what reforms have been proposed for the electoral college

What are the plans for electoral college reform?

• What do they think about the system?
• Do they think it is fair?
• Would they like to see the system changed? Why or why not?

What is the most supported plan for electoral college reform?

The most widely supported plan for reform of the electoral college is the direct popular election plan. Log in for more information. Search for an answer or ask Weegy.

Why we should abolish the Electoral College?

they should abolish it. I challenge any readers of this column, especially any legislators who read this, to write a letter to the editor to state and support at least one “good” reason to support keeping the Electoral College and why it is better than ...

What is the good and bad about the Electoral College?

“More people live in D.C. than in Wyoming, the least populous state in the union; but they both get three electoral votes.” (Plus, unlike Wyoming, D.C. gets no voting representation in Congress.) The biggest problem with the Electoral College is that it encourages vote suppression, says DeRosa.

How many proposals have been made to change the Electoral College system?

They cast legally binding votes which, since 1876, have been based on polling taken in each of the 50 constituent states and Washington, D.C. Since 1800, over 700 proposals to reform or eliminate the system have been introduced in Congress.

What are some possible reforms to the Electoral College quizlet?

Terms in this set (4)District Plan. Counts the votes district by district.Proportional Plan. Each candidate would receive a share of each states electoral votes.Direct Popular Election. Banishes the Electoral College.National Popular Vote Plan.

What is electoral system reform?

Electoral reform in the United States refers to efforts to change American elections and the electoral system used in the United States. Most elections in the U.S. select one person; elections with multiple candidates selected by proportional representation are relatively rare.

What was the original plan for the Electoral College?

Originally, the Electoral College provided the Constitutional Convention with a compromise between two main proposals: the popular election of the President and the election of the President by Congress. About this object The 1953 electoral vote count declared Dwight D. Eisenhower the winner.

What are 3 major flaws in the electoral college?

Three criticisms of the College are made: It is “undemocratic;” It permits the election of a candidate who does not win the most votes; and. Its winner-takes-all approach cancels the votes of the losing candidates in each state.

What are the main arguments to keep the electoral college quizlet?

arguments for the electoral college: promotes unity in the nation by requiring a candidate to have support from various regions in order to be elected. a candidate cannot receive support from only one region and expect to be president regardless of the size of the population. enhances the status of minority groups.

What is the most widely supported plan for reform of the electoral college quizlet?

The Direct Popular Election plan is the most widely supported plan.

Why electoral reforms are necessary?

It is expected that electoral reforms will contribute to better participation of the citizens in electoral practices, reduce corruption and strengthen democracy in India. More than 3000 crores were spent by the government for conducting the 2014 Loksabha elections.

What three events combined to change the intent of the original electoral college?

The ratification of the 12th Amendment, the expansion of voting rights, and the States' use of the popular vote to determine who will be appointed as electors have each substantially changed the process.

What major change did the 12th Amendment make in the Electoral College system?

The new electoral process was first used for the 1804 election. Each presidential election since has been conducted under the terms of the Twelfth Amendment. The Twelfth Amendment stipulates that each elector must cast distinct votes for president and vice president, instead of two votes for president.

How did the 12th Amendment change the Electoral College?

After the experiences of the 1796 and 1800 elections, Congress passed, and the states ratified, the 12th Amendment to the Constitution. Added in time for the 1804 election, the amendment stipulated that the electors would now cast two votes: one for President and the other for Vice President.

Why Electoral College was created?

The Electoral College As prescribed in the U.S. Constitution, American presidents are elected not directly by the people, but by the people's electors. The Electoral College was created by the framers of the U.S. Constitution as an alternative to electing the president by popular vote or by Congress.

When did the electoral college reform shift?

Since 1979, advocates for Electoral College reform have shifted their efforts from Congress to the states. This shift was fueled by the difficulty in getting two-thirds of both congressional chambers and three-quarters of state legislatures to agree on an amendment.

How many proposals were there to change the electoral system?

