Knowledge Builders

why should first cousins not marry

by Ms. Josiane Koch MD Published 3 years ago Updated 2 years ago
image

Marriage between close relatives carries some risk. First cousins who marry run twice the risk of having a child with genetic abnormalities, according to a previous Health24 article . Now a new study suggests that children born to parents who are cousins have a significant risk for developing a mood disorder – such as depression or anxiety.

Marriage between first cousins doubles risk of birth defects, say researchers. Marriage between first cousins doubles the risk of children being born with birth defects, according to a study seeking answers to the higher than expected rates of deaths and congenital abnormalities in the babies of the Pakistani community ...Jul 3, 2013

Full Answer

Which states allow marriage to first cousins?

  • Alabama: First cousins, yes.
  • Alaska: First cousins, yes.
  • Arizona: First cousins, yes, only if they are over a certain age or cannot bear children.
  • California: First cousins, yes.
  • Colorado: First cousins, yes.
  • Connecticut: First cousins, yes.

What does the Bible say about marrying your first cousin?

Bible verses about Marrying Your First Cousin. 1 Kings 11:1-2 ESV / 7 helpful votes Helpful Not Helpful. Now King Solomon loved many foreign women, along with the daughter of Pharaoh: Moabite, Ammonite, Edomite, Sidonian, and Hittite women, from the nations concerning which the Lord had said to the people of Israel, “You shall not enter into marriage with them, neither shall they with you ...

Should first cousins marry each other?

Twenty-four states have laws forbidding first cousins from marrying, and seven states have limits like requiring genetic counseling. But no countries in Europe have such prohibitions, and in parts of the Middle East, Africa and Asia, marriages between cousins are considered preferable.

When did cousin marriage become unacceptable?

The first actual laws against first-cousin marriage appeared during the Civil War era, with Kansas banning the practice in 1858, followed by Nevada, North Dakota, South Dakota, Washington, New Hampshire, Ohio and Wyoming in the 1860s. Why was it OK to marry your cousin in the 1800s?

What are the consequences of being cousins?

How many people were born in Northern Ireland between 1971 and 1986?

Should couples be counselled about consanguineous unions?

Which countries ban consanguineous marriage?

See 1 more

About this website

image

Why you shouldnt marry a first cousin?

Marrying a cousin is usually considered a bad idea, because inbreeding can lead to harmful genetic conditions. But paradoxically, in some societies, marrying a related spouse is linked to having more surviving children, research suggests.

What happens if first cousins have a baby?

Contrary to widely held beliefs and longstanding taboos in America, first cousins can have children together without a great risk of birth defects or genetic disease, scientists are reporting today. They say there is no biological reason to discourage cousins from marrying.

Is it OK to marry your first cousin?

Laws governing the marriage of first cousins vary widely. In 24 states (pink), such marriages are illegal. In 19 states (green), first cousins are permitted to wed. Seven states (peach) allow first-cousin marriage but with conditions.

Is it a sin to marry your first cousin?

In the Bible, and in many parts of the world, the answer is no. But the answer is yes in much of church law and in half the United States. Among the forbidden couples are parent-child, sister-brother, grandparent-grandchild, uncle-niece, aunt-nephew, and between half siblings and certain close in-laws.

What famous person married their cousin?

Jesse James The infamous American outlaw of the Wild West married his first cousin Zerelda Mimms after a nine-year courtship.

How much DNA do cousins share?

You and your first cousin share DNA inherited from your mutual grandparents. The 23andMe DNA Relatives feature uses patterns of DNA sharing to estimate relationships....Percent DNA Shared by Relationship.RelationshipAverage % DNA SharedRange1st Cousin12.5%7.31% - 13.8%1st Cousin once removed6.25%3.3% - 8.51%9 more rows

What are the disadvantages of cousin marriage?

Consanguineous marriages are associated with an increased risk for congenital malformations and autosomal recessive diseases, with some resultant increased postnatal mortality in the offspring of first cousin couples, but demographic and socioeconomic confounders need to be well controlled.

Is it wrong to date your first cousin?

Cousin marriage laws in the United States vary considerably from one state to another, ranging from cousin marriages being legal in some to being a criminal offense in others. However, even in the states where it is legal, the practice is not widespread.

At what point are cousins not related?

What Is a Cousin? Cousins are people who share a common ancestor that is at least 2 generations away, such as a grandparent or great-grandparent. You and your siblings are not cousins because your parents are only 1 generation away from you.

Is it OK to love your cousin?

