What is the story the machine that won the war about?
“The Machine That Won the War” (1961) is a science fiction story by Isaac Asimov (1920-1992). As the tale opens, scientists who have been tending to the enormous “Multivac” computer have taken a rest and the huge machine itself has been given some temporary down-time.
What is dramatic irony in the machine that won the war?
what is dramatic irony in the machine that won the war. In Asimov’s ironically named “The Machine That Won the War,” three leaders reflect on their recent military success in a war against the Deneb.
Who won the war between Earth and Multivac?
Earth has won the war. Main characters celebrating the victory. Henderson states, "Multivac had nothing to do with victory. It's just a machine." 1. Henderson explains how the data being fed to Multivac was corrupted and also how he created data on his own to put into the machine.
Should I read “the machine that won the war” or the interlopers?
While both “The Machine that Won the War” and “The Interlopers” are both splendid short stories, the style in which they are written may lead you to read one over the other. “The Machine that Won the War” and “The Interlopers” are set in different time periods.
What is the irony in The Machine That Won the War?
Both stories show examples of situational irony. In The Machine that Won the War irony occurs when you think the machine won the war because it has complicated techniques and plans when really you find out the war was decided by tossing a coin. While in The Story of an Hour after Mr. Mallard death his wife Mrs.
What is the story The Machine That Won the War about?
Today we have Watson but in 1961 Isaac Asimov wrote a short science fiction story about the Multivac — a supercomputer that helped humans defeat the Denebians in a war. The story is set after the successful conclusion of the war.
What is the falling action of The Machine That Won the War?
Climax: Jablonsky admits that he never trusted the information that Multivac produced and interpreted it. Falling action and Resolution: Swift admits that he never trusted any of the information either and based his decision on the flip of a coin.
What is the genre of The Machine That Won the War?
science fiction short story"The Machine That Won the War" is a science fiction short story by American writer Isaac Asimov. The story first appeared in the October 1961 issue of The Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction, and was reprinted in the collections Nightfall and Other Stories (1969) and Robot Dreams (1986).
What is the theme of the story The Machine That Won the War?
The Machine That Won the War by Isaac Asimov. In The Machine That Won the War by Isaac Asimov we have the theme of doubt, reliability, trust, chance, responsibility, independence and self-importance. Taken from his Nightfall and Other Stories collection the reader realises after reading the story that Asimov may be exploring the theme of doubt.
Who won the war against the Denebians?
Earth won the war against the Denebians. However the bigger question to ask is whether or not any of the three men and Multivac should have been allowed to make the required decisions in the war against the Denebians.
What is interesting about the story of Multivac?
What is also interesting about the story is the fact that it becomes clear to the reader that none of the three men trust the data that Multivac outputs. In Henderson’s case he sees clearly that the information needs correcting and as such does so. Jablonsky like Henderson makes minor adjustments to the information based on intuition and Swift takes a risk between only two options (heads or tails). Not exactly a definitive way to approach or tackle a war but nonetheless it worked to Swift’s advantage. Earth won the war against the Denebians. However the bigger question to ask is whether or not any of the three men and Multivac should have been allowed to make the required decisions in the war against the Denebians. Some critics might argue that Multivac because it was receiving corrected information form Henderson might have a responsibility in winning the war. Others might suggest that Jablonsky by working on intuition was taking unnecessary risks. Though the real driving factor for winning the war appears to be Swift and his game of chance. As mentioned he was guaranteed a fifty-fifty chance of being successful. Which is higher odds than Jablonsky’s method and because Henderson’s information was tampered with by Jablonsky before it reached Swift. Henderson’s input in winning the war is minimal.
Why is the end of the story muted?
The end of the story is rather muted because it becomes clear to the reader that those in responsible roles mistrusted Multivac. Though they were clever enough not to say so. Instead Henderson and Jablonsky worked in secret and allowed for Multivac to output the information that they thought was best.
Did Asimov give tallies for those who died in the war?
Only then did they decide to pass the information on to Swift. Who made his own decisions by flipping a coin. Though Asimov does not give tallies for those who were killed in the war. It is possible that all three men are responsible for unnecessary deaths. As often happens at times of war.
Was Asimov responsible for losing the war?
