Knowledge Builders

why does paul d show sethe the clipping

by Gladys Goyette Published 3 years ago Updated 2 years ago
image

As he stares at Sethe, incredulous, Paul D understands why Stamp Paid showed him the clipping; it was a warning of what Sethe would do to (and for) the people she loved. Paul D is frightened and tells Sethe that her "love is too thick," and when she replies, he tells her that she has two feet, not four.

Full Answer

What does Paul D find in the old newspaper clipping?

Stamp Paid shows Paul D the old newspaper clipping about Sethe killing her baby daughter. Paul D insists that the woman in the picture is not Sethe because "that ain't her mouth."

Why does Paul D think the woman in the clipping is Sethe?

Stamp Paid shows Paul D the old newspaper clipping about Sethe killing her baby daughter. Paul D insists that the woman in the picture is not Sethe because "that ain't her mouth." Stamp Paid, remembering that horrible day, thinks about the fact that no black person sent warning to Sethe.

What does Paul D say about Sethe in stamp paid?

Stamp Paid shows Paul D a newspaper clipping with a drawing of Sethe, but Paul D, refusing to believe that the woman depicted is Sethe, insists, “That ain’t her mouth.” Paul D can’t read, so Stamp Paid tells him the story of Sethe’s tragedy. Stamp Paid leaves some parts of the story out, though.

What happened to Paul D in the House of thieves?

Insecure in his masculinity once again, Paul D takes to drinking and keeps his distance from 124. Only after Beloved has been banished from the house once and for all does Paul D return. Paul D finds Sethe lying in the bed where Baby Suggs died, completely distraught at Beloved’s disappearance.

What does Paul D Sethe show in the newspaper clipping?

What does Paul D ask Sethe for?

What hummingbirds pierce Sethe's headcloth?

What is Paul D's resistance to Stamp Paid's revelation about Beloved's murder?

Does Paul D see blacks in white papers?

See 2 more

About this website

image

Beloved Part 1, Chapter 18 Summary & Analysis | LitCharts

Sethe tells Paul D about her escape from Sweet Home, and how she did it by herself, without Halle’s help. She talks about how she felt when she arrived and felt freedom. She realizes that she is circling around the subject of her child’s death and thinks that she can never explain it to anyone, but that she was trying to carry her children away to “where no one could hurt them.”

Beloved Part Three: Chapter 26 Summary & Analysis | SparkNotes

A summary of Part Three: Chapter 26 in Toni Morrison's Beloved. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of Beloved and what it means. Perfect for acing essays, tests, and quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans.

the description of Sethe’s murder of Beloved is told over the course ...

"Beloved, she my daughter. She mine." The next four chapters are stream of consciousness, the first in the head of Sethe, the second in Denver's head, the third in Beloved's, and the fourth a mixture of all three.

Beloved: Sethe Quotes | SparkNotes

Sethe responds to Paul D’s suggestion that she leave 124 because of the baby ghost. Sethe, however, associates running away with loss. Her escape from Sweet Home separated her from her husband and triggered the events that led her to kill her daughter and attempt to kill her boys, which also contributed to them leaving home.

Sethe Killing In Beloved - 1079 Words | Studymode

“Beloved” In “Beloved” by Toni Morrison, the novel follows the life of an ex-slave African American woman named Sethe, living in Ohio in the 1800s told from both third person omniscient and limited.

What page explains when Sethe kills Beloved? - eNotes.com

I've included a link to the full text of the novel below. If you click on it and then scroll to the bottom of page 81, you will see that the last paragraph on the page begins with the line, "Sethe ...

What does Paul D say to Sethe?

Paul D tells her that her love is “too thick.” He feels distanced from Sethe and condemns her act, saying, “You got two feet, Sethe, not four ,” by which he suggests that she acted like a beast in attempting to murder her own children. His anxiety increases when he sees Beloved standing on the staircase. He leaves 124, and Sethe simply says, “So long.” Although he does not say so, Sethe knows that Paul D isn’t coming back.

What chapter does Sethe find his sons?

Summary: Chapter 16. One day, about a month after Sethe arrived at 124, schoolteacher showed up at the house with one of his nephews, the sheriff, and a slave catcher. In the woodshed, they found Sethe’s sons, Howard and Buglar, lying in the sawdust, bleeding.

What chapter does Stamp Paid take place in?

Summary: Chapter 17. Stamp Paid shows Paul D a newspaper clipping with a drawing of Sethe, but Paul D, refusing to believe that the woman depicted is Sethe, insists, “That ain’t her mouth.”. Paul D can’t read, so Stamp Paid tells him the story of Sethe’s tragedy. Stamp Paid leaves some parts of the story out, though.

What was the excess of the feast?