There were at least 752 known proposals to change the electoral system from 1789 to 2017, according to the Congressional Research Service. Electoral reform efforts often reflect the political anxieties of the time. In 1800, representatives debated a national plan to award electoral votes based on popular vote victories by congressional district.

Why was the electoral college amendment blocked?

Northeast Republicans and Southern Democrats in the Senate ultimately blocked the resolution by 1970 due to concerns about constitutional change and regional influence , respectively. The last electoral college amendment to receive a vote from the full House or Senate occurred in 1979.

What amendment did the electoral college fail to gain traction with?

These efforts have failed to gain traction with the 12th Amendment’s separation of electoral votes for president and vice president a notable exception.

How many electoral votes are there in the compact language?

The compact language only holds participating states to this agreement once states representing 270 electoral votes – a majority of the Electoral College – have joined. Equal Citizens is seeking electoral reform via the court system.

What was the Supreme Court's decision in Gray v. Sanders?

The Supreme Court’s decision in Gray v. Sanders (1963) also encouraged reformers who took up Justice William Douglas’s support for “one person, one vote.”. Proposals during this period focused on eliminating the position of elector and using proportional allocation of electoral votes.

How much of the vote did the opposition win?

Opponents prevailed with 65% of the vote by countering that the state’s influence in national politics would decline by splitting electoral votes. In the 21st century, state legislatures have taken up electoral vote proposals that have not advanced.

How many proposals have been made to reform the electoral college system?

Since 1800, over 700 proposals to reform or eliminate the system have been introduced in Congress. Proponents of these proposals argued that the electoral college system does not provide for direct democratic election, affords less-populous states an advantage, and allows a candidate to win the presidency without winning the most votes.

How did the electoral college work?

Constitution, which was adopted in 1789, as part of the process for the indirect election of the President and Vice-President of the United States . The institution has been criticized since its establishment and a number of efforts have been made to reform the way it works or abolish it altogether. Any change would require a constitutional amendment. In 1971, one of these attempts was almost successful in being proposed to the States. An interstate compact proposal, which would bypass the requirement for a constitutional amendment, is at 73% of successful completion as of October 2020#N#[update]#N#.

What was the Lodge-Gossett Amendment?

Named after its sponsors senator Henry Lodge (R-Massachusetts) and representative Ed Gossett (D-Texas), the Lodge-Gossett Amendment was a plan to allocate the electoral votes proportional to the popular vote. The amendment would have kept the Electoral College, but effectively rendered it useless.

How many electoral votes does each state have?

^ Each state has a number of votes in the Electoral College equal to two more than its number of representatives in the U.S. House, while DC is granted 3 electoral votes. The number of inhabitants per state is calculated as inhabitants divided by electoral votes.

What amendment would replace the electoral college?

Bills have been made proposing constitutional amendments that would replace the Electoral College with the popular election of the president and vice president. Unlike the Bayh–Celler amendment, with its 40% threshold for election, these proposals do not require a candidate to achieve a certain percentage of votes to be elected.

How does the electoral college allocate votes?

The Electoral College allocates votes by giving each state two, and then dividing the remaining votes among the states based on their populations. The two votes being automatically allocated has allowed for disproportional representation of where people live in favor of the smaller states.

What happens when a candidate has high support levels in states with smaller populations?

Thus, when candidates have high support levels in states with smaller populations and lower support level in more populous ones, such as in 2016, this can have the consequence that the winner of the national popular vote can lose the electoral vote and not be elected president.

How many electoral votes are there in the Compact?

Ten states and D.C. have passed the Compact, comprising 165 electoral votes. The Compact will take effect if and when states representing a majority of electoral votes, which is 270, pass it.

How many people signed a petition asking the electors to vote for Hillary Clinton?

It’s not pretty, and many people have concluded they want to squash it. Almost five million people have signed a petition asking the Electors to vote for Hillary Clinton, not Donald Trump. Others have swamped the federal agency that helps coordinate the College with calls and emails.

