shock to another person, would you follow orders? Most people would answer with an adamant "no." However, the Milgram obedience experiment aimed to prove otherwise.
Why were participants carefully screened?
Participants were also carefully screened to eliminate those who might experience adverse reactions to the experiment.
What are some examples of destructive obedience?
An example of destructive obedience would be the Charles Manson murders in which his followers murdered innocent people at his request.
What is the act of obeying a command to harm another?
Destructive Obedience. Destructive obedience is the act of obeying a command to harm another. This type of obedience is seen in criminal relationships, sometimes influenced by substance abuse, where one partner has immense emotional sway over the other.
