Knowledge Builders

whats the difference between a thanksgiving and christmas cactus

by Aaron Feest Jr. Published 3 years ago Updated 2 years ago
image

The difference between the three cacti is found in the shape of the leaves. The Thanksgiving cactus (Schlumgera truncata) has very pointed and claw shaped projections on the edges of the leaf. The Christmas cactus (Schlumgera bridgesti) has leaf projections which are more scalloped or tear drop shaped.

Full Answer

Can a Thanksgiving cactus bloom at Christmas?

Thanksgiving cactus (Schlumbergera truncata) typically blooms between mid-November and late December, sometimes through January.

What are the 3 types of Christmas cactus?

The three types of Christmas cactus plants (holiday cacti) are primarily recognized by the time of bloom. Thanksgiving cactus blooms in late autumn, about a month before Christmas cactus. Easter cactus displays buds in February and blooms around Easter.

What does a Thanksgiving cactus look like?

They resemble a long tube, appearing as if a flower within a flower. They come in a range of colors, mostly pastels, including red, pink, peach, purple, orange, or white, and typically bloom in Thanksgiving. The blooms on a Thanksgiving cactus come in many colors, with yellow pollen-bearing anthers.

What is the difference between Christmas Thanksgiving and Easter cactus?

Thanksgiving cactus (Schlumbergera truncata) has pointy projections on the sides of the leaves, like crab claws. Christmas cactus (Schlumbergera bridgesti) has scalloped or teardrop-shaped projections on the leaves. Easter cactus (Schlumbergera gaertnerrii) has leaves with round edges.

How can you tell a Christmas cactus from a Thanksgiving cactus?

The difference between the three cacti is found in the shape of the leaves. The Thanksgiving cactus (Schlumgera truncata) has very pointed and claw shaped projections on the edges of the leaf. The Christmas cactus (Schlumgera bridgesti) has leaf projections which are more scalloped or tear drop shaped.

What is the rarest color of Christmas cactus?

yellowWhile most people are familiar with the pinkish-to-magenta flowers, white, orange, and yellow are also common -- yellow being among the rarest available varieties. Yellow is more common on the Thanksgiving cactus, Schlumbergera truncata.

How many times a year does a Thanksgiving cactus bloom?

The Thanksgiving cactus most commonly blooms in the late fall, while the Christmas cactus blooms in early to late winter, and the Easter cactus blooms in the early spring. How Often Does a Thanksgiving Cactus Bloom? Under the right conditions, a Thanksgiving cactus will bloom once a year during the late fall.

Should I trim my Thanksgiving cactus?

Prune after the plant's blooming season. Pruning will help your Thanksgiving cactus grow bigger and bushier. The perfect time to prune is right after the first bloom. You can continue to prune the plant until late spring.

Should I water my Thanksgiving cactus while it's blooming?

Since the plant is an epiphyte, it sometimes has exposed roots and will gather moisture through humidity in the air. During the flowering period, keep schlumbergera truncata evenly moist.

Should I deadhead Thanksgiving cactus?

Keep your cacti looking its best during and after the Christmas season by deadheading all the spent blooms. This also encourages the plant to continue blooming. Once Christmas is over you can continue to enjoy your cacti until it finally stops producing flowers. But don't get rid of it once it does!

Do you water a Christmas cactus from the top or bottom?

Experts recommend watering Christmas cactus from the bottom rather than on top. With this method, you can be sure that your plant is getting enough water every time because it will soak into their roots and reach all of them.

Why is my Thanksgiving cactus turning purple?

The four most likely reasons for purple-hued discoloration are: bright light, inappropriate moisture, nutrient deficiency, and extreme temperature fluctuations.

Is a Zygo cactus the same as a Christmas cactus?

Although some producers market the Zygocactus as a Christmas Cactus it is actually a Thanksgiving Cactus. A true Christmas Cactus (Schlumbergera x buckleyi) blooms a few weeks later than a Thanksgiving Cactus and has smooth edges to its fleshy stems, while the Thanksgiving Cactus has toothed edges on the stems.

Are there different kinds of Christmas cactuses?

