Are Mary Magdalene and Mary of Bethany the same Catholic?
However, it was not until 591 that Pope Gregory the Great authoritatively pronounced that Luke's sinner, Mary of Bethany, and Mary Magdalene were one and the same (Sermon 33.1).
Is Mary the sister of Martha the same as Mary Magdalene?
However, once Martha is added to this story, Lazarus' sister Mary isn't Mary Magdalene anymore - instead she's a different Mary from a different gospel (Martha's sister from Luke 10). We know from other early Christian texts that Mary Magdalene was a controversial figure in earliest Christianity.
Who are the 3 Marys in the Bible?
Las Tres Marías, the Three Maries, are the Virgin Mary, Mary Magdalene, and Mary of Cleofas. They are often depicted at the crucifixion of Jesus Christ or at his tomb.
Who is the other Mary Magdalene?
But by the 6th century, Western church traditions identified Mary Magdalene with Mary of Bethany. Pope St.
What is the difference between Mary and Mary Magdalene?
Mary was, by far, the most common Jewish given name for females during the first century, so it was necessary for the authors of the gospels to call her Magdalene in order to distinguish her from the other women named Mary who followed Jesus.
What happened to Mary Magdalene after Jesus died?
Mary Magdalene's life after the Gospel accounts. According to Eastern tradition, she accompanied St. John the Apostle to Ephesus, where she died and was buried. French tradition spuriously claims that she evangelized Provence (southeastern France) and spent her last 30 years in an Alpine cavern.
Who is Mary's sister at the cross?
Mary of Clopas is explicitly mentioned only in John 19:25, where she is among the women present at the crucifixion of Jesus: Now there stood by the cross of Jesus His mother, and His mother's sister, Mary of Clopas, and Mary Magdalene.
Which Mary was at the tomb of Jesus?
Early on the first day of the week, while it was still dark, Mary Magdalene went to the tomb and saw that the stone had been removed from the entrance. and saw two angels in white, seated where Jesus' body had been, one at the head and the other at the foot.
Are there 2 Marys in the Bible?
A common Protestant tradition holds that there are six women named as Mary in the New Testament: Mary, mother of Jesus; Mary Magdalene; Mary of Bethany; Mary mother of James the younger; Mary mother of John Mark; and Mary of Rome.
Who were the two Marys that went to the tomb of Jesus?
10 Now they were Mary Magdalene, and Joanna, and Mary the mother of James: and the other women with them told these things unto the apostles.
Why is the Gospel of Mary Magdalene not in the Bible?
None of these texts were included in the Bible, because the content didn't conform to Christian doctrine, and they're referred to as apocryphal.
Where is Mary of Bethany mentioned in the Bible?
Medieval Western Christianity identified Mary of Bethany with Mary Magdalene and with the sinful woman of Luke 7:36–50, very common for that time period.
What is the difference between Martha and Mary?
There is a fundamental risk involved in labeling someone based upon one or two incidents in their lives. Martha has been called “practical” and Mary “spiritual.” In reality, both were practical, both were spiritual. Both loved and served Jesus; all three scriptural accounts illustrate this.
Is Mary Magdalene in the Last Supper?
And despite what many think, Mary Magdalene is probably not in the painting... Over the years some have alleged that the figure to Jesus' right is actually Mary Magdalene, not St. John. King said this isn't the case.
Is Mary Magdalene wife of Jesus?
Jesus 'married Mary Magdalene and had children', according to ancient manuscript.
Which Mary was at the tomb of Jesus?
Early on the first day of the week, while it was still dark, Mary Magdalene went to the tomb and saw that the stone had been removed from the entrance. and saw two angels in white, seated where Jesus' body had been, one at the head and the other at the foot.
Why doesn't Mark name Mary Magdalene?
There are two things to note in Mark’s account. First, the woman who anoints Jesus is not named. If we only had Mark’s account, this woman would be forever anonymous. Why doesn’t Mark name her? There are two possibilities: Either Mark did not know her identity or he simply chose not to name her (as so many other women in the gospels go unnamed). Whatever the case, in Mark we have the first evidence of the possible equivalency of Mary of Bethany and Mary Magdalene: the anointing takes place in the town of Bethany (the home of the sisters Mary and Martha and their brother Lazarus) and an “alabaster jar” of ointment is used (which has become symbolic of Mary Magdalen in Christian art). We shall see further evidence for this when we examine John’s account. But first, let us look at another story of anointing by an anonymous woman as recorded by Luke (7:36-50 NRSV):
When is the feast of Mary Magdalene?
This identification became cemented in the General Roman Calendar, in which the Feast of Mary Magdalene (July 22) includes a collect referring to Mary of Bethany.
What is the woman in the tomb called?
According to all four gospels a woman name Mary was at the tomb to do just that. And this woman is called Mary Magdalene. My thesis that Mary of Bethany and Mary Magdalene are one and the same person resolves all the discrepancies in the gospels.
How are Mark and Luke similar?
