Knowledge Builders

what experimental evidence is used in defense of the two factor theory of emotion

by Aleen Hartmann Published 3 years ago Updated 2 years ago
image

The misattribution of arousal study tested the two-factor theory of emotion. This theory has helped support Schachter & Singer’s concept of the two-factor theory. Psychologists Donald G. Dutton and Arthur P. Aron wanted to use a natural setting that would induce physiological arousal.

Full Answer

What is the two-factor theory of emotion?

The two-factor theory of emotion focuses on the interaction between physical arousal and how we cognitively label that arousal. In other words, simply feeling arousal is not enough; we also must identify the arousal in order to feel the emotion.

What is Schachter's theory of emotion?

Stanley Schachter, a famous psychologist, proposed the two-factor theory of emotions, which said that people label their emotions according to their environment and their physiological cues. ... Misattribution of arousal is more evidence for the two-factor theory of emotion.

What was the first theory of emotion in psychology?

The first theory of emotion in modern psychology was the James-Lange theory, which centered around the body’s physical arousal. It was replaced by the Cannon-Bard theory, which argued that emotions start in the mind, not the body.

What are the two key components of emotion?

According to one major theory of emotion, there are two key components: physical arousal and a cognitive label. In other words, the experience of emotion involves first having some kind of physiological response which the mind then identifies. Cognitive theories of emotion began to emerge during the 1960s,...

image

What has the two-factor theory of emotion been used to explain?

The two-factor theory of emotion focuses on the interaction between physical arousal and how we cognitively label that arousal. In other words, simply feeling arousal is not enough; we also must identify the arousal in order to feel the emotion. So, imagine you are alone in a dark parking lot walking toward your car.

What is Schachter and Singer's two-factor theory of emotion and what evidence supports it?

Schachter and Singer's (1962) Two-Factor Theory of Emotion suggests that physiological arousal determines the strength of the emotion, while cognitive appraisal identifies the emotion label. So, in this theory, the “two-factor” represents physiological change and cognitive appraisal change.

What is two-factor theory example?

This concept puts forward two factors that motivate employees: job satisfaction and job dissatisfaction. While these might seem like opposites, they work together in a cycle. For example, when an employee is unhappy with their job, they may exhibit low performance or consider quitting the company.

What are the two theories of emotion?

Types of Theories of Emotion Physiological theories suggest that responses within the body are responsible for emotions. Neurological theories propose that activity within the brain leads to emotional responses.

What do the results of Schachter and Singer's experiment suggest?

The main result of the Schachter-Singer experiment is that the epinephrine misinformed group and the epinephrine ignorant group reported higher emotional reactivity than the epinephrine informed group and the placebo group.

Which of the following statements is most consistent with the two-factor theory of emotion?

Which of the following statements is most consistent with the two-factor theory of emotion? Physiological arousal can be interpreted in different ways, resulting in different emotions.

What are the two factors proposed in the two-factor theory?

The two-factor theory of emotion states that emotion is based on two factors: physiological arousal and cognitive label.

What is the two-factor theory quizlet?

The two-factor theory of emotion states that the physiological arousal in different emotion is entirely the same and we label our arousal according to the cognitions we have available.

Why is the two-factor theory of emotion called that quizlet?

This is also known as Schachter's Two-Factor Theory of Emotion, after Stanley Schachter. Schachter proposed that human emotions contain two factors or parts: physical arousal and a cognitive label. According to Schachter, both of these elements must be present for you to experience an emotion.

Which is the most accepted theory of emotion?

The two most well-known cognitive theories are the two-factor and the cognitive-mediational theories of emotion. According to the two-factor theory, proposed by Schachter and Singer, the stimulus leads to the arousal that is labeled using the cognition that leads to the emotion.

Who made the two-factor theory of emotion?

Lesson Summary. Developed by Stanley Schachter and Jerome Singer in the 1960s, the two-factor theory of emotion, also known as the Schachter-Singer theory, proposes our experience of emotions depends on two things: physiological arousal and our cognitive interpretation of the arousal.

How does the 2 factor theory of emotion relate to the misattribution of arousal?