Schlumber... truncataSchlumber... ×buckleyiSchlumber... opuntioidesSchlumber... kautskyiSchlumber... microspha...Schlumbergera/Lower classifications

What is the difference between false Christmas cactus and Christmas cactus?

2:204:43How to tell the difference between a Christmas Cactus & Thanksgiving ...YouTubeStart of suggested clipEnd of suggested clipActually has the Scarlet edging going downwards in a teardrop shape as you can see it's moreMoreActually has the Scarlet edging going downwards in a teardrop shape as you can see it's more teardrop shaped rather than completely rounded. And that's how you can tell the difference between.

What color is a true Christmas cactus?

They are bright magenta to pink, bilaterally symmetrical, and up to 3 inches (7.5 cm) long.

What is a Christmas cactus?

A Christmas cactus, or Schlumbergera bridgesii, has a much softer look to its leaves than its Turkey Day cousin. The segments on a Christmas cactus have scalloped edges, and the ends almost look like they go straight across.

Do Christmas cactus like sun?

The Christmas cactus loves partial sun or diffused light, so a window with a thin window treatment would be perfect! They’re adaptable to most soil conditions, but they prefer their soil to stay moist. While the name cactus might make this confusing, these are “tropical” plants that love water. Don’t let the soil dry out completely between waterings, but the Christmas cactus can handle dryer soil than the Thanksgiving cactus.

Is a Thanksgiving cactus a succulent?

The Thanksgiving cactus, or Schlumbergera truncata, is a pretty plant but is actually a succulent and not a cactus. The best way to distinguish this plant from a Christmas cactus is by inspecting the leaves. The leaves of a Thanksgiving cactus are much pointier than Christmas cacti. In addition, each segment has serrated sides with pointed spines. These toothed edges are likely why this plant is also known as “Crab Claw Cactus.”

How to identify a Thanksgiving cactus?

It also goes by zygocactus ($9, Walmart ). You can identify it by the pointy “teeth” on the sides of each stem segment. These teeth are soft, not sharp, and can vary in size, but are almost always visible on the plant to some degree.

What is a Christmas cactus?

What we call a Christmas cactus ($3, Etsy ), on the other hand, comes from a species called Schlumbergera russelliana with some S. truncata or possibly a couple of other species mixed in. The resulting hybrid is known as Schlumbergera x buckleyi and can be hard to find for sale.

How to tell if a cactus is a Christmas cactus?

Another way to tell which sort of cactus you have is to look carefully at the flowers, which can bloom anytime in the fall or early winter. Sticking out from each blossom, the cluster of long, thin anthers will be tipped with pollen. If the color of the pollen is yellow, you more than likely have a Thanksgiving cactus, and if it's pink, you've got a Christmas cactus.

What does it mean when a cactus is pink?

If the color of the pollen is yellow, you more than likely have a Thanksgiving cactus, and if it's pink, you've got a Christmas cactus.

How to tell if a cactus is a cactus?

Its stem segments lack pointed teeth, with more scalloped or rounded edges. Another way to tell which sort of cactus you have is to look carefully at the flowers, which can bloom anytime in the fall or early winter. Sticking out from each blossom, the cluster of long, thin anthers will be tipped with pollen.

Is a Christmas cactus the same as a Thanksgiving cactus?

Christmas cactus and Thanksgiving cactus are closely related, so it's easy to mistake them for the same plant. Both grow wild in the mountains of southeastern Brazil, so they prefer things on the cool and shady side, unlike the cacti found in desert habitats. This is partly why they make such easy-care houseplants, though they do need more regular watering than a desert cactus would.

Can a Thanksgiving cactus be passed down?

Plus, these long-lived plants can be passed down from generation to generation or shared with friends from a small stem cutting rooted in a bit of damp potting soil.

What is the difference between a Thanksgiving cactus and an Easter cactus?

This cactus has flat, thinner leaves that are small and scalloped. The Thanksgiving cactus has pointier, broad leaves. It is sometimes referred to as thecrab claw cactus” because of its distinctive pointed leaves. And the Easter cactus leaves are flat, round, and scalloped on the edges. The leaves also have fine hairs.

Why are the Thanksgiving cactus called the Thanksgiving cactus?

Because they bloom in late fall, these plants have been named the Thanksgiving cactus.

