Knowledge Builders

which is the best dust extractor

by Carson Wuckert Published 3 years ago Updated 2 years ago
image

Best Dust Extractors

  • Festool CT 26 E
  • Makita VC4710
  • Fein Turbo I

Full Answer

Where to find the best portable dust extractor for You?

Spread the word with and reveal a healthy, happy dust extractor that is simple to use even by a beginner. moitraecardi.com is the place to find the best portable dust collector for you! Find out why moitraecardi.com is #1 in Portable Dust Extractors, Buy Portable Dust Extractors Now!

Which is better ermator or dustcontrol?

For even more dust storage capacity, and comparable performance in other areas, consider an Ermator dust extractor. The downside to the Ermator is weight, 65 pounds compared to 31 for the Dustcontrol. when you tested all the dust collectors did you use the same size diameter hose on all of them ?

What is the best power extractor for home use?

Bosch VAC090AH is as good of an extractor for home use as it is for industrial applications. It is a great model for woodworking projects as it will let you keep the workspace neat and clean.

What is a CT 36 E dust extractor?

This modified CT 36 E was designed specifically for the Festool PLANEX Drywall Sander. The integrated cleaning mechanism shakes the filter periodically to stop caking for continuous work. Works as an advanced Festool dust extractor for all tools, but the optional 27 mm hose or new Reducing Sleeve may be necessary for some tools.

image

Can I use a vacuum cleaner instead of a dust extractor?

A vacuum cleaner is not an alternative for a dust extraction device and it will not be able to perform as per your requirements.

Can a dust extraction machine be used for wet dust?

Not all dust extraction equipment is suitable for wet dust, which is why you should definitely check out the user manual and features before attemp...

Are dust collectors expensive?

The price of a dust collector depends on a lot of features and a product with more features would naturally be more expensive.

What is the difference between a dust extractor and a vacuum cleaner?

Without going into technical details, a dust extractor is capable of handling air quantities far exceeding anything a regular vacuum cleaner can handle. In other words, you get a vacuum cleaner for precision cleaning and material conveyance. A dust extractor (also known as a dust collector ), on the other hand, allows you to maintain breathable air and clean process air throughout the premises. You'll find models that are more suitable for industrial applications but, in this review, we're going to focus on portable extractors that are designed mostly for jobsites and workshops.

How much static water lift does a dust extractor have?

Part of its powerful suction performance isn't just the motor that's capable of delivering 151 CFM but also the 98.4 inches of static water lift. The 13-feet hose is nothing we haven't seen before but the 19-feet power cord is considerably longer than the majority of its counterparts. With it, you'll be able to use the machine while standing 54 feet from the outlet.

How often does a filter clean?

Speaking of the filter system, just as worthy of a mention is the automatic filter cleaning system that, as you'd imagine, automatically cleans the filter every 15 seconds, which is a great improvement over the usual 30-second span. A system like that works wonders maintaining the maximum suction power while keeping the extractor void of dust and debris.

What do you like about Makita VC4710?

What we like about Makita VC4710 is how well it balances performance and practicality. It is a serious machine, no doubt about it. Equipped with a powerful 12 AMP motor that generates solid 135 CFM of raw suction power and 92 inches of water lift, the model is able to take on some of the most challenging applications.

How often does the automatic filter clean function pulse?

The model incorporates heavy-duty castor wheels. The Automatic Filter Clean function pulses every 30 seconds for continuous operations without stopping to clean the filter. The universal hose connector gives you a robust connection with swivel capability.

How much noise does a vacuum extractor make?

Made of high-quality sound-absorbing materials, the extractor's vacuum motor chamber keeps the noise level below 60 dB. The machine features a 10-second delay after you shut it off. In that time, it clears the hose of remaining debris, making for easy maintenance.

Does Festool CT 26 E have a flaw?

Bottom line, Festool CT 26 E has a flaw or two but they pale in comparison to everything the dust extractor has to offer in return. On top of everything else, the model's low center of gravity, sizable wheels, and ergonomically balanced design will let you easily move it around the jobsite.

What is the best dust extractor?