In misattribution of arousal, a person thinks they are feeling an emotion because of a cause that is not actually the cause. Misattribution of arousal is possible in the two-factor theory of emotion, because the physiological arousal is not specific and is dependent on the immediate environment for identification.

What are the motivating factors in Herzberg's two-factor theory?

Herzberg's two-factor theory outlines that humans are motivated by two things: motivators and hygiene factors (see Figure 1). These two factors are both critical to motivation: motivators encourage job satisfaction and hygiene factors prevent job dissatisfaction.

What is Schachter's theory of emotion?

The Schachter-Singer Theory, also known as the Two-Factor theory of emotion, states that 2 factors are needed to experience emotion. First, environmental stimuli elicits a physiological response. Second, we cognitively appraise this physiological activity, and try to give it the correct label.

What is the two factor theory of emotion?

Two-factor Theory of Emotion (Schachter & Singer) Schachter & Singer (1962) The two-factor theory of emotion, or Schachter-Singer theory, states that emotion is a function of both cognitive factors and physiological arousal. According to the theory, “people search the immediate environment for emotionally relevant cues to label ...

What are the four categories of euphoria?

For the euphoria stage, there were four specific categories the observers looked for: the subject joins the stooge’s activity, initiates a new activity, ignores the stooge, or watches the stooge. During any particular behavior, the subjects were was coded in one or more of these categories.

How did Maslach and Singer study work?

Maslach (1979) designed a study to try to replicate and extend on the Schachter and Singer study . Instead of being injected with epinephrine, the administrators used hypnotic suggestions for the source of arousal. Either the subjects were hypnotized or were used as a control (same as the placebo effect in the Schachter and Singer study). Subjects that were hypnotized were given a suggestion to become aroused at the presentation of a cue and were instructed not to remember the source of this arousal. Right after they had hypnotized, a confederate began acting either in a euphoric or anger condition. Later on in the study the subjects were exposed to two more euphoric confederates. One confederate was to keep aware the source of the arousal, while the other confederates told the subjects to expect different arousal symptoms. The results found that all the subjects both on self-reports and on observation found that unexplained arousal causes negative conditions. Subjects still showed angry emotions regardless of the euphoric confederate. Maslach concluded that when there is a lack of explanation for an arousal it will then cause a negative emotion. Which will evoke either angry or fear. Although, Maslach did mention a limitation that there might have been more negative emotion self-reported because there are more terms referring to negative emotions than to positive ones.

What was Maslach's purpose in the Schachter and Singer study?

Maslach (1979) designed a study to try to replicate and extend on the Schachter and Singer study. Instead of being injected with epinephrine, the administrators used hypnotic suggestions for the source of arousal.

What did the misinformed or ignorant subjects behave like?

The subjects that were in the misinformed or ignorant condition behaved similar to the stooge. While those who were informed of the expected feelings had little to no emotion pattern. They found that when the subjects were informed the individual had a perfectly appropriate explanation for his or her feelings.

What is the misattribution study?

The misattribution study tested the two-factor theory of emotion. This theory has helped support Schachter & Singer’s concept of the two-factor theory. Psychologists, Donald G. Dutton and Arthur P. Aron wanted to use a natural setting that would induce physiological arousal. In this experiment, they had male participants walk across two different ...

Who did the Schachter and Singer study?

Schachter and Singer study. Stanley Schachter and Jerome Singer (1962) performed a study on 184 college students on how emotion comes from a state of arousal and what makes the most sense of the situation. From this information, they designed a study that would give the participants a shot of epinephrine (adrenaline).

Why is misattribution of arousal more evidence for the two factor theory of emotion?

Misattribution of arousal is more evidence for the two-factor theory of emotion. Because people are looking at environmental clues to explain their physical symptoms, they can get easily confused. As a result, they think they're feeling one thing when really, they're feeling another. Lesson Summary.

What are the two things that affect emotions?

There are really two things going on with emotions: your body's response to the situation (like when your heart started racing in the dark street) and your cognitive assessment of your emotion, or the thoughts that tell you what emotion you are experiencing. Stanley Schachter, a famous psychologist, proposed the two-factor theory of emotions, which said that people label their emotions according to their environment and their physiological cues.

