What is Anna Quindlen's claim in “a quilt of a country”?
This essay has been submitted by a student. Anna Quindlen’s claim in “A Quilt of a Country” is that America is a diverse nation that is it not supposed to work out, but instead mostly everyone gets along and is able to tolerate each other. She clearly states this in the beginning of the text when she says, “America is an improbable idea.
What is the main idea of a quilt of a country?
'A Quilt of a Country' is a commentary by Anna Quindlen for ''Newsweek'' on the diversity of America, as well as the unity that came in the wake of attacks against Americans on September 11, 2001. In this lesson, we'll learn more about this article.
How is repetition used in a quilt of a country?
Essay on Anna Quindlen’s “A Quilt of a Country” Essay. This repetition acts to cement the idea that America is dysfunctional, which is the core of her claim, and after the repetition stops she ends the paragraph with a change of tone, when she says that despite all of this, America still stands.
How does Quindlen compare the United States to a quilt?
Quindlen uses a metaphor, or a literary comparison, of the U.S. to a quilt to describe its unique creation by using its various parts. Far from perfect, America has suffered from bigotry in many forms.
How does Anna Quindlen prove that America does work?
Why does Anna Quindlen change her tone?
About this website
A quilt of a country test Flashcards | Quizlet
1) the quotation "Americana's was built in no ones image" supports her claim that they fairy but are united. 2) yet even in 1994, the overwhelming majority of those surveyed by the NORC agreed with this statement "The U.S is a unique country that stands for something special."
Essay on Anna Quindlen's "A Quilt of a Country" - StudyMoose
Anna Quindlen writes about why America shouldn’t work, yet does, in a short article titled “A Quilt of a Country.” She uses effective evidence and valid reasoning to support her thesis, and she also divides her article into two separate sections: the first designated to proving why America shouldn’t work, and the second designated to why it does work.
A Quilt of a Country Summary - eNotes.com
Complete summary of Anna Quindlen's A Quilt of a Country. eNotes plot summaries cover all the significant action of A Quilt of a Country.
1. SUMMARIZE: What is Anna Quindlen's claim in "A Quilt of a...
1. SUMMARIZE: What is Anna Quindlen's claim in "A Quilt of a Country"?Summarize her claim. Would you defend her claim or challenge it? 2: INTERPRET: In paragraph 1, what does Quindlen mean when she describes America as being "like the crazy quilts that have been one of its great folk-art forms"?Quindlen uses this image throughout her argument. How does this extended metaphor support her cl
Essay on Anna Quindlen’s “A Quilt of a Country” - EduCheer!
The Essay on Women In America Work Norton Clerical "The Evolution of Women in Society" Throughout United States history oppression of people has always been prominent, whether through African American's and segregation or Asian American's during the Vietnam War.
The Immigrant Contribution And A Quilt Of A Country | Bartleby
A Quilt of a Country and The Immigrant Contribution Compare/Contrast Essay Simply put, America is the land of opportunity. In the past, immigrants have left most of their family, memories, and familiarities with their homeland in search of a better life in America, where jobs were easy to find and the economy was booming.
Summary Of Mark Twain 'Those Extraordinary Twins'
In the story “Those Extraordinary Twins” by Mark Twain he depicts the twins Luigi and Angelo and sharing a body but not sharing philosophies. This separation is also evident of the Civil War time-period in the United states during Twain’s Life.
Anna Quindlen A Quilt Of A Country Analysis
In the article, “A Quilt of a Country,” Anna Quindlen makes solid points for both arguments, and uses a good chunk of evidence for both sides, too. I agree with her idea that America is a unified whole, but at other times is on the verge of collapse.
Rhetorical Analysis Of Ellen Goodman's The Family That Stretch
Although perceptions of who can be determined as ‘family’ have been extremely customary in the past, Ellen Goodman utilizes a plethora of rhetorical strategies including perspective, figurative language and Aristotelian Appeals in order to express that straying away from labels and evolving with society over time will allow individuals to step beyond the realms of tradition and embrace the complexities of a more meaningful, extended family.
Gender Roles In Modern Family
Despite the creator’s of Modern Family effort to portray a progressive view of American families, the show still accentuates outdated female stereotypes and gender roles; reinforcing gender characteristics, patriarchy and hegemonic masculinity.
Cultural Self Reflection Report
The way our societies view other cultures and spread the perceptions regarding them is an unfair practice. It causes discrimination and judgment to foster in the mind of the coming generations and they in turn spread these views even more and thus strengthen those perceptions.
Essay On Interracial Relationships
People still fight for interracial relationships because there is a lot of negativity towards people in interracial relationships. As a matter of fact, a study done where test subjects were shown photos of interracial couples. The test subjects actually made the interracial couples not very human in thier minds.