Why is the cactus named after the holiday?

This cactus blooms in the coldest time of year, which is why it is named after the holiday.

How many species of Schlumberger cactus are there?

There are six species of Schlumberger, many of which are designated holiday names. Each is named after the period in which they bloom in the Northern Hemisphere. The Thanksgiving cactus blooms slightly earlier than the Christmas cactus. But in their native lands, they both flower from April to May, so they are not called by either name.

Where do Christmas and Thanksgiving cacti come from?

The Christmas and the Thanksgiving cacti are from the Schlumbergera family, so their history is very similar. They are both tropical cacti from the rainforests in Brazil. Allen Cunningham discovered them in the early 19th century, and the genus was named after an exotic botanist called Frederic Schlumberger.

Where does the Easter cactus come from?

The Easter cactus is from the Hatiora family . This succulent is also from Brazil but from the drier forests, which is why you’ll see the difference in watering later on. Unfortunately, little is documented about the discovery of the Easter cactus. Still, it is likely to be around the same time as the Christmas and Thanksgiving cactus.

How to tell seasonal cacti apart?

The overall plant shape of each seasonal cacti is also a way to tell them apart from each other.

What is the difference between a Thanksgiving cactus and a Christmas cactus?

The difference between the three cacti is found in the shape of the leaves. The Thanksgiving cactus (Schlum gera truncata) has very pointed and claw shaped projections on the edges of the leaf. The Christmas cactus (Schlumgera bridgesti) has leaf projections which are more scalloped or tear drop shaped.

How long does it take for a Christmas cactus to bloom?

A seldom used bedroom or lower level is the ideal place. The Christmas and Thanksgiving cactus require approximately 6 weeks of short days in order to bloom whereas the Easter cactus requires 8-12 weeks of short days to bloom hence the name Easter cactus. When the buds appear it can be brought into a warmer area for your enjoyment.

When do cactus rebloom?

The Christmas and Thanksgiving cactus may re-bloom again for you in the spring but not as profusely as holiday time bloom. If you want to encourage spring time blooms, simply return the plant to its short day conditions. These plants are relatively disease free unless over watered.

What is the holiday season?

The Holiday season is upon us and that means not only decorations, but holiday plants! This is the time of year when there is an abundance of nice holiday plants to choose from, whether purchased from a florist, nursery or grown at home.

What is the difference between a Christmas cactus and a Thanksgiving cactus?

The blooming time is typically in December. The Christmas Cactus has purplish-brown anthers. In contrast the Thanksgiving Cactus has yellow anthers.

How to tell if a cactus is a Christmas cactus?

If you feel a distinct point or claw it is a Thanksgiving Cactus. If you do not feel a point or claw and you also don’t feel anything on the flat end or tip of the leaf it is a Christmas Cactus. If you do not feel points or claws but you do feel numerous small soft bristles on the tip end of the leaf it is an Easter Cactus.

How long do cacti live?

It’s common to hear of these plants being passed on from generation to generation and sometimes living over 100 years! Although true cacti, these plants are native to rain forests and epiphytic meaning they grow on other plants and derive moisture and nutrients from air and rain. The need for high humidity, bright but filtered light, and soil kept relatively moist most of the year sets these plants apart from the majority of cacti and succulents… Though called Thanksgiving, Christmas and Easter cactus, these common names are primarily for marketing purposes and provide only a general reference for the time of year these plants may bloom.”

What cactus has a flat, wide, and flat leaf?

Christmas Cactus – Has wide and flat segmented leaves that are smaller and rounder than the other two cacti. The edges of the leaves have small indentations (scallops) in contrast to the Thanksgiving Cactus leaves that have outward pointed claws.

How many points are there on each side of a Thanksgiving cactus?

Thanksgiving Cactus – Has broad segmented leaves with serrated (jagged) edges on each side. The serrated edges form into points. There are 2-4 points on each side.

What is the shape of the Easter cactus?

There are slight scallops on the edges of the leaves but the shape is much subtler than the Christmas Cactus.

Where do Christmas cactus grow?