What are the effects of Schachter's experiment?

Some of the participants were told that they might experience side effects similar to that of adrenaline: racing heart, shaking hands, or a warm and flushed face. Other participants were not told of any side effects or were told to expect some side effects but not the real ones.

What are the two parts of emotion?

The two-factor theory of emotion says that there are two parts of emotion: the physiological symptoms and the cognitive thoughts that tell us what we're feeling. When we experience physical signs of emotion, such as a racing heart, we will look to cues in our environment to tell us what emotion we are feeling.

When people feel one emotion but think it's another emotion, it is called?

When people feel one emotion but think it's another emotion, it is called misattribution of arousal. A classic study of misattribution of arousal was done a few years after Schachter's study by Donald G. Dutton and Arthur P. Aron.

What is the two factor theory of emotion?

The two-factor theory of emotion states that emotion is based on two factors: physiological arousal and cognitive label. The theory was created by researchers Stanley Schachter and Jerome E. Singer.

Who tested Schachter and Singer's two-factor theory of emotion?

The misattribution of arousal study tested Schachter and Singer's two-factor theory of emotion. Psychologists Donald G. Dutton and Arthur P. Aron wanted to use a natural setting that would induce physiological arousal. In this experiment, they had male participants walk across two different styles of bridges.

How did Maslach and Singer study work?

Maslach (1979) designed a study to try to replicate and extend on the Scha chter and Singer study. Instead of being injected with epinephrine, the administrators used hypnotic suggestions for the source of arousal. Either the subjects were hypnotized or were used as a control (same as the placebo effect in the Schachter and Singer study). Subjects that were hypnotized were given a suggestion to become aroused at the presentation of a cue and were instructed not to remember the source of this arousal. Right after the subjects had been hypnotized, a confederate began acting either in a euphoric or angry condition. Later on in the study the subjects were exposed to two more euphoric confederates. One confederate was to keep aware the source of the arousal, while the other confederates told the subjects to expect different arousal symptoms. The results found that all the subjects both on self-reports and on observation found that unexplained arousal causes negative conditions. Subjects still showed angry emotions regardless of the euphoric confederate. Maslach concluded that when there is a lack of explanation for an arousal it will cause a negative emotion, which will evoke either anger or fear. However, Maslach did mention a limitation that there might have been more negative emotion self-reported because there are more terms referring to negative emotions than to positive ones.

What happens when you are put in a situation that could have made you feel an emotion?

If a person is put in a situation, which in the past could have made them feel an emotion, they will react emotionally or experience emotions only if they are in a state of physiological arousal.

What was the second bridge in the experiment?

One bridge was a very scary (arousing) suspension bridge, which was very narrow and suspended above a deep ravine. The second bridge was much safer and more stable than the first.

Who created the theory of physiological arousal?

The theory was created by researchers Stanley Schachter and Jerome E. Singer. According to the theory, when an emotion is felt, a physiological arousal occurs and the person uses the immediate environment to search for emotional cues to label the physiological arousal. This can sometimes cause misinterpretations of emotions based on ...

Who tried to replicate Schachter and Singer's euphoria?

Criticism of the theory has come from attempted replications of the Schachter and Singer (1962) study. Marshall and Zimbardo (1979, and Marshall 1976) tried to replicate the Schachter and Singer’s euphoria conditions.

When was the two factor theory of emotion first introduced?

Criticisms of The Two-Factor Theory of Emotion. The two-factor theory of emotion is relatively new to the world of psychology. It was first introduced in 1962. Not all replications of Schachter and Singer’s original studies have gotten the same results.

What Is the Two-Factor Theory of Emotion?

The two-factor theory of emotion recognizes that both cognition and arousal play a part in the identification and feeling of emotions. Emotion is not only caused by a sensation in the body or thoughts in the mind. Both of these processes influence the emotions that we feel and express to others. Context, past experiences, and a person’s knowledge of their own body also play a part into how they label or experience emotions.

Why did the men walk across the scary bridge?