Otherness In American Literature
The concept of otherness in American literature The concept of otherness can take numerous forms; it may be somebody who is of a dissimilar race, gender, culture, religion, class or sexual orientation as Meriem Webster-Online defines otherness as the quality or the state of being other or different.
How does Anna Quindlen prove that America does work?
Anna supports her reason by listing some examples of wars where we were united against a single entity, such as the cold and world wars. After that, she points out that during times where we didn't have a nation to fight against, we were less united and more separate. She also points out that we became reunited as a result of 9/11. This supports her reason because through deductive reasoning, the reader concludes that a common enemy is what binds the people of America. These pieces of evidence support her central thesis because they prove that the existence of an enemy makes us united, which would in turn make us work together and subsequently make America work better, which is her claim. In the next paragraph, however, she starts out by bringing up that most Americans still say that "The U.S. is a unique country that stands for something special in the world", even during peace time. This would imply that there's another reason why America's still united, and Anna Quindlen uses this quote to justify her next sentence. Her next sentence which depicts America in a fashion that makes it seem implausible, supports the part of her claim that says America shouldn't work, and she also says that it somehow does, annoyingly. This aids the second half of her claim, America does work. In the last sentence, she finally states what the other reason for America working is: two strains of behavior. She says that the first strain of behavior is the hardworking psyche of Americans, and the second strain is the pilgrim-like persona of immigrants. Her support for her reason is a quote that the immigrants of a couple decades ago are just like the immigrants of today, who work hard and are subsequently making a living, which would allude to the idea that these personalities persist throughout all of America, regardless of time or space. With that in mind, it supports her claim because it shows that we all have something in common, and therefore can become unified more easily, which makes America work better. After all of that, she moves onto her very last paragraph; her conclusion. She starts off by pondering what word best describes the people who live in America, from tolerance to pride, and then mirrors her claim by describing America as a ludicrous idea that shouldn't work, yet does. She then says that the people of America are so varying, you could trace back the heritage to each person who died during 9/11 to every single country in the world; this analogy aids to the allusion that America is a collage of disparate and disjointed parts. Finally, in the very last sentences of the article, she draws a connection to the beginning of the article by reusing the phrases: mongrel nation, and improbable idea, and by mirroring the beginning and last statements of her article, she creates a lasting impact on the reader.
Why does Anna Quindlen change her tone?
Unlike the first half, where Anna Quindlen's tone implies that America is a collection of warring ethnicities, she changes her diction from doubtful to dumbfounded in order to better suit her goal, proving that America does work. She starts out by claiming that the reason America remains intact is a common enemy.
What is the quilt of a country by Anna Quindlen about?
Quilt of a Country by Anna Quindlen is an essay written after the 9/11 terror attacks in New York. In this piece Quindlen explains how America is like a quilt, and made up of all different cultures sewn together by a common enemy. In her essay Quindlen uses a diction that easy to understand, but at the same time it gives you good information. In the first paragraph of the essay the author states “America is an improbable idea. A mongrel nation built of ever changing disparate parts, it is held together by a notion, the notion that all men are created equal, though everyone knows that most men consider better than someone”. In this quote Quindlen uses wording that has some...
What is the claim of Anna Quindlen in Quilt of the Country?
Quilt of the Country summary Anna Quindlen's claim in Quilt of a Country is that “America is an improbable idea,” even know that we are put together by different cultures, and that we are surrounded by individualism. As she states in paragraph one,” America is an improbable idea .”. America is an improbable idea because we don’t follow our own constitution. It says that all men are created equal, but people still think they're better than others. We are made of many cultures but we still have….
What does Anna Quindlen argue about diversity?
In this argumentative essay, “A Quilt of A Country” , Anna Quindlen argues that diversity connects the people of the United States as seen by her use of many different facts and quotes. As Quindlen argues she mentions “Of all the nations in the world, the United States was built in nobody’s image”, she explains how while the US was being initiated the founding fathers had not based the image they had of the US on any other country or union. Quindlen also mentions, “Today the citizens of the United….
What is Allison Dreggors's essay about?
Allison Dreggors, pd.5, 9/25/14 Essay In Anna Quindlen's essay " A Quilt of a Country " she writes about how a country with so many people of different cultures, ethnicities ,religions, skin colors and sexual preferences can unite as one after a devastating event such as 9/11. The United States of America is a very assorted country with many different ethnicities that don't usually get along. In her essay she gives us examples of how the people of America are combined despite their differences by….
Is there evidence for the quilt of a country?
together as one human race? With fiction stories from several different authors, there is evidence from each story to properly choose an answer of yes or no. The three stories are called, “A Quilt of a Country”, “Once Upon a Time”, and “Making the Future Better, Together”. In the Story, “Quilt of a Country” by Anna Quindlen, the author often suggests that people from different cultures living together often have problems with intolerance. Intolerance is being unwilling to accept views, beliefs, or behavior….