All three cacti are epiphytes, growing naturally in trees in the rainforests of Brazil. They have such similar characteristics it is obvious that they are closely related. Both the Christmas Cactus and Thanksgiving Cactus fall under the genus Schlumbergera . The Easter Cactus (sometimes called Whitsun Cactus) is classified under the genus Hatiora.

image

Thanksgiving, Christmas, and Easter Cacti Bloom at Different Times of The year.

All Three Holiday Cacti Are Short-Day Plants.

  • Both Thanksgiving and Christmas cactus are cued to set buds after daylight hours decrease in autumn. They need at least 6 weeks’ worth of 13- to 14-hour nights to bloom. Plants that contain the most S. truncata (Thanksgiving cactus) lineage tend to bloom a bit earlier than those heavily crossed with S. russelliana. The Easter cactus requires a more...
See more on bobvila.com

Christmas, Thanksgiving, and Easter Cacti Require Similar Care.

  • Fortunately, Christmas cactus care, Thanksgiving cactus care, and Easter cactus care are all similar. Give the plants bright, indirect light and damp, fast-draining soil such as a combination of cactus mix and orchid bark. Fertilize these succulentsonly during spring and summer, keeping them in a protected location if outdoors, such as under a porch roof or tall tree, where they can b…
See more on bobvila.com

1.Christmas Cactus vs Thanksgiving Cactus | Garden Gate

Url:https://www.gardengatemagazine.com/articles/flowers-plants/plant-guide/christmas-cactus-vs-thanksgiving-cactus/

17 hours ago  · The most obvious way to tell the difference between the two types is to look at the phylloclades, or flattened leaflike stems where photosynthesis occurs. The Thanksgiving …

2.Thanksgiving vs. Christmas cactus: How they’re different

Url:https://www.happysprout.com/indoor-plants/thanksgiving-vs-christmas-cactus/

8 hours ago  · The best way to distinguish this plant from a Christmas cactus is by inspecting the leaves. The leaves of a Thanksgiving cactus are much pointier than Christmas cacti. In …

3.Christmas vs. Thanksgiving vs. Easter Cactus: What’s the …

Url:https://www.bobvila.com/articles/christmas-cactus-vs-thanksgiving-cactus/

1 hours ago  · It's logical to think a Thanksgiving cactus (Schlumbergera truncata) will produce flowers in November followed by a Christmas cactus (Schlumbergera x buckleyi) blossoming …

4.How to Tell Thanksgiving Cactus from Christmas Cactus

Url:https://www.bhg.com/gardening/houseplants/thanksgiving-christmas-cactus-differences/

21 hours ago  · Protruding from each blossom, a cluster of long, thin anthers will be tipped with pollen. If the color of the pollen is yellow, you more than likely have a Thanksgiving cactus, and …

5.Christmas Cactus vs. Thanksgiving Cactus vs. Easter …

Url:https://www.allaboutgardening.com/christmas-thanksgiving-easter-cactus/

8 hours ago On the edges of the leaf of the Thanksgiving cactus (Schlumgera truncata), there are exceedingly sharp and claw-shaped projections. The leaf projections of the Christmas cactus (Schlumgera …

6.Is it a Thanksgiving, Christmas or Easter Cactus? | Iowa …

Url:https://www.extension.iastate.edu/linn/news/it-thanksgiving-christmas-or-easter-cactus

10 hours ago The edges of the leaves of the Thanksgiving cactus (Schlumgera truncata) are very sharply pointed and shaped like claws. The leaf projections of the Christmas cactus (Schlumgera …

7.Christmas Cactus vs Thanksgiving Cactus vs Easter Cactus

Url:https://desertsucculents.com/christmas-cactus-vs-thanksgiving-cactus-vs-easter-cactus/

34 hours ago  · The Christmas cactus begins by growing in an upright habit, but as the stems become longer, they begin to droop. The Thanksgiving cactus also grows in an upright habit, …

8.Videos of Whats the Difference Between a Thanksgiving And Chris…

Url:/videos/search?q=whats+the+difference+between+a+thanksgiving+and+christmas+cactus&qpvt=whats+the+difference+between+a+thanksgiving+and+christmas+cactus&FORM=VDRE

35 hours ago The difference between the three cacti is found in the shape of the leaves. The Thanksgiving cactus (Schlumgera truncata) has very pointed and claw shaped projections on the edges of …

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9