The community celebrated long into the night but grew jealous and angry as the feast wore on: to them, the excess of the feast was a measure of Baby Suggs’s unwarranted pride. Baby Suggs sensed a “dark and coming thing” in the distance, but the atmosphere of jealousy created by the townspeople clouded her perception.

How does Paul D repress his past?

In the present, Paul D represses his past by refusing to sit still.

What happens when Paul D arrives on Sethe's porch?

Once Paul D arrives on Sethe’s porch at the beginning of the novel, things begin to change for him. After banishing the ghost that haunts 124, he enters into a romantic relationship with Sethe. This relationship has a stabilizing effect for both.

What is Paul D's caring manner?

Paul D’s caring manner rejuvenates Sethe, and Sethe’s affection returns to Paul D and his lost sense of manhood. However, Paul D also incites conflict. His presence makes Denver jealous, and Beloved eventually targets Paul D, driving him out of the house. Insecure in his masculinity once again, Paul D takes to drinking and keeps his distance ...

Where does Paul D find Sethe?

Paul D finds Sethe lying in the bed where Baby Suggs died, completely distraught at Beloved’s disappearance. Once again, Paul D shows Sethe much-needed care. He insists that she’s her own “best thing,” and he encourages her to let go of the past and build a new, better future with him.

What happened to Paul D in Sweet Home?

Also like Sethe, Paul D is haunted by the horrific experiences of his past. Eighteen years before the novel’s present time, Paul D tried to escape Sweet Home with Sixo, but the two men were caught. After Paul D witnessed Sixo’s murder, schoolteacher affixed an iron bit in Paul D’s mouth and sent him to a prison camp in Georgia.

Why does Paul D want Sethe to be a part of it?

He is thinking about his future and he wants Sethe to be a part of it because he loves her.

Why can't Paul D stand to be with Sethe?

Paul D couldn't stand to be with Sethe after he found out she killed her child. He can't be with someone that he doesn't trust, but it is also hard for him to say goodbye to her.

Why did Paul D want to protect Sethe?

Paul D thought he was protecting Sethe by kicking the spirit out of the house. He wanted to make sure that she was safe because he really cares about her. He takes on the role of the man of the house and makes sure he is there for both Sethe and Denver.

What does Sethe say in the song "I'm here with you, with Denver"?

"Sethe, if I'm here with you, with Denver, you can go anywhere you want. Jump if you want to, 'cause I'll catch you, girl. I'll catch you fore you fall...We can make a life, girl. A life" (55).

Is Paul D in a relationship with Sethe?

Paul D and Sethe aren't in a relationship, but they are intimate. They have lingering feelings for eachother but don't say it.

Why is Paul D coming down hard on Sethe?

He is also coming down hard on Sethe because he is ashamed of his relationship with Beloved, whose gaze he feels he cannot escape.

Why is Paul D insisting that the woman in the picture is not Sethe?

Paul D insists that the woman in the picture is not Sethe because "that ain't her mouth. ". Stamp Paid, remembering that horrible day, thinks about the fact that no black person sent warning to Sethe. The four white people were riding towards 124 with "the Look," and everyone who saw it knew what it meant.

Why did no one in the black community help Sethe?

The revelation that no one in the black community helped Sethe, all because of jealousy aimed at Baby Suggs , is a horrifying one. It makes the tragedy of the child's death the responsibility not only of Sethe and the whites who came to get her, but of the entire black community.

What did Paul D and Stamp Paid do?

During the days, Paul D and Stamp Paid work with hogs. Cincinatti is the city of pork, exporting the valuable meat back to the Northeast. Stamp Paid shows Paul D the old newspaper clipping about Sethe killing her baby daughter. Paul D insists that the woman in the picture is not Sethe because "that ain't her mouth.".

What does Stamp believe?

Stamp believes that there was some meanness that caused the inaction of the black community, jealousy left from the feast weeks earlier. He keeps these thoughts to himself. But Stamp Paid helps Paul D to read through the article, at the end of which Paul D is still insisting the woman in the drawing cannot be Sethe.

What does Sethe's literal circling of the room parallels the way she tells her story?

Sethe's literal circling of the room parallels the way she tells her story, moving around, filling in gaps, trying to explain all the circumstances leading up to the horrible event. Her insistence on loving her children so fiercely actually scares Paul D, who believes that ex-slaves should not love so much. He accuses her of having love that is "too thick," but from Sethe's point of view love is either thick or worthless.

Does Sethe love her children?

Sethe loves her children too much, not knowing where "the world stopped and she began.". What she wanted for her children was guaranteed safety, and she was willing to kill them to get it for them. Paul D also is still ashamed of his sex with Beloved, feeling her eyes on him through the ceiling.

What does Paul D Sethe show in the newspaper clipping?

