Knowledge Builders

which came first the raid vs dredd

by Karlee Jerde Published 3 years ago Updated 2 years ago
image

Just a few months before the release of Dredd, The Raid debuted to become heralded as a modern day action movie classic. The Raid focuses on an Indonesian police unit raiding an apartment complex full of criminals, and finding themselves a battle for survival.Aug 22, 2022

Is the Raid Redemption similar to Dredd?

Any person with even a tiny bit of knowledge of action movie formulas can instantly see the similarities between The Raid: Redemption and Dredd, but just because they have an extremely similar plot structure, there are also a large number of differences that allow each of them to stand on their own.

What happens to Dredd in Judge Dredd?

Throughout the movie, Dredd is faced with wave after wave of criminal foot soldiers, limited resources, and even corrupt Judges as he tries to make it to the top floor where Ma-Ma is waiting for him.

What is the Raid movie about?

The Raid was a project conceived by Welsh-born director and writer Gareth Evans, who originally wanted to make a sprawling crime epic with the added injection of martial arts action– The Godfather mixed with Fists of Fury.

image

Which came first Dredd or The Raid?

According to Wikipedia, Dredd started filming in Novemember 2010, while The Raid began its shoot four months later in March 2011.

Was Dredd inspired by The Raid?

In 2012, two movies were released that while inspired by different material, proved very similar in regards to plot and location; Pete Travis' excellent Dredd and Gareth Evans' martial arts extravaganza, The Raid.

Did Judge Dredd copy The Raid?

Diomedes said: By all accounts Dredd went into production (and had its screenplay written) before The Raid so it appears to be a coincidence.

When was The Raid redemption filmed?

Pre-production began in September 2012 while filming began in January 2013. On the release of The Raid 2 in 2015, Evans said he had ideas for The Raid 3 but that nothing had been written yet and a third film was not likely to happen before 2018 or 2019.

What martial art is used in The Raid?

pencak silatThe fighters in The Raid are all practitioners of pencak silat, an Indonesian martial art that emphasizes—at least in these movies—nasty elbow and knee strikes. Beholding it on-screen is like watching a great UFC fight in fast-forward.

Is raid based on true story?

Raidd is a 2018 Indian Hindi-language crime film based on the real life income-tax raid conducted by the officers of the Income Tax Department on Sardar Inder Singh in the 1980s. The raid distinguished itself from others for being the longest raid in Indian history, lasting three days and two nights.

Are Prakoso and Mad Dog the same person?

This morning, director Gareth Evans tweeted a pic that reveals Prakoso, a new character played by Uwais co-choreographer Yahan Ruhian. Ruhian played the memorable Mad Dog in the first film who, as you may recall, was a cocky, but expert fighter whose own hubris ends up being his downfall.

What was the budget for The Raid: Redemption?

1.1 million USDThe Raid / Budget

Is The Raid: Redemption worth watching?

I was urged by a movie reviewer to see this film, describing it as one of the best action movies ever made. And you have to agree, this film, after providing a few minutes of backstory, takes off straight into the police raid of the apartment building filled with bad guys and a gang lord.

Is The Raid: Redemption a sequel?

The Raid 2The Raid / Sequel

How much money did the raid 2 make?

The Raid 2CountryIndonesiaLanguagesIndonesian JapaneseBudget$4.5 millionBox office1.43 million tickets (Indonesia) $6.77 million (overseas)12 more rows

What is the difference between Dredd and The Raid?

Any person with even a tiny bit of knowledge of action movie formulas can instantly see the similarities between The Raid: Redemption and Dredd, but just because they have an extremely similar plot structure, there are also a large number of differences that allow each of them to stand on their own. For example, the action in Dredd is primarily focused on stylized gun play while The Raid focused on the aforementioned Pencak Silat with a bit of gunplay thrown in to change up the pace. The Raid even takes Dredd’s cut-to-the-chase approach even further by only showing a short scene in the beginning to introduce our main lead immediately before starting the mission.

When did Dredd come out?