What is Anna Quindlen's claim in A Quilt of a Country?
Anna Quindlen’s claim in “A Quilt of a Country” is that America is a diverse nation that is it not supposed to work out, but instead mostly everyone gets along and is able to tolerate each other. She clearly states this in the beginning of the text when she says, “America is an improbable idea. A mongrel nation built of ever-changing disparate parts, it is held together by a notion, the notion that all men are created equal…”
What does Quindlen mean by "like the crazy quilts that have been one of its great folk-art?
When Quindlen describes America as a being “like the crazy quilts that have been one of its great folk-art forms” she means that America is a place filled with people from all different races and ethnicities, like how a quilt usually filled with different patterns. The description supports her claims because before the quote above she states that United States is ‘built off of bits and pieces that seem discordant” which goes to support the part of her claim when she basically says that America is a diverse nation that is not supposed to work out especially when she uses words like discordant which is typically a word used to describe something that is conflicting. And when she compares America to a quilt which supports the part of her claim that basically says that America is a diverse nation.
What is the opposing viewpoint that Quindlen responds to in paragraph 3?
The opposing viewpoint that Quindlen responds to in paragraph 3 is that this nation (America) is not a failure and nation who doesn’t tolerate others. She mentions in the text that most often stories of the nations unfortunate events are most often talked about such as slavery and civil rights movement. In order to counteract that statement about she says, “This is a nation founded on a conundrum, [4] what Mario Cuomo [5] has characterized as “community added to individualism.”… The New York of my children is no more Balkanized, [7] probably less so, than the Philadelphia of my father, in which Jewish boys would walk several blocks out of their way to avoid the Irish divide of Chester Avenue…Do the Cambodians and the Mexicans in California coexist less easily today than did the Irish and Italians of Massachusetts a century ago? You know the answer” When she says those words, she addresses the concern that America doesn’t tolerate others, but instead that for years, America tolerates people no matter their differences.
What is the quilt of a country?
'A Quilt of a Country' is a commentary written by Pulitzer-prize winning author Anna Quindlen for Newsweek following the devastation of the September 11, 2001, attacks on America. The premise behind this article is that despite the diversity that can create a lot of problems within cities across America, diversity serves as a tribute to what makes America special.
Where is Anna Quindlen teaching?
She has been teaching English in Canada and Taiwan for seven years. 'A Quilt of a Country' is a commentary by Anna Quindlen for ''Newsweek'' on the diversity of America, as well as the unity that came in the wake of attacks against Americans on September 11, 2001. In this lesson, we'll learn more about this article.
Why is America so unique?
America is a unique and incredible idea because it is made up of so many parts that don't seem like they should fit together, but is actually made better because of all the diversified pieces. Quindlen uses a metaphor, or a literary comparison, of the U.S. to a quilt to describe its unique creation by using its various parts.
Why is America called a melting pot?
America is often described as a melting pot because people from many different cultures live there. ''A Quilt of a Country'' argues that no other country in the world is as diverse as America.
What is the most important thing about the United States?
The thing that stands out most about the United States is not its culture or character, but the ability of its citizens, from so many different cultures, to peacefully live together despite their diversi ty. No other nation in the world might be comprised of this type of citizenry.
What distinguishes America from other countries?
One of the things that distinguishes America from other countries is the strong commitment of each group to uphold his or her culture of origin. In varying degrees, people with origins in Italy, Ireland, Germany, Mexico, Native America, China, and every other imaginable heritage have, for the most part, maintained their customs, and, unfortunately, in some cases, their hatred towards other groups. Over time, some of the lines have been muted, while others remain staunch.
When people get to know one another as individuals, instead of putting unknown people into categories for the purpose of promoting?
In other words, when people get to know one another as individuals, instead of putting unknown people into categories for the purpose of promoting hate, they may find that they have more in common than they may have realized.
What is the quilt of a country?
Quindlen mentions that the United States of America is a nation founded on a conundrum, no matter what the native Americans may intend to argue, immigrants are not much dissimilar from our own families at home. Also patriotism along with taking pride in this doubtful idea that requires putting all of us together in a country that is just as different as a every other countries, and calling it by one name. By the way Anna Quindlen describes the United States of America, she believes that it is a nation built on the bases of a conundrum. A mongrel country, with many unpleasant events, such as economic unrest and enlarging crime rates, along with its citizens. Simply a nation equivalent to a paradox, and that just like any other improbable idea, will shock you when it actually works. A nation that is founded on a conundrum can be quite puzzling. In order to explain what the author means by this, she brings up a quote written by Mario Cuomo an ex-governor of New York. The quote describes America as a “community added to individualism.” The reason for this quote being included is to show two of our defining ideals which are discordant. It shows that in this “community” we were all disparate individuals in the …show more content…
What did Emerson and Thoreau believe?