Why did they do this? The researchers believe that the men experienced physiological arousal from walking across the scary bridge. They used cognitive processes to determine that their arousal was due to their sexual attraction to the woman. One could argue that the men labeled their emotions incorrectly, but only because their physiological arousal and cognitive interpretations were done in two separate processes.

What did Schachter and Singer believe?

Schachter and Singer believed that people felt emotions when they experienced arousal and had context or stimuli to help them identify and label their feelings. This process started with arousal.

How does emotion affect the body?

Emotion is not only caused by a sensation in the body or thoughts in the mind. Both of these processes influence the emotions that we feel and express to others. Context, past experiences, and a person’s knowledge of their own body also play a part into how they label or experience emotions.

How did Schachter and Singer test their theories?

They injected participants with epinephrine, a hormone that causes an increased heart rate and other side effects. Some participants knew that they were going to experience these side effects, and others didn’t. Then, the participants were placed in a room with a confederate. The confederate either acted euphorically or angrily with the participants.

What is the theory of understanding your emotions?

Understanding Your Emotions. This theory assumes that people are in touch with their emotions and the physical responses happening within their body. The first time you are experiencing a panic attack, for example, you may not be able to identify what is happening within your body.

Definition of the Schachter-Singer Theory in Psychology

Thoughts, bodily sensations, and actions: As you think about these, know that others have debated how these three factors play a role in our emotions. A lot of research has tried to figure out how we experience emotions. One theory that helps us better understand our emotions is Stanley Schachter's and Jerome Singer’s two-factor theory of emotion.

The Schachter-Singer Two-Factor Theory

Stanley Schachter and Jerome Singer came up with their theory of emotion in the early 1960s. The most important part of the Schachter-Singer theory is your cognitive appraisal of your bodily reaction. What you think about how your body is responding determines what emotion you feel. However, there is more to this theory than just these two factors.

The Schachter-Singer Theory Experiment

The very first experiment that Schacter and Singer conducted about their theory was a study using a hormone called epinephrine. Epinephrine is both a hormone and a type of medication. The medication version is often used to treat severe allergic reactions (i.e., Epi-Pens).

The Schachter-Singer and Cannon-Bard Theories

Another important theory of emotion is the Cannon-Bard theory. Walter Cannon and Phillip Bard's theory is all about how we experience both emotional and physiological responses at the same time. The two experiences are strongly connected to each other, even apart from our thoughts.

Schachter-Singer Theory - Key Takeaways

The Schachter-Singer Theory of emotion explains how emotion is experienced after two factors: physiological responses and cognitive appraisals.

image

Overview

The two-factor theory of emotion states that emotion is based on two factors: physiological arousal and cognitive label. The theory was created by researchers Stanley Schachter and Jerome E. Singer. According to the theory, when an emotion is felt, a physiological arousal occurs and the person uses the immediate environment to search for emotional cues to label the physiological arousal. This can sometimes cause misinterpretations of emotions based on the body's physiol…

Empirical support

Stanley Schachter and Jerome E. Singer (1962) performed a study that tested how people use clues in their environment to explain physiological changes. Their hypotheses were:
• If a person experiences a state of arousal for which they have no immediate explanation, they will label this state and describe their feelings in terms of the cognitions available to them at the time.
• If a person experiences a state of arousal for which they have an appropriate explanation (e.g. '…

Criticisms

Criticism of the theory has come from attempted replications of the Schachter and Singer (1962) study. Marshall and Zimbardo (1979, and Marshall 1976) tried to replicate the Schachter and Singer’s euphoria conditions. Just as Schachter and Singer did, the subjects were injected with epinephrine or a placebo, except the administrator told the subjects that they will be experiencing non-arousal symptoms. Then the subjects were put into four different conditions: subjects inject…

See also

• Cannon–Bard theory
• James–Lange theory
• Misattribution of arousal

Notes

1. ^ Schachter, S.; Singer, J. (1962). "Cognitive, Social, and Physiological Determinants of Emotional State" (PDF). Psychological Review. 69 (5): 379–399. doi:10.1037/h0046234. PMID 14497895.
2. ^ Pruett, Chris (February 2011). "Pressed By The Dark". Game Developer. 18 (2): 33. Retrieved 7 November 2013. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)

External links

• A Powerpoint presentation describing Schachter & Singer's experiment
• A Powerpoint presentation describing Dutton & Aron's experiment

What Is The Two-Factor Theory of Emotion?