"It is not unusual, especially for elderly couples, to feel comfortable with and be attracted to their cousins. To say they shouldn't marry if they fall in love is unfair." But as cousincouples.com points out, unlike with other relationships, if things don't work out, you'll still be cousins for the rest of your life.

What is the closest cousin you can marry?

In the United States, second cousins are legally allowed to marry in every state. However, marriage between first cousins is legal in only about half of the American states.

Do Christians marry their cousins?

According to Goody, cousin marriage was allowed in the newly Christian and presumably also pre-Christian Ireland, where an heiress was also obligated to marry a paternal cousin. From the seventh century, the Irish Church only recognized four degrees of prohibited kinship, and civil law fewer.

Does inbreeding really cause birth defects?

Inbreeding can lead to higher frequencies of genetic defects. Inbreeding occurs when the alleles at a gene site are identical by descent. This can occur when a common ancestor appears on both the maternal and paternal side of the pedigree.

What level of cousin can you marry?

In the United States, second cousins are legally allowed to marry in every state. However, marriage between first cousins is legal in only about half of the American states. All in all, marrying your cousin or half-sibling will largely depend on the laws where you live and personal and/or cultural beliefs.

What happens if you have a baby with your first cousin once removed?

The son of your first cousin once removed is the same generation as you. This is your second cousin.

What will happen if you have a baby with your sister?

The risk for passing down a genetic disease is much higher for siblings than first cousins. To be more specific, two siblings who have kids together have a higher chance of passing on a recessive disease to their kids.

People should know the risks of marrying their cousin

When there have been generations of people marrying their cousins, I do feel like it gets a bit dangerous. Nowadays, parents can get tested to check whether their genes carry mutations that could ...

What does "consanguineous" mean in marriage?

The topic of consanguineous marriage raises both interest and unease in Western societies. For those who are wondering, that big word means “marrying your cousin”.

Which countries have restrictions on cousin marriage?

Apart from 31 of the 50 US states, only China, Taiwan, the Koreas and The Philippines have introduced similar civil restrictions on first cousin unions, although regulations that curtail cousin marriage apply to members of the Roman Catholic and Orthodox churches.

Is consanguinity good or bad?

In assessing whether or not consanguinity is “good” or “ bad” there has been a notable failure to take into account the social and economic benefits of close kin marriage, which is a particularly important consideration in the poorer sections of societies where consanguinity is more common. Or to acknowledge that wives in consanguineous unions generally seem to enjoy more equal status.

Do first cousins have disadvantages?

While some families and communities are indeed more likely to be affected by otherwise rare inherited diseases, a large majority of first cousin offspring show no disadvantage in health terms.

Is cousin marriage a reality?

The reality is that cousin marriage is something health planners and the general public will need to come to terms with in Australia’s multi-ethnic society.

Does Alan Bittles work for a company?

Alan Bittles does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Does Murdoch University provide funding?

Murdoch University provides funding as a member of The Conversation AU.

What percentage of first-cousins have been given antipsychotics?

Almost 9 percent of first-cousin offspring had been given antipsychotic meds, compared with roughly 4 percent of second-cousin offspring, and about 3 percent of unrelated offspring, the study authors said.

How many people were born in Northern Ireland between 1971 and 1986?

The findings -- based on an analysis of nearly 364,000 people born in Northern Ireland between 1971 and 1986 -- may seem unremarkable at first glance. But fully 10 percent of people worldwide are born to parents who are first- or second-cousins, largely in Asia and eastern Africa.

Can cousins cause depression?

WEDNESDAY, April 4, 2018 (HealthDay News) -- Children born to parents who are cousins have a significant risk for developing a mood disorder -- such as depression or anxiety -- when they grow up, a new study suggests. For adults whose parents are first-cousins, the risk is triple that of people whose parents are unrelated, the researchers reported.

Is mood disorder higher in second cousins?

And, mood disorder risk is also significantly higher among children of second-cousins, they said. "The size of this association is significant, and understanding why children of 'related parents' are at an increased risk of psychoses and common mood disorders warrants further research," said study lead author Aideen Maguire.

Who is the secretary of the American Psychiatric Association?

Dr. Philip Muskin, secretary of the American Psychiatric Association, called the findings unsurprising and suggested that they be taken with a grain of salt. When couples who are close relatives have children, genes that may be rare in the general population are more likely to appear in their offspring, he said.

How many mutations per person per generation?

