What was Einstein’s mistake with E=mc2?
Einstein made three basic mistakes in his interpretation of the E=MC 2 equation. Einstein’s first mistake with E=MC 2 was to take a simple equation and then try to interpret it with two contradictory and paradoxical ideas of mass and energy. In the general interpretation, k E=MC 2 defines the relationship between mass and kinetic energy.
Why is E=mc2 wrong?
E=mc2 is Wrong – Einstein’s “Special Relativity” Fundamentally Flawed. Albert Einstein borrowed from the ideas of Fitzgerald, Lorentz and Voigt to create a new concept of the universe. His first work in this regard later came to be known as Special Relativity and contained many controversial ideas which today are considered axiomatic.
Is E=mc^2 Einstein’s greatest achievement?
Most people hold the mistaken assumption that E=mc^2 is Einstein’s and that is some kind of super brilliant achievement of pure genius that proffers time travel, worm holes, infinite mass and other horseshit fictions that affirm theoretical physics has turned into junk science.
What was Einstein's first mistake?
Why did Einstein refuse to believe in deceleration?
Why did Einstein make the assumption of relative motion?
When we compare the masses of a large number of protons, we find them to be identical?
Is E mc2 right or wrong?
GAITHERSBURG--Albert Einstein was correct in his prediction that E=mc2, according to scientists at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), the Commerce Department's National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), and the Institute Laue Langevin, Genoble, France (ILL) who conducted the most precise ...
What theory of Einstein was proven wrong?
Einstein thought his biggest mistake was refusing to believe his own equations that predicted the expansion of the Universe. Yet we now know he actually missed out on predicting something even bigger: Dark Energy. The trouble began when he first applied General Relativity, to the entire Universe.
Who proved that theory of relativity is false?
In 1935, Silberstein claimed to have found a contradiction in the Two-body problem in general relativity. The claim was refuted by Einstein and Rosen (1935).
Can E mc2 be proved?
It's taken more than a century, but Einstein's celebrated formula e=mc2 has finally been corroborated, thanks to a heroic computational effort by French, German and Hungarian physicists.
When did Einstein get it wrong?
To remain in accordance with the idea of a static universe, Einstein introduced a cosmological constant into his equations, which froze the state of the universe. His intuition led him astray: in 1929, when Hubble demonstrated that the universe is expanding, Einstein admitted that he had made “his biggest mistake”.
Is time the 4th Dimension?
According to Einstein , you need to describe where you are not only in three-dimensional space — length, width and height — but also in time. Time is the fourth dimension. So to know where you are, you have to know what time it is.
Did Einstein say time is an illusion?
Albert Einstein once wrote: People like us who believe in physics know that the distinction between past, present and future is only a stubbornly persistent illusion. Time, in other words, he said, is an illusion.
Who disagreed with Einstein?
Niels BohrBut what made the conference so memorable was a disagreement — a disagreement between two of the titans of physics: Niels Bohr and Albert Einstein. The year was 1927, and physicists were puzzled.
Why did Einstein dislike quantum mechanics?
Einstein always believed that everything is certain, and we can calculate everything. That's why he rejected quantum mechanics, due to its factor of uncertainty.
How did Einstein think of E mc2?
0:002:10Einstein's Proof of E=mc² - YouTubeYouTubeStart of suggested clipEnd of suggested clipAnd here's how he did it suppose you're watching a cat float freely in empty. Space when suddenly itMoreAnd here's how he did it suppose you're watching a cat float freely in empty. Space when suddenly it emits a flash of light in all directions. The light carries away some energy we'll call it e.
Did E mc2 help make the atomic bomb?
Although he never worked directly on the atomic bomb, Einstein is often incorrectly associated with the advent of nuclear weapons. His famous equation E=mc2 explains the energy released in an atomic bomb but doesn't explain how to build one.
Why is E mc2 right?
When mass and speed of light squared are multiplied, they give the same unit as that of energy – Joules. Thus, E=mc2 is dimensionally correct.
Why did Einstein dislike quantum mechanics?
Einstein always believed that everything is certain, and we can calculate everything. That's why he rejected quantum mechanics, due to its factor of uncertainty.
Has gravity been disproved?
The apple falling on Newton's head which gave us the famous gravitational law has recently been disproved by scientist researching black holes, according to international news reports.
What is the biggest drawback to relativity?
The drawback to Einstein's Special Theory of Relativity, however, is that it is “special” in the respect that it only considers the effects of relativity to an observer moving at constant speed. Motion at constant speed is clearly a very special case, and in practice, bodies change their speed with time.
Who said anyone who has never made a mistake has never tried anything new?
Albert EinsteinAlbert Einstein Quotes Anyone who has never made a mistake has never tried anything new.
What was Einstein's first mistake?
Einstein made three basic mistakes in his interpretation of the E=MC 2 equation. Einstein’s first mistake with E=MC 2 was to take a simple equation and then try to interpret it with two contradictory and paradoxical ideas of mass and energy.
Why did Einstein refuse to believe in deceleration?
Einstein refused to believe in deceleration as a meaningful concept that could be differentiated from acceleration to establish a position of absolute rest because the mass changes caused by motion cannot be measured locally. Einstein’s Second Mistake with E=MC 2. Einstein’s second mistake with his equation was in his failure to realize ...
Why did Einstein make the assumption of relative motion?
Einstein made this assumption of relative motion not because he could prove it but because no one disprove it. The very nature of the accelerometer and the Doppler effect make it impossible to measure the difference between an acceleration and a deceleration or between motion and rest. Just because you can’t measure absolute rest doesn’t mean it can’t exist.
When we compare the masses of a large number of protons, we find them to be identical?
Here, it must be realized that these protons may have had substantially different masses for much of their histories. Yet, as they were accelerated and decelerated to the frame of our measuring device , we find their masses to be identical. If it were possible for different particles of matter to move relative to different absolute reference frames then they could not have identical masses in any given frame.
What does it mean when the equation e=mc2 is incorrect?from quora.com
If the widely recognised equation e=mc^2 happens to be incorrect (I would personally think that this is highly unlikely considering that many tests and procedures would have to be undergone before any scientific theory can be as widely accepted as this equation), it just means that now scientists will rush to come up with better theories. Theories that are harder to disprove. In no way could it change the way objects move around.
What is the extreme case of m = 0?from science20.com
Also the extreme case of m = 0, applicable to massless particles like photons, is well captured in the triangle. For m = 0 the triangle collapses to a vertical line element and it follows immediately that Ev = Ec or v = c. Massless particles move at the speed of light.
What is the relation between Einstein and Pythagoras?from science20.com
Einstein meets Pythagoras: the mass-energy-momentum relation. In the rectangular triangle, the hypotenuse represents energy times c (c denoting the speed of light), the vertical edge momentum times c2, and the base mass times c3.
What did Einstein discover about relativity?from quora.com
Einstein first proposed the idea that since it is impossible for an observer to determine if he is at true rest, any observer is a good as any other observer, and a pair of observers should observe the laws of physics equally - with the observation that an electromagnetic wave travels at the speed of light being one such observation. He considered the simple case of one observer traveling at some speed relative to another observer, and deduced that for both observers to observe that an electromagnetic wave travels at the speed of light, each observer must observe the other observer as having a clock that runs slow (time dilation) and observe that the other observer ’s ruler as contracted - and both exactly in keeping with the Lorentz-Fitzgerald behavior. He then was able to fix the quirky seemingly disjointed laws of electromagnetic attraction, and published his first paper on relativity detailing his work.
What did Einstein find out about the conservation of momentum?from quora.com
Einstein then considered the effect of this time dilation & length contraction on the law of the conservation of momentum - which as a law of physics must be observed by any observer - using his clock, ruler & mass scale - as being true. From this, he deduced that an object being observed in motion is observed as having a higher mass than one being observed at rest. He then calculated the amount of energy in the form of a force being applied over a distance to get a mass that is observed to be at rest to being observed as being in motion at some speed, and deduced that the extra amount of observed mass was equal to the amount of energy applied to it divided by the square of the speed of light - IOW, his famous mass-energy equivalence equation. He then proposed that even if a mass is observed macroscopically to be at rest, just by the fact that it is observed to have mass, it must have energy locked inside of it, and that any energy that is coaxed out of it must decrease that rest-mass amount as per the mass-equivalence equation. (While this has not yet been observed for chemical reactions because the amount of mass liberated is so tiny, it has been observed in nuclear reactions, which has much higher energy yield per mass.)
What is the only wrong thing about Einstein?from quora.com
Continue Reading. The only wrong thing is the belief that Einstein invented E=mc^2. The equation, in different form, existed for about a year before Einstein published his first paper.
What is the consequence of special relativity?from quora.com
To understand this equation first we need to know about special relativity.One of the consequence of special relativity is that mass appears to increase with speed.The faster an object goes,the heavier it seems to get.
What is the extreme case of m = 0?
Also the extreme case of m = 0, applicable to massless particles like photons, is well captured in the triangle. For m = 0 the triangle collapses to a vertical line element and it follows immediately that Ev = Ec or v = c. Massless particles move at the speed of light.
What is the relation between Einstein and Pythagoras?
Einstein meets Pythagoras: the mass-energy-momentum relation. In the rectangular triangle, the hypotenuse represents energy times c (c denoting the speed of light), the vertical edge momentum times c2, and the base mass times c3.
Did Einstein warn about mass energy?
Einstein was very well aware of this, and in later papers repetitively stressed that his mass-ener gy equation is strictly limited to observers co-moving with the object under study. However, very, very few people seem to have paid attention to Einstein's warnings, nor to any of the more recent warnings.
What is the only wrong thing about Einstein?
Continue Reading. The only wrong thing is the belief that Einstein invented E=mc^2. The equation, in different form, existed for about a year before Einstein published his first paper.
What did Michelson and Morely discover?
A pair of American physicists - Michelson & Morely - who were really good at making very delicate optical equipment proposed that they could make a device which could measure the speed of light to such a high degree of accuracy that they could measure the Earth’s motion (and their motion around the Earth) in the ether. Unfortunately, their device yielded absolutely no motion of the Earth in the ether. Another pair of physicists - Lorentz & Fitzgerald - figured out what needed to be happening for this experiment result, and it was that an object traveling through the ether had to be contracting and as well that its time is dilating (i.e., time slows down). Needless to say that while the contracting seemed reasonable, the time dilating was completely a mystery.
What did Einstein discover about relativity?
Einstein first proposed the idea that since it is impossible for an observer to determine if he is at true rest, any observer is a good as any other observer, and a pair of observers should observe the laws of physics equally - with the observation that an electromagnetic wave travels at the speed of light being one such observation. He considered the simple case of one observer traveling at some speed relative to another observer, and deduced that for both observers to observe that an electromagnetic wave travels at the speed of light, each observer must observe the other observer as having a clock that runs slow (time dilation) and observe that the other observer ’s ruler as contracted - and both exactly in keeping with the Lorentz-Fitzgerald behavior. He then was able to fix the quirky seemingly disjointed laws of electromagnetic attraction, and published his first paper on relativity detailing his work.
What did Einstein find out about the conservation of momentum?
Einstein then considered the effect of this time dilation & length contraction on the law of the conservation of momentum - which as a law of physics must be observed by any observer - using his clock, ruler & mass scale - as being true. From this, he deduced that an object being observed in motion is observed as having a higher mass than one being observed at rest. He then calculated the amount of energy in the form of a force being applied over a distance to get a mass that is observed to be at rest to being observed as being in motion at some speed, and deduced that the extra amount of observed mass was equal to the amount of energy applied to it divided by the square of the speed of light - IOW, his famous mass-energy equivalence equation. He then proposed that even if a mass is observed macroscopically to be at rest, just by the fact that it is observed to have mass, it must have energy locked inside of it, and that any energy that is coaxed out of it must decrease that rest-mass amount as per the mass-equivalence equation. (While this has not yet been observed for chemical reactions because the amount of mass liberated is so tiny, it has been observed in nuclear reactions, which has much higher energy yield per mass.)
What does 511 keV mean?
What he really means is that it is 511 keV divided by the square of the speed of light, but everybody knows that, so there’s no point stating it… because mass and energy are equivalent. If it turned out that mass and energy were not equivalent, it would invalidate much of modern physics, including sp. Continue Reading.
Who discovered that electromagnetic waves propagate in space?
In the mid 19-th Century, a physicist named Maxwell completed the laws of electromagnetism and discovered that an electromagnetic disturbance (this could be as simple as an electrical charge accelerating) generates a spherical wave - an electromagnetic wave - to propagate in space with that speed of the wave being the speed of light (i.e., since light is simply such a wave). Physicists after Maxwell presumed that just like a wave in a river propagates in
Who discovered the mass of an electron?
JJ Thomson, who discovered the electron, suggested (1981) that mass was a consequence of the Faraday-Maxwell electromagnetic field. Heaviside had the value E = 4/3 mc^2 for the energy of an electric field.
What was Einstein's first mistake?
Einstein made three basic mistakes in his interpretation of the E=MC 2 equation. Einstein’s first mistake with E=MC 2 was to take a simple equation and then try to interpret it with two contradictory and paradoxical ideas of mass and energy.
Why did Einstein refuse to believe in deceleration?
Einstein refused to believe in deceleration as a meaningful concept that could be differentiated from acceleration to establish a position of absolute rest because the mass changes caused by motion cannot be measured locally. Einstein’s Second Mistake with E=MC 2. Einstein’s second mistake with his equation was in his failure to realize ...
Why did Einstein make the assumption of relative motion?
Einstein made this assumption of relative motion not because he could prove it but because no one disprove it. The very nature of the accelerometer and the Doppler effect make it impossible to measure the difference between an acceleration and a deceleration or between motion and rest. Just because you can’t measure absolute rest doesn’t mean it can’t exist.
When we compare the masses of a large number of protons, we find them to be identical?
Here, it must be realized that these protons may have had substantially different masses for much of their histories. Yet, as they were accelerated and decelerated to the frame of our measuring device , we find their masses to be identical. If it were possible for different particles of matter to move relative to different absolute reference frames then they could not have identical masses in any given frame.
