Knowledge Builders

why is spray foam insulation bad

by Annabelle Armstrong Published 3 years ago Updated 2 years ago
image

Because spray foams contain highly reactive chemicals called isocyanates

Isocyanate

Isocyanate is the functional group with the formula R−N=C=O. Organic compounds that contain an isocyanate group are referred to as isocyanates. An organic compound with two isocyanate groups is known as a diisocyanate. Diisocyanates are manufactured for the production of polyurethane…

, exposure can cause severe breathing and skin problems. If you have preexisting skin, respiratory, or asthma conditions, you are at an even greater risk of exacerbating these problems when introducing the chemicals in spray foam insulation into your home’s air.

The biggest problem we have with spray foam from a sustainability standpoint, is that it is undeniably made of toxic chemicals, some of which will pollute the indoor air long after owners take occupancy of a home. And once it is applied to a substrate, it is extremely difficult to remove it.Jul 28, 2021

Full Answer

What could go wrong with spray foam insulation?

  • Incorrectly mixed chemicals result in foam pulling away from the surface.
  • Incorrecting mixed chemicals result in lingering odors and health problems for occupants.
  • Overspraying and/or inadequate ventilation result in lingering odors and health problems for the occupants.
  • Inconsistently applied spray foam results in gaps that reduce product efficiency.

More items...

What are some of the pros and cons of spray foam insulation?

Spray Foam Insulation Pros and Cons

  1. More Expensive The cost of spray foam insulation is significantly higher than traditional forms of insulation. ...
  2. Not a DIY Project The insulation procedure requires experienced professionals and generally isn't a do-it-yourself project. ...
  3. Longer Installation Process

Are there any health issues with spray foam insulation?

The health risks associated with spray foam insulation are one of its most underrated disadvantages. Spray foam contains a class of chemicals called isocyanates. According to OSHA, long-term exposure to the chemicals used in spray foam can cause lung irritation, skin irritation, and respiratory issues.

Is spray foam insulation good or bad?

Therefore the short answer to the question in the header is “spray foam is good when PROPERLY installed, and BAD when installed in inappropriate places or in an incorrect manner. There are also issues of the impact on the environment, and potential impact on the health of the people living in the homes where the product is used.

What is the third cause of spray foam insulation problems?

What Are The Disadvantages Of Spray Foam Insulation?

How long does spray foam insulation last?

What is termite damage?

Why does my insulation pull away from the edges?

Why is spray foam not adhesion?

What are your objectives for insulation?

See 2 more

image

What are the dangers of spray foam insulation?

According to the US EPA, the dangers of spray foam insulation include exposure to harmful chemicals, lung and eye irritation, shortness of breath, sore throat, and fever. However, you can avoid these adverse effects by using protective equipment when installing spray foam insulation.

When should you not use spray foam?

When NOT to Use Spray Foam InsulationFor areas that are too close to electrical boxes:For areas too close to ceiling light boxes:Open-cell spray foam on your roof:For closed-cavity spaces:If you have a history of skin, respiratory, or asthma problems:

Is it OK to use spray foam insulation?

But today, Icynene open cell spray foam insulation is the safest form of home insulation with almost no risk involved for homes or homeowner.

Does spray foam insulation cause moisture problems?

Because of the excellent air sealing properties of spray foam insulation, moisture is less likely to enter your home. This reduces the risk of mold, as well as the risks of rot and structural damage that accompany water infiltration.

How long is spray foam toxic?

Of course, spray foam can be unsafe for occupants too. According to the EPA, occupants must stay away from the building while it cures (and as long as the dust remains) for at least 24 to 72 hours, something they, devastatingly, are not always told.

How long does spray foam insulation last?

80 years to 100 yearsBoth types of spray foam insulation can last anywhere from 80 years to 100 years, with closed cell spray foam having a slight edge in terms of durability. For most families, this represents the lifetime of the house and then some!

Does spray foam insulation cause mold?

There are air leaks in the spray foam insulation - at FOAM SPRAY INSULATION TYPES we warn about inexpert application of spray foam that leaves gaps, holes, air leaks. Building air movement through such openings may bring moisture as well as organic dust that invite mold growth.

Can you sell a house with spray foam insulation?

Spray foam insulation is one of those many factors that can throw up a red flag to a mortgage lender. For a lender, your insulation matters because it affects crucial metrics such as the home's saleable value and energy efficiency rating.

Will mortgage lenders accept spray foam insulation?

The hardened foam can also warp wooden beams. This has led to many mortgage and equity release firms refusing to lend to homes with this type of loft insulation.

What is the healthiest insulation?