  • The two-factor theory of emotion recognizes that both cognition and arousal play a part in the identification and feeling of emotions. Emotion is not only caused by a sensation in the body or thoughts in the mind. Both of these processes influence the emotions that we feel and express. Context, past experiences, and a person’s knowledge of their ow...
See more on practicalpie.com

Who Proposed The Two-Factor Theory of Emotion?

  • The first theory of emotion in modern psychology was the James-Lange theory, which centered around the body’s physical arousal. It was replaced by the Cannon-Bard theory, which argued that emotions start in the mind, not the body. These theories didn’t satisfy many cognitive psychologists, including Stanley Schachter and Jerome Singer. This led to the creation of the Sc…
See more on practicalpie.com

Example

  • Picture this. You’re down the street at night. All of a sudden, a person wearing a clown costume pops out of nowhere and starts running toward you. You have an emotional response. But what is it? Maybe you say, “I feel afraid.” Maybe you say, “I start running.” Maybe you say, “I completely freeze up and start sweating.” There is a lot that goes into our emotions. We don’t just feel them …
See more on practicalpie.com

The Two Factors

  • Schachter and Singer believed that people felt emotions when they experienced arousal and had context or stimuli to help them identify and label their feelings. This process started with arousal.
See more on practicalpie.com

Testing Schachter and Singer’S Theory

  • Schachter and Singer tested out their theories about these processes by conducting an experiment. They injected participants with epinephrine, a hormone that causes an increased heart rate and other side effects. Some participants knew that they were going to experience these side effects, and others didn’t. Then, the participants were placed in a room with a confed…
See more on practicalpie.com

Understanding Your Emotions

  • This theory assumes that people are in touch with their emotions and the physical responses happening within their body. The first time you are experiencing a panic attack, for example, you may not be able to identify what is happening within your body. These new sensations, like your chest tightening or your hands tingling, may be confusing. Yet they are still occurring, whether y…
See more on practicalpie.com

Criticisms of The Two-Factor Theory of Emotion

  • The two-factor theory of emotion is relatively new to the world of psychology. It was first introduced in 1962. Not all replications of Schachter and Singer’s original studies have gotten the same results. While there might be more to explore when it comes to the mental and physical processes involved in identifying emotions, Schachter and Singer’s theory brings us closer than …
See more on practicalpie.com

1.The Schachter-Singer Two-Factor Theory of Emotion

Url:https://www.verywellmind.com/the-two-factor-theory-of-emotion-2795718

8 hours ago Schachter’s cognitive labeling theory thus identifies “cognitive attribution,” the mind’s attempt to pair the feeling of arousal with its (inferred) causal pattern in the environment as the second …

2.Two-factor Theory of Emotion (Schachter & Singer)

Url:https://psynso.com/two-factor-theory-emotion-schachter-singer/

4 hours ago Define the two factor theory. Physiological arousal and cognition work together to create emotions. Describe what a stooge is. An experimenter pretending to be a participant; in this …

3.Two-factor theory of emotion - Wikipedia

Url:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-factor_theory_of_emotion

13 hours ago 1.Schachter and Singer believe that emotion is based on both a physiological (arousal) factor and psychological (cognitive) factor, this became known as the two-factor theory of emotion. …

4.Two Factor Theory of Emotion | Practical Psychology

Url:https://practicalpie.com/two-factor-theory-of-emotion/

29 hours ago What is the circumplex model of emotion, and how is it reflected in the brain? What is stress? What are the two pathways by which stress affects the body? What is the HPA axis? Question: …

5.Schachter-Singer Theory: Definition & Experiment

Url:https://www.studysmarter.us/explanations/psychology/emotion-and-motivation/schachter-singer-theory/

31 hours ago Abstract. Traditional two-factor theory is supported by parallels in the clinical literature. Theoretical problems with two-factor theory are obviated by the role of safety signals, which …

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9