Gilligan's Stages of Moral Development
- Preconventional Morality. At the Preconventional Level, moral judgment is entirely focused on the self and the need to survive.
- Transition 1. During the first transition from the Preconventional to the Conventional Level, the woman realizes that she has a responsibility to others.
- Conventional Morality. ...
- Transition 2. ...
- Postconventional Morality. ...
See more
What are the three steps in Carol Gilligan's theory of moral development?
Lesson Summary Gilligan's theory focused on both care-based morality and justice-based morality by proposing three stages of moral development: pre-conventional, conventional and post-conventional.
What is Gilligan's perspective on moral development?
Gilligan's work on moral development outlines how a woman's morality is influenced by relationships and how women form their moral and ethical foundation based on how their decisions will affect others. She believes that women tend to develop morality in stages.
How is Gilligan's moral development applied to teaching?
By listening to women's experiences, Gilligan offered that a morality of care can serve in the place of the morality of justice and rights espoused by Kohlberg. In her view, the morality of caring and responsibility is premised in nonviolence, while the morality of justice and rights is based on equality.
What do you mean by Kohlberg's and Gilligan's theory?
Kohlberg pursues development of universal abstract moral principles while Gilligan's moral reasoning is contextual and grounded with a goal of taking ethical actions that preserve both the self and relationships with others.
What is the greatest strength of Gilligan's theory?
"Gilligan's goal was to prove that women are not "moral midgets", so she was going against many psychological opinions. Strengths: Better understanding of each gender so they can work together better.
What is Carol Gilligan best known for?
Carol Gilligan, (born November 28, 1936, New York, New York, U.S.), American developmental psychologist best known for her research into the moral development of girls and women.
What is the main essence of Gilligan's theory?
Gilligan's theory is based on the two main ideas, the care-based morality (usually found in women) and the justice-based morality (usually found in men).
Why Carol Gilligan was critical of Kohlberg's theory of moral development?
Why was Carol Gilligan critical of Kohlberg's theory of moral development? Gilligan criticized Kohlberg because his theory was based on the responses of upper class White men and boys, arguing that it was biased against women.
What is the difference between Kohlberg's theory of moral development and Gilligan's theory of moral development and gender?
(2) Kohlberg's theory is based upon rationality, duty, impartiality, and universally accepted abstract principle of justice. Gilligan's model is based upon female characteristics of care and relationship. (3) Women as per Kohlberg's model are inferior to men so long as moral development is concerned.
Why Carol Gilligan was critical of Kohlberg's theory of moral development?
Why was Carol Gilligan critical of Kohlberg's theory of moral development? Gilligan criticized Kohlberg because his theory was based on the responses of upper class White men and boys, arguing that it was biased against women.
How does Kohlberg's theory of moral development differ from Gilligan's theory quizlet?
Gilligan felt that women went through the same three stages of development developed by Kohlberg, but that women reasoned differently than men on moral issues due to having different perspectives on moral issues.
What is Carol Gilligan's moral development?
Carol Gilligan: Moral Development. A community of moles gives shelter to a homeless porcupine. The moles, however, are constantly stabbed by the porcupine's quills.
What are Gilligan's three stages of moral development?
Gilligan's theory focused on both care-based morality and justice-based morality by proposing three stages of moral development: pre-conventional, conventional and post-conventional. In each stage, the individual transitions from one focus to another, eventually establishing a balance between caring for one's self and others.
What is moral development?
The field of moral development encompasses prosocial behavior, such as altruism, caring and helping, along with traits such as honesty, fairness, and respect. Many theories of moral development have been proposed, but this lesson will focus on the specific theory proposed by Psychologist Carol Gilligan. Gilligan was a student of Developmental ...
What is Gilligan's theory of care?
Gilligan's theory focused on both care-based morality and justice-based morality. Care-based morality is based on the following principles: Emphasizes interconnectedness and universality.
How many stages are there in the Ethics of Care Theory?
There are three stages in the Ethics of Care Theory. Like Kohlberg, Gilligan proposed three stages in her Ethics of Care theory: pre-conventional, conventional and post-conventional. Within each stage, there are goals and specific transition points that move the individual through the stages.
Why is care based morality more common in girls?
Care-based morality is thought to be more common in girls because of their connections to their mothers.
What is the goal of Gilligan's transition?
During the pre-conventional stage, the individual learns to care for oneself. The goal is individual survival. The transition is from selfishness to responsibility toward others.
What are the two moral orientations of Gilligan's theory?
It is now widely acknowledged that there are two moral orientations, one that emphasizes justice and one that emphasizes care, as Gilligan proposed.
What is the movement through Gilligan's stages of moral development?
Movement through Gilligan's stages of moral development hinges on an evolving sense of self. At the Preconventional Level, only the needs of the self are recognized; at the Conventional Level, the needs of others are prioritized while the needs of the self are denied; at the Postconventional Level, a balance is struck between the needs of the self and others.
Why did Gilligan propose that women come to prioritize an ethic of care?
Gilligan proposed that women come to prioritize an "ethics of care" as their sense of morality evolves along with their sense of self while men prioritize an "ethics of justice."
What is Kohlberg's theory of moral development?
Kohlberg's theory of moral development consists of three levels each made up of two stages. At the lowest, the Preconventional Level, the needs of the self are prioritized. This evolves into the Conventional Level to an understanding of how to be a moral member of society. Finally, at the highest level, the Postconventional Level, the individual adopts a universal idea of justice. 1
Why did Gilligan conduct interviews?
Gilligan conducted several interview studies with girls and women, including one with women who were deciding whether to have an abortion, in order to flesh out her ideas about women's morality.