5 Healthiest Insulation Options For Your HomeCork. When it comes to healthy insulation, cork tops the list, at least according to a report done by Energy Efficiency For All. ... FIberglass. ... Cellulose. ... Recycled Cotton. ... Sheep's Wool.

What are the disadvantages of foam?

Compared to other types of insulations it' is more expensive. It should not be exposed to direct sunlight and certain solvents. People allergic to foam insulation may develop health issues on coming in direct contact with it. Moreover, foam releases toxic fumes when set to fire.

Does spray foam cause wood rot?

No spray foam will not rot your roof.

Do you need ventilation with spray foam?

There are different types of insulation and you want to choose what is right for your home. One of those is spray foam. Do you need attic ventilation with spray foam insulation? No, spray foam insulation is applied to the ceiling and creates an air-tight seal.

Is spray foam carcinogenic?

Current spray foam mixtures containing formaldehyde can produce the airborne MDI against which the EPA warns. Such chemicals can cause cancer and contribute to unsafe air quality.

How long does spray foam take to off gas?

24 to 72 hoursDifferent manufacturers and installers of spray foam will insist that occupants vacate their homes - anywhere from 24 to 72 hours are the recommendations we've seen - to allow the foam to fully cure and off-gas.

Is spray foam insulation toxic after it dries?

After proper curing, spray foam insulation is safe and should not cause any health-related or even structural problems in your property. However, it is highly important for you to call a licensed insulation contractor to install this type of insulation in your property.

Can you spray foam in the winter?

While you can apply spray foam insulation in cold weather, the job becomes a little trickier. Contractors can make things easier by storing their equipment properly. There are specific closed cell spray foam mixtures that work better in the winter. You should always store these at 70 to 80 degrees Fahrenheit.

Can spray foam rot your roof?

Studies show that open-cell spray foam is risky in colder climates. Indoor moisture diffuses through the foam and comes in contact with the cold roof sheathing. The spray foam traps the moisture against the roof, which results in eventual decay.

Can you use spray foam around hot water pipes?

Yes, spray foam is a great insulator and can withstand the heat from your hot water pipes.

Does expanding foam corrode copper pipes?

An expanding foam on a copper pipe may cause corrosion. Non-water-resistant expanding foams can let water sip through and damage your copper pipes. Therefore, you should consider many factors before going for a particular type of expanding foam to avoid damage.

4 Pitfalls of Spray Foam Insulation - Energy Vanguard

Spray foam insulation is a great product. Homes insulated with it can be some of the most efficient and comfortable homes built. I’ve been in plenty of these homes and can tell you that a typical spray foam insulated house outperforms a typical fiberglass batt insulated house.

The Dangers of Using Spray Foam Insulation - LHSFNA

In recent years, spray polyurethane foam (SPF) insulation has become increasingly popular in both residential and commercial construction. More energy efficient than traditional fiberglass insulation, SPF insulation is used to create a moisture and vapor barrier in perimeter walls, crawl spaces and attics. However, despite claims from manufacturers that SPF is “green” or “environmentally ...

What is the ingredient in spray foam?

The ingredients in spray foam typically include isocyanate and polyol, with a smattering of blowing agent and additives like toxic flame retardants. The polyol, which is mixed with isocyanate to form polyurethane is, in general, a relatively harmless alcohol compound and is primarily added for greenwashing PR reasons as it can be made with soy and other natural oils.

When did spray foam switch to climate safe blowing agents?

The ‘greening’ happened because spray foam manufacturers in Canada were obliged to switch to climate safe blowing agents on January 1, 2021 by the regulatory elimination of HFCs, driven by the Kigali Amendment to the 1987 Montréal Protocol.

Is spray foam recyclable?

Currently, not really no. I’m sure someone somewhere has come up with a creative use for old bits of spray foam, but for the most part it will be heading to a landfill at the end of its life. Wood studs are recyclable, plywood is recyclable, rigid foam insulation boards like EPS are recyclable and even reusable, but anything with spray foam stuck to it is in all likelihood going to the dump. That means any wood, concrete or plastics that it is adhered to that could have been useful will fill up a landfill.

How long does it take for spray foam to cure?

There's no escaping the fact that spray foam is a petroleum based toxic chemical concoction that is sprayed on the inside of walls, making them not just well insulated, but very airtight as mentioned earlier.#N#Different manufacturers and installers of spray foam will insist that occupants vacate their homes - anywhere from 24 to 72 hours are the recommendations we’ve seen - to allow the foam to fully cure and off-gas. Are we to assume then, that after that time period - somewhere between 25 and 73 hours - that the human health risks are all gone?