However, by the time Dredd hit theaters in 2012, it was beaten to the punch by an Indonesian martial arts film with a similar plot– The Raid: Redemption.

Who made the Raid?

The Raid was a project conceived by Welsh-born director and writer Gareth Evans, who originally wanted to make a sprawling crime epic with the added injection of martial arts action– The Godfather mixed with Fists of Fury. However, being a relatively inexperienced director, there was no way he could secure the funds necessary to have this vision become a reality. Instead, he decided to make a smaller, more focused movie that would put all of the emphasis on the action, an approach extremely similar to that of Dredd.

Who played Judge Dredd in the movie?

Dredd follows the story of the eponymous Judge Dredd (Karl Urban )–a one-man SWAT team in the future dystopia of Mega-City One. During a routine investigation, he is trapped in a 200-story high-rise building controlled by ruthless drug kingpin Ma-Ma ( Game of Thrones ‘ Lena Headey) along with his new rookie partner, Judge Anderson (Olivia Thirlby). Throughout the movie, Dredd is faced with wave after wave of criminal foot soldiers, limited resources, and even corrupt Judges as he tries to make it to the top floor where Ma-Ma is waiting for him. Already, this sounds like a very formulaic action movie plot that requires very little setup and has been done innumerable times since the 1980s, but Dredd received critical acclaim–receiving 78% approval on Rotten Tomatoes–for its tight and focused plot and characters, which worked as a strong skeleton to build the stylish yet visceral action scenes around. Instead of spending the inordinate amount of time spent on worldbuilding required for most modern Sci-Fi movies, Dredd cuts to the chase by putting the characters–and the viewer, in turn– right into the action. Instead of wasting time and effort on building a structure of its own, it takes advantage of a familiar one in order to build a unique movie around it.

image

1.Dredd vs The Raid - The Inevitable Comparison - Blogger

Url:https://woodstockthoughts.blogspot.com/2018/03/dredd-vs-raid-inevitable-comparison.html

2 hours ago Which Came First: The Raid was released first, yet Dredd started filming almost sixth months before, so though claims soon emerged that Dredd was ripping off The Raid, if anything it was …

2.Yes, Dredd Is Similar To The Raid... But Now That's A …

Url:https://screenrant.com/dredd-movie-raid-comparison-similar-good/

1 hours ago  · This is also something that shows in how they fight as well; Rama’s style is elaborate and showy but it’s ultimately about getting through as many bad guys as he can while …

3.The Raid Vs Dredd - A Tale of Two Sieges

Url:https://nouse.co.uk/2022/09/03/the-raid-vs-dredd---a-tale-of-two-seiges

13 hours ago  · Published Aug 22, 2022. Dredd dealt with comparisons to The Raid when it was released, but in the years since, Dredd being likened to The Raid has become complimentary. …

4.Why were Dredd 3D and The Raid: Redemption so similar?

Url:https://www.quora.com/Why-were-Dredd-3D-and-The-Raid-Redemption-so-similar

34 hours ago  · Cavan Compares the action from these two tower block siege movies. Saturday 3 Sep 2022 Cavan Gilbey. Image Credit: IMDb. Within the stretch of a year, two very similar action …

5.VERSUS Ep.6: The Raid (2011) VS. DREDD (2012) - YouTube

Url:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pm8R8AUsy94

33 hours ago These films had to be cheap because neither of them are Hollywood movies. The Raid is an Indonesian movie while Dredd is a British-South African cooperation. The production on Dredd …

6.Dredd, The Raid, and the Power of Formula | The Artifice

Url:https://the-artifice.com/dredd-the-raid-formula/

10 hours ago What's up all you bad asses out there! Welcome to our series called VERSUS! Where we put two or more films against each other and decide which film is the be...

7.Dredd VS! The Raid - YouTube

Url:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3lM5U4Wxgas

11 hours ago  · Both The Raid: Redemption and Dredd show that there is a place in modern cinema for formula. Exhibit A: Dredd In the many years following the disastrous Sylvester Stallone-led …

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9