Their dynamic personality clash would symbolize one of the essential paradoxes of America-that even while two people may hold similar beliefs about freedom, the nature of their relationship may still be fraught with conflict. While both Emerson and Thoreau believed in one of the fundamental tenants of Transcendentalism (man is fundamentally good, and organized government is a corrupting force) the force of their different approaches to it would test the limits of natural brotherhood (Parker…
What is the unorthodox character in The Handmaid's Tale?
William O’ Douglas, former Associate Justic of the Supreme Court of the United States once said, “The great and invigorating influences in American life have been the unorthodox: the people who challenge an existing institution or way of life, or say and do things that make people think.” The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood presents unorthodox characters in Offred, The Commander, and Moira through freedom, relationships, and individuality. Offred, the protagonist of the novel, is an unorthodox character because of her small defiance of rules, want of little freedoms, and knowledge of Mayday. Firstly, Offred takes pleasure in the ability to manipulate her world, Gilead, in the little ways that she can. For instance, one day Offred makes eye…
Why is America like a quilt?
America is like a quilt because a quilt is made up of a lot of different pieces that are put together into one. Just like a quilt, America is made up of different races, ethnicity, and cultures. We’re all made up the same but we claim that we’re all different.
What did De Crevecoeur say about America?
These individuals came from all over and hold different beliefs. De Crevecoeur finds that “Diverse nationalities and faiths, he said, might well ‘melt’ into a more peaceful, justice-loving, and prosperous original, and it should be the envy of the world ” (Horwitz 23). The frontier brought about a whole new race of individuals who could bring a whole new perspective.
What is the Immigrant Contribution?
While A Quilt of a Country concerns the diversity of America after the tragedy of September 11, 2001, The Immigrant Contribution revolves around the idea that immigrants are American history and isn’t specifically about the diversity of America. A few quotes may explain some confusions:”When photographs of the faces of all those who died in the World Trade Center destruction are assembled in one place, it will be possible to trace in the skin color, the shape of the eyes and the noses, the texture of the hair, a map of the world” (Quindlen 16). This quote is about how when the World Trade Center came crashing down, viewers can recognize how diverse America is just by examining the photos of those who died; to put it in plain English, they can trace features from every part of the world in those photos. “Oscar Handlin has said, ‘Once I thought to write a history of the immigrants in America. Then I discovered that the immigrants were American history.’” (Kennedy 23). This quote elaborates on how there were no people originally in America, as they all immigrated here. Now that I expanded on it, do you recognize their
How does Anna Quindlen prove that America does work?
Anna supports her reason by listing some examples of wars where we were united against a single entity, such as the cold and world wars. After that, she points out that during times where we didn't have a nation to fight against, we were less united and more separate. She also points out that we became reunited as a result of 9/11. This supports her reason because through deductive reasoning, the reader concludes that a common enemy is what binds the people of America. These pieces of evidence support her central thesis because they prove that the existence of an enemy makes us united, which would in turn make us work together and subsequently make America work better, which is her claim. In the next paragraph, however, she starts out by bringing up that most Americans still say that "The U.S. is a unique country that stands for something special in the world", even during peace time. This would imply that there's another reason why America's still united, and Anna Quindlen uses this quote to justify her next sentence. Her next sentence which depicts America in a fashion that makes it seem implausible, supports the part of her claim that says America shouldn't work, and she also says that it somehow does, annoyingly. This aids the second half of her claim, America does work. In the last sentence, she finally states what the other reason for America working is: two strains of behavior. She says that the first strain of behavior is the hardworking psyche of Americans, and the second strain is the pilgrim-like persona of immigrants. Her support for her reason is a quote that the immigrants of a couple decades ago are just like the immigrants of today, who work hard and are subsequently making a living, which would allude to the idea that these personalities persist throughout all of America, regardless of time or space. With that in mind, it supports her claim because it shows that we all have something in common, and therefore can become unified more easily, which makes America work better. After all of that, she moves onto her very last paragraph; her conclusion. She starts off by pondering what word best describes the people who live in America, from tolerance to pride, and then mirrors her claim by describing America as a ludicrous idea that shouldn't work, yet does. She then says that the people of America are so varying, you could trace back the heritage to each person who died during 9/11 to every single country in the world; this analogy aids to the allusion that America is a collage of disparate and disjointed parts. Finally, in the very last sentences of the article, she draws a connection to the beginning of the article by reusing the phrases: mongrel nation, and improbable idea, and by mirroring the beginning and last statements of her article, she creates a lasting impact on the reader.
Why does Anna Quindlen change her tone?
Unlike the first half, where Anna Quindlen's tone implies that America is a collection of warring ethnicities, she changes her diction from doubtful to dumbfounded in order to better suit her goal, proving that America does work. She starts out by claiming that the reason America remains intact is a common enemy.