When did Demilec switch to spray foam?

We do like to give credit where it's due, and we did write about Demilec's switch to the climate-safe spray foam blowing agents back in 2017. That was well ahead of some other well-known insulation manufacturers who just kept on pumping out the old HFC blowing agents, which were as much as 1,430 times worse in Global Warming Potential.

Is spray foam blowing agent eco friendly?

Regardless of the adoption of more eco-friendly spray foam blowing agents, there is still the matters of air quality, building durability and end-of-life disposal of the product itself and anything it touches.

Is spray foam eco friendly?

This created the perfect opportunity to talk up spray foam as an ‘eco-friendly green insulation’, even though quite a few manufacturers just squeaked into compliance with the new regulations at the very last minute.

What is spray foam insulation?

Spray foam insulation is commonly applied to the joists or rafters in roof spaces. It’s designed to stop the property from becoming too cold during Autumn and Winter, and too hot during the Summer.

What happens when your house has an air tight seal?

Once your home has an impenetrable, air tight seal, it will feel a lot more cosy and comfortable during the Winter . The draughts and cold spots will be no more.

Does spray foam insulation need to be installed?

Spray foam insulation really does need to be installed by the experts with skills, experience and the right techniques to do a good job . Self-installation may result in problems with ventilation, but there are other dangers involved caused by hazardous fumes.

Does spray foam insulation help with water tank?

The foam increases the insulation of the roof, which provides the additional benefit of protecting your water tank, and preventing pipes from freezing in the Winter. Those are the main benefits to using spray foam insulation in your roof, but here are a few more you may not have initially considered:

How does reducing heat affect heating?

By reducing the amount of heat that escapes the home, you increase the efficiency of your heating, and decrease your reliance on additional appliances to provide an extra boost of warmth.

Does foam insulation help with noise?

The foam insulation hardens on application, and creates a natural barrier to external noise, in addition to a whole host of benefits.#N#As a result, your interiors become peaceful and comfortable. We recommend the insulation especially in areas of high noise pollution, such as properties close to busy roads, and in urban locations.

Can foam spray hurt you?

The person installing the foam spray could easily hurt themselves and/or the property. It really isn’t worth taking the risk; get the job done by a professional.

What is spray foam insulation?

Spray foam insulation is a building material that has been used for many years, nearly 30 years by many home builders and homeowners, and placed in attics and roofs for insulation. As this building material has been continually used for decades, there has been increasingly more information and studies that have found that this popular, ...

How long should you stay out of the house after spray foam insulation?

The EPA standards say that under conditions where the chemicals fully react that individuals should stay out of this environment for at least 24 hours, maybe up to 72 hours to avoid certain health issues from spray foam insulation fumes in the air.

How long does spray foam insulation off-gas?

As we discussed previously, spray foam insulation will go through a curing process that will release two forms of toxic chemicals into the air that are used as the core components of the insulation material. In addition to the off-gassing volatile organic compounds, the uncured chemical dust will also be an issue in the environment. During the installation process of the spray foam, it is recommended that all occupants be removed from the tainted environment or the building. The only construction workers onside should be the spray foam installers that are wearing protective equipment.

How does spray foam work?

Spray foam is a chemical product that is created by two materials, isocyanates, and polyol resin, that will react when mixed with each other to expand out to about 30 to 60 times its liquid volume after it is sprayed and applied to the area in the indoor building. The capability of these two chemicals to work together to expand out is useful as ...

Why does spray foam shrink?

However, this material can also shrink in some situations – due to aging, constant exposure to temperature changes, and the reduction of coverage overtime. If this does occur, it can lead to insulation problems ...

What happens if you miss a gap in the attic?

During the installation process if a gap is missed in your attic it can increase the potential for water intrusions to occur in the environment. This can lead to rot and insect infestations and even the potential for mold to grow in the space.

Can spray foam cause problems?

There are several majors spray foam installation problems that have been associated with the use and application of spray foam in a home – some of these problems will vary based on how much of the spray foam is used, where it is placed, who applies the spray foam, and the conditions in this environment. Additionally, spray foam can create issues ...

When did spray foam insulation start?

Spray foam insulation has been an option since the 1950s, but it only really took off in the next century, around 2006 when next-generation polyols were manufactured as a blowing agent for insulation.

What is liquid foam insulation?

Liquid foam insulation materials are used in various parts of buildings to insulate surfaces and reduce air leakage. Different types may be sprayed or foamed-in-place to insulate open cavities in the structure including attics, crawl spaces, and the wall cavities of new-build homes.

What type of insulation is used in a closed cell?

There are two types of foam insulation that are applied in place: open-cell and closed-cell. Typically, both are made with polyurethane. These have their own pros and cons, so let’s consider this first off.

What is injection foam?

Some injection foams are three-part resin products that are mixed with a foaming agent and water. A great advantage of this type of foam insulation is that it can be installed in walls with existing fiberglass insulation, without removing the old material.

What is the R value of insulation?

As you probably know, the R-value of insulation is its thermal resistance, and it is a measure of how well the material will resist heat flow. It is determined by several factors, including thickness and density, which is why closed-cell spray foam is tops for the R-factor!

Where to put spray foam insulation?

Spray foam insulation can be applied to the underside of the roof, where it makes a huge difference in heat gain and loss.

What is closed cell foam?

Closed-cell foam is literally made up of high-density cells that are closed. These cells are filled with a gas that enables the foam to expand and fill all the gaps and spaces around it. When it cures, it becomes rigid, which has the benefit of also making the structure it has been applied to stronger.

Why doesn't spray foam stick?

Then during application, spray foam might not stick well for many reasons. Or it’s applied too thick. Or it’s applied in layers and one layer doesn’t stick to the next well. Or one layer isn’t allowed to cool off and the second is applied too early, which again traps chemicals inside the foam. Lots and lots of things can go wrong and barely anyone will tell you much about it because there is simply too much money in the game, so don’t expect honesty from this industry.

Why does spray foam stink?

Because it is impossible to mix chemicals on-site perfectly and it’s impossible to control the environment, the in-balance is almost certain to happen . In other words, your spray foam will stink, perhaps not enough for you to smell it; that depends on the person.

How long does spray foam need to dry?

The house itself needs to be ventilated well during the process and for 24 hours afterwards.

How does isocyanate react with foam?

Isocyanates can become trapped in the foam and then slowly react with moisture in the air or other chemicals in the foam. Slowly these substances are given off to the surrounding air….not just for 24 hours; rather, many, many years.

What does closed cell foam smell like?

While open cell foam smells like paint, closed cell foam has a rotten fish smell to it.

Is spray foam insulation a business?

Spray foam insulation is a booming industry. It’s a huge money-maker and where there is lots of money to be made, there is lots of brainwash going on—a huge marketing machine that’s bigger than one can comprehend.

Is fiberglass insulation toxic?

Basically the industry took a commodity, low-cost building material (fiberglass insulation) and replaced it with a better performing, very expensive, and potentially toxic to human health alternative under the ‘green building’ umbrella.

What happens if you don't mix spray foam?

If the chemicals in the spray foam aren’t mixed properly it can cause the insulation material to pull away from the cavity where it has been applied. When this happens, an air seal is not created, thus cool air will still be able to move around the insulation which will make your home uncomfortable.

Why does spray foam smell?

A permanent odor can also be created when this happens. The reason this occurs is because the chemicals in the spray foam get too hot and a permanent odor is created. This is due to the chemicals not having time to cool before more material was applied.

How long does spray foam last?

The problem lies in how the contractor handles the odor. Some odors only last for maybe an hour or two, while others can last much longer if the space to be insulated isn’t well ventilated.

How thick should spray foam be before air sealing?

For example, Icynene-Lapolla open cell spray foam must be installed at 3-inches before an air seal is created.

Why do people use spray foam?

Energy efficiency and comfort are the biggest reason a homeowner adds spray foam to their home. If your expectations for both of these topics don't match up with what the contractor thinks will happen, then there is going to inevitably be issues.

Why is my imitation foam moldy?

The problem arises when an imitation product is falsely represented so you have lack of adhesion to the cavity the foam is sprayed in and moisture management issues that can create mold and mildew , according to Icynene.

What can lead to gaps in insulation?

Being hasty and missing areas can lead to gaps in your insulation coverage which reduces the efficiency of the spray foam.

Where is spray foam insulation found?

Spray foam insulation is often found in roof spaces either at the joist or at rafter level . This type of insulation helps to reduce heat loss and keep warm air contained within the home during colder months. It also helps to prevent a property from becoming too warm in the summer months.

Why spray foam on slate roof?

If spray foam is applied to the underside of your roof slates, you are effectively removing this ventilation gap. Trapping moisture inside, foam completely encapsulates your roofing battens and the top of your rafters.

Why do you need to leave a ventilation gap on a roof?

This is to allow moisture an escape route from your roof, before it begins to settle and rot away your wooden roof rafters.

Why is ventilation important in insulation?

Ventilation is extremely important for your household, allowing fresh air to circulate and stale air to escape.

Can you spray foam insulation?

Ideally – no! Spray foam insulation should be installed by an experienced professional. Spray foam can sometimes emit hazardous fumes so it is important that a competent person handles this operation. LogicFoam Spray Foam is safe to install and does not contain any harmful or toxic chemicals either.

Can spray foam be used on rafters?

Trapping moisture inside, foam completely encapsulates your roofing battens and the top of your rafters. Spray foam insula tion should be installed by an experienced professional . Spray foam can sometimes emit hazardous fumes so it is important that a competent person handles this operation!

Is logic foam safe to use?

LogicFoam Spray Foam is safe to install and does not contain any harmful or toxic chemicals either. Is spray foam roof insulation good or bad? When you choose LogicFoam – it’s simply the best!

What is the third cause of spray foam insulation problems?

Consumer error leads to the third cause of spray foam insulation problems.

What Are The Disadvantages Of Spray Foam Insulation?

The installer must know chemical science and how to ratio the ingredients to get the right consistency for the foam. They must also know the basics of house layouts so they don’t miss sections or cover sensitive spots like wire channels and electrical outlets.

How long does spray foam insulation last?

Spray foam insulation is a long-term solution. You’re looking at an expected lifespan from 10 years to 80 years. For a new home, these are good numbers if it’s a first-time installation. However, you need to check your home’s history if it comes with insulation. Older homes will likely need a re-application or a touch-up in some sections.

What is termite damage?

Termite damage is an indication of poor application of the spray foam. Houses need occasional inspections to make sure everything is in good condition. However, it can be hard to see some hidden areas if an insulation contractor covered part of the house from being visible during inspection.

Why does my insulation pull away from the edges?

If you notice that a section of the insulation pulls away from the edges after spraying, there are two possible problems. The spray foam mixture is bad, or the substrate is wet.

Why is spray foam not adhesion?

Non-adhesion is a common problem in spray foam insulation. Bad chemicals and improper mixing of the chemicals causes cause non-adhesion. When it doesn’t adhere to the surface, spray foam leaves cavities that seal in water and provide grounds for unfettered growth of mold and mildew in damp spaces such as the basement and attic.

What are your objectives for insulation?

Your objectives for the insulation will determine what rooms they can cover and what type of insulation they will apply.

image

1.6 Problems With Spray Foam Insulation - Home …

Url:https://homeinspectioninsider.com/problems-with-spray-foam-insulation/

28 hours ago  · But most spray foam insulation products are manufactured from polyurethane that contains toxic compounds. This contributes to health risks. Also, while cost-effective in the …

2.Videos of Why Is Spray Foam Insulation Bad

Url:/videos/search?q=why+is+spray+foam+insulation+bad&qpvt=why+is+spray+foam+insulation+bad&FORM=VDRE

36 hours ago The typical paint type odor of spray foam comes from isocyanates, which are very reactive and known to cause cancer and other health problems. Spray foam is typically mixed on site (!) …

3.Is Spray Foam Insulation Good or Bad? | Home Logic

Url:https://www.homelogic.co.uk/is-spray-foam-insulation-good-or-bad

34 hours ago  · Despite the numerous benefits that spray foam insulation offers, it can be a tricky idea for some homeowners. For starters, it is hard to see termite damage with this type of …

4.Disadvantages of Spray Foam Insulation | EnviroKlenz

Url:https://enviroklenz.com/disadvantage-of-spray-foam-insulation/

21 hours ago  · The Spray Foam has an Odor and Off-Gassing. All spray foams have an odor at the very least during the installation process. The problem lies in how the contractor handles the …

5.The Great Debate: Pros & Cons Of Spray Foam Insulation

Url:https://www.attainablehome.com/debate-pros-cons-of-spray-foam-insulation/

29 hours ago What Does Spray Foam Insulation Cost spray foam insulation costs spray foam insulation costs $0.44.44 to $1.50 per board foot. A board foot is one square foot that is one-inch thick, or one …

6.Spray Foam Risks, Dangers, Odor, Smell: Is this Insulation …

Url:https://doctorpapadopoulos.com/spray-foam-risks-dangers-odor-smell-is-this-insulation-toxic/

7 hours ago

7.Spray Foam Insulation Problems: Look Out for These 7 …

Url:https://www.retrofoamofmichigan.com/blog/spray-foam-insulation-problems

36 hours ago

8.Spray Foam Roof Insulation Good or Bad? | Home Logic

Url:https://www.homelogic.co.uk/spray-foam-roof-insulation-good-or-bad

10 hours ago

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9