what was wrong with the star wars prequels

by Dr. Maximo Beatty Published 3 years ago Updated 2 years ago

10 Times The Star Wars Prequels Disregarded The Original Trilogy

Midichlorians. The most controversial thing George Lucas did with his prequel trilogy was attempting to explain the force.
They Suggest That Technology Devolved. The prequels see a few very strange pieces of technology that seem years beyond anything in the original trilogy.
Yoda Trained Obi-Wan. ...
Yoda’s Acrobatics. ...
Jedi Fighting Style In General. ...

Without a doubt, the biggest issue with the trilogy is the dialogue. While the story of the trilogy was excellent, and things like politics could be interesting and fantastic (as shown in The Clone Wars), the dialogue was atrocious throughout. The trilogy definitely has some great lines.Jun 27, 2021

Full Answer

Were the Star Wars prequels about good or bad things?

Dec 17, 2019 · 10 Wrong: Overreliance on CGI. To be fair to George Lucas, CGI was in its infancy when he made the Star Wars prequel trilogy, and he was one of the pioneers at the forefront of its technological advancement. At the time, the ability to fill the frame with all kinds of computer …

Is there anything wrong with a prequel?

The Star Wars prequels are bad. They're stilted and strange, with bland stories that get stuck in first gear, performances that can't escape director George Lucas's apparent desire to create an emotionless universe, and gratuitous visual effects that at times seem to be the movies' main …

Do you think the prequels dragged down the original trilogy?

Dec 08, 2015 · The reason the Star Wars prequels fail so spectacularly, both as Star Wars films and science fiction cinema, is a total lack of humanity. The prequels are a cold, joyless experience, spawned by the uninhibited mania of George Lucas and his mob of adoring yes …

What was the appeal of the original Star Wars trilogy?

In short, the prequels were crucial to worldbuilding in Star Wars, an aspect that was mostly ignored in the original trilogy. They introduced so much lore that they made Star Wars much …

What went wrong with the Star Wars prequels?

The writing was bad, the character names were laughably on-the-nose, and the movies were too long. They were stuffed with action set-pieces that contributed little to the plot while leaving out critical scenes that provided much-needed depth.Feb 3, 2021

What's wrong with The Phantom Menace?

phantom menace is very boring. flat dialogue, poor acting, few duels, dull discussions( be it midclorians or trade routes). phantom menace is the only boring film that has passed the one-billion mark at the box-office because of its star wars name.Mar 17, 2022

Why didn't George Lucas make the prequels first?

George Lucas always meant for the first Star Wars film to not be the true first. With the background in place — at least vaguely in his head — prior to the opening scene of A New Hope, Lucas ensured he would already have a semi-formed story for a prequel trilogy, should the films turn into a success.Jan 2, 2022

What does Mark Hamill think of the prequels?

In the interview, as reported by IndieWire, Hamill gave some love to prequel defenders across the galaxy. “I was impressed the prequels had their own identity,” Hamill said. “They were criticized because they were exposition-heavy and more cerebral and probably, like he said back in 1976, they weren't as commercial.Sep 27, 2021

Was The Phantom Menace a flop?

No amount of commercial success, though, could cover up the consensus that The Phantom Menace was a creative failure. The force was not with the film when it came to critics, who savaged Lucas's creation with Maul-like malice.May 19, 2019

Why is episode one called The Phantom Menace?

Lucas later revealed that the Phantom Menace title was a reference to Palpatine hiding his true identity as an evil Sith Lord behind the facade of a well-intentioned public servant.

Did George Lucas know he would make prequels?

A major gap had been crossed and things were never going to be the same. In 1992, Lucas acknowledged that he had plans to create the prequel trilogy in the Lucasfilm Fan Club magazine, and announced this to Variety in late 1993.

Why is Clone Wars out of order?

Earliest Clone Wars episodes were stand-alone episodes, in which the viewers are not required to watch the previous episodes in order to understand the story. However, as they realized that the show attracts older people, they made the stories more complex by making the episodes chronological .

Why did Star Wars start at 4?

In the end, making the first film, Episode IV, was symbolic for being the opportunity Lucas needed to give fans even more stories that could potentially evolve beyond even that.Mar 27, 2022

Which Star Wars movies are the prequels?

Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith

Star Wars: Episode IV – A New Hope / Prequel

What did Mark Hamill do before Star Wars?

Hamill continued to land small television roles in other series like General Hospital and The Magician before landing his breakthrough role as Luke Skywalker in 1977. Hamill remains most recognizable as Luke even at 70 years old.Feb 15, 2022

What did Mark Hamill do after Return of the Jedi?

Hamill returned to film after a six-year hiatus with the 1989 science fiction film Slipstream. He continued to star in films throughout the 1990s, including in such films as the thriller Midnight Ride, The Guyver in 1991, the 1995 remake of Village of the Damned, and the 1998 Swedish action film Hamilton.

Do the original movies use lightsabers?

