Knowledge Builders

why did the dodgers and giants leave new york

by Mikayla Paucek V Published 3 years ago Updated 2 years ago
image

Both teams were definitely motivated by money, as any profit earning business should be. Prior to and during the 1957 season, the Giants and Dodgers both cited financial problems as the main motivation for leaving New York!

See more

image

Why did the Dodgers move from New York to LA?

Despite the team's enduring popularity in Brooklyn—they finished first or second in NL attendance in seven of the nine seasons between 1949 and 1957—team owner Walter O'Malley moved the franchise to Los Angeles in 1958 in order to capitalize on the financial windfall that was likely to come from Major League Baseball's ...

Why did the Giants move from New York to San Francisco?

Despite those high points, attendance at the Giants' now legendary home, the Polo Grounds, lagged as the team continued to play in the Yankees' shadow, so the franchise relocated to San Francisco in 1958, at the same time that the Dodgers moved from Brooklyn to Los Angeles.

What happened to the NY Giants baseball team?

It continued as the New York Giants until it relocated to San Francisco, California after the 1957 season, where it continues its history as the San Francisco Giants....New York Giants (baseball)New York GiantsBallparkPolo Grounds III (1891–1957)Year established1883Year folded1957 (moved to San Francisco, California in 1958)10 more rows

When did the Giants and Dodgers leave NY?

May 28, 1957On May 28, 1957, National League owners vote unanimously to allow the New York Giants and Brooklyn Dodgers to move to San Francisco and Los Angeles, respectively, at the mid-season owner's meeting in Chicago, Illinois.

Did the Giants almost leave San Francisco?

In 1977, a group tried to purchase the club to move it to Washington, D.C. In 1985, it seemed likely the Giants would leave San Francisco for Denver, unless they were moving to San Jose, unless they were moving to New Jersey, unless they were going to share Oakland with the A's.

How many baseball teams did New York have at one time?

three teamsThe number of cities that have a Major League Baseball team is limited, but New York had the luxury of having three teams from 1947-1957. We earn from qualifying purchases made through affiliate links. Long-time baseball fans know there have been a number of great eras (and ERAs) throughout the history of the game.

Why did the New York Giants move to New Jersey?

Mara said he was moving his team to New Jersey to give the club the first real home it has ever had after 46 years in New York and to provide more convenient and pleasurable surroundings to the tens of thousands of Giant foot ball fans who have endured watching football in an aging stadium that was never meant for that ...

Why are the Giants in New Jersey?

The Giants have played in East Rutherford since 1976, when they moved across the Hudson River to Giants Stadium after playing their glory years at Yankee Stadium in the Bronx. The Jets became tenants with the Giants in New Jersey in 1984 after playing at Shea Stadium in Queens.

What is the Polo Grounds now?

The only part of the Polo Grounds that still remains is the "John T. Brush Stairway", which runs down Coogan's Bluff from Edgecombe Avenue to Harlem River Driveway at about 158th Street.

Why do the Giants and Dodgers hate each other?

The rivalry between the Giants and Dodgers began in the late 19th century when both clubs were based in New York City. The Giants played at the Polo Grounds in the borough of Manhattan and the Dodgers played in the borough of Brooklyn.

Are any Brooklyn Dodgers still alive?

The Brooklyn Dodgers played from 1890 to 1957. Of the myriad players who donned a Brooklyn uniform in those many decades, just 9 survive, as of May 23, 2022. The oldest is Chris Haughey, born in 1925.

What if the Giants and Dodgers stayed in New York?

What if the Dodgers and Giants stayed in New York? As mentioned above, there would have been no need for the Mets. Sure, Major League Baseball eventually would have expanded, but the West Coast would have received the expansion teams and not New York. And that would have changed the way we all rooted for our teams.

Where did Moses want to move the Dodgers?

But Moses wasn't having it. He saw driving as the future of New York transportation, and he wanted to move the Dodgers to Queens, near the site that became Shea Stadium -- publicly owned land that would create far fewer traffic jams than downtown Brooklyn.

Where did the Boston Braves move to?

The original target was Minneapolis: Stoneham saw the attendance bonanza that accompanied the Boston Braves' recent move to Milwaukee, and he envisioned similar riches for his team in the Midwest. But up and moving a Major League franchise was a tough sell; there were all kinds of scheduling logistics to consider.

How many times did New York win the pennant?

Led by bombastic manager and literal vaudeville star John McGraw (not to mention studs like pitcher Christy Mathewson), New York won the pennant nine times from 1905 to 1924, winning three World Series. The Polo Grounds was the envy of the entire league, a 55,000-seat cathedral seated squarely amid the glamour of upper Manhattan.

When did O'Malley buy the Stars?

O'Malley bought the Minor League L.A. Stars in 1956, and despite a last-ditch effort from Nelson Rockefeller himself, the move seemed all but done.

How many seats are there in the Polo Grounds?

The Polo Grounds was the envy of the entire league, a 55,000-seat cathedral seated squarely amid the glamour of upper Manhattan. But baseball is a fickle game, and soon enough the franchise's fortunes changed. Roster mismanagement led to on-field struggles -- at no point in the 1940s did the team finish better than third in ...

How many times did the Dodgers and Giants face each other?

Although the Giants and Dodgers continued to face each other some 20 times each season, for many the storied rivalry just wasn’t the same. Once just a subway ride away, the teams were now separated by 382 miles. Meanwhile, back in New York, fans consoled themselves by following the National League’s Mets, added as an expansion team in 1962.

When did the Dodgers move to New York?

In the end, both teams did move: The Giants hosted a farewell party at a game on September 29, and the Dodgers formally announced their move on October 8. West Coast baseball fans were overjoyed, and the people of New York City were heartbroken.

How many pennants did the Dodgers win in 1957?

In 1957, the Dodgers were in the midst of an impressive run; they had won five pennants and one World Championship in eight years.

When did the Dodgers move to Los Angeles?

Baseball owners allow Dodgers and Giants to move. On May 28, 1957 , National League owners vote unanimously to allow the New York Giants and Brooklyn Dodgers to move to San Francisco and Los Angeles, respectively, at the mid-season owner’s meeting in Chicago, Illinois.

When did the Giants win the World Series?

The Giants were an up-and-down team leading up to 1957, both fiscally and on the field. In spite of winning the World Series in 1954, the team could not draw fans as consistently as their Brooklyn rivals did.

Who said if all the people who claim in the future that they were here today had actually turned out, we wouldn

On their final day at the Polo Grounds in Coogan’s Bluff, after fans stormed the field, former baseball writer and the Giants PR man Garry Schumacher chided, “If all the people who will claim in the future that they were here today had actually turned out, we wouldn’t have to be moving in the first place.”.

Did the Mets and Yankees play each other?

The Yankees and Mets did not face each other as the Giants and Dodgers had until inter-league play began in 1997. In 2000, the two teams faced off in the World Series, the first “subway series” since the Dodgers and the Yankees met in 1956. The Yankees prevailed, four games to one.

image

GAME CENTER

Today · Final
4 - 7
  • Top
    9th
    Trea Turner homers to center field.
    LAD 4 - COL 7
  • Bottom
    6th
    Brendan Rodgers out on a sacrifice fly to left center field to Gavin Lux. Charlie Blackmon scores.
    LAD 3 - COL 7
  • Top
    6th
    Max Muncy homers to center field.
    LAD 3 - COL 6
  • Bottom
    4th
    José Iglesias singles to left center field. Brendan Rodgers to second. Charlie Blackmon scores.
    LAD 2 - COL 6
  • Bottom
    3rd
    Elias Díaz homers to left field.
    LAD 2 - COL 5
  • Bottom
    2nd
    Brendan Rodgers singles to shallow infield. C.J. Cron to second. Charlie Blackmon to third. Elehuris Montero scores.
    LAD 2 - COL 4
  • Bottom
    2nd
    Charlie Blackmon singles to right field. Elehuris Montero to second. Elias Díaz scores.
    LAD 2 - COL 3
  • Bottom
    2nd
    Randal Grichuk homers to left field.
    LAD 2 - COL 2
  • Top
    2nd
    Hanser Alberto homers to left field.
    LAD 2 - COL 1
  • Bottom
    1st
    C.J. Cron grounds out to shallow infield, Trea Turner to Freddie Freeman. Connor Joe scores.
    LAD 1 - COL 1
  • Top
    1st
    Justin Turner singles to deep left field, tagged out at second, Connor Joe to Brendan Rodgers. Freddie Freeman scores.
    LAD 1 - COL 0
All times are Eastern Time

GAMES

NEWS

See more news about Los Angeles Dodgers

STANDINGS

CentralW-LPCTGBWCGBL10STRK
1
Logo of the Milwaukee Brewers
Brewers43-33.566--7-3W3
2
Logo of the St. Louis Cardinals
Cardinals43-34.5580.5-5-5W2
3
Logo of the Pittsburgh Pirates
Pirates29-45.3921312.54-6L5
4
Logo of the Chicago Cubs
Cubs28-46.3781413.54-6L1
5
Logo of the Cincinnati Reds
Reds26-47.35615.5153-7W2
EastW-LPCTGBWCGBL10STRK
1
Logo of the New York Mets
Mets47-28.627--5-5L2
2
Logo of the Atlanta Braves
Braves43-32.5734+16-4W1
3
Logo of the Philadelphia Phillies
Phillies39-36.520835-5L1
4
Logo of the Miami Marlins
Marlins33-40.4521385-5L2
5
Logo of the Washington Nationals
Nationals29-48.37719146-4W3
WestW-LPCTGBWCGBL10STRK
1
Logo of the Los Angeles Dodgers
Dodgers45-28.616--6-4L2
2
Logo of the San Diego Padres
Padres45-30.6001+34-6L2
3
Logo of the San Francisco Giants
Giants39-33.5425.51.54-6L1
4
Logo of the Arizona Diamondbacks
Diamondbacks33-41.44612.58.54-6W1
5
Logo of the Colorado Rockies
Rockies33-42.4401395-5W2

ROSTER

NO NAMEPOSAGEHTWT
15
Austin Barnes
Austin BarnesC325'10"187
16
Will Smith
Will SmithC275'10"195
17
Hanser Alberto
Hanser Alberto3B295'11"215
37
Eddy Alvarez
Eddy Alvarez2B325'9"185
76
Jacob Amaya
Jacob AmayaSS236'0"180
5
Freddie Freeman
Freddie Freeman1B326'5"220
83
Eddys Leonard
Eddys LeonardSS216'0"160
9
Gavin Lux
Gavin Lux2B246'2"190
8
Zach McKinstry
Zach McKinstrySS276'0"180
13
Max Muncy
Max Muncy1B316'0"215
43
Edwin Ríos
Edwin Ríos3B286'3"220
10
Justin Turner
Justin Turner3B375'11"202
6
Trea Turner
Trea TurnerSS286'2"185
80
Jorbit Vivas
Jorbit Vivas2B215'10"171
35
Cody Bellinger
Cody BellingerCF266'4"203
50
Mookie Betts
Mookie BettsRF295'9"180
77
James Outman
James OutmanCF256'3"215
11
Kevin Pillar
Kevin PillarCF336'0"200
3
Chris Taylor
Chris TaylorLF316'1"196
25
Trayce Thompson
Trayce ThompsonCF316'3"225

VIDEOS

1.Why Did the Dodgers and Giants Leave New York?

Url:https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/55491/why-did-dodgers-and-giants-leave-new-york

2 hours ago The Dodgers left because the City of New York refused to fund a new stadium. Walter O’Malley then got the Giants owner, Horace Stoneham, to join him on the West Coast. Braque Hildreth. Self Help Guru (2013–present) Author has 701 answers and 107.7K answer views 2 y. $.

2.Just why did the Dodgers and Giants move from New …

Url:https://www.mlb.com/cut4/why-did-the-dodgers-and-giants-move-to-california-c303090362

29 hours ago  · On May 28, 1957, National League owners vote unanimously to allow the New York Giants and Brooklyn Dodgers to move to San Francisco and Los Angeles, respectively, at …

3.Videos of Why Did the Dodgers and Giants Leave New York

Url:/videos/search?q=why+did+the+dodgers+and+giants+leave+new+york&qpvt=why+did+the+dodgers+and+giants+leave+new+york&FORM=VDRE

9 hours ago  · On May 28 1957, the NL turned two years of speculation into crisis, stunningly granting permission to move. The Giants, guaranteed a stadium on …

4.Why did the Dodgers and Giants both leave NY? - Quora

Url:https://www.quora.com/Why-did-the-Dodgers-and-Giants-both-leave-NY

23 hours ago The Brooklyn Dodgers were coming to the West Coast and as rivals in New York it would make a natural rivalry out here. The Giants also wanted a new park and the city of New York wasn't working with them to give them the area they wanted to build it in. Jim Thielman Covered Major League Baseball for 16 years.

5.Why Did The Brooklyn Dodgers and New York Giants …

Url:https://imaginesports.com/news/why-brooklyn-dodgers-moved

13 hours ago

6.Baseball owners allow Dodgers and Giants to move

Url:https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/baseball-owners-allow-dodgers-and-giants-to-move

25 hours ago

7.NO. 22: 1957 DODGERS AND GIANTS LEAVE NEW YORK : …

Url:https://nypost.com/1999/09/12/no-22-1957-dodgers-and-giants-leave-new-york-say-it-aint-go/

31 hours ago

8.Why did the Giants move from New York to San Francisco?

Url:https://www.quora.com/Why-did-the-Giants-move-from-New-York-to-San-Francisco

22 hours ago

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9