Coming in first place, and what we consider to be the BEST dust extractor on the market today is the Hilti VC 150-10 XE. While it may be the most expensive dust extractor to buy, it offers excellent power and it comes with an excellent warranty that is tough to beat in the industry. The Hilti 20-2-1 warranty is a 20 year limited manufacturers warranty, a 2 year unconditional warranty covers anything including cutting the cord and other non-manufacturer related items, and a 1 day in Hilti’s regional repair shop with pre-paid shipping labels, all of which is really awesome!

Why do dust extractors need head to head tests?

One of the key reasons to develop a Head-to-Head test of dust extractors is to objectively measure the relative differences in performance. Tool Box Buzz carefully researched how to best derive these measurements. Our goal was to create a series of measurements that accurately depicted the unit performance.

What was used to test air volume, suction, and airwatts?

For the air volume, suction, and airwatts measurements and calculations, testing was done with clean dust extractors as an “out of the box” baseline. Each dust extractor was equipped with a filter (s) and a fleece bag (without a bag the filters would clog very fast, and we always recommend using fleece bags on the jobsite).

How to measure air flow through dust collector?

To accurately measure the air volume (flow) through the dust collectors, TBB used a commercial Dwyer hot-wire anemometer. This measuring device has a probe in the air stream that has two openings. In one opening, there is a temperature sensor. In the other opening is a very small wire that is heated up by a power source in the anemometer. As the air flows over the heated wire and cools the wire, additional power is supplied to keep the wire at a constant temperature. The additional power needed is directly correlated to the air flow over the wire. TBB constructed a jig to hold the anemometer probe in the center of the airflow to consistently test units. A close up view of the front of the CFM test rig follows:

Why use fleece bags in dust extractors?

As stated above, we used fleece bags in all of the dust extractors as the primary filter to prevent premature clogging of the pleated filters. Using fleece bags increases the life of the pleated filters (they cost far more than the fleece bags), increases the life of the motor, and makes cleanup easier and safer for users.

Why did Bosch drop Dewalt?

Again we see DEWALT drastically fall off and this is due to it’s struggle in the suction testing above. Both Bosch and Milwaukee dropped about 40% from clean to dirty which is also something to consider when evaluating this data.

How to measure static power?

To measure static power (suction) we used both an industrial gauge that registered up to 200 inches of water column, and a water column test. The water column test is a much more visual representation of suction so it’s a great way to show the relative suction of the dust collectors. We also used the gauge to calibrate the water column jig that TBB built. The Water Column Jig had a clear 2” PVC water column that visually indicated the suction power of the test units using colored water and a measurement scale. TBB marked the maximum water column reading on to the PVC column with tape that indicated the unit name and test type. The units were tested with the manufacturers’ supplied hoses for each unit and the hose was coupled to the Water Column with airtight rubber compression fittings.

Keep the workshop and your projects clean by investing in a dust collector to continuously pull in the dust while you work

BobVila.com and its partners may earn a commission if you purchase a product through one of our links.

Types of Dust Collectors

There are several different types of dust collectors that are typically grouped based on dust collection capacity, portability, and power. These types include standard shop vacuums, dust extractors, single-stage bag dust collectors, canister dust collectors, and cyclonic dust collectors.

What to Consider When Choosing the Best Dust Collector

With the various dust collector types in mind, it’s easier to understand the important factors that can affect your choice of dust collector for the workshop.

Our Top Picks

The list of top products below is made up of several different types of dust collector that were selected based on dust collection capacity, motor power, suction, filter efficiency, and overall value in order to help you find the best dust collector to keep the workshop clean.

Our Verdict

For its impressive 800-CFM air suction power, 2.5-micron filter efficiency, and 2.1-cubic-foot dust collection capacity, the SHOP FOX W1727 Dust Collector is an outstanding option for small or medium workshops.

How We Chose the Best Dust Collectors

There are many different features to consider when selecting the best dust collectors, but the main factors that were explored during extensive product research include the dust collector type, the product suitability, horsepower, air suction power, filter efficiency, and functionality.

FAQs

After taking the time to learn about the top considerations for choosing a new dust collector, you may still have some lingering questions about the noise level, power, and even the functionality of a dust collector. Keep reading for answers to these and several other frequently asked questions that are addressed below.