He shows Paul D Sethe's pencil-drawn portrait in a newspaper clipping that describes the murder. Paul D denies that the mouth of the pictured woman belongs to Sethe. Stamp Paid explains how the murder occurred, noting that Baby Suggs felt the approach of danger. He indicates that because of the revelry the previous night, ...

What does Paul D ask Sethe for?

Paul D asks Sethe for the truth , and her words mix tender memories with horror. Too distraught to sit, Sethe spins around the kitchen, recalling her insufficient knowledge about babies and nutrition, the painting of the steps that enticed the crawling Beloved, and her attempts to work and simultaneously watch over her children at Sweet Home. Paul D realizes that Sethe killed her child with a handsaw. He accuses Sethe of the crime, and then withdraws from the house. Sethe suspects that she may never see Paul D again.

What hummingbirds pierce Sethe's headcloth?

Within Sethe's psyche, metaphoric hummingbirds pierce her headcloth, their wings drumming into her brain a desperate course of action. Therefore, by the time her pursuer reaches her, the child in her arms has pumped out the last of its blood.

What is Paul D's resistance to Stamp Paid's revelation about Beloved's murder?

Paul D's resistance to Stamp Paid's revelation about Beloved's murder demonstrates the degree of horror and disbelief such an act creates. As we have seen, Paul D has undergone terrible, dehumanizing experiences which have toughened him and made him nearly impervious to hardship and pain.

Does Paul D see blacks in white papers?

News about blacks does not normally appear in white papers unless something terrible enough has occurred to capture the white readers' interest.

image

1.Chapters 17-18 - CliffsNotes

Url:https://www.cliffsnotes.com/literature/b/beloved/summary-and-analysis/part-1-chapters-1718

30 hours ago Summary and Analysis Part 1: Chapters 17-18. Returning to the present, Stamp Paid offers Paul D proof that Sethe was jailed for murdering Beloved. He shows Paul D Sethe's pencil-drawn …

2.Beloved Part One: Chapters 15–18 Summary & Analysis

Url:https://www.sparknotes.com/lit/beloved/section7/

5 hours ago Summary: Chapter 17. Stamp Paid shows Paul D a newspaper clipping with a drawing of Sethe, but Paul D, refusing to believe that the woman depicted is Sethe, insists, “That ain’t her mouth.”. …

3.Beloved: Paul D | SparkNotes

Url:https://www.sparknotes.com/lit/beloved/character/paul-d/

25 hours ago Insecure in his masculinity once again, Paul D takes to drinking and keeps his distance from 124. Only after Beloved has been banished from the house once and for all does Paul D return. Paul …

4.What page explains when Sethe kills Beloved? - eNotes.com

Url:https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/what-page-explains-when-sethe-kills-beloved-85513

24 hours ago  · Sethe describes to Paul how "She just flew. Collected every bit of life she had made, all the parts of her that were precious and fine and beautiful, and carried, pushed, …

5.Sethe and Paul D by Janelly R - Prezi

Url:https://prezi.com/cptbbnb9gpy6/sethe-and-paul-d/

32 hours ago Paul D kicks the Baby's spirit out of the house. "Sethe, if I'm here with you, with Denver, you can go anywhere you want. Jump if you want to, 'cause I'll catch you, girl. I'll catch you fore you …

6.english 10 Beloved Chapters 11-18 Flashcards | Quizlet

Url:https://quizlet.com/193247231/english-10-beloved-chapters-11-18-flash-cards/

23 hours ago  · Paul D's focus on Sethe's mouth truly shows the loving obsession that Paul D has for her. The mouth can be described as sacred, the place where a kiss is held. Paul D has …

7.Beloved Part One, Chapters 17-18 Summary and Analysis

Url:https://www.gradesaver.com/beloved/study-guide/summary-part-one-chapters-17-18

17 hours ago Why does Paul D show Sethe the clipping. He wants answers- he wants her to explain. What is the importance of the hummingbirds. Sethe is bothered by school tacher's presence so much that …

8.Beloved part 3 Flashcards | Quizlet

Url:https://quizlet.com/244245578/beloved-part-3-flash-cards/

21 hours ago Stamp Paid shows Paul D the old newspaper clipping about Sethe killing her baby daughter. Paul D insists that the woman in the picture is not Sethe because "that ain't her mouth." Stamp Paid, …

9.Part I Eighteenth Chapter pp 187 195 1 Why does Paul D …

Url:https://www.coursehero.com/file/p739k6v/Part-I-Eighteenth-Chapter-pp-187-195-1-Why-does-Paul-D-show-Sethe-the-clipping-2/

13 hours ago When Paul D sleeps with Beloved what does he end up saying? Red heart. ... Why does Sethe not want to become pregnant? She doesn't think she can stay alive long enough to love the child. …

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9