However, despite these differences in time and place, there is one striking similarity between Mark and Luke. In both accounts an anonymous woman just suddenly appears out of nowhere and anoints Jesus. This is most unusual. And it seems highly unlikely that two different anonymous women would have done this on two different occasions (and in two different houses of a man named Simon). The most likely explanations are that Luke either received this tradition in a different form than what Mark had (from his unique “L source,” according to what scholars call the Two-Document Theory), or Luke had theological reasons for changing the setting of the tradition he found in Mark. It is the latter that seems most logical as I shall now explain.
How does John differ from Mark?
This can be seen here, in that John differs from Mark in one other detail: He agrees with Luke against Mark that Mary anoints the feet of Jesus not his head. John also agrees with Luke that she wiped his feet with her hair. As we saw, it is this highly controversial act that impelled Luke to deem this woman a sinner.
Who anoints Jesus' head with an alabaster flask?
One might well presume this is at the house of Lazarus and his two sisters, Mary and Martha. Mark also relates the story of a mysterious unnamed “woman” who anoints Jesus’ head with an alabaster flask of costly spikenard, also at Bethany that last week of Jesus’ life.
Who anoints Jesus feet with spikenard?
In John it is clearly Mary of Bethany who does a similar (if not the same) anointing with spikenard–but of Jesus feet, wiping them with her hair. Quite oddly, Luke has his own anointing story, with an unnamed woman who is a “sinner,” who anoints Jesus feet, weeps, and dries them with her hair. But his account is much earlier in his gospel ...
How many times is Mary Magdalene mentioned in the Gospels?
14 times that Mary Magdalene is mentioned in the Gospels, but never once is she called a prostitute or a sinner. But could Mary of Bethany be her name or known public designation prior to her conversion and Magdalene her name after her life changing encounter with Yeshua and this be the reason Mary Magdalene is not called a sinner? Could Magdala be her hometown of childhood innocence and Bethany the town of her innocence lost?
Did the writers of the Gospels know Mary Magdalene?
I think the writers of the gospels would have known both Marys very well ......particularly Mary Magdalene. Some say they were jealous of her and I wouldn't be a bit surprised if that's true.
Did Mary Magdalene have demons?
The gospels say she had demons and Yeshua cleansed her of them and she followed him in devotion to what he had done for her. Of course these demons would be the source of her sinning but it is never said her sins were prostitution. Mary Magdalene is a name like Judas Iscariot.
Was Magdala a city?
Magdala was a city on the Galilee. On the other hand Mary of Bethany was from Bethany. This is clear by the many visits Yeshua paid them. She was the sister of Marta and Lazarus. Bethany was only a few miles outside of Jerusalem.
Was Mary Magdalene a prostitute?
First point- Mary Magdalene was a prostitute - this is a fallacy born and breed from the RCC. The gospels only say she was a sinner. Are only prostitute's sinners? Not likely. The gospels say she had demons and Yeshua cleansed her of them and she followed him in devotion to what he had done for her. Of course these demons would be the source of her sinning but it is never said her sins were prostitution.
Published by
Katia is a consecrated independent sacramental bishop. She directs the online Esoteric Mystery School and Interfaith Theological Seminary. Check it out at NorthernWay.org. View all posts by Katia
Katia
Katia is a consecrated independent sacramental bishop. She directs the online Esoteric Mystery School and Interfaith Theological Seminary. Check it out at NorthernWay.org. View all posts by Katia
What does Mary Magdalene call Jesus?
Clue Three: Mary Magdalene calls Jesus “’Rabboni!’ (that is to say, Master) (Jn 20:16) which is the same way that Martha identifies Jesus to her sister Mary, “The Master is here and calls you” (Jn 11:28).
What did Mary of Bethany say to Jesus?
When Mary of Bethany anointed Jesus with “a pound of ointment, genuine nard of great value” (Jn 12:3), Jesus defended her by saying, “Let her be—that she may keep it for the day of my burial” (Jn 12:7). Clue Five: Although when Gabriel appeared to Zachary St. Luke indicates that the angel was “standing at the right of the altar of incense” ...
What did Mary think when her brother died?
People who knew Mary thought that when her brother Lazarus had died, she would go to the tomb to weep there (Jn 11:31). j. Jesus defended her second anointing by saying in reference to the “pound of ointment, genuine nard of great value” (Jn 12:3), “Let her be—that she may keep it for the day of my burial” (Jn 12:7).
How many devils did Jesus cast out of Mary Magdalene?
In fact he connects the two passages with the word “afterwards” and at the same time indicates that Jesus had cast seven devils out of Mary Magdalene (Luke 8:1-2). In Scripture the number “seven” indicates perfection; the implication is that Mary Magdalene had been perfectly possessed by Satan before Jesus set her free.
How many clues does Mary Magdalene have?
Seven Gospel Clues that Mary Magdalene is Mary of Bethany. It has become sadly prevalent today to assume that Mary Magdalene was not Mary of Bethany. This is a great disservice to the whole Church since her witness to the Merciful Love of God has benefited countless souls throughout the centuries. There are at least seven powerful Scriptural clues ...
What did Jesus say about Mary the mother of James and Joseph?
Jesus never said of Mary the mother of James and Joseph that “wherever this gospel is preached in the whole world, what she has done will be told in memory of her” (Mt 26:13).
