Knowledge Builders

why does baba like hassan or amir

by Ahmad Feeney DDS Published 2 years ago Updated 2 years ago
image

Baba and Amir are both privileged Pashtuns, who enjoy many opportunities in Afghanistan. They both value Western culture and are not particularly religious. Baba admires American leaders and drives a Mustang, while Amir enjoys watching old Westerns with Hassan. Baba and Amir also are very close with their Hazara

Hazaras

The Hazaras are an ethnic group native to the mountainous region of Hazarajat in central Afghanistan. They speak the Hazaragi variant of Dari, one of the two official languages of Afghanistan.

servants, Ali and Hassan.

Full Answer

How are Baba and Amir portrayed?

Why did Baba sacrifice his life?

How long is the free trial for eNotes?

What did the people learn from duress and financial precarity?

What is a certified educator?

Is Baba brave?

Who is Amir proud of?

See 4 more

About this website

image

What is the relationship between Baba and Hassan?

Baba, his father, takes interest in Hassan a servant in the house of Amir. Hassan is also Amir's best friend despite the competition between them for Baba's attention.

How does Baba feel about Amir?

When Amir is a boy, Baba's major concern about him is that he doesn't have the courage to stand up for himself, demonstrating that Baba places great value on doing what is right. If Amir cannot take of himself as a boy, he worries, he will not have the strength to behave morally as an adult.

Why did Baba lie to Amir about Hassan?

Why did Baba lie about Hassan being his son? Baba lied about Hassan being his son because if he didn't, he would have had to admit that he had sex with Sanaubar, Ali's wife and a Hazara woman. He'd also have to reveal that the encounter occurred soon after Amir's mother had died.

What does Baba say about Hassan?

'Hassan's not going anywhere,' Baba snapped. He dug a new hole with the trowel, striking the dirt harder than he had to. 'He's staying right here with us, where he belongs. This is his home and we're his family.

Do Amir and Baba love each other?

Amir loves Baba very much, however, throughout the book Amir feels as if he is fighting for Baba's acceptance and affection. Although their relationship is strained for a majority of the book, there are both differences and similarities that Baba and Amir share.

How does Baba and Amir relationship change?

Sharon Erpicum 5C The kite runner: Baba and Amir's relationship evolution When Amir and Baba move to the States, their characters change a little bit. Consequently, their relationship changes too. They, now, live in a modest apartment. Baba works at a gas station, but apart from his job, Amir is the only thing he has.

Does Amir truly love Hassan?

From Amir's perspective, his friendship with Hassan is filled with tension: He is jealous that Hassan is the type of boy that his father values, but he also loves and values Hassan as the only person who appears to genuinely care for him.

Who did Baba sleep with in kite Runner?

One of the biggest betrayals in the book is shown through Amir's father, Baba. Baba sleeps with Ali's wife, Sanaubar and she becomes pregnant.

How does Baba betray Hassan?

Later in the book, Amir learns that Baba also betrayed his own best friend and servant – Ali, Hassan's father – by fathering a child (Hassan) with Ali's wife Sanaubar. This knowledge comes as another kind of betrayal for Amir, who had always hero-worshipped Baba and is shocked to learn of his father's flaws.

What is Baba's only sin?

Baba tells him that there is only one sin: theft. Every other sin is a variation of theft. Murdering a man, for instance, is stealing his life.

What did Baba steal from Hassan?

Summary: Chapter 18 Baba had said that theft was the only sin, and Amir thinks how Baba stole from him a brother, from Hassan his identity, from Ali his honor. Amir realizes he and Baba were more alike than he knew.

What sins did Baba commit?

Baba, the father in The Kite Runner, a novel by Khaled Hosseini, argues that theft is the only sin.

How does Baba feel about Amir in Chapter 3?

Baba feels disappointed in and bewildered by Amir by the end of chapter 3. He does not see any of himself in Amir and can hardly believe Amir is his son.

Why is Baba disappointed in Amir?

Baba is disappointed by Amir's decision to become a writer because he does not see writing as a manly job or a job that would give him a high status in Afghanistan. Baba is more concerned about how society views him while the adult version of Amir is more concerned about doing what is proper and being happy.

Why was Baba hard on Amir?

He explains that Baba was hard on Amir because he could not openly show his love for Hassan. Farid searches, but discovers no sign of the adoptive parents Rahim Khan promised for Sohrab. Amir decides to take Sohrab with him to Islamabad while he considers what to do.

What is Baba's attitude towards his son?

Baba is very emotionally distant from his son because he feels that there is no real connection between the two of them other than Amir coming “out of” Baba's wife: “If I hadn't seen the doctor pull him out of my wife with my own eyes, I'd never believe he's my son” (25).

Compare And Contrast Amir And Baba In The Kite Runner

As father and son, Baba and Amir have some similarities, but they are both very different people. One of the major differences between Amir and Baba is that Baba is seen as courageous, while Amir is more cowardly.

How are amir and baba similar Free Essays | Studymode

father. Throughout the novel‚ Baba‚ Amir’s father‚ guides Amir through certain events which are crucial to his coming-of-age‚ and does it in a way in which it is not always clear what his intentions are.Baba takes Amir out of Afghanistan before the Soviet invasion‚ and while not specific events‚ he leads Amir by example‚ and helps him to get out of his shell and experience ...

Compare And Contrast Amir And Baba In The Kite Runner

Fathers have a remarkable influence on their children. Every son looks up to their dad, and dreams of becoming a man just like them. In the novel Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini, Ali and Baba play a tremendous role in their sons lives: Hassan and Amir.

Compare and contrast Baba and Amir in The Kite Runner - eNotes

In The Kite Runner, Baba and Amir are both privileged Pashtuns who are extremely close to Ali and Hassan.Baba and Amir both betray their best friends and make significant sacrifices to atone for ...

Kite Runner: Compare and Contrast Baba and Amir’s Sins

In Khaled Hosseini’s novel, The Kite Runner relationships drive the plot. The connection between father and son plays a major roll in the characterization of two main character, Amir and Baba. Throughout the beginning of the novel, Amir is constantly looking for his Baba’s approval.

Th Kite Runner Flashcards | Quizlet

Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like The novel begins with a flashback .What do you think is its purpose? What do you learn about the narrator?, Who is Hassan? Describe him physically. What is a cleft lip? What was his first word? Why is that important? What contrast is made between Amir and Hassan?*, What does it mean to be Hazara, Shi'a Muslim, Afghanistan's ...

How are Baba and Amir portrayed?

Baba and Amir are also portrayed as secretive individuals, especially if the issue exposes them to some level of shame. In such situations, the two individuals are only focused on safeguarding their interests despite the fact that the people close to them may get hurt due to their actions. An example of this is when Baba withholds the truth about Hassan being his son, which eventually hurts Amir when he finds out. On the other hand, Amir withholds information about the attack on Hassan by Assef. Hassan is later forced to serve his attackers when they attend a party hosted by Baba in his home.

Why did Baba sacrifice his life?

Baba sacrificed his secure, wealthy life in Afghanistan to give Amir a second chance at life in America, while Amir risks his life to save Sohrab from Taliban-occupied Afghanistan. Baba and Amir's differences are more surface-level and concern their own particular interests.

How long is the free trial for eNotes?

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

What did the people learn from duress and financial precarity?

Under duress and financial precarity, they learn to be better people than they were before.

What is a certified educator?

Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team.

Is Baba brave?

Baba is brave. On the trip out of Afghanistan, they encounter Russian soldiers, and Baba displays tremendous courage that borders on recklessness. Amir thinks to himself, “Do you have to always be the hero?” Conversely, Amir believes that he is a coward who betrayed Hassan when he was attacked. Amir writes that he had:

Who is Amir proud of?

Amir also writes that he is proud of Baba:

What does Rahim say to Hassan?

He remembers Hassan, whom he calls "the harelipped kite runner," saying "For you, a thousand times over." Rahim's words also echo in his head, "There is a way to be good again." These two phrases will become focal points for the rest of the novel and our protagonist's story. Chapter Two The protagonist remembers sitting in trees with Hassan when they were boys and annoying the neighbors. Any mischief they perpetrated was the protagonist's idea, but even when Hassan's father, Ali, scolded Hassan, he never told on the protagonist. Hassan's father was a servant to the protagonist's father, Baba and lived in a small servant's house on his property. Baba's house was widely considered the most beautiful one in Kabul. There Baba held large dinner parties and entertained friends, including Rahim Khan, in his smoking room. Though the protagonist was often surrounded by adults, he never knew his mother because she died in childbirth. Hassan never knew his mother, either, because she eloped with a performance troupe a few days after his birth. The protagonist always felt a special affinity with Hassan because he too was motherless. It was not a surprise that Hassan's mother, Sanaubar, left Ali. The only things these first cousins had in common were being of the Hazara ethnicity and the Shi'a religion. Otherwise, Sanaubar was nineteen years younger than Ali, gorgeous, and reportedly...

What is the relationship between Amir and Hassan?

Despite their ethnic and religious differences, Amir and Hassan grow to be friends, although Amir is troubled by Hassan, and his relationship with his companion, one year his junior, is complex. Amir and Hassan seem to have a "best friend" type relationship. The two boys, Hassan and Amir, are main characters in the book titled, The Kite Runner. The two boys have a relationship that is significantly different compared to most. There are many different facets that distinguish the relationship the boys possess. The boys do write their names in a pomegranate tree as the "sultans of Kabul" (Kite Runner 27) but, their friendship is not strong and it is one sided. Hassan has love for Amir. He loves him like a brother. Hassan is exceedingly loyal to Amir. The relationship between the two boys is emotionally wearing and rather gloomy for the most part. The main reason for their complicated relationship is the fact that Amir is Pashtun, and Hassan is Hazara. The Afghan society places Hassan lower than Amir. Hassan is Amir's servant. The placement of Hassan in the Afghan society disenables Amir from becoming Hassan's true friend. Amir sees Hassan as lower than human. Amir ruins the chance for friendship between himself and Hassan because he is jealous of Hassan, he thinks of Hassan as a lower human, and because Amir possesses such...

How does Baba forgive Hassan?

... with themselves. Baba forgives Hassan, Hassan forgives easily , and Amir is unable to forgive himself but throughout the book the readers saw the travel of Amir how he forgive himself. The opening sentence sets this theme with "I became what I am today at the age of twelve," as Amir relates how he believes one action at that young age defined his entire life. However, as the novel progresses, the reader comes to the conclusion that it was not one action, but a series of choices and events that created Amir's persona as an adult. By holding onto his guilt and fear of discovery, Amir could only bury his past for short periods of time before his own conscience uncovered it and the emotional baggage attached. Throughout the course of Amir's life, he made choices based on jealousy, fear, and guilt, and thus allowed his life to be immersed in regret and shame until he finally allowed himself redemption. Baba first demonstrates forgiveness when he pardons Hassan for stealing Amir's money and watch (even though Hassan didn't actually steal it). Baba is unaware that Amir was only framing Hassan for stealing his money and watch. Baba asks, "Did you steal that money? Did you steal Amir's watch, Hassan?" Hassan responded, "Yes." By Hassan taking the blame of stealing Amir's belongings, he shows indirect forgiveness towards Amir who is in the room with Amir and Baba. There are two acts of forgiveness in the situation, one indirectly and one directly. Even though Baba claims, "There is......

What is the story of the kite runner?

‘The Kite Runner’, written by Khaled Hosseni, tells the story about part of the protagonist----Amir’s life from Afghanistan to America from his own perspective. It’s a story about destiny, friendship, redemption and forgiveness. And it’s also a story about father and son’s difficult relationship, Baba is the only person who is with Amir from the start to the end. However, Baba and Amir’s relationship eventually works out.

Is Baba a tragic hero?

...Is it possible to see Baba as a tragic hero? (21) The definition of a tragic hero is a noble person with heroic or potentially heroic tendencies; however has a tragic flaw that leads to his downfall and a reversal of fortune. The audience typically pities this character. Although it may be argued that Baba is, in fact, a tragic hero, I do not believe that he is. Some readers may see Baba as a tragic hero as Baba does hold some of the characteristics needed for him to be a tragic hero. For example, he is sometimes noble, as on occasion, he quite clearly shows that he has high moral principles, as a noble person would. For example, when he stands up for the woman in the truck. ‘I’ll take a thousand bullets before I let this indecency take place.’ This is considered particularly noble as, given the context in Afghanistan in 1981, to stand up to a Russian soldier in order to stand up for your morals, is noble and heroic. Readers may also view Baba as a tragic hero, because, as a character, he most certainly does have flaws. From the way he treated Amir ‘Baba grunted, didn’t answer.’ (Chapter 2) to the adultery with Hassan’s mother, a high crime in Afghanistan in the past, especially with a servant, resulting in the birth of Hassan. The fact he kept this hidden for so long is a flaw in itself, as he sees himself to have the moral high ground on many occasions, for example, when he forgives Hassan from stealing from Amir. However, these flaws do not instigate Baba’s......

Why does Assef freeze?

As Assef goes to hit Amir, Assef suddenly freezes because Hassan has his slingshot aimed at him, which allows Amir and Hassan to get away. After Daoud Khan’s coup, life goes back to normal. The following winter, on Hassan’s birthday, Ali calls Hassan inside. Baba is waiting for him with a man named Dr. Kumar.

What is the story of Baba and Hassan?

Amir ’s grandfather takes the young Ali in, and Ali and Baba grow up together. Baba, however, never calls Ali his friend. Similarly, because of their ethnic and religious differences, Amir says as a child he never thought of Hassan as a friend. Even so, Amir’s youth seems to him like a long stretch of playing games with Hassan. But while Amir would wake up in the morning and go to school, Hassan would clean the house and get groceries. Amir often read to Hassan, who was illiterate. Their favorite story was “Rostam and Sohrab,” in which Rostam fatally wounds Sohrab in battle and then finds out Sohrab is his lost son.

Why does Amir say he never thought of Hassan as a friend?

Similarly, because of their ethnic and religious differences, Amir says as a child he never thought of Hassan as a friend. Even so, Amir’s youth seems to him like a long stretch of playing games with Hassan. But while Amir would wake up in the morning and go to school, Hassan would clean the house and get groceries.

Why does Amir feel Hassan is beneath him?

The young Amir genuinely felt that Hassan was beneath him because of Hassan’s poverty, ethnicity, religion, and deformity. Whenever Hassan does something that earns Baba’s love and respect, Amir lashes out at him in his thoughts. If Hassan is better at something than Amir, like solving riddles, Amir stops doing it.

What is the land of Pashtuns and the Hazaras?

Afghanistan is the land of Pashtuns and the Hazaras just pollute the country. Assef takes out his brass knuckles. He says Amir is part of the problem for being friends with a Hazara. For a moment, Amir thinks that Hassan is his servant, not his friend, but he quickly recognizes his thought is wrong.

What is the theme of chapter 4 of Amir and Hassan?

In fact, the overall theme of the section is change, in politics, in society, and in the personal lives of Amir and Hassan. In Chapter 4, for instance, Amir recognizes his gift for storytelling, first when he strays from the text he is reading to Hassan and then when he writes his own short story.

What is the best story Amir has read?

Hassan says it is one of the best stories Amir has read. That night, Amir writes his first short story, about a man whose tears turn to pearls. The man finds new ways to make himself sad so he can cry and become richer, until the story ends with him sitting atop a mound of pearls, sobbing over the wife he has stabbed.

Why did Baba build the orphanage?

But as Rahim Khan explains, Baba built the orphanage to make up for the guilt he felt for not being able to acknowledge Hassan as his son. Baba’s hesitation to reveal his emotions causes Amir to feel that he never knows Baba completely, alienating Amir from Baba while Amir is growing up.

What does the reader see in Baba?

As Amir describes him, he is proud, independent, determined, but sometimes emotionally distant and impatient. We learn from a note Rahim Khan writes to Amir toward the end of the book that Baba was a man torn between two halves, specifically between Amir and Hassan. Amir never sees Baba’s inner conflict because Baba has very much separated his outward appearance from his internal emotions. For instance, Baba builds an orphanage, which appears to be a simple act of charity. But as Rahim Khan explains, Baba built the orphanage to make up for the guilt he felt for not being able to acknowledge Hassan as his son. Baba’s hesitation to reveal his emotions causes Amir to feel that he never knows Baba completely, alienating Amir from Baba while Amir is growing up.

What happens when Hassan is not around?

When he no longer has his wealth, his guilt diminishes, and with Hassan not around, he is not straining uncomfortably to act one way with Amir and another with Hassan. As a result, he is able to open up more with Amir, and the two grow much closer in Baba’s final years.

Why did Baba feel guilty?

Baba, as Rahim Khan explains in his note, felt guilty over his rich, privileged life because Hassan was not able to share in it.

What is Baba's moral concern in The Kite Runner?

When Amir is a boy, Baba’s major concern about him is that he doesn’t have the courage to stand up for himself, demonstrating that Baba places great value on doing what is right.

Why does Amir sacrifice his life?

When he and Amir flee Kabul, he is willing to sacrifice his life to keep the Russian guard from raping the woman with them , and in doing so he sets the example that Amir will follow later when he must choose between saving himself or doing what he knows to be right.

How are Baba and Amir portrayed?

Baba and Amir are also portrayed as secretive individuals, especially if the issue exposes them to some level of shame. In such situations, the two individuals are only focused on safeguarding their interests despite the fact that the people close to them may get hurt due to their actions. An example of this is when Baba withholds the truth about Hassan being his son, which eventually hurts Amir when he finds out. On the other hand, Amir withholds information about the attack on Hassan by Assef. Hassan is later forced to serve his attackers when they attend a party hosted by Baba in his home.

Why did Baba sacrifice his life?

Baba sacrificed his secure, wealthy life in Afghanistan to give Amir a second chance at life in America, while Amir risks his life to save Sohrab from Taliban-occupied Afghanistan. Baba and Amir's differences are more surface-level and concern their own particular interests.

How long is the free trial for eNotes?

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

What did the people learn from duress and financial precarity?

Under duress and financial precarity, they learn to be better people than they were before.

What is a certified educator?

Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team.

Is Baba brave?

Baba is brave. On the trip out of Afghanistan, they encounter Russian soldiers, and Baba displays tremendous courage that borders on recklessness. Amir thinks to himself, “Do you have to always be the hero?” Conversely, Amir believes that he is a coward who betrayed Hassan when he was attacked. Amir writes that he had:

Who is Amir proud of?

Amir also writes that he is proud of Baba:

image

1.The Kite Runner - Amir and Baba's Relationship, Amir …

Url:https://graduateway.com/the-kite-runner-amir-and-babas-relationship-amir-and-hassans-relationship/

5 hours ago Web · The Kite Runner – Amir and Baba’s Relationship, Amir and Hassan’s Relationship. From reading chapters one to four, one of the main aspects of Amir and …

2.In The Kite Runner, what is the relationship between …

Url:https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/in-the-kite-runner-what-is-the-relationship-335848

33 hours ago WebWhy did Baba treat Hassan better than Amir? Amir sees Hassan as his servant and feels no need to treat him well. Amir also treats Hassan badly because he resents and is …

3.How Does Baba Influence Amir - 1003 Words | Studymode

Url:https://www.studymode.com/essays/How-Does-Baba-Influence-Amir-8F6853BF08FB3392.html

10 hours ago WebWhy is Baba so nice to Hassan? At first, it seems like Baba, Amir’s father, is acting in an altruistic manner by allowing Hassan and his father Ali to live as his servants. Amir notes …

4.In The Kite Runner, are Baba and Amir more similar or …

Url:https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/baba-amir-more-similar-more-different-how-why-67443

30 hours ago WebAmir notes that Baba is very loving towards Hassan, and attributes that love to Baba's own giving nature. However, it turns out that Hassan is actually Baba's child, not Ali's; Ali is...

5.Baba and Amir's Relationship - Term Paper - TermPaper …

Url:https://www.termpaperwarehouse.com/essay-on/Baba-And-Amir-s-Relationship/193899

3 hours ago Web · In other words, Baba is very important to Amir’s upbringing through his practice of leading by example. One of the key situations is when Baba forgives Hassan …

6.The Kite Runner Chapters 4 & 5 Summary & Analysis

Url:https://www.sparknotes.com/lit/the-kite-runner/section2/

22 hours ago WebBaba and Amir are both privileged Pashtuns, who enjoy many opportunities in Afghanistan. They both value Western culture and are not particularly religious. Baba admires …

7.The Kite Runner: Baba | SparkNotes

Url:https://www.sparknotes.com/lit/the-kite-runner/character/baba/

15 hours ago WebAmir feels guilty when he thinks about kite flying. It reminds him of his childhood memories with Hassan, the friend he betrayes for a kite, letting him get raped. After this, his …

8.Why does amir lie about hassans health when baba

Url:https://www.coursehero.com/file/p65gmmd9/Why-does-Amir-lie-about-Hassans-health-when-Baba-wants-to-take-them-to-Ghangha/

28 hours ago WebWhenever Hassan does something that earns Baba’s love and respect, Amir lashes out at him in his thoughts. If Hassan is better at something than Amir, like solving riddles, Amir …

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9