The Keightley paper says that the point mutation rate (designated ‘u’) is 70 point mutations per person per generation. This is in the ball park of what I have been saying all along. But he also calculates the rate of deleterious (non-neutral) mutations (designated ‘U’). He comes up with 2.2 deleterious mutations per person per generation. This is simply because he is assuming most mutations are neutral, in other words he believes most mutations arise in the ‘ junk DNA ’ portion of our genome. The recent ENCODE findings show that most of the genome is functional, but Dr. Keightley is in denial of this new understanding, and so assumes only a few percent of the genome is functional.

What happens if two people from different races marry?

If two people from very different racial backgrounds marry, the chance that both carry the same recessive mutation is much lower, so the probability of a child carrying two copies of a deleterious recessive mutation is extremely low . Yet, so was the probability from two random people in the same population marrying.

How many babies are carriers of recessive mutations?

Figure 1: The probability of appearance for a recessive mutation with a frequency of 0.001 (1 out of 1,000 people are carriers) per million babies. Different degrees of relatedness are calculated. The probability of a child being born with two copies of a recessive mutation falls rapidly toward the background level (‘unrelated’) as the degree of relatedness goes down. This is an extreme example because most mutations are not nearly this common.

What is the probability of a mutation carried by one of the two?

We can calculate these probabilities for any degree of relatedness. For example, if an uncle marries his niece (or an aunt her nephew), there is a 25% probability ( ¼) that any mutation carried by one is also carried by the other. Thus, 1 ⁄ 1,000 × ¼ × ¼ = 0.0000625, or 6.25 out of every 100,000. The risk is 250 times greater than if two unrelated people marry. Of course, we’re still only talking about 0.00625% of babies from uncle/niece marriages would be affected, even with this extreme example.

What is appealing to unknown processes?

Appealing to unknown processes is wishful thinking. Worse, those unknown processes are not actually unknown. They have been studied, and quantified, and they fail to solve the problem.

Is Keightley a scientist?

In summary, while Keightley is a well-known scientist and does decent work in many areas, in this case he is clearly attempting to wish away the problems he knows exist. He knows the mutation rate is too high and appeals to unknowns to solve the problem.

Is the risk of inbreeding a mutation greater than the risk for a single mutation?

But there are many thousands of deleterious mutations circulating within every population. Thus, the true inbreeding risk is significantly greater than the risk for a single mutation.

Why is it better to find a spouse outside of your own population?

Because a man and woman from any closely related population have a greater chance of carrying recessive genes that can be detrimental to offspring. Generally, this is why it is better to find a spouse outside of your own population because any harmful genes you have have a greater chance of never taking effect, and if you want to make it even better, look for a spouse outside of your “race” since it will be even less likely you will pair up with someone who has a similar harmful mutation. Your most recent ancestor will be even farther removed than usual.

What is genetic disorder?

An inherited medical conditions caused by DNA abnormality. In simple words, suppose if your father has mutation (abnormality) in his DNA but your mother has perfectly fine DNA than your genetical disorder will be 50% (assumption). But, if your both parents has mutations in their DNA than change of genetical disorder will be 100% (assumption) and if both are fine than 0% Normal!

What happens if a third generation man and woman breeds first cousins?

Should a man and woman in the third generation breed, first cousins, the chance is much greater offspring will suffer from a genetic problem.

How many folds does the potential of compounding negative genetic traits go up?

The potential of compounding negative genetic traits goes up more than 100 fold. This can be disastrous to any children from such a pairing.

Why do first cousins have birth defects?

Mainly, because of the increased risk that the children of first cousin marriages will have serious or fatal birth defects.

How many people are there in the world?

7.7 billion people as of November 2018. It took over 200,000 years of human history for the world's population to reach 1 billion ; and only 200 years more to reach 7 billion. (Wikipedia).

Why did the Habsburgs disappear?

It’s believed the Spanish Habsburgs disappeared because of excessive inbreeding: Inbreeding caused demise of the Spanish Habsburg dynasty, new study reveals .

What are the consequences of being cousins?

Now a new study suggests that children born to parents who are cousins have a significant risk for developing a mood disorder – such as depression or anxiety.

How many people were born in Northern Ireland between 1971 and 1986?

The findings – based on an analysis of nearly 364 000 people born in Northern Ireland between 1971 and 1986 – may seem unremarkable at first glance. But 10% of people worldwide are born to parents who are first- or second-cousins, largely in Asia and eastern Africa.

Should couples be counselled about consanguineous unions?

Based on those findings, Maguire suggested that couples should be counselled about the reproductive risks associated with consanguineous unions .

Which countries ban consanguineous marriage?

Though marriage between blood relatives increases the risk of genetic defects in offspring, the practice is banned in only 3 nations: the United States, North Korea and China.

image

The Times They Are A'changin

Image
The public mood in Europe and North America gradually changed, with a growing belief that marriages between couples who were close kin would result in unfavourable health outcomes for their offspring. In the USA this reversal in attitude resulted in the introduction of state-based legislation to restrict or even b…
See more on theconversation.com

Good Law Or Prejudice?

  • Are these proscriptions justified, and if so why do they not apply to the rest of the world’s population, where a conservatively estimated 1100+ million people are married to a spouse who is a second cousin or closer, or are the offspring of such a marriage? And what is the actual basis for our suspicion of consanguinity – is it primarily founded on religious, social or genetic ground…
See more on theconversation.com

You Won’T Have Children with Webbed Toes … Really

  • Perhaps surprisingly to many, the genetic risks which have been associated with cousin marriage have been substantially overstated. While some families and communities are indeed more likely to be affected by otherwise rare inherited diseases, a large majority of first cousin offspring show no disadvantage in health terms. Further, many of the ill-effects on health that have been ascribe…
See more on theconversation.com

Inevitable Challenge

  • Given the entrenched opinions that the topic of cousin marriage often attracts, it is probable that these opinions will be challenged. But that is the nature of science, and I have undertaken extensive research to support the conclusions drawn. The reality is that cousin marriage is something health planners and the general public will need to come to terms with in Australia’s …
See more on theconversation.com

Common Custom in Many Countries

  • The custom of marrying immediate family members is usually carried out to keep riches in the family. This in return develops further medical complications and disadvantages for both men and women, especially among women during the stage of pregnancy. 1. In southern Asia, middle eastern, and North African countries, as many as half of the marriages are consanguineous. 2. I…
See more on thehealthsite.com

Medical Complications

  • As mentioned earlier, there are many medical complications associated with such unions. This includes doubled risk of birth defects and genetic disorders. Here are some diseases that are common in children born of this kind of wedlock. 1. Thalassemia 2. Cystic fibrosis 3. Downs syndrome 4. Infantile cerebral palsy 5. Hearing, and visual disabilitie...
See more on thehealthsite.com

How Countries Deal with It

  • Some countries with high rates of consanguinity offer tests to detect carriers of genetic disorders, as well as genetic counselling programmes. In Saudi Arabia and parts of Iran, a prenuptial consultation for blood relatives with a history of genetic complications is mandatory. To summarise, consanguineous marriages have a strong influence on behaviour in our population. …
See more on thehealthsite.com

1.Here's another reason why you shouldn't marry your cousin

Url:https://www.news24.com/health24/Medical/Genetics/News/heres-another-reason-why-you-shouldnt-marry-your-cousin-20180409

21 hours ago  · Marriage between close relatives carries some risk. First cousins who marry run twice the risk of having a child with genetic abnormalities, according to a previous Health24 …

2.Here's Another Reason to Not Marry Your Cousin

Url:https://consumer.healthday.com/diseases-and-conditions-information-37/genetic-disorder-news-332/here-s-another-reason-to-not-marry-your-cousin-732647.html

18 hours ago  · A lot of people are telling us that first cousins shouldn't marry because children born out of this kind of marriage could be retarded. I've also heard that this isn't true. Enlighten …

3.Should First Cousins Marry Each Other? - Creators …

Url:https://www.creators.com/read/tween-12-and-20/01/14/should-first-cousins-marry-each-other

9 hours ago  · Reading Time: 2 minutes Cousin marriages are highly discouraged in the West but this social trend is still deeply rooted among one-fifth of the…

4.Mutations, and why you shouldn’t marry your cousin

Url:https://creation.com/dont-marry-cousin

29 hours ago Marriage between first cousins doubles risk of birth defects, say researchers. Marriage between first cousins doubles the risk of children being born with birth defects, according to a study …

5.Here's Another Reason to Not Marry Your Cousin

Url:https://www.medicinenet.com/script/main/art.asp?articlekey=211269

32 hours ago Cons of marrying a first cousin: Increased risk of genetic disorders Extended family relations could suffer if the marriage doesn't work out No new interesting in-laws because everyone …

6.Why is it bad for first cousins to marry and have children?

Url:https://www.quora.com/Why-is-it-bad-for-first-cousins-to-marry-and-have-children

7 hours ago

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9