Where did Gilligan get her PhD?
Gilligan received her PhD in social psychology from Harvard University in 1964 and by 1967 was working as a research assistant to Lawrence Kohlberg at her alma mater.
Which philosopher said most people won't reach the highest stages of his scale but would stop developing morally in the middle?
Kohlberg observed that most people won't reach the highest stages of his scale but would stop developing morally in the middle stages at the Conventional Level, and that's exactly what research showed.
What is Gilligan's theory of moral development?
Gilligan's theory of moral development in adolescent girls argues that women develop differently than men do. Explore moral development and the differences between Kohlberg's theory and Gilligan's theory. Updated: 10/01/2021
What is the moral development of Gilligan?
Of course, in Gilligan's model (and often in life), it is usually the woman sacrificing herself for others, not the man. 3. Morality of nonviolence. The final stage in Gilligan's moral development of women is when they come to believe that hurting anyone, including themselves, is immoral.
What are the stages of moral development?
Based on why people believe that Heinz was right or wrong in stealing the drugs for his wife, Lawrence Kohlberg came up with Kohlberg's three stages (divided into six substages) of moral development: preconventional morality, conventional morality and postconventional morality.
What did Carol Gilligan believe?
Carol Gilligan didn't believe so. She argued that men and women are raised differently, and therefore experience moral development differently. Specifically, Gilligan pointed out that while men are raised to see morality as being about justice and fairness, women are raised to see morality as being about compassion and sacrifice.
What is Carol Gilligan's alternative theory of moral development?
Carol Gilligan's alternative theory of moral development in girls looks at how women move from seeing the right thing as being about selfishness or selflessness to finding a balance between the two.
What is the moral development of Lawrence Kohlberg?
Lawrence Kohlberg's theory of moral development looked at the way that people move from focusing on rewards and punishment to focusing on justice. But many people have criticized Kohlberg for basing his theory on white, Western males. Carol Gilligan's alternative theory of moral development in girls looks at how women move from seeing ...
How do people develop according to Kohlberg?
So, according to Kohlberg, people develop by going from thinking about rewards and punishment to thinking about justice. But is this an accurate description of all people?
What is Gilligan's contribution to moral development?
At the morality as equality stage, one would have to equally balance the benefits to everyone in making a moral judgment. Gilligan’s contribution to our understanding of moral develop has been acknowledged by Kohlberg and others (Levine, Kohlberg.
What is Gilligan's stage theory?
Gilligan’s Stage Theory of Moral Development. The young child’s first sense of what is “right” is what is good for him or her . Young children follow rules to obtain rewards for themselves and to avoid punishment.
How did Kohlberg collect data for his stage theory of moral development?
Kohlberg collected data for his stage theory of moral development by presenting boys with moral dilemmas and asking for evaluations of the people and actions involved . The following is an example of the type of dilemma used by Kohlberg in his research: In Europe, a lady was dying because she was very sick.
Why is Heinz wrong in Kohlberg's premoral stage?
As in Kohlberg’s premoral stage, the kind of immature moral reasoning that Gilligan terms the morality as individual survival stage would judge Heinz to be wrong simply because he would be punished. At the morality as self-sacrifice stage. Heinz might be judged to be correct in sacrificing his own welfare to save his wife.
Why did Kohlberg use boys?
Because Kohlberg and others used mostly boys in the initial studies that led to Kohlberg’s theory of moral development. Carol Gilligan (1982) has suggested that Kohlberg’s theory does not always accurately describe moral development in girls. She argues that female children pass through somewhat different stages.
What was Kohlberg interested in?
Kohlberg was interested in the logical process through which people arrived at their answers to moral dilemmas. He concluded that we pass through the three major levels of the development of moral reasoning shown in table below.
When do children use premoral reasoning?
Nearly all children use only premoral reasoning at age 7, but conventional moral reasoning predominates after age 11. Thus, Kohlberg sees the first two major shifts in moral reasoning as occurring at the same times as the beginnings of the preoperational and concrete operational stages in Piaget’s theory of cognitive development.
What is Kohlberg's theory of moral development?
Kohlberg's theory suggests that moral development occurs in a series of six stages. The theory also suggests that moral logic is primarily focused on seeking and maintaining justice.
What Is Moral Development?
How do people develop morality? This question has fascinated parents, religious leaders, and philosophers for ages, but moral development has also become a hot-button issue in psychology and education. 1 Do parental or societal influences play a greater role in moral development? Do all kids develop morality in similar ways?
How many levels of moral development did Kohlberg have?
Kohlberg's theory is broken down into three primary levels. At each level of moral development, there are two stages. Similar to how Piaget believed that not all people reach the highest levels of cognitive development, Kohlberg believed not everyone progresses to the highest stages of moral development.
How did Piaget and Kohlberg differ?
3 Kohlberg extended Piaget's theory, proposing that moral development is a continual process that occurs throughout the lifespan. His theory outlines six stages of moral development within three different levels.
Which level of moral development did Kohlberg believe everyone progressed to?
Level 1. Preconventional Morality. Preconventional morality is the earliest period of moral development.
What is the final stage of Kohlberg's moral reasoning?
Stage 6 (Universal Principles): Kohlberg’s final level of moral reasoning is based on universal ethical principles and abstract reasoning. At this stage, people follow these internalized principles of justice, even if they conflict with laws and rules.
What is Kohlberg's theory?
Kohlberg's theory played an important role in the development of moral psychology. While the theory has been highly influential, aspects of the theory have been critiqued for a number of reasons:
