Knowledge Builders

which is better memory foam or pillow top mattress

by Marisol Hettinger Published 3 years ago Updated 2 years ago
image

If you are a side or back sleeper, then memory foam is better for you. If you prefer a bouncier feel then it is better to get a pillow top mattress. It is also better for heavy people. Do pillow-top mattresses wear out faster? Pillow top mattresses are not the most durable choice. They are made from innerspring coils that wear out after a while.

Full Answer

Is pillow top better than memory foam?

Innerspring pillow tops are better at temperature control compared to memory foam. The breathability of the coil core is a lot more effective, which ensures heat won’t get trapped inside the mattress. However, if the pillow top is made with memory foam, some heat could still get trapped there.

Should I try a memory foam mattress?

A memory foam mattress can last up to nine years, but you should look into replacing it after seven. Constant use wears out the mattress and gradually loses support over time. Also, if the mattress surface is lumpy or uneven, or if you notice a visible sag, it might be time to replace your mattress.

What inch memory foam mattress should I get?

  • An 11 inch memory foam mattress is at a sweet spot when it comes to mattress thickness because it is capable enough to support sleepers who weigh more than 250 ...
  • Moreover, in 11 inch memory foam mattress, more foam is used to render it smoother. ...
  • It is seen similar to 10 inch memory foam mattress with a few tweaks for better.

Should you flip a memory foam mattress?

  • If you have a memory foam mattress, rotate it every three months .
  • If you have a traditional innerspring mattress, flip and rotate it every three months .
  • If you have a hybrid mattress, rotate it every three months .

image

Is memory foam or pillow top topper better?

Memory foam tends to have better durability and motion isolation. The material offers more pressure relief than pillow tops. However, memory foam can retain body heat and may have a strong but temporary smell when first opened.

Are pillow top mattresses good for your back?

Pressure Relief: The comfort of a pillow top is renowned for supporting sleep. They are the preferred mattress for side sleepers for hip and shoulder support and are considered great for reducing back and joint pain. They are overall exceptional for pressure point relief.

Whats better than a pillow top for a mattress?

Euro tops are plush layers of foam covering the entire top of the mattress. Euro tops are generally the more luxurious option compared to pillow tops since they're made from high-quality fiberfill or foam.

Does a pillow top mattress have memory foam?

A pillow top is an extra comfort layer on top of an innerspring mattress. This additional layer is usually filled with down, cotton, polyester fiberfill, latex, or memory foam and looks like a gigantic pillow sitting on top of the bed—thus the name “pillow top.”

What is the average life of a pillow top mattress?

approximately six and a half yearsOn average, a pillow-top mattress lasts approximately six and a half years.

Does a pillow top mattress need a boxspring?

Most modern mattresses including mattresses in a box do not require a box spring. In fact, traditional box springs don't provide the rigid support needed for many newer foam and latex beds. Box springs are primarily designed for use with coil-based mattresses.

Which type of mattress is best?

Among foams that are used in these mattresses, memory foam is the most well-known. Innerspring: An innerspring mattress has a coil-based support system and few other layers....Firmness.Firmness ScaleFirmness LevelBest For2Extra SoftSide sleepers under 130 pounds3SoftSide sleepers under 130 pounds5 more rows•Mar 11, 2022

Do pillow top mattresses hold up?

Pillow top beds are less durable than other mattress types like latex and memory foam beds. These beds lose their bounce in a short amount of time, causing them to sag or compress.

How do I choose the right mattress?

How to choose a mattressMattress type. Share on Pinterest. ... Firmness. Mattress firmness describes how a mattress feels under your body. ... Support. ... Pressure relief and body contouring. ... Mattress height. ... Motion isolation. ... Temperature regulation and cooling. ... Off-gassing.More items...•

What are the advantages and disadvantages of a pillow top mattress?

Pros: A plush feel on the top of the mattress that pillows the body on top of the support layers. Cons: The pillow top alone will not make a good bed -- the materials used in the pillow top and the rest of the mattress can sag or have issues if they are lower quality.

Which mattress is good for back pain?

Sl. NoSl. NoProduct NamePrice1The Sleep Company SmartGRID Ortho Mattress₹ 17,9252Sunday Ortho Latex 4 mattress₹ 22,9993Wakefit Orthopedic Memory Foam Mattress₹ 12,7364Sleepyhead Original - 3 Layered Orthopedic Memory Foam Mattress₹ 11,2494 more rows•Apr 1, 2021

Are hotel beds firm or medium?

First, hotel beds are most commonly either hybrid or innerspring mattresses that fall around a medium on the firmness scale to suit most people. Additionally, most hotels turn to classic brands such as Sealy, Serta-Simmons, and Beautyrest.

What is the purpose of a pillow top mattress?

Benefits of Pillow Top Mattresses Pillow top beds have a softer surface, creating a good mattress for side sleepers that eases some of the tension in the shoulders. The extra cushioning of pillow top beds may also be helpful for back sleepers who need a medium-firm mattress.

Which mattress is good for back pain?

Sl. NoSl. NoProduct NamePrice1The Sleep Company SmartGRID Ortho Mattress₹ 17,9252Sunday Ortho Latex 4 mattress₹ 22,9993Wakefit Orthopedic Memory Foam Mattress₹ 12,7364Sleepyhead Original - 3 Layered Orthopedic Memory Foam Mattress₹ 11,2494 more rows•Apr 1, 2021

Why does my back hurt so much when I wake up in the morning?

Morning back pain is often attributed to the morning being the most vulnerable time for your spine. This vulnerability can be due to what you do before bed or how you sleep, but your back pain might also be a sign of an underlying issue with your nervous system.

What kind of mattress is good for side sleepers?

Memory foam mattressesMemory foam mattresses are widely regarded as the first choice for side sleepers because they create a cradling, body-hug feel that also relieves all pressure on your body during side sleeping. You can normally find these in soft-medium and medium-firm, both of which would suit side sleepers.

What is a memory foam bed?

Memory foam beds are typically made of multiple layers of foam with varying densities. This blend of materials is necessary so the bed is not only soft and comfortable but supportive as well, keeping your spine in alignment as you snooze through the night. Memory foam is excellent for many individuals, especially side sleepers, as it has excellent contouring capabilities.

What is a pillow top bed?

Pillow-top beds are great for folks who like the feel of traditional innerspring mattresses but prefer a softer surface. These products work well for those who require robust support and considerable spinal alignment but enjoy plush comfort. Stomach, combo, and back sleepers are commonly good matches for this type of firmer support. Pillow Top Vs.

What to do if your mattress is old?

If a mattress grows old or saggy you could combine a firmer mattress pad with the bed to add additional support. Mattresses are expensive products, and if you're not in a position to fork over a significant amount of money, a mattress topper or pillow top could be a cost-efficient solution to reinvigorating your bed.

Why do we use pillow tops for hot sleepers?

Thermal Regulation. We typically recommend pillow-top and coil designs for hot sleepers because traditional foam often retains heat. However, many modern beds made of foam include advanced cooling features like gel, open-cells, or other additives that help maintain a comfortable temperature.

What is the best material for side sleepers?

Foam can provide excellent pressure relief, particularly for side sleepers who suffer from shoulder or hip pain. The material is marvelous for contouring to your body, providing soft support where you need it most. Pillow-tops or euro-top designs can also be just as great at providing pressure relief.

How long does memory foam last?

Both memory foam and pillow-top products can provide notable longevity when made with high-quality materials, either lasting up to ten years when properly cared for and thoughtfully crafted. However, pillow-top beds sometimes have a better reputation in terms of longevity merely because the feature is often paired with strong innersprings.

Why do pillow tops rest over coils?

Pillow-tops resting over individually wrapped coils should minimize motion transfer because each spring is meant to individually compress under pressure without bringing the entire bed along with it.

Which is better for sleeping: a pillow top or a memory foam mattress?

If you sleep really hot and want a cooling mattress, a pillow top is probably better for you because the coil support layer allows for much more airflow than what you’d get with memory foam. Memory foam is almost always the hottest option—even latex foam tends to sleep cooler.

What is a pillow top mattress?

A pillow top is an innerspring mattress with an extra layer of padding. This padding can be made of anything plush, but some of the more popular materials include cotton, wool, natural latex, memory foam, down, etc.

What is hybrid mattress?

Hybrid mattresses combine an innerspring coil system with at least 2 inches of foam on top. This combo has the bounce and airflow of an innerspring mattress and the support and compression of a foam mattress, making it a great option if you’re a fan of both mattress types.

What is memory foam made of?

Memory foam mattresses are made of a special blend of polyurethane foam originally developed by NASA to cushion and support astronauts through the immense gravitational force of a rocket takeoff . The material was so comfortable it eventually made its way to mattresses, where it’s been providing the same plush support ever since.

How much does a memory foam mattress cost?

Memory foam beds are usually more pricey than pillow tops, ranging anywhere from $600 to $4,000 depending on the size and brand of the mattress, as well as additional sleep technologies included with it.

Why are pillow tops good for hot sleepers?

It’s also great for hot sleepers because the coils increase airflow.

Why does my mattress smell so bad?

When these VOCs start breaking down, they’re released as gas into the air around your mattress. As you probably guessed, this gas is not great for your health and can be dangerous at high dosages. That’s why it’s important to buy a mattress with a low VOC count.

Which is better, innerspring or memory foam?

Innerspring pillow tops are better at temperature control compared to memory foam. The breathability of the coil core is a lot more effective, which ensures heat won’t get trapped inside the mattress. However, if the pillow top is made with memory foam, some heat could still get trapped there.

Why is memory foam good for back pain?

Because of its natural conforming abilities, memory foam provides excellent pressure point support and pain relief. It contours to the body , allowing the hips and the shoulders to sink down while keeping the legs and head evenly supported. This naturally aligns the spine, making memory foam beds perfect for sleepers with back pain and hip pain .

How long do pillow tops last?

Pillow tops typically only last 3-5 years. After this time, they tend to sag and lose their effectiveness in providing pressure point support and pain relief. Fortunately, you can always purchase a pillow top mattress topper as a replacement. However, this means investing extra money into a mattress you already invested in.

Why was memory foam invented?

It was invented with one goal—to improve temperature control. Because traditional memory foam tends to trap heat, mattress companies began infusing it with various cooling agents. The most common ones are gel, graphite, and copper. Gel can be added as a layer on top of the memory foam.

What is the support system on a pillow top mattress?

When it comes to pillow top mattresses, the support system we find inside is usually innerspring coils. Occasionally, the core of pillow top beds can feature a transition layer made with latex or even memory foam, but that’s rare. Most often, it’s just a spring support system inside that offers targeted pressure point relief and keeps ...

What is memory foam made of?

Memory foam is made from polyurethane foam, which is combined with certain chemicals for extra viscoelasticity. It responds to body heat and pressure as it contours and supports the sleeper. Memory foam bounces back to its original shape slowly so it can contour closely to the body.

How does gel memory foam work?

Whichever the method, gel memory foam works by absorbing excess body heat and slowly dissipating it into the mattress. Copper and graphite also effectively absorb and dissipate heat. Both are natural elements that are heat-conductive and anti-microbial, making them an excellent cooling agent for a mattress.

Share

If you’ve ever been mattress shopping before, you know there are a lot of options. First, you’ll need to choose the size. Most adults sleep on a Queen, King, or California King size mattress. From there, you’ll want to find a mattress that feels comfortable when you lie down on it.

What is a Pillow Top Mattress?

Long ago, your best option to make a too-firm mattress a bit softer was to add on a mattress topper. Now, there are pillow top mattresses which have an extra layer of padding sewn directly to the top of the mattress. The stitch attaching the extra layer to the mattress cover is placed just before each edge of the bed.

What is a Memory Foam Mattress?

One of the most popular options for a new mattress is memory foam. Memory foam isn’t a comfort feel, but rather a material that some mattresses are made from. Memory foam uses your body heat to soften and mold to your shape. If you push your hand down into memory foam, the shape of your hand will stay for a few moments.

Pillow Top mattress vs. Memory Foam: Is One Better Than the Other?

There’s no exact answer to this question, but we can help you decide on your own personal answer.

Come to City Mattress to Feel these Options for Yourself

If you are shopping for a new mattress and find that many options feel too firm for you, consider a memory foam or pillow top mattress. Both of these deliver the soft comfort you love without diminishing the support you need.

Pillow Top Mattress

Let’s begin with the definition of a pillowtop mattress. It is a mattress that has two parts; the support underneath and the plush covering on top. The support is made from innerspring coils and this gives a little bounce that can be seen in firm mattresses, while the covering is made from soft materials to provide the sinkage in soft mattresses.

Memory Foam Mattress

This type is all foam from top to bottom. It is made from visco-elastic material that makes it very soft with great sinkage. This is a very option for petite people because it provides the right amount of cradle.

Pillow top vs Memory Foam Comparison Table

From the above discussion on both mattresses, you can already tell which is better for you. But in the case that it still seems a little too complicating, here is a table comparing both mattresses to answer: what’s better; memory foam or pillow top?

Conclusion

Pillow top mattresses and Memory foam mattresses are both great but they also have their differences. It makes them good choices for different sets of people. This article has explained why one is a better choice over the other. We hope you have found this article helpful. If so, check out some of the frequently asked questions to learn more.

What is a Pillow-Top Mattress?

A pillow-top mattress gets its name from the extra layer, resembling a pillow, that is permanently attached to the top of the outer cover. This layer is usually between 2 and 4 inches thick and consists of materials such as memory foam, polyfoam, fiberfill, latex, or cotton.

Why do pillow top mattresses compress?

Since the pillow-top is sewn on top of the comfort layers and often not attached around the perimeter, pillow-top mattresses can compress considerably when pressure is put on the edges. This is inconvenient when getting in and out of bed, and may reduce the usable surface area when sharing the bed with a partner.

Why do you need a pillow top?

The primary purpose of a pillow-top is to add more cushioning to a mattress with relatively thin comfort layers. Latex and memory foam mattresses already succeed in providing contouring pressure relief, so adding a pillow-top would usually be redundant.

How tall is a Helix Luxe mattress?

Helix Luxe mattresses are 2 inches taller than their standard counterparts and feature a memory foam pillow-top with a Tencel cover. The 14-inch Midnight Luxe is a hybrid designed for side sleepers, with thick memory foam and polyfoam comfort layers that cushion the shoulders and hips. The support core contains pocketed coils divided into different zones based on coil gauge, or thickness, to ensure extra support around the midsection. We rate the Midnight Luxe as a medium firm, or a 6 out of 10 on the firmness scale.

Which mattress is best for back sleepers?

Sleeping Position: Sleepers interact differently with the layers of a mattress depending on whether they sleep on their side, back, stomach, or a combination of the three. Pillow-top mattresses are usually best for back and side sleepers due to their plush, conforming feel.

What is the cooling feature of a cashmere blanket?

Another cooling feature is the cashmere-blend cover, which also has moisture-wicking properties.

How many inches is a firm mattress?

You can choose between soft (3), medium firm (6), and firm (8) feels for the mattress, depending on your ideal level of support, as well as a 11.5-inch or 14.5- inch profile. The soft feel and lower profile are best suited to side sleepers and those who weigh 130 pounds or less.

image

1.Memory Foam vs. Pillow Top Mattress: What’s the Best?

Url:https://amerisleep.com/blog/memory-foam-vs-pillow-top/

31 hours ago  · There are a few differences between a pillow-top mattress and memory foam. The five main differences are: (i) Feel: The memory foam mattress is very dense, and its feel is …

2.Memory Foam vs. Pillow Top - Best Mattress Brand

Url:https://bestmattress-brand.org/memory-foam-vs-pillow-top/

17 hours ago Keep reading to learn whether a memory foam or pillow-top mattress is right for you. Memory Foam Pros. Memory foam became a popular mattress material about 30 years ago in 1991. Its …

3.Memory Foam VS Pillow Top: Which One Is Better?

Url:https://simplyrest.com/memory-foam-vs-pillow-top/

15 hours ago Two of your main options will be a pillow top mattress and a memory foam mattress. When considering pillow top vs memory foam, you should know that both of these options deliver a …

4.Pillow Top vs Memory Foam Mattress: Which One is …

Url:https://www.citymattress.com/blogs/news/pillow-top-vs-memory-foam-mattress-which-one-is-right-for-you

14 hours ago 7 rows · Are Pillow top mattresses or memory foam better for me? If you are a side or back sleeper, ...

5.Pillow Top Mattress vs. Memory Foam Mattress

Url:https://mattressella.com/pillow-top-mattress-vs-memory-foam/

6 hours ago

6.Best Pillow-Top Mattress of 2022 – (Queen, King Sizes)

Url:https://www.sleepfoundation.org/best-mattress/best-pillow-top-mattress

2 hours ago

7.Videos of Which Is Better Memory Foam Or Pillow Top Mattress

Url:/videos/search?q=which+is+better+memory+foam+or+pillow+top+mattress&qpvt=which+is+better+memory+foam+or+pillow+top+mattress&FORM=VDRE

12 hours ago

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9