Has the electoral college survived?

The Electoral College has survived more efforts to reform or abolish it than any other American political institution. “There have been more proposals for Constitutional amendments on changing the Electoral College than on any other subject,” according to the National Archives.

Is the Hail Mary effort to change the outcome of the election?

These are all Hail Mary efforts to change the outcome of the election, which is to say they are extremely unlikely to succeed.

Is Hertzberg a fan of the electoral college?

Hertzberg is no fan of the Electoral College and has written persuasively about its flaws. He’s a big supporter of the Compact. The Electoral College “distorts and perverts democracy and participation,” he told me, “because the general election only happens in about a dozen states at most and the other 40 states are just spectators.

What is electoral reform?

Electoral reform in the United States refers to efforts to change American elections and the electoral system used in the United States . Most elections in the U.S. select one person; elections with multiple candidates selected by proportional representation are relatively rare. Typical examples include the House of Representatives, ...

What is the bill that proposes a system for congressional elections?

One bill that proposes such a system for U.S. congressional elections is "The Grassroots Democracy Act". It was introduced September 14, 2012, by U.S. Representative John Sarbanes as H.R. 6426 and reintroduced on January 15, 2013 as H. R. 268.

What did Lawrence Lessig say about Citizens United?

Lawrence Lessig said, "On January 20, 2010, the day before Citizens United was decided, our democracy was already broken. Citizens United may have shot the body, but the body was already cold. And any response to Citizens United must also respond to that more fundamental corruption. We must find a way to restore a government 'dependent upon the People alone,' so that we give 'the People' a reason again to have confidence in their government."

How does gerrymandering work?

When this process is manipulated to benefit a particular political party or incumbent, the result is known as gerrymandering. The Open Our Democracy Act & the For the People Act are bills designed to end gerrymandering. The For the People Act passed the United States House of Representatives on March 3, 2020. As of June 2021, it has not been passed by the United States Senate.

How many states have approved the Interstate Compact?

This is the idea behind the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact. As of November 2019, sixteen states with electoral votes totaling 196 had approved the compact. To take effect it must be approved by states with electoral votes totaling 270, just over half of the 538 current total electoral votes.

How many amendments did the United States Congress pass in 2013?

The web site of United for the People lists 17 constitutional amendments introduced in the 112th United States Congress and 12 introduced by March 13, 2013, in the 113th proposing to overturn Citizens United in different ways.

When was Citizens United v. FEC?

The Citizens United v. FEC decision, January 21, 2010, of the U.S. Supreme Court has received substantial notoriety, pushing many people to work for a constitutional amendment to overturn it. Key provisions of that decision assert in essence that money is speech and subject to first amendment protections.

How many proposals have been made to reform the electoral college?

Reference sources indicate that over the past 200 years more than 700 proposals have been introduced in Congress to reform or eliminate the Electoral College. There have been more proposals for Constitutional amendments on changing the Electoral College than on any other subject.

Which amendments do not refer to electoral colleges?

Article II of the Constitution and the 12th Amendment refer to “electors,” but not to the “electoral college.”. Since the Electoral College process is part of the original design of the U.S. Constitution it would be necessary to pass a Constitutional amendment to change this system.

What is the electoral college?

The Founding Fathers established the Electoral College in the Constitution, in part, as a compromise between the election of the President by a vote in Congress and election of the President by a popular vote of qualified citizens. However, the term “electoral college” does not appear in the Constitution. Article II of the Constitution and the 12th ...

Who was the last third party candidate?

The last third party, or splinter party, candidate to make a strong showing was Theodore Roosevelt in 1912 (Progressive, also known as the Bull Moose Party). He finished a distant second in Electoral and popular votes (taking 88 of the 266 electoral votes needed to win at the time).

Early Reform Efforts

See more on electoralvotemap.com

The Peak of Congressional Electoral College Reform

State Level Reform Efforts

Reform Efforts by Advocacy Groups

Related