The original movies really use the Lightsaber to full effect. Such an incredible and otherworldly piece of technology, its drawn only on those occasions when we know its required. These confrontations are slow, at a standstill compared to the prequels, but layered with a depth of subtext that visually conveys the characters emotional states. The duels in the new trilogy, while admittedly spectacular from a technical viewpoint, lack any sort of emotional depth and fail to serve any purpose other than to herd the unruly plot, and dazzle those who believe CGI to be the new story. Even the long foreshadowed Anakin vs. Obi -Wan duel, which pulls some of the most sophisticated fight choreography Ive ever seen out of the bag (and is admittedly vaguely exciting for a minute or two into it's colossal but self-indulgent run time) feels emotionally flat thanks to the fact that were never given a real reason to care.

Is R2 a service droid?

R2 is a normal service droid that is illogically awarded a medal in Episode I, just for performing his function and 3PO is built from junk on Tatooine, despite the fact that he is clearly a mass-produced protocol droid.

What is Jar Jar Binks?

Jar Jar Binks is almost an inadvertent metaphor for the state of the Star Wars prequels; insidious and saccharine. He is literally one of the most ridiculous, banal characters ever to have been immortalised on screen and that includes Childrens Television.

7 The Jedi Order Allowed Its Own weakening To Happen

The Jedi Order was one of the most powerful groups in the entire Republic, beholden to the Senate and the Supreme Chancellor, the guardians of justice in the galaxy. However, that was the problem with the Jedi and it's where their biggest mistakes stemmed from.

6 The Jedi Council Trusted In Their Power To Weather Any Storm

The weakening of the Order started at the top and the Jedi Council moved the Order into the direction that would spell doom for it. The Council was composed of some of the most powerful Jedi in the galaxy, beings who were secure in their powers and their ability to listen to the will of the Force.

5 Ahsoka Tano Allowed Her Disillusionment With The Jedi & The War To Drive Her From The Order

Ahsoka proved her worth during the Clone Wars, but war is hard on adults and she was just a teenager. The straw that broke the camel's back was the bombing of the Jedi Temple and the revelation that her friend Barriss Offee was behind it. The war had broken the young Padawan and that had a profound effect on Ahsoka.

4 Mace Windu's Failure To Kill Palpatine Doomed The Republic

Mace Windu could have ended the whole thing before it even happened if he had been better. He and a group of Council masters went to arrest Supreme Chancellor Palpatine and the battle cost all but Mace their lives. The Jedi and the Sith battled it out, with Windu able to keep up with the Sith Lord.

3 Yoda's Failure To See Through Palpatine's Lies Doomed Everyone

Yoda was one of the Order's most venerable Masters, but that doesn't mean he was the best Jedi. Yoda was just as responsible for what happened to the Jedi Order as anyone, so sure was he in its power and the righteousness of its cause.

2 Obi-Wan's Failure To Kill Anakin Doomed Millions At The Hands Of Darth Vader

Obi-Wan Kenobi and Anakin Skywalker's relationship was one of the most unique in the Jedi Order. They were brothers as much as they were partners and they worked together flawlessly. Many foes lost to the pair and the two of them were an unstoppable team.

1 Anakin's Failure To Realize What Palpatine Was Doing Doomed Everyone

Lots of people failed Anakin— including the Jedi Council— but his own failure with Palpatine doomed everyone. Anakin felt like he was greater than he was given credit for and Palpatine was there to pad his ego.

Is the Star Wars prequel a good movie?

The Star Wars prequel trilogy was reviewed quite harshly by critics and viewers alike at first, but over time has become far more appreciated. Some of the biggest complaints involved the chemistry between Hayden Christenson’s Anakin Skywalker and Natalie Portman’s Padme Amidala, too strong of a focus on politics (and subsequently slow pacing), and an overabundance of computer-generated imagery instead of practical effects.

When did Disney buy Star Wars?

Lucasfilm, and subsequently the Star Wars franchise, were purchased by Disney in October of 2012 and a sequel trilogy was announced simultaneously. While Star Wars has always been popular, and many fans had warmed up to the prequels in the years since their release, the general audience still wasn't immediately sold on the idea ...

Is the Force Awakens a remake?

Unfortunately, this led to one of the film’s most common criticisms: The basic plot of The Force Awakens is so similar to Star Wars, that the film often feels like a remake. While Legends and the prequels told their own stories and had their own identities, The Force Awakens often lacked originality.

Is Rey related to anyone?

Most viewers assumed that Rey was related to an established character, so The Last Jedi made her related to nobody. Some applaud this choice for its message that anybody can be a Jedi, but the original and prequel trilogies already established this quite clearly.

Is Rise of Skywalker an apology?

In short, it felt like an apology for Star Wars: The Last Jedi.

Who is David Miller?

David Miller (155 Articles Published) David Miller is an author for Screen Rant, indie comic writer, and life-long lover of all things Star Wars, Marvel, and DC. He was born and raised in New York and has a degree in English from Rider University. He relates to Peter Parker maybe a little too much.

What happened at the end of Return of the Jedi?

At the end of Return of the Jedi, we watched as the good guys fell into a trap. Han and Leia were captured on Endor, the fleet was about to be blown up by the Death Star , and Luke was considering a move to the dark side. The good guys were losing and it was hard to see any way out.

Was Jar Jar funny?

Jar Jar was a huge mistake on every level. He wasn’t funny at all, and the need to insert him into every scene made him even more annoying. He bumbled around in the background of conversations, he stepped in shit, got farted on, and generally behaved like the cheapest comic relief character there was.