He could have been responsible for losing the war and in the process Earth’s in habitants may be under the rule of the Denebians. However Asimov might be suggesting that regardless of how the war was won. It was just as risky to allow Multivac make the decisions as it was for Swift to make them.
What was the name of the machine that won the war?
The machine, named Multivac, is featured in ...
What is the name of the machine that is used in Isaac Asimov's stories?
The machine, named Multivac, is featured in several of Isaac Asimov’s tales, but in this one, in particular, the relationship between computers and humans no longer looks like science fiction. Despite the nearly five decades that have elapsed since its initial publication, the story not only remains relevant but continues to impress contemporary ...
Where does the story of the Multivac take place?
The setting of the tale occurs in “the silent depths of Multivac’s underground chambers” (593) in the aftermath of Earth’s triumph over Deneb. Unaccustomed to being at peace after years of conflict, three men relax in the brief interval between war and peace and discuss the reasons for Earth’s victory. Lamar Swift, a military captain and executive director of the Solar Federation, is the oldest of the three; using almost human terms, the other two men, John Henderson, chief programmer, and Max Jablonsky, chief interpreter of Multivac, discuss the machine as the apparent “hero” of the war. Henderson is the first to unburden himself of his guilty secret when he announces that Multivac was irrelevant to the victory. Believing Multivac’s data to be corrupt and therefore unreliable, Henderson confesses that he corrected the data by using his intuition and juggling the bits and pieces “until they looked right” (595).
What is the purpose of the confessional urge in Isaac Asimov's tale?
Although Asimov’s tale is brief, it employs human guilt and the confessional urge to demonstrate that human arrogance, self-centeredness, and propensity for risk taking are inherent in all human action, whether or not “machines” are involved . Asimov, Isaac.
What is the difference between the Machine that won the war and the Interlopers?
“The Machine that Won the War” and “The Interlopers” are set in different time periods. “The Machine that Won the War” is set in a futuristic setting. It talks about advanced computers, and wars that were fought on distant planets. On a different note, “The Interlopers” is set in time that has passed. An example is shown….
Why is the Civil War so controversial?
In 150 years later, battle lingers over how textbooks explain Civil War (Washington Post) , the author wrote that even today some people still thinks that the civil war is about state right instead of slavery. The reason why the civil war is still controversial is that all the education and general opinion is the north fought for slave rights….
Who won the first Punic War?
first Punic War began in 264 B.C. and was fought between Carthage and Rome jostling to control Sicily because of its prime trade location, resulting in a Roman victory. The second Punic War was also won by Rome and was fought in Spain because of the incredible hatred Carthaginian general Hannibal had for Rome. The third and final Punic War ended in 146 B.C. when Rome destroyed Carthage. Although the Romans were lucky that Hannibal let many opportunities to attack them slip by, the Romans won the Punic….
Why were the demographics unsure at the end of the war?
The reason for the unsure demographics is that near the end of the war, records of enlistment were either incomplete or destroyed. In total, the Union outnumbered the Confederacy at least three to one, militarily wise. 2. Missed opportunities At many stages, events on the battlefield might have gone differently.
Is the war on terror a war that can be won?
Ever since, there has been a vigorous debate about how to win it.’1 However more than 12 years on there is still no indication of how close it is to being won and whether it can actually be won. In fact, many such as Jonathan Steele (journalist and international affairs author) suggests it is ‘A war that can never be won.’2 However, before we….
The story "machine that won the war"
Based on the story, machine that won the war, it can be said that trust is the only equipments that can be used to win war.
New questions in English
Which detail from the article is MOST important to the development of its MAIN idea? I am from a small village in Germany and never dreamed of becomin …
What does Henderson say about Multivac?
It's just a. machine.". 1. Henderson explains how the data being fed to Multivac was corrupted and also how he created data on his own to put into the machine. Ultimately he thinks he won the war. 2.
Did Swift leave a life or death decision to a computer?
Swift states he couldn't leave a life or death decision to a computer, and ignored any recommendation made by Jablonsky. Thus Jablonsky didn't win the war and Henderson's efforts were done in vain. Climax. Swift reveals that he flipped a coin to make all his important decisions. Falling Action. None.