Why did Mary's sins be forgiven by Jesus?
Her many sins were forgiven by Jesus because she loved much (Lk 7:47-48) ; f. She sat at his feet and listened to His word and Jesus told her sister Martha that Mary had chosen the best part that would not be taken away from her (Lk 10:38-42); g.
What really matters about Mary Magdalene and Mary of Bethany?
What Really Matters: Perhaps what is significant for us in the discussion of the identity of Mary Magdalene and Mary of Bethany is that, whether or not they were the same person, Jesus trained women to proclaim the good news of salvation. He called men and women to the service of the gospel.
Where did Mary of Bethany live?
This is what we know: She was the sister of Martha and Lazarus and lived in Bethany, in the region of Judea (Luke 10:38, 39; John 11:1, 2). She used to sit at Jesus’ feet to learn from Him.
What did Mary of Bethany do before Jesus was crucifixion?
She anointed Jesus shortly before His crucifixion, revealing her devotion and love for Him (John 11:2; 12:1-8). This act was her expression of gratitude for the forgiving love of the Savior she experienced (Luke 7:47, 48). Luke implies that she had been forgiven much. After the anointing, no other mention is made of Mary of Bethany.
What does Luke mean by Mary Magdalene?
Luke implies that she had been forgiven much. After the anointing, no other mention is made of Mary of Bethany. 2. Mary Magdalene: The full name of this woman has traditionally been taken to imply that she was from the city of Magdala, located on the northwest shore of the Sea of Galilee.
Where did Mary go after Jesus?
One could speculate that perhaps early in her life Mary left her home in Bethany, went to live in Magdala, and after she met Jesus she returned to Bethany. This does not contradict any of the biblical evidence, but simply goes beyond it.
Who was the first disciple to see Jesus' body?
Mary Magdalene came to play a significant role in the gospel narrative. She almost became the disciple par excellence. She witnessed Jesus’ death on the cross (Matt. 27:55, 56; John 19:25) and accompanied His body to the tomb (Matt. 27:60, 61). On Sunday morning she was the first to get to Jesus’ tomb, and, seeing that it was empty, went and informed the disciples that someone had taken away Jesus’ body (John 20:1, 2). The other disciples came and found it to be true and went away, but Mary stayed behind and was the first to see the risen Lord (verse 15). He commissioned her to tell the disciples He had been resurrected (verse 17). In obedience, she and the other women went to the disciples and announced that the Lord had risen (John 20:18; Matt. 28:7; Luke 24:9).
Is Bethany the same as Magdala?
Besides, there is the problem of the place of origin. Bethany is in Judea, while Magdala is in Galilee.
Why is Mary Magdalene called Mary of Bethany?
In medieval Western Christian tradition, Mary of Bethany was identified as Mary Magdalene perhaps in large part because of a homily given by Pope Gregory the Great in which he taught about several women in the New Testament as though they were the same person. This led to a conflation of Mary of Bethany with Mary Magdalene as well as with another woman (beside Mary of Bethany who anointed Jesus), and the woman caught in adultery. Eastern Christianity never adopted this identification. In his article in the 1910 Catholic Encyclopedia, Hugh Pope stated, "The Greek Fathers, as a whole, distinguish the three persons: the 'sinner' of Luke 7:36–50; the sister of Martha and Lazarus, Luke 10:38–42 and John 11; and Mary Magdalen."
Who is Mary of Bethany?
Mary of Bethany. From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Jump to navigation Jump to search. Figure described in the Gospel of John; sister of Lazarus and Martha, living in the village of Bethany near Jerusalem; traditionally identified with Mary Magdalene. Saint.
What perfume did Mary give Jesus?
Here a dinner was given in Jesus' honor. Martha served, while Lazarus was among those reclining at the table with him. Then Mary took about a pint of pure nard, an expensive perfume; she poured it on Jesus' feet and wiped his feet with her hair. And the house was filled with the fragrance of the perfume.
Where did Mary of Bethany live?
Together with her siblings Lazarus and Martha, she is described by John as living in the village of Bethany, a small village in Judaea to the south of the Mount of Olives near Jerusalem. Medieval Western Christianity identified Mary of Bethany with Mary Magdalene and with the sinful woman of Luke 7:36–50. This influenced the Roman Rite liturgy of ...
What does Mary say to Jesus when he meets her?
This portrayal of the sisters agrees with that found in Luke 10:38–42.". When Mary meets Jesus, she falls at his feet. In speaking with Jesus, both sisters lament that he did not arrive in time to prevent their brother's death: "Lord, if you had been here, my brother would not have died.".
Why did Mary sit at Jesus' feet?
For Mary to sit at Jesus' feet, and for him to allow her to do so, was itself controversial. In doing so, as one commentator notes, Mary took "the place of a disciple by sitting at the feet of the teacher. It was unusual for a woman in first-century Judaism to be accepted by a teacher as a disciple.".
Where is the woman's name in the Gospels?
The woman's name is not given in the Gospels of Matthew [26:6–13] and Mark, [14:3–9] but the event is likewise placed in Bethany, specifically at the home of one Simon the Leper, a man whose significance is not explained elsewhere in the gospels.