How much CFM does a Festool extractor have?

Large Festool Dust Extractor Power: With the same 137 CFM as the CT 36 and 48, you’re getting heavy-duty power in a tighter package.

How many gallons is a Festool CT mini?

This is a recent upgrade among premier Festool dust extractors. The compact, Bluetooth-enabled Festool CT MINI packs a 2.6-gallon container into a highly maneuverable CT that’s a sleek 18 inches tall.

What is CT 36 E?

This modified CT 36 E was designed specifically for the Festool PLANEX Drywall Sander. The integrated cleaning mechanism shakes the filter periodically to stop caking for continuous work. Works as a general dust extractor for all tools, but the optional 27 mm hose or new Reducing Sleeve may be required for some of the tools. Other highlights include:

Can you use a Micron filter on a Festool?

1-Micron filter: Non-HEPA, but you can use an additional hose to fit other Festool tools.

Is CT 26 E a dust extractor?

The CT 26 E bridges the gap between the maneuverability of the Bluetooth models and the performance of a heavy-duty Festool dust extractor.

image

1.The Best Dust Extractors in 2021 - Woodsmith Reviews

Url:https://www.woodsmith.com/review/dust-extractor/

5 hours ago  · The Best Dust Extractor You Can Buy In 2022. Fein Turbo Dust Extractor. – Best Overall. Check On Amazon. This turbo dust extractor by Fein is one of our top picks for multiple reasons. It’s an ... Makita Portable Dust Extractor. Dewalt Onboard Rotary Hammer Dust …

2.Videos of Which Is the Best Dust Extractor

Url:/videos/search?q=which+is+the+best+dust+extractor&qpvt=which+is+the+best+dust+extractor&FORM=VDRE

14 hours ago  · Best overall: FESTOOL CT 15 HEPA Dust Extractor. Dust extractor reduces dust build up in your home or office. Cleantec® offers a powerful solution for dust removal in …

3.5 Best Dust Extractors Reviews of 2021 - BestAdvisor.com

Url:https://www.bestadvisor.com/dust-extractor

36 hours ago  · Best value: Makita VC4210L 11 Gallon Wet/Dry HEPA Filter Dust Extractor/Vacuum; Makita VC4210L 11 Gallon, Wet/Dry HEPA Filter Dust Extractor/Vacuum, can safely remove all …

4.Guide To Choose The Best Dust Extractor -According To …

Url:https://www.cchit.org/best-dust-extractor/

12 hours ago  · BOSCH 14 Gallon Dust Extractor with Auto Filter Clean and HEPA Filter VAC140AH. PERFORMANCE: The included HEPA filter caputres 99.97% of particles at 0.3 microns or larger …

5.Best Dust Extractor - Head-To-Head - Tool Box Buzz

Url:https://www.toolboxbuzz.com/head-to-head/best-dust-extractors-head-to-head/

35 hours ago  · 1. Amazon Prime - Get access to free shipping for the best portable dust extractor. Amazon Prime is the best way to get free shipping. Amazon Prime has many benefits, …

6.The Best Dust Collectors of 2022 - Recommendations …

Url:https://www.bobvila.com/articles/best-dust-collector/

13 hours ago  · BEST CORDLESS EXTRACTOR: Makita XCV11T 18V LXT Wet/Dry Dust Extractor; BEST FOR MITER SAWS: Rousseau 5000 Dust Solution for Miter Saws; Types of Dust Collectors

7.Which Festool Dust Extractor Should I Buy? - US Tool and …

Url:https://blog.ustoolandfastener.com/which-festool-dust-extractor-should-i-buy

12 hours ago  · Festool Dust Extractor Comparison. This comparison isn't an exhaustive list of Festool CTs, but these are the best dust extractors available at each size. The first few are …

8.What’s the best dust extractor : r/Carpentry

Url:https://www.reddit.com/r/Carpentry/comments/xzn526/whats_the_best_dust_extractor/

18 hours ago What’s the best dust extractor. I have mainly dewalt batteries and a few Milwaukee ones but would invest into another platform if they have some good tools such as Hikoki, doesn’t have to …

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9